Sample Judgments
This page features court decision analyses prepared by anonymizing personal data across various fields of law. The content is designed to examine the practical aspects of legal disputes and to provide interested parties with general legal information.
The court decision analyses explain the subject matter of the dispute, the core claims of the parties, the court's legal assessment, and the practical significance of the ruling. When sharing decisions concerning lawsuits filed and handled by our firm, personal data and any information that could directly or indirectly allow for identification are anonymized.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.
20 precedent reviews
-
Review the decision: Decision of Non-Prosecution in Auto Spare Parts Fraud Investigation – Bolu Chief Public Prosecutor's Office
Decision of Non-Prosecution in Vehicle Spare Parts Fraud Investigation – Bolu Chief Public Prosecutor's Office
Does the failure of a person who sends money online to purchase auto spare parts to receive their product mean that the crime of fraud has been committed in every case? The purchase price being transferred to another…
-
Review the decision: RESIDENCE PERMIT BASED ON PROPERTY PURCHASED FROM REIT – ISTANBUL 9TH ADMINISTRATIVE LAW DIVISION
RESIDENCE PERMIT OBTAINED FROM A REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST (GYO) – ISTANBUL 9TH ADMINISTRATIVE LITIGATION DIVISION
In the lawsuit filed upon the rejection of the residence permit application based on a residence purchased from a REIT (GYO), the 9th Administrative Law Division of the Istanbul Regional Administrative Court upheld the court of first instance's dismissal of the action concerning…
-
Review the decision: Acquittal Decision in Drug Trafficking Crime | Istanbul 16th Heavy Penal Court
Acquittal Judgment in Drug Trafficking | Istanbul 16th Heavy Penal Court
In a trial resulting in an acquittal for the crime of drug trafficking, the Istanbul 16th Heavy Penal Court ruled that, on the grounds that there was no definitive and convincing evidence supporting the allegation that the defendant sold drugs…
-
Review the decision: Age Correction Lawsuit – Sample Court Decision
Age Correction Lawsuit – Sample Court Judgment
In the age correction lawsuit filed due to the incorrect recording of the date of birth during the acquisition of Turkish citizenship, the Büyükçekmece 4th Civil Court of First Instance based the correction on the correct dates of birth for the two plaintiffs…
-
Review the decision: Example of Recognition of a Divorce Decree Issued by a Foreign Court in Turkey
Example of Recognition of a Divorce Decree Rendered by a Foreign Court in Turkey
In the lawsuit filed for the recognition and enforcement of a divorce decree issued in Azerbaijan within Turkey, the Sivas 2nd Family Court reviewed the decision issued by the Binegedi District Court of Baku City of the Republic of Azerbaijan dated January 22, 2023, and numbered 22…
-
Review the decision: Annulment of the 15-Year Extension of the G-87 Restriction Code: Ankara 26th Administrative Court Decision
Annulment of G-87 Restriction Code Extended for 15 Years: Ankara 26th Administrative Court Ruling
Ankara 26th Administrative Court's ruling concerning a foreign national who was subjected to a 5-year G-87 restriction code in 2012, whose entry ban to Turkey was subsequently extended by 15 years…
-
Review the decision: Withdrawal of the Red Notice and Extradition Request Based on the Principle of Proportionality: Bolu 1st Assize Court Decision
Revocation of Red Notice and Extradition Request Based on the Principle of Proportionality: Bolu 1st Heavy Penal Court Ruling
Bolu 1st Assize Court's ruling to lift the arrest warrant issued against a defendant who was detained in Argentina due to an INTERPOL notice in a criminal case where our firm acts as defense counsel, and instead ordering…
-
Review the decision: Cancellation of Police Officer Performance Score: Absence of Concrete Justification
Annulment of Police Personnel Performance Rating: Lack of Concrete Justification
The cancellation of a police officer's performance score may arise if the reasons for the assigned score cannot be explained with concrete information and documents. The Osmaniye Administrative Court; a police officer's 2023 performance evaluation…
-
Review the decision: Residence Permit Cancellation Decision: Annulment of the Act Due to Deficient Address Verification
Residence Permit Annulment Decision: Annulment of the Act Due to Defective Address Verification
The Istanbul 15th Administrative Court, in its decision numbered E. 2024/2663 and K. 2024/7206, ruled that the cancellation of a foreign property owner's short-term residence permit based on deficient address research was unlawful…
-
Review the decision: Annulment of Deportation Order Issued Without Specifying a Safe Third Country – Istanbul 15th Administrative Court
Annulation of Deportation Order Issued Without Designating a Safe Third Country – Istanbul 15th Administrative Court
The Istanbul 15th Administrative Court, in its decision numbered E. 2024/2102 and K. 2025/427, found the administrative assessment that the foreigner posed a threat to public order and security to be based on legal grounds…
-
Review the decision: Cancellation of Short-Term Residence Permit Due to Inspection Conducted at the Wrong Address
Cancellation of Short-Term Residence Permit Due to Inspection Conducted at the Wrong Address
The Istanbul 16th Administrative Court ruled that an inspection conducted at another property belonging to the foreigner, rather than the address declared in the residence permit extension application, is insufficient to prove that the individual does not reside at the declared address…
-
Review the decision: Annulment Decision Regarding Rejection of Citizenship Through Marriage Due to Lack of Concrete Evidence
Annulment Ruling Regarding the Rejection of Citizenship by Marriage Due to Absence of Concrete Evidence
The rejection of citizenship through marriage may not be deemed lawful if the administration relies solely on a general and abstract assessment of “national security and public order.” The Ankara 12th Administrative Court;…
-
Review the decision: Annulment of Public Order-Based Deportation Order Due to Lack of Concrete Evidence
Annulment of a Deportation Decision Based on Public Order Due to the Absence of Concrete Evidence
A deportation order based on public order grounds cannot be issued by solely taking into account the fact that judicial proceedings have been initiated against the foreigner. The Istanbul 1st Administrative Court; insult and resisting a public official…
-
Review the decision: Child's Age in Citizenship Applications: Annulment Ruling Based on the Application Date
Child's Age in Citizenship Applications: Annulment Ruling Based on the Application Date
Ankara 4th Administrative Court ruled that the age of two children included in an exceptional Turkish citizenship application along with their parents must be evaluated as of the application date. The children's application...
-
Review the decision: Denial of Student Residence Permit: Annulment Ruling Regarding the Rejection of the Extension Request – Siirt Administrative Court
Student Residence Permit Denial: Annulment Ruling Regarding the Denial of the Extension Request – Siirt Administrative Court
In its ruling numbered E. 2023/864 and K. 2024/174, the Siirt Administrative Court held that a foreign national's student residence permit extension request, whose active student status at the university continues, on the grounds that the permit was "used outside the purpose of issuance"...
-
Review the decision: Denial of Commercial Connection Residence Permit: Annulment Ruling Due to Documented Purpose of Stay
Commercial Connection Residence Permit Denial: Annulment Decision Due to Documented Purpose of Stay
The denial of a residence permit based on commercial connections may be unlawful if issued solely on the grounds that "the purpose of stay could not be justified with valid reasons," without evaluating the documents demonstrating the foreign national's commercial activity in Turkey. Istanbul 1....
-
Review the decision: Annulment of Ç-149 Restriction Code Due to Lack of Concrete Evidence
Annulment of the Ç-149 Restriction Code Due to Lack of Concrete Evidence
Ankara 26th Administrative Court ruled that the imposition of the Ç-149 restriction code barring entry to Turkey, enacted without submitting concrete information and documents demonstrating that the foreign national poses a threat to public order or public security...
-
Review the decision: Annulment of Real Estate Residence Permit Revocation and V-69 Entry Ban – Court Ruling
Annulment of Real Estate Residence Permit and Annulment of V-69 Entry Ban – Court Decision
In its ruling numbered E. 2022/1053 and K. 2023/3928, the Istanbul 15th Administrative Court held that since the allegation that the foreign national rented out their residence to someone else could not be proven with concrete evidence, the short-term residence permit for real estate purposes...
-
Review the decision: Annulment of Deportation Order Issued Without Country of Origin Assessment
Annulment Decision of the Deportation Order Issued Without Country of Origin Research
In its ruling numbered E. 2022/4831 and K. 2023/2420, the Istanbul 15th Administrative Court accepted that grounds for deportation had arisen regarding a foreign national who violated the provisions for legal entry into Turkey, but...
-
Review the decision: Decision on the Revocation of the Red Notice – Istanbul 21st Heavy Penal Court
Decision on the Withdrawal of the Red Notice – Istanbul 21st Heavy Penal Court
In a case defended by Atty. Batın Yılmaz, the Istanbul 21st Heavy Penal Court decided via an interim ruling to revoke the red notice issued against the defendant.…
Sample Court Decisions and Legal Analyses
This section includes anonymized court decisions from various practice areas and legal analyses prepared regarding these decisions. The decision analyses outline the subject matter of the dispute, the core claims of the parties, the legal reasoning of the court, and the practical implications of the ruling.
The analyzed decisions stem from cases filed and conducted by Atty. Batın Yılmaz. Prior to publication, all personal data and information that may directly or indirectly lead to identification are anonymized. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal counsel, a definitive legal opinion, or a guarantee of outcome for any specific case.
To access other content sections alongside court decisions, Sample Petitions and Court Decisions you may visit our main page.