Precedent decision reviews
Work Accident Involving a Foreign Worker Without a Work Permit: The Court of Cassation Overturned Due to Incomplete Investigation
In this article 19 headings
- Short Answer: Foreign worker without a work permit
- Citation of the Court of Cassation 10th Civil Chamber Decision
- How Did the Dispute Begin? Uninsured Work and the Accident of June 17, 2020
- What Did the Employer and SGK Argue, and What Did the Worker Rely On?
- Why Did the Court of Cassation Overturn the Rejection Based on Hospital Statement and Lack of Permit?
- Does the Lack of a Work Permit Make the Employment Contract Invalid?
- Severance, Notice, and Wages: Where Does Each Claim Stand If There Is No Work Permit?
- If There Is No Work Permit, Can SGK Registration and Service Determination Be Requested?
- Can a Foreign Worker I Employed Without Authorization File a Debt Lawsuit?
- How Is Unauthorized Work Proven, and Does Fear of Deportation Affect the Lawsuit?
- Is a Worker Under Temporary or International Protection a Separate Question?
- How Did the Court of Cassation View the Work Permit Debate in Different Files?
- Where Is the Lawsuit Filed, Is Mediation Mandatory?
- The Limits of the Decision and 2026 Developments
- What Should the Worker and Employer Examine in a Similar File?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion: Lack of a Work Permit Is Not a Question with a Single Answer
- Legal Resources and Related Reviews
- Author and Legal Information
Publication: · Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.
Short Answer: Foreign worker without a work permit
They may request and file a lawsuit; however, this does not mean that compensation or a receivable will be adjudicated. The 10th Civil Chamber of the Yargıtay has reversed the dismissal of a work accident claim involving a foreign worker without a work permit, citing incomplete investigation regarding hospital declarations and the lack of a permit. No reasoned decisions have been found in the scanned results that directly resolve severance and notice pay in terms of the lack of a permit.
The Chamber reached this conclusion In the decision dated February 27, 2025, numbered E. 2024/11639, K. 2025/3133 was reached. In the file of the plaintiff of Syrian nationality, the decision of the Regional Court of Justice was set aside and the first-instance decision was unanimously reversed. The reversal does not mean that the plaintiff has won the case or that the incident is considered a work accident; the file has been sent back for the evaluation of the employer's statement in the criminal case file and witness testimonies.
Since the decision is a work accident determination file, it does not contain a ruling on severance, notice pay, or wages; the text draws analogies from decisions not related to foreign workers in these areas. The General Assembly of Civil Chambers included the work of a child under 15, which is prohibited, in the calculation of receivables, while the 9th Civil Chamber found it incorrect to rule for notice pay while protecting wages and overtime in the invalid contract of an employee who does not hold the status of a teacher. The application of these decisions to unauthorized foreigners is the author's assessment and the following results should not be read as a guarantee of rights.
This review is based on published decision texts. For the general conditions of the permit to the foreigner work permit guide, for the sanction applied to the employer article on penalties for unauthorized employment of foreigners can be consulted.
Citation of the Court of Cassation 10th Civil Chamber Decision
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Title | Information |
|---|---|
| Court | Yargıtay 10th Civil Chamber |
| Basis and decision number | E. 2024/11639, K. 2025/3133 |
| Decision date | 27.02.2025 |
| Case type | Determination that the incident dated 17.06.2020 was a work accident |
| First instance | Konya 3rd Labor Court, E. 2021/53, K. 2022/149: Dismissal |
| Appeal (Istinaf) | Konya Regional Court of Justice 9th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/1678, K. 2024/1632: Dismissal on the merits |
| Appellant | Counsel for the plaintiff |
| Conclusion | Setting aside the Regional Court of Justice decision, reversing the first-instance decision |
| Vote status | Unanimous |
| Finalization | The outcome of the trial after the reversal is not understood from the text |
How Did the Dispute Begin? Uninsured Work and the Accident of June 17, 2020
The plaintiff of Syrian nationality claimed that they worked uninsured at the defendant's workplace between May 2020 and July 2020 on a plastic machine. According to the plaintiff, their finger was crushed while taking a piece from the machine on June 17, 2020, resulting in the amputation of the tip of their left finger. Stating that they noticed the incident was not recorded as a work accident in hospital records, that they filed a complaint with the prosecutor's office, and that the Institution did not consider the incident a work accident, they filed a determination lawsuit.
The first-instance court rejected the case, stating that the plaintiff did not have a work permit and had declared in the hospital admission documents that they crushed their hand in a steel door; the Regional Court of Justice also rejected the appeal on the merits.
What Did the Employer and SGK Argue, and What Did the Worker Rely On?
The defendant company argued that the plaintiff came for an interview to get a job, was warned not to touch the machines, and intervened with the machine without authorization before even starting work. According to the company, the accident occurred due to the plaintiff's fault; the Institution reported that no concrete evidence could be reached regarding the occurrence of the incident.
The published summaries of the responses do not contain a defense regarding the work permit, and the absence of a permit appears in the reasoning of the first-instance court. The plaintiff's counsel argued on appeal that relying on the lack of a permit was erroneous, that the permit could be obtained by the employer, and that the defendant employed the plaintiff without making an application. The decision does not contain an explicit assessment of who should have obtained the permit.
Why Did the Court of Cassation Overturn the Rejection Based on Hospital Statement and Lack of Permit?
The Chamber established its reasoning in three steps:
- Conditions for social security coverage. In order to qualify as an insured person within the meaning of Law No. 5510, the employment relationship must, as a rule, be based on a service contract, the work must be performed at a place belonging to the employer, and the person must not be among those listed in the Law as not to be considered insured.
- Conditions for a work accident. It is required that the person who suffered the incident be an insured person and that the incident occurs in one of the circumstances listed in Article 13.
- Unexamined evidence. In the file numbered E. 2022/14 of the Konya 6th Criminal Court of First Instance, the employer (plaintiff) had admitted to the work, given an explicit statement regarding the work accident, and the conviction against him had become final. The witness in the same file was a payroll witness.
The Chamber explained the result with the following sentence:
“...It is erroneous for the court not to accept the incident as a work accident solely based on the plaintiff's statement upon admission to the hospital and the fact that he is a foreigner and does not have a work permit.”
The Chamber stated that the first-instance decision was based on incomplete examination and erroneous evaluation. The word “solely” depends on two factors; the error lies not only in the lack of a permit, but also in considering the hospital statement and the lack of a permit sufficient without examining the criminal file and witnesses. In the new trial, the statements in the criminal file will be evaluated, and if deemed necessary, the witnesses and other persons who have knowledge of the work will be heard.
The Chamber did not list a work permit among the conditions for insurance it enumerated, yet it did not state that the absence of a permit would have no consequences in any file, and it made a limited determination with the expression “solely.”
Does the Lack of a Work Permit Make the Employment Contract Invalid?
In the examined decisions, there is no clear majority answer to this question regarding foreign workers. The discussion proceeds in three steps:
- Prohibition: International Labor Law No. 6735 The second paragraph of Article 6, as quoted in the dissenting opinions, prohibits the unauthorized work and employment of foreigners within the scope.
- Invalidity: According to the decision of the General Assembly of Civil Chambers with E. 2015/1389, K. 2017/1368, pursuant to the Turkish Code of Obligations, Article 27, employment contracts that are contrary to the mandatory and prohibitive provisions of the law are invalid.
- Conclusion: According to the same decision, invalidity in an employment contract is not retroactive. Article 394/3 of the Turkish Code of Obligations states: “A service contract whose invalidity is subsequently realized produces all the effects and consequences of a valid service contract until the service relationship is terminated.”
In a file not concerning a foreign worker, the General Assembly stated that excluding the period during which a worker, who was employed in violation of the law while under the age of 15, worked would be contrary to the Unification of Judgments Decision dated 18.06.1958, E. 1957/20, K. 1958/9 and the principle of interpretation in favor of the worker. It overturned the resistance decision with a different reasoning regarding the date of commencement of work and by a majority vote. The criterion quoted by the Assembly is as follows:
“...that the application of a legal rule requiring the invalidity of a contract in a way that would yield results against the very person whom the invalidation of the contract is intended to protect would be contrary to the legal principle that it must be interpreted in accordance with the purpose of the law...”
The Explicit Question: Whom Does the Work Permit Rule Protect?
The General Assembly decision does not address work permits; attributing this decision to a foreign national without a permit is an inference by the author. The Unification of Jurisprudence Judgment refers to prohibitions imposed for reasons such as age, gender, and heavy labor, and the General Assembly also notes that not all rules in labor legislation are established for the protection of the worker. Whether the primary purpose of the work permit rule is to protect the worker is debatable; an employer may argue that this jurisprudence cannot be applied to a prohibition that does not have a protective purpose. The worker, however, may argue that the prohibition covers both the employee and the employer, that the sanction is foreseen as an administrative fine, and that performed work cannot be left uncompensated.
Among the decisions reviewed, the reasoning that applies the provision of TBK Art. 394 to a foreign national without a permit is not in the majority opinion but in the dissenting opinion within the decision of the 10th Civil Chamber with E. 2022/5942, K. 2022/7922. According to the dissenting opinion, the work of a foreign worker employed without a permit should be accepted as valid, and the rules of individual labor law and social security law should be applied to them.
The second open question is the phrase “subsequently understood,” because how the provision is applied if the employer knew about the lack of permit from the beginning was not discussed in the reviewed decisions. However, the Unification of Jurisprudence Judgment accepted protection even for a person who conceals the situation through fraud, and the General Assembly did not deem the work null and void in the case file where the employer acted in violation of the prohibition.
Severance, Notice, and Wages: Where Does Each Claim Stand If There Is No Work Permit?
Even if invalidity does not have retroactive effect, not every claim is in the same position. The decisions in the lines of wages, severance, and notice pay do not relate to foreign workers; the analogy is the author’s evaluation, and it cannot be said that these decisions will be applied exactly to a foreign national without a permit.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Request | Relevant Decision | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Wages and overtime | 9th Civil Chamber E. 2015/31328: Wages and overtime proven in an invalid contract were protected | The file does not relate to a foreign worker; work and amount must be proven |
| Severance pay | HGK E. 2015/1389: The prohibited period was included in the calculation of labor receivables including severance pay | The file relates to a child worker; the contract ended with death; the period and termination conditions are examined separately |
| Notice pay | 9th Civil Chamber E. 2015/31328: The termination of a worker not possessing the required qualifications was considered justified, the acceptance of notice pay was overturned | The file does not relate to a foreign worker and the lack of a permit; the reason for termination is the qualification requirement in Law No. 5580 |
| Reinstatement | 9th Civil Chamber E. 2014/13164: It was argued that a worker whose permit was cancelled cannot benefit from job security | There is no explicit evaluation regarding this defense in the decision; the termination was deemed valid for another reason |
In the Case File “I Did Not Have a Work Permit, I Was Fired,” the Main Question Is the Reason for Termination
Since no decision that directly resolves this question was encountered in the search results, the following evaluation is an analogy. The closest result is seen in file E. 2015/31328, which does not relate to a foreign worker or the lack of a permit. The contract of the plaintiff, who worked as a teacher at a private education center without a written contract and without providing necessary documents, was considered null and void. The Chamber found it appropriate to rule for wages and overtime pay in accordance with TBK Art. 394/3; it unanimously overturned the decision on February 18, 2019, to award notice pay, accepting that the termination was justified because the plaintiff lacked the teacher qualification. According to the Chamber, both parties were at fault, but the employer's fault did not grant a right to the plaintiff in the face of Law No. 5580.
The employer can use this decision to argue, by analogy, that the absence of a permit is a valid reason for termination. The worker, however, may argue that the decision is based on the professional qualification requirement in Law No. 5580, that the plaintiff in that file presented themselves as a teacher, that the application for the permit could have been made by the employer in that instance, and that the employer was aware of the situation from the beginning. Decision No. E. 2017/9609, K. 2019/8119 although close in terms of the event, it does not provide a standard. There, the employer argued that they terminated the contract immediately upon learning that the plaintiff, who declared they were a dual citizen when starting work, was only a Greek citizen and lacked a permit. The Chamber reversed the total rejection of overtime pay in favor of the plaintiff; the decision does not contain an explicit assessment regarding the permit defense, nor are the accepted receivables clear from the text.
If There Is No Work Permit, Can SGK Registration and Service Determination Be Requested?
A debt lawsuit and insurance status are not the same issue, and the disagreement within the 10th Civil Chamber becomes visible here. In file E. 2022/5942, it was decided to determine that the Syrian national plaintiff worked for one day on April 12, 2017. As expressed in the dissenting opinion, this partial acceptance decision was reversed to investigate the permit; the court complied with the reversal, rejected the case on the grounds that there was no permit, and the Chamber upheld this decision by a majority vote on May 26, 2022. According to the dissenting opinion, the permit requirement is not a validity condition that prevents the determination of service; the result of unauthorized employment is an administrative fine.
In file E. 2025/16745, K. 2026/5404 on the other hand, the employer requested the determination that the incident of January 5, 2018, involving an employee who was stated to be working unregistered in the law enforcement report and was accepted by the Institution as having had a work accident, was not a work accident. The case was rejected, and the Chamber upheld the decision by a majority vote on April 22, 2026. The dissenting opinion stated that foreigners to be considered insured must have legal employment and requested that the permit be investigated. A dissenting opinion in the same direction is also present in five other decisions of the Chamber dated 2025 and 2026 (E. 2024/15659, E. 2024/2915, E. 2025/13339, E. 2025/18983, E. 2025/11871). Two of these dissenting opinions requested rejection due to the lack of a permit, and three requested a permit investigation.
In these six files, the majority did not request a permit investigation but did not write a clear justification regarding the permit, nor did they use the expression of a change in case law. Therefore, the view that an unauthorized foreigner cannot be considered insured remained in the dissenting opinion in these decisions, while the permit investigation was included in the Chamber's reversal justification in file E. 2022/5942. No decision of the General Assembly of Civil Chambers has been found in the scanned results that resolves this issue regarding foreign workers. For the registration obligation to the foreign worker's SGK entry letter can be consulted.
Can a Foreign Worker I Employed Without Authorization File a Debt Lawsuit?
Yes, because the lack of a permit in the examined files did not make the case unfiled, and the courts examined the disputes; the outcome of the case is a separate issue. The employee's wage and compensation claims are private law disputes, while the sanction for unauthorized employment is an administrative issue. According to the 2026 table of the Ministry of Labor and Social Security the fine based on Article 23 of Law No. 6735 is 102,503 TL per foreigner for the employer and 40,977 TL for the dependent foreign worker. There is no reasoning in the examined decisions stating that the payment of this fine eliminates the labor receivable.
Accepting the work and relying only on the lack of a permit can be risky for the employer. In the main decision, the company owner's admission in the criminal file was considered evidence that should be examined in the work accident file; such a statement unregistered employment and can also be used against the employer regarding sanctions for unauthorized employment. More concrete areas of defense include the fact of employment, the amount of wages, payment receipts, and the reason for termination.
How Is Unauthorized Work Proven, and Does Fear of Deportation Affect the Lawsuit?
Results in the opposite direction In the file of the 9th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation with E. 2023/11781, K. 2023/14802 the plaintiff claimed that they worked as a manager in two hotels and had outstanding wage and premium receivables. The defendants also argued the absence of a permit, but the dismissal decision was based not on the absence of a permit but on the failure to prove the employment. The Regional Court of Justice based its decision on social security records and the plaintiff's statements at the police station and the criminal court regarding their stay at the hotel, treating these statements as a confession.
The plaintiff's attorney claimed that the statement made at the high criminal court was given under the instruction of the defendant company's attorney and out of fear of deportation. The Chamber upheld the decision unanimously on October 17, 2023, without making an explicit assessment regarding this allegation. The court of first instance had also stated that even if the employment were accepted, the calculated receivable had been met by payments. This file shows that previous statements can be treated as a confession leading to the conclusion that employment could not be proven, while the main decision indicates that the employer's admission in the criminal file is evidence that must be examined despite the initial statement at the hospital.
The claim of deportation can also be raised regarding settlement documents; In the file of the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation with E. 2022/15677, K. 2025/9369 the plaintiff, an Afghan citizen, claimed that they were injured at the factory where they worked without authorization and were forced to sign a mediation settlement agreement under the threat of being denied medical treatment and deportation. According to the document, the plaintiff was also to waive their claim of having worked at the company. The Chamber did not determine that the threat had occurred but ruled unanimously on June 16, 2025, to vacate and remand, stating that the validity of the document must be examined as a preliminary issue with all evidence. The remand does not mean the document is considered invalid or that compensation is awarded; the Chamber also stated that the allegation of vitiated intent must be concretely provable.
In the examined decisions, the effect of deportation proceedings on labor lawsuits was not addressed; therefore, it cannot be said that it either terminates the lawsuit or protects the plaintiff from this process. The revocation of a work permit and deportation decision are separate administrative files.
Is a Worker Under Temporary or International Protection a Separate Question?
is a somewhat separate question; although the main decision concerns a Syrian national plaintiff, the status of temporary protection was not discussed in the text. The dissenting opinion in the decision E. 2025/16745, relying on Article 29 of the Temporary Protection Regulation, stated that these individuals could also apply for a permit and that legal employment would be sought. No decision specifically addressing the receivables of an international protection applicant or a worker holding such status was found in the examined results.
The situation appears to have changed after the events. The Minister of Interior, in the statement reported by DHA on June 26, 2026, stated that the permit requirement for foreigners under temporary protection has been abolished. According to the announcement dated June 30, 2026, reported by Esas Denetim, employers can directly notify the SGK of Syrians stated to have refugee status at the source, no administrative fines will be applied for the lack of a permit, and the exemption will be for a limited time. This information is based on the Minister's statement and a secondary source; an official text or publication in the Official Gazette could not be verified in this review. There is also no explanation in the sources regarding work performed in past periods. For the distinction based on statuses, protection status and right to work article can be consulted.
How Did the Court of Cassation View the Work Permit Debate in Different Files?
As of November 3, 2026, in the UYAP Precedent Case database, the query for “no work permit” returned 39 Yargıtay decisions, the query for “International Workforce Law” returned 40, and the query for “invalidity subsequently understood” returned 15. The numbers cover only published decisions, including criminal or irrelevant files, and should not be read as a success rate.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Ruling | Case | Where was the work permit discussed? | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10. HD E. 2025/16745, K. 2026/5404 (22.04.2026) | Employer's lawsuit claiming “not a work accident” | Only in the dissenting opinion | Upholding the dismissal, majority vote |
| 4. HD E. 2022/15677, K. 2025/9369 (16.06.2025) | Work accident compensation | In the plaintiff's claim; the dispute is the mediation document | Reversal and annulment, unanimous |
| 10. HD E. 2024/11639, K. 2025/3133 (27.02.2025) | Determination of work accident | In the reasoning of the first instance; the Chamber did not find it sufficient | Reversal and annulment, unanimous |
| 9. HD E. 2023/11781, K. 2023/14802 (17.10.2023) | Salary and premium | In the defense; dismissal was based on the absence of proof | Upholding, unanimous |
| 10. HD E. 2022/5942, K. 2022/7922 (26.05.2022) | Determination of service | In the reversal decision and dissenting opinion | Upholding, majority vote |
| 9. HD E. 2017/9609, K. 2019/8119 (09.04.2019) | Severance, notice pay, and other receivables | Only in the defense | Reversal regarding overtime, unanimous |
| 9. HD E. 2015/31328, K. 2019/3936 (18.02.2019) | Salary, notice pay, and other receivables | Not discussed; absence of teacher status | Reversal regarding notice pay, unanimous |
| HGK E. 2015/1389, K. 2017/1368 (15.11.2017) | Labor receivables | Not discussed; age prohibition | Reversal of the resistance decision with different reasoning, majority vote |
| 9. HD E. 2014/13164, K. 2014/31851 (30.10.2014) | Reinstatement | Only in the defense | Reversal and annulment, dismissal of the case, final, unanimous |
Three conclusions can be drawn from these decisions:
- The absence of a permit was not the sole determining factor: Apart from the decision E. 2022/5942 which complied with the reversal, in the foreign worker files examined, the result was not based on the lack of a permit, but on the evaluation of proof, termination, or procedure.
- Past period receivables and termination compensation must be separated: In the file E. 2015/31328, which is not related to a foreign worker, the salary was protected, but the notice pay was not; the transfer to the unauthorized foreigner is an analogy.
- Silence does not imply acceptance: In the foreign worker files of the 9th Civil Chamber, the permit defense was not discussed; it cannot be concluded from these decisions that the defense was rejected.
Where Is the Lawsuit Filed, Is Mediation Mandatory?
Cited by the 4th Civil Chamber According to Article 3 of the Labor Courts Law No. 7036, it is a mandatory condition to apply to a mediator in claims for receivables and compensation based on law, individual or collective labor agreements, and reinstatement requests. This condition does not apply to material and moral compensation claims arising from work accidents or occupational diseases, nor to related determination, objection, and recourse lawsuits.
The main decision came from the labor court, while the compensation file E. 2022/15677 was heard in the civil court of general jurisdiction. The plaintiff's attorney argued that the unauthorized worker was subject to general provisions, and the 4th Civil Chamber did not make a clear assessment regarding jurisdiction. Therefore, the competent court and time limits must be evaluated according to the concrete request.
The Limits of the Decision and 2026 Developments
- Reversal: The decision is not the end of the case; whether the incident is a work accident or not will be determined in the new trial; this result is not understood from the text.
- Evaluation criteria: The criteria mentioned in the article on the site, which entered into force on August 3, 2026 relate to the employment conditions in the permit application, while the June 2026 exemption relates to the need for a permit. These developments were not addressed in the decision texts and were not read from the official text in this examination. The sources utilized do not indicate that these modified the text of Law No. 6735. The applicable legislation must be checked according to the date of the incident.
What Should the Worker and Employer Examine in a Similar File?
- Evidence of work: Witness statements, payroll witnesses, and criminal file records should be evaluated together (E. 2024/11639).
- Previous statements: Law enforcement, hospital, and court statements can affect the outcome (E. 2023/11781, E. 2024/11639).
- Termination reason: Whether the termination is based on the lack of a permit or another fact must be specifically determined (E. 2017/9609 defense; for analogy see E. 2015/31328).
- Permit history: It should be investigated whether a permit exists (E. 2022/5942), who made the application, and residency status must also be included in the file.
- Settlement documents: The compliance of the mediation process with procedure, the freedom of will, and the scope of the document must be examined (E. 2022/15677).
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a Foreign Worker Without a Work Permit Receive Severance Pay?
In the scanned Court of Cassation decisions, no reasoned decision was found that directly resolves the severance pay of an unauthorized foreigner based on the lack of a permit. Although the General Assembly of Civil Chambers included the illegal working period of a child worker in the calculation of labor receivables, the application to an unauthorized foreigner is only an analogy. The duration of employment and the form of termination are examined separately.
Can a Worker Without a Work Permit Demand Their Wages?
They can request it, but no decision was found that directly resolves the result. The 9th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation found it appropriate to rule on proven wages and overtime pay pursuant to TBK art. 394/3 in an employment contract deemed invalid. Since the file does not pertain to a foreign worker, the application is an analogy; the fact of employment and the amount of wages must be proven.
Does the Lack of a Work Permit Eliminate Notice Pay?
No reasoned Court of Cassation decision that directly resolves this question was found in the scanned results. The 9th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation found it erroneous to rule on notice pay by considering the termination of the contract of an employee who lacked the necessary qualifications as justified. Whether this approach, which does not relate to a foreign worker, can be applied to an unauthorized foreigner is an open question.
Can an Employer Escape a Lawsuit with the Defense 'No Work Permit, Not Considered a Worker'?
The 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation found it erroneous to issue a rejection based solely on the lack of a permit and a hospital statement in a work accident determination. Conversely, in another file dated 2022, the Chamber upheld the rejection of a service determination claim based on the lack of a permit by complying with the reversal. The outcome of the defense can vary depending on the procedural status of the file and the evidence.
What Happens if a Foreign Worker Without a Work Permit Has a Work Accident?
The 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation overturned a rejection based on a hospital statement and the lack of a permit in one file due to incomplete investigation, and upheld the rejection of a lawsuit filed by an employer claiming 'it is not a work accident' in another file. Whether the incident is considered a work accident depends on the evidence; there are also dissenting opinions in the Chamber requesting a permit investigation.
Is the Result Different for a Worker Under Temporary Protection?
The dissenting opinions in the decisions of the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation discussed the temporary protection legislation separately. The Minister of Interior announced in June 2026 that the permit requirement for this group was lifted. The scope of the regulation and its effect on previous work periods should be checked from the official text.
Conclusion: Lack of a Work Permit Is Not a Question with a Single Answer
The decision of the 10th Civil Chamber of the Yargıtay dated February 27, 2025, demonstrates that, in that specific case, the lack of a permit for a foreign worker and a statement made at a hospital are insufficient to dismiss a work accident claim without reviewing the criminal file and witness testimonies. The decision is a reversal; it does not determine that the incident is a work accident and does not issue a judgment regarding severance pay, notice pay, or wages.
Regarding receivables, TBK art. 394/3 and the jurisprudence of the Hukuk Genel Kurulu provide the worker with an opportunity for defense by analogy, while the reason for termination becomes the primary area of defense for the employer. No majority decision adopting this approach for unauthorized foreigners has been encountered. Due to the disagreement within the Chamber and the clear question regarding the protective purpose of the permit, the outcome may vary depending on the file. Therefore, in addition to the permit status, how the employment is proven and why the relationship ended must be examined together.
Legal Resources and Related Reviews
Legislation
- International Workforce Law No. 6735, art. 6 and 23.
- Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, art. 27 and 394.
- Social Insurance and Universal Health Insurance Law No. 5510, art. 4, 6 and 13.
- Labor Courts Law No. 7036, art. 3.
- Law No. 6458 on Foreigners and International Protection, art. 91 and Temporary Protection Regulation, art. 29.
Court of Cassation Decisions
The list contains the decisions mentioned in the letter and does not represent all search results.
- 10th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/11639, K. 2025/3133, D. 27.02.2025
- 10th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/16745, K. 2026/5404, D. 22.04.2026
- 10th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/5942, K. 2022/7922, D. 26.05.2022
- Hukuk Genel Kurulu, E. 2015/1389, K. 2017/1368, D. 15.11.2017
- 9th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/11781, K. 2023/14802, D. 17.10.2023
- 9th Civil Chamber, E. 2017/9609, K. 2019/8119, D. 09.04.2019
- 9th Civil Chamber, E. 2015/31328, K. 2019/3936, D. 18.02.2019
- 9th Civil Chamber, E. 2014/13164, K. 2014/31851, D. 30.10.2014
- 4th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/15677, K. 2025/9369, D. 16.06.2025
Other Resources and Related Articles
- Ministry of Labor and Social Security, table of administrative fines
- DHA news report regarding the Minister of Interior's statement, 26.06.2026.
- Esas Audit, circular regarding the work permit exemption announcement
- Foreigner work permit guide
- Penalty for employing unauthorized foreigners
- SGK registration of a foreign employee
- Is employing illegal immigrants considered migrant smuggling?
Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008
This text is a legal case review based on the Yargıtay 10th Civil Chamber decision dated 27.02.2025, E. 2024/11639, K. 2025/3133. The review is limited to the published decision text; it does not imply that the same result will be obtained in other files.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.