Precedent decision reviews

Cannabis Greenhouse Set Up at Home: General Assembly of Criminal Chambers Rules It Was for Personal Use

In this article 13 headings
  1. Short Answer: Is Setting Up a Greenhouse and Planting Cannabis Considered Trafficking?
  2. Details of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers Decision
  3. How Did the Dispute Begin? From a Search in Another File to a Greenhouse Setup
  4. Why Did the Majority of the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers Say Possession Instead of Trafficking?
  5. Why Did the Dissenting Opinion Say Trafficking?
  6. Amount or Sales Behavior? Comparison of Two CGK Decisions
  7. What Stages Did the File Go Through?
  8. Consequences and Limits of the Decision
  9. What Points Should Be Examined in a Similar Cannabis File?
  10. Frequently Asked Questions
  11. Conclusion: A Greenhouse Setup Is Not Sufficient for a Presumption of Trafficking; Evidence of Sale Is Required
  12. Legal Resources and Related Reviews
  13. Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Written and reviewed by: Atty. Batın Yılmaz (Istanbul Bar Association, Reg. No: 77008)
Publication:  ·  Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.

Short Answer: Is Setting Up a Greenhouse and Planting Cannabis Considered Trafficking?

Not always; the distinction between cannabis greenhouse possession and trafficking depends on the amount, the manner of possession, and the presence of a sales act. The General Assembly of Criminal Chambers did not accept the fact that 21 cannabis roots were planted by setting up an indoor greenhouse as sole evidence of trafficking and evaluated the defendant's act as possession of narcotic substances for personal use. In its decision dated October 30, 2025, numbered E. 2025/180 and K. 2025/445, the General Assembly rejected by majority vote the objection of the Yargıtay Chief Public Prosecutor's Office regarding the reversal decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay. In the case file, a greenhouse setup equipped with lighting and ventilation systems containing 21 planted cannabis plants was seized in a room at the defendant's residence, and it was determined that approximately 78 grams of net cannabis could be obtained from the dried plants.

The majority of the Assembly applied the principle of 'in dubio pro reo' (the defendant benefits from doubt), noting that the amount of seized cannabis fell within the limits of personal use, the substance was found in a single piece, no precision scales or packaging materials were found in the home, and the act of sale or transfer to others could not be proven. To understand the place of this decision in the distinction between use and trade, you may refer to the article on acquittal for drug trafficking., for methods used in drug detection, for the article on drug detection periods in blood and hair For the penalty, elements, execution of the crime, and its consequences for foreigners, please refer to the guide on the crime of drug trafficking. can be consulted.

Details of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers Decision

Title Information
Court General Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation
Basis and decision number E. 2025/180, K. 2025/445
Decision date 30.10.2025
First instance court Izmir 9th Assize Court, 29.12.2016, 363-335 (acquittal)
Regional Court of Justice Izmir Regional Court of Justice (BAM) 3rd Criminal Chamber, 17.04.2018, 446-575 (reversed and convicted)
10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation 22.10.2024, 18168-24396 (reversal: act constitutes use)
Subject of the lawsuit Drug trafficking pursuant to TCK 188/3, cannabis cultivation pursuant to Law No. 2313, art. 23/5
Conclusion Rejection of the Yargıtay Chief Public Prosecutor's Office objection
Vote status Majority vote (3 members dissenting)

How Did the Dispute Begin? From a Search in Another File to a Greenhouse Setup

The incident occurred on November 20, 2015, during a search conducted on a defendant of another file. While searching the person's home, law enforcement discovered that a room had been converted into a greenhouse setup with lighting and ventilation systems. 21 planted cannabis plants and dried cannabis with a gross weight of 804 grams were seized in the room. According to the laboratory report, while approximately 78 grams of net cannabis could be obtained from the dried plants, it was calculated that approximately 2,107.8 grams of cannabis could be obtained from the 21 planted cannabis roots.

Date and Stage Development Legal consequence
20.11.2015 Search A greenhouse setup, 21 cannabis roots, and dried cannabis were seized during a search directed at the defendant of another file. An investigation was initiated against the defendant; the other person was tried in a separate file.
29.12.2016 First Instance The Izmir 9th Assize Court acquitted the defendant of drug trafficking. The court accepted that the act was committed for the purpose of use.
17.04.2018 Appeal The Izmir BAM 3rd Criminal Chamber overturned the acquittal and issued a conviction judgment. The defendant was sentenced to imprisonment and a judicial fine.
22.10.2024 10th Criminal Chamber The Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber reversed the conviction; assessed the act as use. The file was sent to the local court for re-examination.
30.10.2025 General Assembly of Criminal Chambers The Chief Public Prosecutor's objection was rejected by majority vote; the 10th Criminal Chamber's decision was found to be appropriate. It was finalized that the act constitutes possession for the purpose of use.

Another dimension of the case is the status of the other person who planted the cannabis in the greenhouse setup together with the defendant. This individual was tried in a separate file for the crime of drug trafficking, sentenced to 9 years and 2 months in prison, and this decision was upheld and finalized by the 9th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay. However, the same person later declared that they had planted the cannabis with the defendant for personal use and that they were not engaged in trafficking. The defendant, for their part, consistently maintained at all stages that they cultivated the substance for personal use, purchased the greenhouse materials with a credit card, and never engaged in any sales or transfers.

Why Did the Majority of the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers Say Possession Instead of Trafficking?

The majority of the Board based its determination of the intent to possess on four criteria established in Yargıtay jurisprudence: whether there was any act directed at selling or transferring the substance to another, the location and manner in which the substance was found, the type and quantity of the substance, and whether it was medically determined through a report that the perpetrator is a drug user. In the concrete file, each of these criteria was evaluated in favor of personal use.

Regarding the first criterion, the act of selling or transferring, there is no evidence in the file that the defendant sold, transferred, or prepared the cannabis for sale to another person. The information gathered by law enforcement regarding the trafficking investigation belongs not to the defendant, but to the other person tried in a separate file. The only act attributed to the defendant is cultivating cannabis by setting up a greenhouse and obtaining cannabis; this act alone has not been accepted as evidence of an intent to supply to others.

Regarding the second criterion, the manner of possession, the cannabis was seized in a single piece rather than in packets or doses. No precision scales, materials for portioning, or packaging tools were found in the house. These findings indicate that there is no physical evidence of preparation for trade.

Regarding the third criterion, quantity, the majority of the Board did not take the estimated amount that could be obtained from the planted cannabis (2,107.8 grams) as a basis, but rather the net amount of cannabis that could be obtained from the dried plants actually seized (78 grams). Although this choice is not explicitly justified in the text of the decision, it can be interpreted as acknowledging that there is a difference between the substance actually seized and the estimated calculation in terms of direct evidence. The 78 grams of net cannabis seized was evaluated as being below the personal use limit generally accepted in Yargıtay practice for cannabis derivative substances (usually referring to the annual consumption amount).

Regarding the fourth criterion, the user profile, it is understood from the scope of the file that the defendant is a drug user. The defendant admitted the purpose of use during the investigation phase and stated that they purchased the greenhouse materials with their own credit card.

The current evidence is insufficient to form a full conscientious conviction regarding the intent to sell or give to another. Therefore, in accordance with the principle that the defendant benefits from doubt, the doubt has been interpreted in favor of the defendant.

Evaluating these four criteria together, the Board concluded that the act does not constitute the crime of drug trafficking under TCK 188, but rather the crime of possessing drugs for personal use under TCK 191. This conclusion is a direct application of the principle of 'in dubio pro reo' (the defendant benefits from doubt); since the intent to trade could not be definitively proven with the existing evidence, the doubt was used in favor of the defendant. The objection by the Yargıtay Chief Public Prosecutor's Office regarding trafficking was rejected by a majority of votes, and the reversal decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber was found to be appropriate.

Why Did the Dissenting Opinion Say Trafficking?

Three members of the General Assembly of the Criminal Chambers disagreed with the majority opinion and cast dissenting votes in favor of accepting the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office's objection. Although the detailed reasoning for the dissenting vote is not included in the text of the decision, the fundamental arguments on which the dissenting opinion is based can be summarized as follows, starting from the objection petition and the limits of the majority reasoning.

The strongest argument of the dissenting voters is the nature of the greenhouse setup. Equipping an entire room with a lighting and ventilation system is beyond the preparation that an ordinary user would make; an infrastructure investment at this level may indicate an intent for continuous and high-volume production. In fact, it was calculated that approximately 2,107.8 grams of cannabis could be obtained from the 21 planted cannabis roots; this amount represents a production capacity far exceeding the expectation of annual personal consumption.

The second argument is the final conviction for drug trafficking of the other person who grew cannabis in the same greenhouse setup. This person was sentenced to 9 years and 2 months of imprisonment, and the decision was upheld. According to the dissenting voters, the conclusion that one of two people dealing with the same plants in the same place with the same setup acts for the purpose of trafficking while the other acts for personal use is not fully consistent with the file as a whole.

The main disagreement between the majority and the dissenting opinion lies in the question of whether the greenhouse setup and the estimated production capacity constitute a presumption of trafficking on their own. While the majority focuses on the net amount actually seized and the absence of concrete evidence of sale, the dissenting opinion sees the size of the production infrastructure and the estimated capacity as decisive. This disagreement is a reflection of the ongoing debate regarding whether quantity or intent is the priority criterion in drug files. For the evidence law dimension of the subject, to the article on what is digital evidence can be consulted.

Amount or Sales Behavior? Comparison of Two CGK Decisions

Two decisions rendered by the General Assembly of the Criminal Chambers in the same period demonstrate that it is the act of selling, not the quantity, that is decisive in the distinction between personal use and trafficking. The table below compares the examined decision with a file in which a conviction for trafficking of a small quantity was upheld, highlighting the differences.

Criterion CGK E. 2025/180, K. 2025/445 (examined decision) CGK E. 2023/251, K. 2025/588 (Antalya file)
Amount seized 78 grams of net cannabis + 21 planted cannabis roots 1.64 grams of cocaine
Evidence of sale or transfer None; there are no witnesses to the sale, buyer statements, or communication records in the file There is a sales relationship verified by buyer statements, photo identification, and HTS records
Packaging status In a single piece; no precision scale or packaging materials present Packaging materials ready for sale are present
User profile The defendant stated he was a user and purchased the greenhouse materials with a credit card Medical findings regarding the defendant's user status are not mentioned in the text
Conclusion Personal use (majority vote, objection rejected) Trafficking (unanimous vote, objection accepted)

The conclusion drawn from the comparison table is this: while 78 grams of cannabis is considered personal use, 1.64 grams of cocaine is considered trafficking. This paradoxical appearance proves that quantity is not the sole determinant. In the Antalya file, despite the small quantity, there are statements, identification, and HTS records showing a sales chain; in the Izmir file, despite the large quantity and the greenhouse setup, no sales relationship could be proven. Therefore, what determines the distinction is the nature of the act rather than the substance: the question of whether there is an act aimed at supplying to others directly shapes the result.

This comparison, in the illegal search order is also linked to the legal framework regarding the search conducted; the outcome is determined not only by the manner in which the evidence was obtained but also by what the obtained evidence actually proves. Both General Assembly of Criminal Chambers (CGK) decisions demonstrate that in drug-related cases, quantity is not a threshold in itself; the entire body of evidence in the file is evaluated collectively.

What Stages Did the File Go Through?

The file has passed through five stages, from the court of first instance to the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers. The initial trial was held at the İzmir 9th High Criminal Court, and the defendant was acquitted on December 29, 2016. The court accepted that the act was committed for personal use. This decision was overturned by the 3rd Criminal Chamber of the İzmir Regional Court of Justice on April 17, 2018, and a conviction was entered against the defendant. The sentence amounts mentioned in the text are inconsistent; in one place, 4 years and 2 months of imprisonment and a 20 TL judicial fine are mentioned, while in another, a 3-year and 4-month prison sentence is mentioned in accordance with Law No. 2313.

Upon the appeal filed by the defendant's counsel, the file reached the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), and on October 22, 2024, the 10th Criminal Chamber overturned the decision of the Regional Court of Justice. The rationale for the reversal is that the defendant's act constituted the crime of possession of drugs for personal use, not for trafficking. Subsequently, the Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor of the Court of Cassation appealed to the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers, arguing that the act constituted trafficking. On October 30, 2025, the Assembly rejected this appeal by a majority vote and upheld the reversal decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber.

The fact that the file reached the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers demonstrates how controversial the distinction between personal use and trafficking is. The court of first instance ruled for acquittal, the Regional Court of Justice for conviction, the 10th Criminal Chamber again for personal use, the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office for trafficking, and finally, the majority of the Assembly for personal use. Three different outcomes emerged in five stages; this shows that the same evidence is evaluated differently by different judges and that there is no definitive threshold in cannabis greenhouse cases.

Consequences and Limits of the Decision

With the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers rejecting the appeal, the file was sent to the local court. Within the framework of the 10th Criminal Chamber's reversal decision, the defendant's act will be classified as the crime of possession of drugs for personal use under TCK 191. The practical consequences of the decision can be summarized as follows:

  • The defendant has been spared the heavy sentence required for the crime of trafficking, and the sanction to be applied to their act will be determined under TCK 191; the difference in sentencing between these two crimes is measured in years.
  • The greenhouse setup and the number of planted specimens were not accepted as a sole presumption of trafficking; this finding serves as a precedent for similar cases.
  • The Assembly based its decision on the net amount of cannabis actually seized, not considering the estimated amount that could be obtained from the planted specimens as a deciding factor; this preference continues the debate on how to evaluate the amount of unharvested products in quantity calculations.
  • The principle that the defendant benefits from doubt comes into play whenever the body of evidence in the file cannot conclusively prove the intent of trafficking.

It is also necessary to define the limits of the decision: The Assembly does not state that setting up a greenhouse can never be evidence of trafficking. What was decisive in the examined file is the absence of any other evidence, in addition to the greenhouse setup, indicating a sales relationship. If there had been evidence in the file establishing a sales chain—such as buyer statements, HTS records, money transfers related to the sales price, or witness accounts—the same greenhouse setup and the same quantity could have led to a verdict of trafficking. Indeed, the finalized trafficking conviction of the other person in the same file clearly illustrates this possibility. In the article discussing the rules of evidence collection in criminal proceedings, the principles discussed are directly linked to the evaluation of evidence in this file.

What Points Should Be Examined in a Similar Cannabis File?

  • The existence of a greenhouse setup does not in itself create a presumption of drug trafficking; however, the size of the setup, the degree of professionalism, and the production capacity must be evaluated within the context of the entire case file.
  • When calculating the quantity of the seized substance, the difference between the net amount actually obtained and the amount that could be estimated from the planted specimens must be clarified; in the reviewed decision, the Board relied on the actual amount seized.
  • Concrete evidence indicating the act of sale or transfer to another party must be sought: the existence of evidence such as buyer statements, communication interception records, money transfers, photo identification, or witness testimonies directly changes the outcome.
  • The manner in which the substance is kept must be checked: whether it is in a single piece, divided into doses, or packaged; the presence of precision scales and packaging materials at home influences the result.
  • If a medical finding (blood, urine, or hair test) regarding the defendant being a drug user is present in the file, it can be evaluated as favorable data for the purpose of use; in this regard, the article on drug detection periods serves as a reference.
  • The status of other defendants in the same or connected files should be examined; the fact that a conviction for drug trafficking has become final for one defendant does not automatically point to trafficking intent for another defendant, but it is evaluated within the overall body of evidence.
  • Of the defendant effective remorse the possibility of benefiting from the provisions must also be evaluated; in files where the intent is determined to be for personal use, the mitigation mechanisms under TCK 192 are applied differently.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is setting up an indoor cannabis greenhouse considered a trafficking offense?

According to the reviewed decision of the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers, the existence of a greenhouse setup does not automatically imply trafficking. For a trafficking offense to occur, in addition to the greenhouse setup, there must be concrete evidence indicating an intent to sell or transfer to others; otherwise, the act may be characterized as possession.

Does 78 grams of cannabis fall within the limit for personal use?

In the reviewed case file, the majority of the Board considered the 78 grams of net cannabis that could be obtained from the dried plants to be within the limits of personal use. However, there is no absolute gram threshold in Yargıtay practice; the amount is evaluated in conjunction with other evidence in the file and by referencing expectations for annual personal consumption.

Why was the estimated amount that could be obtained from the planted cannabis not taken as the basis?

The majority of the Board based their decision on the 78 grams obtained from the actually seized dried plants, rather than the estimated 2,107.8 grams that could have been obtained from the 21 planted roots. Although the reasoning for this preference is not explicitly stated in the decision text, it can be said that the evidentiary value of the substance actually seized differs from estimated calculations made from plants that have not yet been harvested.

The other defendant in the same file was convicted of trafficking; why was this defendant considered as possession?

The final conviction for trafficking of the other defendant does not automatically mean that the defendant in the reviewed file will be considered a trafficking offender. Each defendant's act and evidentiary status are evaluated separately; the absence of evidence specific to the defendant regarding sale or transfer is the factor that differentiates the outcome.

How is the 'in dubio pro reo' principle applied in drug cases?

If the intent for trafficking cannot be definitively proven with existing evidence, the doubt is interpreted in favor of the defendant, and the act is accepted as a less severe offense. In the reviewed file, the majority of the Board evaluated the absence of evidence of sale, despite the greenhouse setup, in favor of possession within the framework of this principle.

What is the difference between the offense of planting cannabis and drug trafficking?

The offense of planting cannabis is specifically regulated under Law No. 2313 on the Control of Narcotic Substances. Drug trafficking, on the other hand, is covered under TCK 188. For a person who plants cannabis, both offenses may be evaluated together; however, whether the cannabis obtained from the planted plants is held for use or for trafficking is a separate legal question.

How does one go to the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers in drug cases?

If the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office of the Yargıtay appeals against the reversal decision of the relevant Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay, the file goes to the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers. The Assembly resolves the dispute definitively by either accepting or rejecting the appeal. In the reviewed file, the Chief Prosecutor's Office appealed in the direction of trafficking, and the Board rejected this appeal.

Conclusion: A Greenhouse Setup Is Not Sufficient for a Presumption of Trafficking; Evidence of Sale Is Required

The General Assembly of Criminal Chambers' decision dated October 30, 2025, confirmed that cultivating cannabis at home using a greenhouse system does not automatically constitute a drug trafficking crime. The existence of a greenhouse setup, the scale of production capacity, and the number of planted specimens do not create a presumption of trafficking unless supported by independent evidence showing the intent to sell or transfer. In the reviewed file, the Board evaluated the 78 grams of net cannabis actually seized within the limits of personal use, and considering the absence of packaging materials and precision scales at home, the lack of any evidence establishing a sales chain, and the principle that the defendant benefits from doubt, it classified the act as personal use.

The most striking aspect of the decision emerges from the comparative table: while 1.64 grams of cocaine were considered drug trafficking in the same period, 78 grams of cannabis were considered personal use. This difference shows that the quantity is not the decisive criterion, but rather the presence of sales behavior. For a defendant who sets up a greenhouse to be convicted of drug trafficking, concrete evidence proving a sales relationship must be placed alongside the greenhouse setup; if such evidence is absent, the doubt remains in favor of the defendant. For the general framework on the subject, you may refer to the article on acquittal for drug trafficking. and the guide on the crime of drug trafficking. can be consulted.

Legal Resources and Related Reviews

Legislation

  • Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237, Art. 188/3 (drug trafficking), Art. 191 (possession of drugs for personal use), Art. 192 (effective remorse).
  • Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271, Art. 217 (free assessment of evidence), Art. 223/2-e (acquittal).
  • Law No. 2313 on the Control of Narcotic Substances, Art. 23/5 (cultivation of cannabis).

Court of Cassation Decisions

The list contains the decisions directly examined and compared in this article.

  • Court of Cassation Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, E. 2025/180, K. 2025/445, T. 30.10.2025
  • Court of Cassation General Assembly of Criminal Chambers, E. 2023/251, K. 2025/588, D. 17.12.2025 (comparison)

İlgili Yazılar

Author and Legal Information

Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registration No: 77008

This text is a legal review based on the Court of Cassation General Assembly of Criminal Chambers' decision dated 30.10.2025, E. 2025/180, K. 2025/445. The review is limited to the published text of the decision; it does not imply that the same result will be obtained in other files.

The contents on this page are for general information purposes and are open for use by all our colleagues. However, in accordance with the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, if all or a portion of this text is used, we kindly request that you provide a citation in the form of 'Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr' and include a link to the relevant article.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Author

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Founding attorney of Batın Yılmaz Law Office. Handles litigation and consultancy in foreigners and citizenship law, as well as criminal, corporate, administrative, real estate, enforcement, and compensation law.

About our office