Criminal Law
Criminal Courts and Their Jurisdictions: Magistrate, Criminal Court of First Instance, High Criminal Court, Regional Court of Appeal, and Court of Cassation
In this article 18 headings
- Short Answer: How Are Criminal Courts Organized in Türkiye?
- General Structure of Criminal Justice
- Concepts of Jurisdiction and Competence
- Criminal Judgeship of Peace
- Criminal Court of First Instance
- High Criminal Court
- Juvenile Courts and Other Specialized Criminal Courts
- Qualities of Decisions Rendered by First Instance Courts
- Regional Court of Appeal Criminal Chambers (Appellate)
- Court of Cassation Criminal Chambers (Cassation)
- Court of Cassation Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers and Extraordinary Legal Remedies
- Table of Legal Remedies and Time Limits
- Criminal Courts Regarding Foreign Nationals
- Checklist for a Criminal Case Regarding Courts and Legal Remedies
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
- Legal Resources and Related Reviews
- Author and Legal Information
Publication: · Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.
Short Answer: How Are Criminal Courts Organized in Türkiye?
Criminal courts in Türkiye operate within a three-tier system: first instance courts hear the case and deliver a judgment, Regional Court of Appeal criminal chambers perform appellate review, and Court of Cassation criminal chambers supervise compliance with the law through cassation review. According to Article 8 of Law No. 5235 on the Establishment, Duties and Powers of First Instance Courts and Regional Courts of Appeal, criminal courts consist of criminal courts of first instance, high criminal courts, and other criminal courts established by special laws. Matters requiring a judge's decision during the investigation stage are conducted not by the court, but by the criminal judgeship of peace.
The high criminal court hears serious crimes listed in the law such as robbery, intentional killing, drug trafficking, and crimes requiring imprisonment of more than ten years, and convenes as a panel consisting of a presiding judge and two members. The criminal court of first instance hears all cases and matters outside the jurisdiction of the criminal judgeship of peace and the high criminal court and is presided over by a single judge. Juvenile courts, intellectual and industrial property criminal courts, enforcement courts, and execution judgeships hear matters determined by special laws.
This guide explains the establishment, duties, primary offenses handled, the nature of decisions rendered by each court, and the legal remedies and deadlines available against these decisions, in light of the amendments made in 2024 and 2026, as well as current decisions of the Court of Cassation and the Constitutional Court.

General Structure of Criminal Justice
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Rating | Authority | Primary function | Legal Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Investigation | Criminal judgeship of peace | Pre-trial detention, search, seizure, interception of communication, objection to the decision of non-prosecution | Article 10 of Law No. 5235; CMK |
| First instance | Criminal Court of First Instance | General jurisdiction court; single judge | Article 11 of Law No. 5235 |
| First instance | High Criminal Court | Offenses specified in the law requiring imprisonment for more than ten years; collegiate court | Article 12 of Law No. 5235 |
| First instance | Juvenile court and juvenile high criminal court | Children driven to crime | Articles 25-26 of Law No. 5395 |
| First instance | Other criminal courts | Intellectual and industrial property rights, enforcement-related crimes | Article 13 of Law No. 5235; special laws |
| Execution | Execution judgeship | Execution institution procedures, aggregation of sentences, execution calculations | Law No. 4675; Articles 98-101 of Law No. 5275 |
| Appeal (Istinaf) | Criminal chamber of the regional court of appeal | Factual and legal review | Article 37 of Law No. 5235; Articles 272-285 of the CMK |
| Appeal on points of law (cassation) | Criminal chamber of the Court of Cassation | Review of legality | Law No. 2797; Articles 286-307 of the CMK |
| Higher appeals | General Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation | Resistance, objection, unification of jurisprudence | Article 15 of Law No. 2797; Articles 307-308 of the CMK |
Two authorities outside this structure also directly affect criminal proceedings. In accordance with Article 148 of the Constitution, the Constitutional Court tries certain persons, such as the President, the Speaker of the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye, ministers, and presidents and members of high courts, for crimes related to their duties in the capacity of the Supreme Court (Yüce Divan), and examines individual applications in accordance with Law No. 6216. Military courts were abolished by the 2017 constitutional amendment; Article 145 of the Constitution provides that military courts can only be established in times of war.

Concepts of Jurisdiction and Competence
Jurisdiction: What Type of Court?
Jurisdiction determines which type and level of court will hear a case. According to Article 3 of the CMK, the jurisdiction of courts is determined by law; jurisdictional rules concern public order and cannot be changed by the parties. According to Article 4 of the CMK, the court handling the case may decide ex officio at any stage of the prosecution phase whether it has jurisdiction. According to Article 5 of the CMK, if it is understood after the acceptance of the indictment that the matter exceeds or falls outside the court's jurisdiction, the court sends the file to the court with jurisdiction, and the objection path may be pursued against decisions of lack of jurisdiction within the judicial system. According to Article 7 of the CMK, except for those that cannot be renewed, proceedings performed by a judge or court without jurisdiction are void.
Article 6 of the CMK introduces an important limitation: a decision of lack of jurisdiction cannot be rendered to send the file to a lower court on the grounds that the legal classification of the crime changed during the hearing. In other words, if it is understood that the act of a defendant being tried for robbery in a high criminal court is actually blackmail, the high criminal court does not send the case to the criminal court of first instance but renders a judgment for blackmail itself. The reverse, i.e., if it is understood that a case being heard in a criminal court of first instance falls under the jurisdiction of the high criminal court, a decision of lack of jurisdiction must be rendered.
The Upper Limit Rule in Determining Jurisdiction
According to Article 14 of Law No. 5235, the upper limit of the penalty for the crime in the law is taken into account when determining the jurisdiction of the courts, without considering aggravating or mitigating factors. This rule is read together with the "more than ten years of imprisonment" criterion in Article 12 of the same Law. For example, if the upper limit of the base penalty for a crime is ten years, the case is generally heard in the criminal court of first instance, even if the penalty could be increased by half due to an aggravating circumstance.
This rule applies only to jurisdiction. In the decision of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers dated 11.03.2026, with Case No. 2025/341 and Decision No. 2026/172,it was stated that Article 14 of Law No. 5235 is a clear provision regarding the non-consideration of aggravating circumstances, while Article 66/3 of the TCK mandates that aggravating circumstances be considered for the statute of limitations. Considering the exceptional nature of the simple trial procedure, the Assembly decided that the two-year limit in Article 251 of the CMK should be determined according to the base and aggravated forms of the crime and that the simple trial procedure cannot be applied if the upper limit exceeds two years when the aggravating circumstance is applied. Regarding mandatory defense counsel, in the Court of Cassation 11th Criminal Chamber's decision for reversal for the benefit of the law dated 20.04.2026, with Case No. 2026/1777 and Decision No. 2026/4207In the qualified fraud file, considering the Article 158/3 enhancement of the TCK, it has been accepted that the five-year lower limit specified in Article 150/3 of the CMK is exceeded and that establishing a verdict without appointing a defense counsel constitutes a definitive violation of the law; there is a dissenting opinion on this matter in the decision.
Related Cases
According to CMK Article 8, if a person is a defendant for multiple crimes or if there are multiple defendants in a single crime, a connection is assumed. In accordance with CMK Articles 9 and 10, if each of the connected crimes falls under the jurisdiction of different courts, the cases may be consolidated and filed in the higher-ranked court, or ongoing cases may be consolidated by the higher-ranked court. In consolidated cases, the trial procedure applicable to the court handling these cases is applied. For this reason, a crime falling under the jurisdiction of the Criminal Court of First Instance may be heard in the High Criminal Court if it is connected to a crime that falls under the jurisdiction of the High Criminal Court.
Jurisdiction: Which Court?
Jurisdiction determines which of the competent courts will hear the case. According to CMK Article 12/1, the authority to hear the case belongs to the court of the place where the crime was committed. In cases of attempt, the court of the place where the final act was performed is competent; for continuous crimes, the court of the place where the continuity ceased is competent; and for chain crimes, the court of the place where the final crime was committed is competent. According to CMK Article 12/6, in crimes committed by using information systems, banks, credit institutions, or bank or credit cards as a tool, the courts of the victim's place of residence are also competent. If the place where the crime was committed is unknown, the court of the place where the suspect or defendant was apprehended is competent, or if not apprehended, the court of their place of residence is competent pursuant to CMK Article 13.
Article 15 of Law No. 5235 introduces a special jurisdiction rule for crimes within the scope of the Anti-Terror Law and crimes against the security of the state and the constitutional order: these cases are heard in the High Criminal Court named after the province to which the place where the crime was committed is attached. Furthermore, pursuant to Article 9 of Law No. 5235, the Council of Judges and Prosecutors may distribute work among court chambers to ensure specialization; these decisions are published in the Official Gazette.
Criminal Judgeship of Peace
Establishment and Legal Nature
The Judgeship of Peace (sulh ceza hâkimliği) was established by Law No. 6545 dated 18.06.2014. The former courts of peace that existed before this date were abolished, their trial duties were transferred to the Criminal Courts of First Instance, and their duties during the investigation phase were transferred to the newly established Judgeships of Peace. According to Article 10 of Law No. 5235, the Judgeship of Peace is established, reserving cases where laws explicitly assign jurisdiction to other authorities, to make decisions that must be taken by a judge during ongoing investigations, perform tasks, and review objections filed against these. The Judgeship of Peace is not a trial court; as a rule, it does not issue conviction or acquittal verdicts.
Principal Duties
- To review applications made against decisions of police custody, apprehension, and extension of custody duration (CMK 91/5).
- To decide on requests for pre-trial detention, judicial control, continuation of detention, and release during the investigation phase (CMK 100-109).
- To decide on protective measures such as search, seizure, search and copying of computers, and interception and recording of communication (CMK 116-140).
- To review the objection of the person harmed by the crime against the public prosecutor's decision of non-prosecution (KYOK) (CMK 173).
- To decide on blocking access to internet content and the removal of content (Law No. 5651, Articles 8 and 9).
- To review applications made against administrative detention decisions for foreigners (Law No. 6458, Articles 57/6 and 68).
Access blocking decisions of the Judgeship of Peace and application procedures against these decisions in the article on blocking internet access, while the application against the administrative detention of foreigners is in the letter of objection to the removal center and deportation decision has been explained.
Objection to Decisions
The legal remedy against the decisions of the criminal judgeship of peace is an objection. According to Article 268/3-a of the CMK, if there is more than one criminal judgeship of peace in that location, the objection is made to the judgeship with the next sequential number, and for the last numbered judgeship, it is made to the first numbered judgeship. According to Article 268/3-b of the CMK, introduced by Law No. 7331 dated July 8, 2021, objections made against the decisions of the criminal judgeship of peace regarding pre-trial detention and judicial control are reviewed by the judge of the criminal court of first instance within its jurisdiction. This amendment was made in response to criticisms directed at the closed system in which criminal judgeships of peace audited each other's decisions. The period for objection, pursuant to Article 268/1 of the CMK, was increased from seven days to two weeks by Law No. 7499 dated March 2, 2024.
Criminal Court of First Instance
Jurisdiction
According to Article 11 of Law No. 5235, provided that cases in which laws have assigned specific jurisdiction are reserved, cases and matters outside the jurisdiction of the criminal judgeship of peace and the high criminal court are handled by criminal courts of first instance. The criminal court of first instance is therefore the general jurisdiction criminal court and is composed of a single judge. Since the jurisdiction of the high criminal court is enumerated individually in the law, every offense not so enumerated falls under the jurisdiction of the criminal court of first instance.
Main Offenses Handled
The simple and many aggravated forms of intentional injury, threat, blackmail, insult, violation of home immunity, the simple form of deprivation of liberty, simple and qualified theft (TCK 141 and 142/1-2), fraud including its aggravated forms after Law No. 7571 dated December 24, 2025, breach of trust, property damage, the basic form of forgery in official documents, crimes against personal data and private life, possession of narcotic substances for use (TCK 191), endangering traffic safety, negligent killing and injury, and violations of Law No. 6136 are the main offenses falling under the jurisdiction of the criminal court of first instance. Details of these offenses threat, blackmail, theft, fraud and intentional injury are explained in the articles.
Procedures Specific to the Criminal Court of First Instance
The simple trial procedure in Article 251 of the CMK is applied only in the criminal court of first instance. After the indictment is accepted, in offenses requiring a judicial fine and/or imprisonment with an upper limit of two years or less, the court may render a decision based on the written statements of the parties without holding a hearing; in the event of a conviction, the final sentence is reduced by one-fourth. The fast-track procedure in Article 250 of the CMK is proposed by the public prosecutor during the investigation phase, and the result is submitted to the approval of the criminal court of first instance. The appellate path is available against the judgments of the criminal court of first instance; pursuant to Article 286/2-a of the CMK, a decision of rejection on the merits by the regional court of appeal is final for prison sentences of five years or less.
High Criminal Court
Organization
According to Article 9 of Law No. 5235, the high criminal court consists of a president and a sufficient number of members, and the court convenes with one president and two members. Decisions are rendered by unanimity or majority vote; the dissenting opinion is included in the minutes and the reasoned decision.
Jurisdiction
According to Article 12 of Law No. 5235, provided that cases in which laws have assigned specific jurisdiction are reserved, high criminal courts handle the following cases:
- Looting (TCK 148), extortion (TCK 250/1 and 2), forgery in official documents by a public official (TCK 204/2), and fraudulent bankruptcy (TCK 161).
- Crimes against the security of the state, the constitutional order, national defense, and state secrets defined in the fourth, fifth, sixth, and seventh chapters of the Second Book, Fourth Part of the TCK (excluding articles 318, 319, 324, 325, and 332).
- Offenses within the scope of the Anti-Terrorism Law No. 3713.
- Offenses requiring aggravated life imprisonment, life imprisonment, and imprisonment for more than ten years.
Due to the final clause, crimes such as intentional killing, qualified sexual assault and sexual abuse of children, manufacture and trade of narcotics, qualified robbery, and theft from energy facilities (TCK 142/3) are tried in the high criminal court. In contrast, crimes with an upper limit not exceeding ten years, such as migrant smuggling (TCK 79/1: five to eight years) and the form of qualified theft under TCK 142/2 (upper limit ten years), are as a rule tried in the criminal court of first instance, even if qualified circumstances exist. Qualified fraud was removed from the high criminal court's list of duties by Law No. 7571 dated December 24, 2025; through a transitional provision, it was stipulated that cases pending in high criminal courts on that date would be concluded in those courts. Some of the crimes falling under the jurisdiction of the high criminal court are the crime of robbery, drug trafficking, intentional homicide and sexual abuse of children covered in the articles.
Characteristics of High Criminal Proceedings
According to CMK 150/3, the presence of a defense attorney is mandatory in investigations and prosecutions for crimes requiring a prison sentence with a lower limit of more than five years; if the suspect or defendant does not have an attorney, one is appointed by the bar association. The vast majority of files tried in the high criminal court fall within this scope. Objections against the decisions of the high criminal court and its president are, pursuant to CMK 268/3-c, made to the next numbered chamber if there is more than one chamber in that location, or to the nearest high criminal court if there is only one chamber. Furthermore, objections against the decisions of the judge of the criminal court of first instance are examined by the high criminal court within whose judicial district it is located. The high criminal court is also tasked with examining extradition requests from foreign states in accordance with Law No. 6706 on International Judicial Cooperation in Criminal Matters; this subject is in the red notice and extradition request article is also explained.
Juvenile Courts and Other Specialized Criminal Courts
Juvenile Court and Juvenile High Criminal Court
According to Article 25 of the Child Protection Law No. 5395, the juvenile court consists of a single judge and is established in every provincial center; the juvenile high criminal court convenes with a president and two members. According to Article 26 of the same Law, the juvenile court handles cases brought against children in the judicial process regarding crimes within the jurisdiction of the criminal court of first instance; the juvenile high criminal court handles crimes committed by children that fall within the jurisdiction of the high criminal court. The public prosecutor does not attend hearings held in juvenile courts; however, prosecutors may apply for legal remedies against the decisions of these courts.
In cases where children commit crimes together with adults, the investigation and prosecution are, as a rule, conducted separately in accordance with Article 17 of Law No. 5395. If it is deemed necessary to conduct the cases together, a consolidation decision may be issued in general courts, and the consolidated cases are heard in the general courts. Age at the time of the crime is decisive in juvenile proceedings; a person who has not completed the age of eighteen at the time of the act is tried in the juvenile court even if they are an adult during the trial, and the age reduction in TCK 31 and the rule that it cannot be the basis for recidivism pursuant to TCK 58/5 are applied.
Intellectual and Industrial Rights Criminal Court
Pursuant to Article 76 of the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846 and Article 156 of the Industrial Property Law No. 6769, cases related to crimes in these laws are tried in intellectual and industrial rights criminal courts. Copyright infringement, piracy, trademark infringement, and the sale of counterfeit products are the main crimes falling within the jurisdiction of these courts. In places where these courts are not established, the criminal courts of first instance designated by the Council of Judges and Prosecutors perform this duty.
Criminal Duties of the Enforcement Court
Acts such as failure to submit a statement of assets, breach of undertaking, non-compliance with a child delivery order, and non-compliance with maintenance obligations, which are regulated in Articles 331 to 354 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004, are adjudicated by the enforcement court. A significant portion of these acts are sanctioned by enforcement imprisonment or disciplinary imprisonment. According to Article 353 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, objections against the enforcement court’s decisions regarding enforcement imprisonment and disciplinary imprisonment may be filed within two weeks of notification, and the decision rendered upon the objection is final. For verdicts issued regarding crimes contained in this section, the provisions of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure regarding legal remedies apply.
Enforcement Judgeship
Enforcement judgeships, established by the Enforcement Judgeship Law No. 4675, examine complaints regarding procedures concerning convicted persons and detainees in penal execution institutions and disciplinary penalties. Following Law No. 7242 dated 14.04.2020, in accordance with Articles 98 to 101 of Law No. 5275, uncertainties in the calculation of the sentence to be served and the aggregation of sentences in multiple verdicts also fall under the duties of the enforcement judgeship. In the decision of the 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 06.02.2024, in its decision No. E. 2023/12366, K. 2024/1023, a negative jurisdictional conflict that arose between two enforcement judgeships upon a request for resolution of sentence aggregation was resolved. The aggregation of sentences and the resolution of sentencing in the guide on recidivism, serial offenses, and aggregation, whereas transition to an open prison explained in the article on the open prison execution process. has been explained.
Qualities of Decisions Rendered by First Instance Courts
According to Article 223/1 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure, decisions of acquittal, dismissal of a case due to no penalty required, conviction, imposition of security measures, refusal of the case, and dismissal of the case are considered verdicts. Decisions that qualify as verdicts conclude the case and are subject to legal remedies. Decisions other than verdicts are interim decisions; as a rule, these are appealed together with the verdict, or may be objected to if specifically provided for in the law.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Ruling | When is it issued? | Legal Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Acquittal | If the act is not a crime, if the defendant did not commit it, if there is no intent or negligence, if there is a legal justification, or if it is not proven that the crime was committed | Article 223/2 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure |
| No penalty required | Reasons eliminating culpability such as young age, mental illness, state of necessity; effective remorse, personal exemption from penalty, mutual insult, insignificance of the content of the injustice | Article 223/3-4 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure |
| Conviction | If it is proven that the crime was committed | Article 223/5 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure |
| Security measure | If a security measure is required in addition to or instead of a penalty | Article 223/6 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure |
| Dismissal of the case | If there is a previously rendered verdict or a case filed for the same act | Article 223/7 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure |
| Dismissal of the case | Reasons such as statute of limitations, withdrawal of the complaint, death, mediation | Article 223/8 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure |
| Stay of proceedings | If the condition for prosecution has not yet been met; an objection may be filed | Article 223/8 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure |
| Deferral of the announcement of the verdict (HAGB) | For imprisonment of two years or less or judicial fines, if the conditions are met | Article 231 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure |
| Lack of jurisdiction and venue | If the court does not have jurisdiction or venue; an objection procedure is available within the judicial judiciary | Articles 4-5, 17 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure |
According to Article 223/9 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure, in cases where an acquittal can be immediately granted, a decision for a stay of proceedings, dismissal of the case, or a ruling that no penalty is required cannot be issued. This rule protects the defendant’s right to not be tarnished: for example, even if the statute of limitations has expired, if it is understood from the evidence in the file that the defendant did not commit the crime, an acquittal must be issued instead of a dismissal. The conditions of the deferral of the announcement of the verdict institution, which were re-regulated by Law No. 7589 dated 16.07.2026 in the 12th Judicial Package HAGB regulation article has been explained.
A change in the legal characterization of the crime during the trial imposes an additional obligation on the court. In the decision of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation dated 25.10.2023 numbered E. 2022/154, K. 2023/551,, it was accepted that in a case filed for extortion, the application of provisions for aggravated threat against the defendants requires the granting of the right to additional defense in accordance with Article 226 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure, and that failure to do so constitutes a restriction of the right to defense.
Regional Court of Appeal Criminal Chambers (Appellate)
Establishment and Duties
Regional courts of appeal are established in locations determined by considering the geographical conditions and workload of the regions in accordance with Article 25 of Law No. 5235 and have been in operation since July 20, 2016. According to Article 29 of the Law, each regional court of appeal contains at least two criminal chambers; the chambers consist of a presiding judge and members. According to Article 37 of Law No. 5235, the duties of the criminal chambers are to examine applications made against non-final rulings and decisions rendered by criminal courts of first instance, to resolve disputes regarding jurisdiction and authority between criminal courts of first instance within their judicial district, and to decide on the transfer of a case to another court if an obstacle arises for the judges to hear the case.
Which Decisions Can Be Appealed?
According to CMK 272/1, the appellate procedure may be initiated against rulings rendered by courts of first instance; rulings concerning sentences of imprisonment for fifteen years or more are reviewed ex officio by the regional court of appeal. According to CMK 272/3, convictions for judicial fines—excluding those converted from imprisonment—up to and including fifteen thousand Turkish Liras as the final result, acquittal rulings for crimes requiring a judicial fine with an upper limit not exceeding five hundred days, and rulings stated by law to be final cannot be appealed; these rulings also do not form the basis for recidivism. The threshold for final judicial fines was increased from three thousand liras to fifteen thousand liras by Law No. 7499.
Appeal Period
According to CMK 273/1, the request for appeal is made within two weeks from the date the ruling is served together with its reasoned decision by submitting a petition to the court that rendered the ruling or by making a statement to the clerk of the court. Before Law No. 7499 dated March 2, 2024, the period was seven days from the announcement of the ruling, and an additional period was provided for a reasoned appeal petition. Since the period in the new system begins with the service of the reasoned decision, the appeal petition must be prepared to address the reasoned decision and must be filed within this two-week period.
Decisions of the Regional Court of Appeal
According to CMK 280/1, after reviewing the file, the regional court of appeal renders one of the following decisions:
- Dismissal on the merits: If there is no violation of the law in the first instance decision, no deficiency in evidence or procedures, and the evaluation of proof is appropriate.
- Dismissal on the merits with correction: The correction of the violation of the law by the regional court of appeal in limited cases specified by law.
- Reversal and remittal: Only in cases of absolute violation of the law under CMK 289 (280/1-e) or cases where the condition for investigation or prosecution is not met, pre-payment or mediation is not applied, or it is necessary for the case to be conducted together with another case (280/1-f).
- Rendering a new judgment by opening a hearing: In all other cases, the regional court of appeal decides to retry the case; at the end of the hearing, it dismisses the appeal on the merits or vacates the first instance ruling and establishes a new judgment.
The limited nature of the authority to reverse is clearly emphasized in the decisions of the Court of Cassation and the Constitutional Court. In the decision of the 2nd Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated June 22, 2026, with E. 2026/7867, K. 2026/11982, it was stated that the reversal decision rendered by the regional court of appeal over the file on the grounds that the provisions of chain crimes were not applied does not fall within the reasons listed in CMK 280/1-e and f. The Chamber, with reference to the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers decision dated 30.04.2025, E. 2024/6-490, K. 2025/197, and the Constitutional Court decision dated 09.01.2025 with application number 2023/33667, accepted that such reversal decisions without legal basis and the judgments established by the court of first instance based on them are marred by a clear and grave illegality. In the same decision, the Constitutional Court stated that reversal for a reason other than those listed in the law deprives the applicant of their right to appeal and violates their right of access to court.
If the regional court of appeal is to reach a different conclusion than the court of first instance by re-evaluating the evidence, it must hold a hearing. The 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 09.09.2026 in its decision No. E. 2022/712, K. 2026/7699The decision was reversed, stating that a regional court of appeal, which overturned the conviction of a court of first instance and acquitted the defendant without opening a hearing, must perform such an assessment by opening a hearing and summoning the parties in accordance with Article 280/1-g of the CMK.
Extraordinary Remedies Against Regional Court of Appeal Decisions
Pursuant to Article 308/A of the CMK, against final decisions of the criminal chambers of a regional court of appeal, the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office of the regional court of appeal may file an objection with the chamber that issued the decision, either ex officio or upon request, within one month from the date the decision is received; there is no time limit for objections filed in favor of the defendant. For objections filed against the defendant, it is mandatory that there be a substantive error of such a nature that it would affect the decision. If the chamber does not find the objection appropriate, it sends the case file to the Board of Presidents of the criminal chambers. In the decision of the 6th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 20.04.2026, under E. 2025/4399, K. 2026/3454, concerning the file, final decisions of the regional court of appeal rejecting the case on the merits were overturned by this means, and new judgments were established.
According to Article 35 of Law No. 5235, the Board of Presidents of the criminal chambers of the regional court of appeal resolves jurisdictional disputes between chambers and, in the event of a conflict between final decisions of regional courts of appeal in similar cases, requests the resolution of the conflict from the relevant criminal chamber of the Court of Cassation through the Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor of the Court of Cassation. The jurisprudence applied in the decision issued by the 12th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation in 2024 regarding the system queries of public officials, and in its decision dated 11.05.2026, E. 2024/1298, K. 2026/4850, is a conflict resolution decision issued via this method.
Court of Cassation Criminal Chambers (Cassation)
Establishment and Division of Labor
According to Article 5 of the Court of Cassation Law No. 2797, there are twelve civil and twelve criminal chambers in the Court of Cassation. The division of labor between the chambers is determined by a decision prepared by the Board of Presidents and approved by the Grand General Assembly in accordance with Article 14 of the Law. The current division of labor was determined by the decision of the Grand General Assembly of the Court of Cassation dated 29.06.2026 and numbered 2026/1, and was published in the Official Gazette on 30.06.2026. According to this decision, the main types of cases handled by the criminal chambers are as follows:
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Chamber | Primary Offenses |
|---|---|
| 1st Criminal Chamber | Intentional killing and intentional injury (TCK 81-88) |
| 2nd Criminal Chamber | Theft (TCK 141-147), violation of residential immunity, unauthorized use |
| 3rd Criminal Chamber | Genocide and crimes against humanity, crimes against the security of the state, espionage, terrorism legislation |
| 4th Criminal Chamber | Migrant smuggling, human trafficking, defamation, hate and discrimination |
| 5th Criminal Chamber | Embezzlement, extortion, bribery, rigging of tenders, misconduct in public office (TCK 235-266) |
| 6th Criminal Chamber | Threats, blackmail, robbery (TCK 148-152), damage to property |
| 7th Criminal Chamber | Smuggling, crimes arising from banking and petroleum market legislation |
| 8th Criminal Chamber | Torture and torment, counterfeiting of money, praising an offense, some drug-related crimes |
| 9th Criminal Chamber | Sexual assault, child sexual abuse, sexual harassment (TCK 102-105) |
| 10th Criminal Chamber | Some drug-related crimes, food and drug safety |
| 11th Criminal Chamber | Fraud, breach of trust, forgery of documents, cybercrimes |
| 12th Criminal Chamber | Negligent killing and injury, privacy of private life and personal data, traffic safety, obscenity |
Files related to drug offenses are distributed between the 8th and 10th Criminal Chambers based on a shared workload. If a case involves multiple offenses, as a rule, the chamber responsible for the offense with the most severe sanction conducts the review. Since the division of labor changes from time to time, it may be observed in older decisions that the same offense was reviewed by a different chamber; for example, threat cases were reviewed by the 4th Criminal Chamber before July 2026.
Which Decisions Can Be Appealed to the Court of Cassation?
According to CMK 286/1, judgments of criminal chambers of the regional court of appeal, excluding reversals, are subject to appeal on points of law (cassation). However, CMK 286/2 contains an extensive list of exceptions. Accordingly, decisions rejecting an appeal on the merits regarding prison sentences of five years or less or judicial fines of any amount from courts of first instance, decisions that do not increase sentences of five years or less, decisions regarding crimes where the upper limit of the penalty is up to two years imprisonment, decisions regarding crimes requiring judicial fines, and decisions rejecting an appeal on the merits regarding acquittal from crimes requiring ten years or less of imprisonment or judicial fines cannot be appealed on points of law. CMK 286/3 keeps the path to appeal on points of law open for specific crimes regardless of these limits, such as qualified forms of insult, inciting the public to hatred and hostility, armed organizations, and violations of the Law on Meetings and Demonstrations.
The result of this limitation in practice is clear: the majority of cases handled in the criminal court of first instance become final at the regional court of appeal. Therefore, the appeal petition must be prepared as the final legal remedy petition in most cases. Against these final decisions, only extraordinary remedies remain, such as CMK 308/A, extraordinary appeal for the benefit of the law, retrial, or individual application.
Time Limit for Appeal and Grounds for Appeal
According to CMK 291/1, a request for appeal on points of law is made to the court that rendered the judgment within two weeks from the date the judgment is notified along with its reasoning. This period has been rearranged by Law No. 7499. According to CMK 288, an appeal is based solely on the grounds that the judgment is contrary to law; failure to apply a rule of law or its incorrect application constitutes a violation of the law. According to CMK 294, the appellant must state in the petition why they request the judgment to be reversed. Unlike the regional court of appeal, the Court of Cassation does not re-evaluate the material facts as a rule; it supervises whether the evidence was collected in accordance with the law and whether the law was applied correctly. Absolute violations of law under CMK 289 are taken into account even if they are not stated in the appeal petition.
Decisions of the Court of Cassation
- Rejection of the appeal request on the merits: If the judgment of the regional court of appeal is in accordance with the law (CMK 302/1).
- Reversal: Due to violations of law of a nature that would affect the judgment; grounds for reversal are shown separately in the ruling (CMK 302/2-4).
- Upholding with rectification or the Court of Cassation rendering the judgment itself: In cases listed in CMK 303 that do not require a retrial.
According to CMK 304, the Court of Cassation generally sends the reversed file to the regional court of appeal whose judgment was reversed or to another regional court of appeal; if the reversal relates to a decision rejecting an appeal on the merits, it sends it to the court of first instance. According to CMK 307/3, if the reversal decision of the Court of Cassation is complied with, only the path to appeal on points of law can be pursued against the decision rendered by the court of first instance, regardless of appeal or cassation limits. According to CMK 307/4, the regional court of appeal or the court of first instance has the right to resist the reversal decision of the Court of Cassation; the resistance decision is first sent to the chamber that issued the reversal, and if the chamber does not correct its decision, the file goes to the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers. According to CMK 307/5, if the judgment has been appealed only in favor of the defendant, the newly rendered judgment cannot be more severe than the penalty determined by the previous judgment.
Duty of the Court of Cassation as a Court of First Instance
For certain individuals specified by law, criminal chambers of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) serve as the court of first instance. A typical example of this involves crimes arising from the duties of, or personal crimes committed by, first-class judges and prosecutors or those separated as first-class, pursuant to the Judges and Prosecutors Law No. 2802. In these cases, the judgments rendered by the criminal chamber of the Court of Cassation are reviewed on appeal (temyiz) by the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers (Ceza Genel Kurulu) in accordance with Article 15/3 of Law No. 2797. The Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers' decision dated 10.06.2026 Decision No. E. 2025/124, K. 2026/365, acting as a court of first instance, the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation reviewed and reversed the verdict rendered against a judge through this method. According to Article 268/3-e of the CMK, objections against decisions rendered by criminal chambers of the Court of Cassation in cases where they serve as the court of origin are reviewed by the subsequent numbered criminal chamber.
Court of Cassation Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers and Extraordinary Legal Remedies
Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers
According to Article 7 of Law No. 2797, the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers consists of the presidents and members of the criminal chambers. Pursuant to Article 15 of the Law, the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers reviews resistance decisions rendered against the reversal decisions of the Court of Cassation chambers, resolves discrepancies in case law between criminal chambers and cases where a chamber wishes to deviate from established case law through the procedure of unifying case law, and reviews as an appellate court the verdicts rendered by the relevant chambers as a court of first instance. Although the decisions of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers are not legally binding on lower courts, they are considered as guidance in practice; however, decisions on the unification of case law are binding on all courts.
Objection by the Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor at the Court of Cassation (CMK 308)
Article 308 of the CMK was significantly amended by Law No. 7589 dated July 16, 2026. According to the new text, the Chief Public Prosecutor at the Court of Cassation may, ex officio or upon request, file an objection with the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers against all decisions of the criminal chambers of the Court of Cassation, except for decisions on the determination of jurisdiction and decisions of lack of jurisdiction, within three months from the date the case file is delivered to them; there is no time limit for objections filed in favor of the defendant. According to the fourth paragraph added to the article, the objection request may be made by the defendant, those entitled to apply for legal remedies on behalf of the defendant, the intervening party, and those harmed by the crime who may acquire the status of an intervening party. Upon objection, the file is first sent to the chamber that rendered the decision; if the chamber does not correct its decision, the file goes to the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers.
Reversal in Favor of the Law (CMK 309)
The Ministry of Justice, upon learning that there is an illegality in a decision or verdict rendered by a judge or court that has become final without undergoing appellate review or review by the Court of Cassation, notifies the Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor at the Court of Cassation of the request for this decision to be reversed by the Court of Cassation; the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office forwards this request to the relevant criminal chamber. Reversal in favor of the law allows for the correction of final decisions that have not undergone legal remedy supervision. In the decision of the 6th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated May 15, 2025, in Case No. 2025/1811, Decision No. 2025/5333, a final conviction for extortion rendered against a defendant who only made threats to publish photographs without the intent to obtain a benefit was reversed through this method. According to CMK 309/4, if the reason for reversal concerns a decision that does not resolve the merits of the case, the court that rendered the decision conducts a re-examination; in the case of convictions, a reversal in favor of the law does not, as a rule, result in consequences detrimental to the convict.
Retrial
According to Article 311 and subsequent articles of the CMK, a case that has been concluded with a final verdict may be retried in favor of or against the convict for limited reasons enumerated in the law. Major grounds for retrial include rendering a verdict based on forged documents or perjured testimony, the misconduct of a judge who participated in the verdict, the emergence of new events or evidence, and the issuance of a violation decision by the European Court of Human Rights or the Constitutional Court. The request is made to the court that rendered the verdict.
Individual Application to the Constitutional Court and the European Court of Human Rights
After ordinary legal remedies have been exhausted, a person who claims that a right guaranteed by the Constitution and within the scope of the European Convention on Human Rights has been violated may, in accordance with Article 47/5 of Law No. 6216, within thirty days from the date of learning of the final decision, file an application with the Constitutional Court can file an individual application. A violation decision by the Constitutional Court is grounds for a retrial. After the exhaustion of domestic remedies, it must be filed within four months from the notification of the final decision. to the European Court of Human Rights can also be applied. The use of the individual application procedure for foreigners in the individual application petition against a deportation decision explained in the article on the open prison execution process.
Table of Legal Remedies and Time Limits
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Legal remedy | Against which decision | Duration | Authority | Legal Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Appeal | Judge and court decisions (magistrate criminal court, interim decisions) | 2 weeks from the date of learning | The authority specified in CMK 268/3 | CMK 267-271 |
| Appeal (Istinaf) | First instance verdicts | 2 weeks from the service of the reasoned decision | Criminal chamber of the regional court of appeal | CMK 272-273 |
| Appeal on points of law (cassation) | Regional Court of Appeal verdicts | 2 weeks from the service of the reasoned decision | Criminal chamber of the Court of Cassation | CMK 286, 291 |
| Appeal by the Public Prosecutor of the Regional Court of Appeal | Final decisions of the criminal chambers of the Regional Court of Appeal | 1 month from the date of the decision; no time limit for appeals in favor of the defendant | The Chamber, then the Board of Presidents of Criminal Chambers | CMK 308/A |
| Appeal by the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office of the Court of Cassation | Decisions of the criminal chambers of the Court of Cassation | 3 months from the delivery of the file; no time limit for appeals in favor of the defendant | The Chamber, then the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers | CMK 308 |
| Appeal for reversal in favor of the law | Decisions finalized without going through ordinary appeals | No time limit | Criminal chamber of the Court of Cassation | CMK 309 |
| Retrial | Final verdicts | As a rule, no time limit | The court that rendered the judgment | CMK 311-323 |
| Individual application | Finalized decisions | 30 days | Constitutional Court (Anayasa Mahkemesi) | Article 47 of Law No. 6216 |
Criminal Courts Regarding Foreign Nationals
Foreigners who commit crimes in Türkiye are tried in the same courts and by the same procedures as Turkish citizens; there is no separate criminal court for foreigners. Pursuant to TCK 8, a crime is considered committed in Türkiye if the act is partially or fully committed in Türkiye or if the result occurs in Türkiye. For crimes committed in a foreign country that require prosecution in Türkiye under TCK 12-13, the competent court is determined according to CMK 14; if the suspect has not been apprehended and is not a resident in Türkiye, the Court of Cassation determines the competent court upon the request of the Ministry of Justice.
A suspect or defendant who does not speak Turkish is assigned an interpreter at every stage of the investigation and prosecution pursuant to CMK 202; essential parts of the indictment and the verdict are also translated. Regarding foreigners, the criminal judgeship of peace additionally reviews applications against administrative detention decisions pursuant to Article 57/6 of Law No. 6458. Extradition requests by foreign states are evaluated by the High Criminal Court. Lawsuits against deportation decisions are filed in administrative courts, not criminal courts; this matter in the article on deportation decisions, and the residence and citizenship status of the detained foreigner are explained in the article on what happens if a foreigner is arrested. has been explained.
Checklist for a Criminal Case Regarding Courts and Legal Remedies
- Was the case filed in the correct court according to the upper limit of the penalty in the law; were the rules of jurisdiction and the possibility of consolidation due to connectivity examined?
- In cybercrimes, was the jurisdiction of the court at the victim's place of residence evaluated?
- Was the defendant under eighteen years of age at the time of the act; is the case being heard in a juvenile court?
- Has a mandatory defense attorney been appointed for crimes with an upper limit exceeding five years?
- If the legal characterization of the crime has changed, has the right to supplementary defense been granted pursuant to CMK 226?
- When was the reasoned decision served; was the two-week period for appeal or cassation calculated correctly?
- Is the verdict appealable; have the finality limits in CMK 272/3 and 286/2 been checked?
- Has the Regional Court of Appeal issued a reversal decision on the merits for a reason other than those in CMK 280/1-e and f?
- For finalized decisions, have the possibilities and time limits for CMK 308/A, 308, appeal for reversal in favor of the law, or individual application been evaluated?
- Is there a situation that requires an application to the execution judge regarding the enforcement and consolidation of the sentence after finalization?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a criminal court of first instance and a high criminal court?
A high criminal court hears cases specified by law, such as robbery, extortion, terrorism offenses, and offenses requiring more than ten years of imprisonment, and it convenes with a panel of three judges. A criminal court of first instance is a general jurisdiction court with a single judge that hears all cases not covered by these.
Do magistrate criminal courts still exist?
No. Magistrate criminal courts were abolished in 2014 by Law No. 6545, and their judicial duties were transferred to criminal courts of first instance. The magistrate criminal judgeships established in their place do not conduct trials; they handle matters requiring judicial decisions during the investigation phase, such as pre-trial detention, searches, seizures, and blocking access.
Where should one appeal a detention decision by the magistrate criminal judgeship?
With the change made in 2021, objections against detention and judicial control decisions by the magistrate criminal judgeship are reviewed by the judge of the criminal court of first instance within the jurisdiction. Objections to other decisions are made to the next numbered magistrate criminal judgeship. The objection period is two weeks.
Are aggravated forms considered when determining the court's jurisdiction?
No. According to Article 14 of Law No. 5235, the upper limit of the penalty for the offense in the law is taken as the basis when determining jurisdiction, without regard to aggravating or mitigating factors. In contrast, aggravated forms are considered for the statute of limitations and, according to the 2026 decision of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, for the simple trial procedure.
When does the appeal period begin?
Following the amendment made in 2024 with Law No. 7499, the appeal period is two weeks from the date the verdict is notified along with its justification. The seven-day period from the announcement of the verdict in the previous system and the additional justification period have been abolished. The period for appeal on points of law (cassation) is regulated in the same way.
Does every criminal case go to the Court of Cassation?
No. Pursuant to CMK 286/2, many regional court of appeal decisions—such as decisions to uphold convictions for prison sentences of five years or less, judicial fines, and offenses with an upper limit of up to two years—cannot be appealed to the Court of Cassation. The majority of criminal cases of first instance are finalized at the appeal stage.
In which situations can the regional court of appeal overturn the file?
Only in the limited cases listed in CMK 280/1-e and f: absolute violation of law, failure to satisfy a condition of prosecution, failure to apply advance payment or mediation, and the obligation to conduct trials together. In other cases, it must open a hearing and establish a judgment itself. Otherwise, a reversal decision rendered is considered a grave violation of law according to the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay).
What can be done after a Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) decision becomes final?
You may request an objection to the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers through the Yargıtay Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor pursuant to CMK 308; with the 2026 amendment, the defendant and the intervening party can make this request, and the time limit is three months. Furthermore, an individual application to the Constitutional Court within thirty days and, if conditions are met, a retrial is available.
In which court are children tried?
Individuals who have not completed the age of eighteen at the time of the act are tried in juvenile courts for crimes under the jurisdiction of the criminal court of first instance, and in juvenile high criminal courts for crimes under the jurisdiction of the high criminal court. Cases for crimes committed with adults are generally separated; if there is a necessity, they may be combined in the general court.
What does the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers do?
The Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers examines resistance decisions rendered by courts against Yargıtay reversals, objections from the Yargıtay Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor, and judgments rendered by Yargıtay chambers as a court of first instance. It also resolves disagreements in case law between chambers through the unification of case law.
Is there a separate criminal court for foreigners?
No. Foreigners are tried in the same criminal courts and under the same procedure as Turkish citizens; if they do not know Turkish, an interpreter is appointed. Objections to administrative detention are made to the criminal judgeship of peace, and lawsuits against deportation decisions are filed in the administrative court.
What is the reversal for the sake of law (kanun yararına bozma)?
It is the reversal by a Yargıtay criminal chamber of an illegality in a decision that has become final without undergoing appellate or cassation review, upon the request of the Ministry of Justice and the application of the Yargıtay Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor. As a rule, the reversal in conviction judgments does not produce results against the convict.
Conclusion
Turkish criminal justice is divided among the criminal judgeship of peace during the investigation phase; the criminal court of first instance, high criminal court, juvenile court, and special criminal courts during the trial phase; the criminal chambers of the Regional Court of Appeal, the criminal chambers of the Court of Cassation, and the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers during the appeal phase; and execution judgeships during the enforcement phase. Jurisdiction is determined by the upper limit of the penalty in the law and concerns public order; the jurisdiction of the High Criminal Court is specified individually in the law, while everything else is left to the criminal court of first instance.
In 2024, with Law No. 7499, the time limits for appeal (istinaf), appeal on points of law (temyiz), and objection were increased to two weeks and tied to the notification of the reasoned decision; in 2026, with Law No. 7589, the objection period for the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office of the Court of Cassation was increased to three months, and parties were granted the right to request an objection; the division of labor among the criminal chambers of the Court of Cassation was also redetermined effective July 1, 2026. Considering that the reversal authority of the Regional Courts of Appeal is limited and that most cases in the Criminal Courts of First Instance become final at the appeal stage, correctly determining which decision should be brought to which authority and within what time frame is one of the fundamental elements of both defense and representation of victims.
Legal Resources and Related Reviews
Legislation
- Law No. 5235 on the Establishment, Duties and Powers of First Instance Courts of General Jurisdiction and Regional Courts of Appeal, Art. 8-15, 25-37.
- Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271, Art. 3-14, 150, 202, 223, 226, 231, 250, 251, 267-311.
- Law No. 2797 on the Court of Cassation, Art. 5, 7, 14, 15.
- Child Protection Law No. 5395, Art. 17, 25-27.
- Enforcement Judgeship Law No. 4675 and Law No. 5275 on the Execution of Penalties and Security Measures, Art. 98-101.
- Law No. 6216 on the Establishment and Rules of Procedure of the Constitutional Court, Art. 47.
- Yargıtay Resolution of the Plenary Assembly of the Court of Cassation on the division of work dated June 29, 2026, No. 2026/1 (Official Gazette, June 30, 2026, No. 33296).
Court of Cassation Decisions
- Court of Cassation 11th Criminal Chamber, E. 2022/712, K. 2026/7699, T. 09.09.2026
- Court of Cassation 2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2026/7867, K. 2026/11982, T. 06.22.2026
- Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation, E. 2025/124, K. 2026/365, T. 06.10.2026
- Court of Cassation 12th Criminal Chamber, E. 2024/1298, K. 2026/4850, T. 05.11.2026
- Court of Cassation 11th Criminal Chamber, E. 2026/1777, K. 2026/4207, T. 04.20.2026
- Court of Cassation 6th Criminal Chamber, E. 2025/4399, K. 2026/3454, T. 04.20.2026
- Court of Cassation Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, E. 2025/341, K. 2026/172, T. 03.11.2026
- Court of Cassation 6th Criminal Chamber, E. 2025/1811, K. 2025/5333, T. 05.15.2025
- Court of Cassation Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, E. 2024/6-490, K. 2025/197, T. 04.30.2025
- Constitutional Court, Application No. 2023/33667, T. 01.09.2025 (Official Gazette 06.12.2025)
- Court of Cassation 5th Criminal Chamber, E. 2023/12366, K. 2024/1023, T. 06.02.2024
- Court of Cassation Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, E. 2022/154, K. 2023/551, T. 10.25.2023
Related Reviews
Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registration No: 77008
This guide has been prepared based on the current legislation regarding the establishment, duties, and legal remedies of criminal courts, as well as published decisions of the Court of Cassation and the Constitutional Court. Legislative information has been verified as of November 10, 2026. Since legal remedy deadlines and finality thresholds change frequently, the legislation in effect at the time of application must be checked separately for each case file.
The contents on this page are for general information purposes and are open for use by all our colleagues. However, in accordance with the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, if all or a portion of this text is used, we kindly request that you provide a citation in the form of 'Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr' and include a link to the relevant article.