Precedent decision reviews

Phone Search Conducted with Consent Ruled a Violation of CMK 134: Yargıtay Overturns Conviction

In this article 14 headings
  1. Short Answer: Does the Defendant's Consent Make a Phone Inspection Lawful?
  2. Citation of the Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber Decision
  3. How Did the Dispute Begin? From a Stopped Vehicle to a Locked Bag
  4. Why Did the Yargıtay Find Consent-Based Phone Inspection Unlawful?
  5. CMK 134 and the Requirement of a Judicial Decision in Phone Inspection
  6. The Fate of Phone Evidence: Three Different Scenarios
  7. Why Could the TCK 188/5 Qualified Circumstance Not Be Applied?
  8. Where and How Was the Case Tried?
  9. What Does the Reversal Decision Mean?
  10. Which Points Should Be Examined in a Similar Case File?
  11. Frequently Asked Questions
  12. Conclusion: Consent Does Not Replace a Judicial Decision, and the Case Changes When Digital Evidence Is Excluded
  13. Legal Resources and Related Reviews
  14. Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Written and reviewed by: Atty. Batın Yılmaz (Istanbul Bar Association, Reg. No: 77008)
Publication:  ·  Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.

Short Answer: Does the Defendant's Consent Make a Phone Inspection Lawful?

It does not. The inspection of a mobile phone is a protective measure requiring a judicial decision under CMK 134, and the defendant's consent cannot replace this condition; a phone inspection performed with consent constitutes a violation of CMK 134. The 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay, in its decision dated May 7, 2025, numbered E. 2025/1446, K. 2025/5295, applied this principle to a case involving drug trafficking. During a search of a suspicious vehicle, cannabis was seized in a locked bag under the floor mat, and the mobile phone of one of the defendants was examined without a court order, based solely on the defendant's statement of consent. The Chamber determined that the evidence obtained from the phone constituted unlawfully obtained evidence and could not be used as a basis for the verdict, and thus unanimously overturned the regional court of justice's decision.

Once the unlawful phone evidence was excluded, the remaining evidence in the file was insufficient to prove that two of the defendants had participated in the drug crime, and the Chamber stated that a verdict of acquittal should be issued for these defendants. For the third defendant, it was requested that the sentence be redetermined as the conditions for the qualified offense under TCK 188/5 were not met. For the general framework related to this topic to the article on what is digital evidence, for precedents on drug acquittal you may refer to the article on acquittal for drug trafficking. and for the framework of unlawful search to our article on unlawful searches For the penalty, elements, execution of the crime, and its consequences for foreigners, please refer to the guide on the crime of drug trafficking. can be consulted.

Citation of the Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber Decision

Title Information
Court 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation
Basis and decision number E. 2025/1446, K. 2025/5295
Decision date 07.05.2025
First instance court Istanbul Anadolu 22nd High Criminal Court
Regional Court of Justice Istanbul Regional Court of Justice 36th Criminal Chamber, rejection of the appeal on its merits
Subject of the lawsuit Drug trafficking pursuant to TCK 188
Opinion of the Prosecutor’s Office (Tebliğname) Upholding
Conclusion Overturning contrary to the prosecutor's notification (Tebliğname)
Vote status Unanimous

How Did the Dispute Begin? From a Stopped Vehicle to a Locked Bag

The incident began when law enforcement officers stopped a vehicle they deemed suspicious. It was observed that the individuals in the vehicle were trying to do something, and during the search, cannabis plants were seized in a locked bag under the right rear floor mat of the vehicle. During the investigation, it was determined that the bag had been left in that spot by one of the defendants in the vehicle. However, the main crux of the dispute was the examination of another defendant's mobile phone during the search without a judge's order, based solely on the defendant's statement of consent. The data obtained from the phone was included among the primary pieces of evidence showing the participation of the other defendants in the crime.

Stage Development Legal consequence
Apprehension Law enforcement stopped the suspicious vehicle; those in the vehicle were observed actively trying to do something. Grounds for a search were prepared.
Search Cannabis was seized in a locked bag under the right rear floor mat; it was determined that one of the defendants had left the bag there. The material subject of the crime was established in terms of the physical substance.
Phone examination Another defendant's mobile phone was examined without a court order, based only on a statement of consent. A protective measure requiring a court order under CMK 134 was implemented without authorization.
First instance The Istanbul Anadolu 22nd High Criminal Court convicted the defendants of drug trafficking. All evidence, including the phone data, was taken as the basis for the verdict.
Appeal (Istinaf) The Istanbul BAM 36th Criminal Chamber rejected the appeal on its merits. The conviction judgment was upheld.
Appeal on points of law (cassation) Defense counsel appealed; the Prosecutor's Office (Tebliğname) expressed an opinion in favor of upholding the conviction. The 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay unanimously overturned the decision, contrary to the prosecutor's notification.

One of the noteworthy procedural aspects of the case is that the Yargıtay Chief Public Prosecutor's Office had expressed an opinion for upholding the conviction in its notification (Tebliğname). The Chamber did not agree with this opinion of the Prosecutor's Office and unanimously overturned the conviction; this is one of the examples in practice showing that the opinion in the Tebliğname does not bind the Yargıtay chamber. The file has been sent to the Istanbul Anadolu 22nd High Criminal Court in accordance with CMK 304/2-a.

Why Did the Yargıtay Find Consent-Based Phone Inspection Unlawful?

The Chamber’s reasoning is based on two fundamental findings. The first finding is that a mobile phone is a digital data carrier within the scope of CMK 134 and that its examination requires a court order. Pursuant to CMK 134/1, searches of computers, computer programs, and computer logs, as well as the making of copies from records, are performed by a court order; in cases where delay is prejudicial, the public prosecutor may also issue a decision, but this decision must be submitted for a judge's approval within twenty-four hours. In its established practice, the Yargıtay considers mobile phones to be within the scope of this article; because phones are digital data carriers containing personal data, messages, call logs, and location information.

The second finding is that the defendant's statement of consent cannot substitute for the decision required by law. In the concrete case file, law enforcement examined the phone based on the defendant's consent; however, the Chamber rejected this approach. CMK 134 mandates a court order or a prosecutor's decision submitted for judicial approval in a timely manner for the application of this protective measure, and this condition cannot be bypassed by the consent of the parties. The background of this approach lies in the protection of fundamental rights: the privacy of private life, regulated in Article 20 of the Constitution, and the freedom of communication, regulated in Article 22, are safeguards that limit state intervention regardless of the individual's will. A statement of consent given by an individual under the pressure of an investigation prevents these safeguards from fulfilling their function.

The defendant's mobile phone was examined based on consent without obtaining a court order under CMK 134. This examination constitutes evidence obtained by unlawful methods and cannot be taken as the basis for a judgment.

The Chamber also explained in detail how the exclusion of the phone evidence changed the balance of evidence in the file. When the unlawful phone data is removed, there is no sufficient and convincing evidence left in the file showing that two of the defendants participated in the drug offense or acted together with the other defendant. It has been determined that an acquittal should be given for these defendants in accordance with the principle that the defendant benefits from doubt. The material evidence in the file, i.e., the determination that the bag of cannabis under the floor mat was left by one defendant, only binds that defendant; without the phone evidence, it cannot be proven that the others were partners in this act.

CMK 134 and the Requirement of a Judicial Decision in Phone Inspection

CMK 134 regulates the measure of search, copying, and seizure on information systems. The first paragraph of the article requires the existence of strong suspicion based on concrete evidence for this measure and that there is no other possibility of obtaining evidence. The authority to decide belongs to the judge; in cases where delay is prejudicial, the public prosecutor may also issue a decision, but this decision must be submitted for a judge's approval within twenty-four hours. If the period expires or the judge decides otherwise, the copies made are destroyed immediately. Unlike the general provisions on search, CMK 134 does not provide for a written order from a law enforcement commander; the reason for this is that the scope and privacy of digital data are much broader compared to a physical search.

In Yargıtay practice, mobile phones are accepted as computers or computer logs within the meaning of CMK 134. This acceptance is based on the fact that phones are not merely a means of communication but contain a digital record of personal life: when messages, photos, location data, internet history, and application contents are considered together, they can reflect nearly the entire private life of an individual. Therefore, a phone examination is not evaluated as a simple seizure or search operation, but as a separate protective measure.

In the examined file, there may be a practical reason for law enforcement's preference to rely on consent: as obtaining a judge's decision requires time, they may have wanted to achieve quick results on the scene with the defendant's consent. However, the Chamber's decision clearly reveals that this practice has no legal basis. A declaration of consent is not a valid source of authority under CMK 134. In the article examining the rules of evidence collection in criminal proceedings, the general framework of this issue is addressed. A similar problem, in the article examining the concept of digital evidence, has been evaluated from a different perspective.

The Fate of Phone Evidence: Three Different Scenarios

The legal consequence of examining a mobile phone changes depending on the authority upon which the examination is based. The table below compares the situation in the examined decision with two alternative scenarios.

Scenario Source of authority CMK 134 compliance Status of evidence Possible outcome
Examined decision (E. 2025/1446) Defendant's declaration of consent No judge's decision; consent was not considered sufficient Unlawful evidence Acquittal for two defendants, sentence reduction required for the third defendant
Examination by judge's decision Judge's decision pursuant to CMK 134/1 Condition fully met Lawfully obtained evidence Phone data can be used as a basis for the verdict
Claim of emergency Public prosecutor's written order Prosecutor's decision is valid if submitted for judge's approval within twenty-four hours; if approval is not obtained, copies are destroyed Unlawful evidence Even if confused with CMK 116 et al., the result does not change

The third row of the table shows a common confusion in practice. CMK 134 allows the public prosecutor to make a decision in cases where delay is disadvantageous; however, if this decision is not submitted for the judge's approval within twenty-four hours or if the judge decides otherwise, the copies obtained are immediately destroyed. Therefore, a phone examination conducted with a prosecutor's decision that is not submitted for the judge's approval will also be considered unlawful. This distinction arises from the fact that digital evidence examination is subject to a different legal regime than physical searches.

When compared to other files examined in the same series, a common thread is observed: when unlawful evidence is excluded, the sufficiency of the remaining evidence determines the result. In the file examining the unauthorized opening of a cargo package, a CMK 129 violation was detected; in the file examining the expiration of the search warrant period, a CMK 116 violation was identified; and in this file, a CMK 134 violation is in question. The common point in all three files is that with the exclusion of improperly obtained evidence, the balance of evidence in the file becomes insufficient for conviction.

Why Could the TCK 188/5 Qualified Circumstance Not Be Applied?

TCK 188/5 regulates that the penalty for the crime of drug trafficking shall be increased if it is committed by three or more persons together. The court of first instance evaluated the three defendants in the file as persons who committed the crime by acting together and applied this qualified state to all defendants. The Yargıtay, however, found this evaluation to be unlawful.

In order for the qualified state to be applied, there must be a common intent among joint perpetrators to commit the same crime together. When the phone evidence is excluded in the examined file, no sufficient evidence remains to show any connection of two of the defendants to the narcotic substance. Although the defendant who left the physical substance at the spot in the vehicle has been identified, there is no independent evidence proving that the other two defendants participated in or were aware of this act. Since the qualified state cannot be applied without proving the common intent for the act, TCK 188/5 should not be applied for the defendant who left the physical substance either; this defendant's sentence should be determined based on the basic form of the crime.

Where and How Was the Case Tried?

The crime of drug trafficking falls under the jurisdiction of the High Criminal Court in accordance with Law No. 5235. The first-instance trial was conducted at the Istanbul Anadolu 22nd High Criminal Court, and the defendants were convicted pursuant to Article 188 of the TCK. The 36th Criminal Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Justice rejected the appeal on its merits. Upon the appeal by the defense counsel, the file was brought before the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay, which rendered its decision based on the file.

The 10th Criminal Chamber is the specialized chamber handling drug-related crimes at the Yargıtay. Although the notification (Tebliğname) presented an opinion in favor of upholding the verdict, the Chamber issued a reversal decision contrary to the notification. The file was sent to the Istanbul Anadolu 22nd High Criminal Court in accordance with CMK 304/2-a. Since the phone evidence was deemed unlawful, it was also decided that a letter be written to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office for the release of two defendants, provided they are not convicted or detained for another crime.

The Chamber's decision against the notification is a concrete example showing that the opinion of the Yargıtay Chief Public Prosecutor's Office is not binding in criminal proceedings. The notification is a form of opinion that the chamber takes into account during its evaluation; however, the final decision rests on the chamber's own legal findings. In this case, the chamber reached a different conclusion by making an assessment under CMK 134, which was not included in the notification.

What Does the Reversal Decision Mean?

The Yargıtay's reversal decision has sent the file back to the first-instance court. The concrete consequences of this reversal differ according to the defendant:

  • It was clearly stated that an acquittal decision must be rendered for the defendant whose phone was examined and for another defendant; when unlawful evidence is excluded, there is insufficient evidence to show these defendants' participation in the crime.
  • It was determined that the qualified circumstance under TCK 188/5 could not be applied to the defendant who left the physical substance, and the sentence should be determined based on the basic form of the crime.
  • A letter has been written for the release of the two defendants who should be acquitted, provided they are not convicted or detained for another crime.

It is also necessary to define the boundaries of the decision: The Chamber does not state that every phone examination will automatically be considered unlawful. The determining factor here is whether the examination was based on a judge's decision. Data obtained from a phone examination conducted with a judge's decision obtained in accordance with CMK 134 can be evaluated as lawful evidence. The difference between a declaration of consent and a judge's decision is the fundamental distinction in this file, and this distinction is, linked to the issues of timing in obtaining evidence in the article examining drug detection periods.

Which Points Should Be Examined in a Similar Case File?

  • It must be meticulously determined which authority source is cited as the basis for the examination of the mobile phone; whether it is a judge's decision, a prosecutor's order, or solely the defendant's declaration of consent. CMK 134 requires a judge's decision or a prosecutor's order submitted for a judge's approval within twenty-four hours; consent does not replace these decisions.
  • The conditions under which the declaration of consent was obtained should be examined; whether the declaration of consent given by the defendant under the pressure of detention or arrest reflects free will must be evaluated.
  • When the unlawful phone evidence is excluded, it must be further evaluated whether the remaining evidence in the file is sufficient for a conviction; in the file examined, this exclusion necessitated acquittal for two defendants.
  • In order to apply the qualified circumstance of TCK 188/5, it must be checked whether the joint intent of action of the joint perpetrators has been proven with independent evidence; when the phone evidence is dropped, this proof may also be invalidated.
  • The applicability of the provisions of legal effect (sirayet) should be considered; an illegality determined for one defendant may also affect other defendants who rely on the same evidence.
  • Of the defendant effective remorse the possibility of benefiting from the provisions should also be evaluated; the position of a defendant who makes a voluntary statement is different from a situation where evidence is examined with consent and subsequently excluded.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a phone inspection conducted with the defendant's consent lawful?

According to the reviewed decision of the Yargıtay 10. Ceza Dairesi, it is not. The inspection of a mobile phone is a protective measure requiring a judicial decision under CMK 134, and the defendant's declaration of consent cannot replace this legal requirement; an inspection performed with consent constitutes unlawful evidence.

Why is a mobile phone evaluated under CMK 134?

In established Yargıtay practice, mobile phones are accepted as digital data carriers containing personal data, messages, call logs, and location information. Due to this nature, the inspection of a phone is subject to the provisions of CMK 134 regarding digital data inspection, rather than general search provisions.

Is a written order from the Public Prosecutor sufficient for a phone inspection?

It is not sufficient on its own. Under CMK 134, the Public Prosecutor may only issue a decision in cases where there is a risk of delay, and this decision must be submitted to a judge for approval within twenty-four hours. If judicial approval is not obtained or if the judge decides otherwise, the copies made and the transcribed texts must be destroyed immediately.

Does the defendant automatically get acquitted when unlawful phone evidence is excluded?

Automatic acquittal is not the case. In the reviewed file, it was determined that acquittal was necessary for two defendants as there was insufficient evidence remaining once the phone evidence was excluded; however, the conviction remained for the third defendant who left the physical substance, only the qualified circumstance was removed.

When can the qualified circumstance of TCK 188/5 be applied?

TCK 188/5 provides for an increased penalty if the crime of drug trafficking is committed by three or more persons acting together. For the qualified circumstance to be applied, the joint intent of the co-perpetrators must be proven with independent and lawful evidence; otherwise, the penalty is determined based on the basic offense.

Can the Yargıtay issue a reversal decision when the notification (Tebliğname) recommends upholding the verdict?

Yes, it can. In the reviewed file, although the Tebliğname recommended upholding the verdict, the Chamber identified a violation of CMK 134 and unanimously issued a reversal decision, contrary to the Tebliğname. The opinion in the Tebliğname is a legal opinion considered by the Chamber but is not binding.

Which court has jurisdiction in a drug trafficking case?

The crime of drug trafficking within the scope of TCK 188 falls under the jurisdiction of the Heavy Penal Court (Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi) pursuant to the Law No. 5235. In the reviewed file, the trial was held at the Istanbul Anadolu 22. Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi, and the appeal review was conducted by the Yargıtay 10. Ceza Dairesi.

Conclusion: Consent Does Not Replace a Judicial Decision, and the Case Changes When Digital Evidence Is Excluded

The decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay dated May 7, 2025, has clearly defined the legal limits of digital evidence examination in drug-related cases. The defendant's statement of consent does not legitimize the examination of a phone, which requires a court order or a prosecutor's decision submitted for court approval under CMK 134. In the examined case, the concrete result of this principle was the necessity of acquittal for two defendants along with the exclusion of the phone evidence.

The message of the decision regarding implementation is clear: law enforcement agencies should obtain a court order in accordance with CMK 134 instead of relying on the defendant's consent to achieve quick results at the crime scene. Although this procedure may take time, it ensures the legal validity of the evidence obtained. A contrary practice may lead to both the exclusion of the evidence and the acquittal of other defendants in the case, as seen in the reviewed file. For the limits of other protective measures used in drug trafficking cases, to the evidence section of the drug trafficking crime guide can be consulted.

Legal Resources and Related Reviews

Legislation

Court of Cassation Decisions

The list contains the decision examined in this article; for all compared and cited decisions, the relevant articles of the same series can be consulted.

  • Court of Cassation 10th Criminal Chamber, E. 2025/1446, K. 2025/5295, T. 07.05.2025

İlgili Yazılar

Author and Legal Information

Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registration No: 77008

This text is a legal decision analysis based on the decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay dated 07.05.2025, E. 2025/1446, K. 2025/5295. The analysis is limited to the published text of the decision; it does not mean that the same result will be obtained in other files.

The contents on this page are for general information purposes and are open for use by all our colleagues. However, in accordance with the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, if all or a portion of this text is used, we kindly request that you provide a citation in the form of 'Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr' and include a link to the relevant article.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Author

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Founding attorney of Batın Yılmaz Law Office. Handles litigation and consultancy in foreigners and citizenship law, as well as criminal, corporate, administrative, real estate, enforcement, and compensation law.

About our office