Precedent decision reviews

Is Employing an Illegal Immigrant Migrant Smuggling? Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers Reversed on Procedural Grounds

In this article 15 headings
  1. Short Answer: Is Employing or Housing an Illegal Migrant a Crime of Migrant Smuggling?
  2. Details of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers Decision
  3. How Did the Dispute Begin? The File Extending from the Allegation of Illegal Employment to the Plenary Assembly
  4. What Did the Majority of the Chamber, the Dissenting Opinion, and the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office Think?
  5. Why Did the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers Overturn the Verdict?
  6. How Does TCK 79 Cover Employing Illegal Migrants?
  7. Is Employing a Foreigner Without Permission the Same Thing as Employing an Illegal Migrant?
  8. How Did the Court of Cassation Evaluate Similar Acts?
  9. What Will Happen Next in the File?
  10. What Are the Consequences and Limits of the Decision?
  11. What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?
  12. Frequently Asked Questions
  13. Conclusion: The Assembly Resolved the Procedure; the Employer's Question Remains Subject to the 2020 Criteria
  14. Legal Resources and Related Reviews
  15. Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Written and reviewed by: Atty. Batın Yılmaz (Istanbul Bar Association, Reg. No: 77008)
Publication:  ·  Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.

employing illegal immigrants

employing illegal immigrants

Short Answer: Is Employing or Housing an Illegal Migrant a Crime of Migrant Smuggling?

Employing an illegal immigrant may be considered the crime of migrant smuggling under Article 79 of the TCK, depending on the specific circumstances of the case; however, not every instance of unauthorized employment leads to this outcome. In a 2020 decision, the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) considered an employer to have committed this crime when it was determined that the employer profited by employing undocumented foreigners whom they knew had entered the country illegally and wished to remain in Türkiye. It limited the misdemeanor of employing a foreigner without a work permit to those foreigners who are in the country through legal means.

The Board's decision dated September 9, 2026 E. 2026/209, K. 2026/463 did not resolve this question. The dispute concerned the elements of the offense, but the Assembly remained on a preliminary issue. It unanimously reversed the resistance judgment of the 2nd Criminal Chamber of the Samsun Regional Court of Appeal without examining other aspects, because the public prosecutor’s opinion on the merits had not been requested, the defendant and their defense counsel had not been granted the opportunity to make a statement on the merits, and the defendant had not been asked for their final statement.

This reversal does not indicate whether the defendant is guilty or innocent. The decision also contains no explicit evaluation regarding the correctness of the 2020 standard. The file will be sent back to the local court, and the framework to be referred to regarding the employer's question remains the 2020 Plenary Assembly decision and the decisions of the 4th Criminal Chamber applying it.

This review is based on published decision texts; party information has been redacted in the texts. For the general framework of the offense, see the guide to the offense of migrant smuggling, and for the administrative fine aspect, see the article on penalties for unauthorized employment of foreigners can be consulted.

Details of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers Decision

Title Information
Court General Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation
Basis and decision number Case No. 2026/209, Decision No. 2026/463
Decision date 09.09.2026
Judgment reviewed 2nd Criminal Chamber of the Samsun Regional Court of Appeal, resistance judgment dated 24.09.2025, No. 1782-1889
Resisted reversal 4th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation, Case No. 2024/3621, Decision No. 2025/6886, Date 16.04.2025
Crime Migrant smuggling, TCK Art. 79/1-a
The main dispute Whether the elements of the offense were satisfied
Preliminary issue Rendering a judgment without obtaining an opinion on the merits, without granting an opportunity for defense, and without asking for the defendant’s final statement
Conclusion Reversal of the resistance judgment without examining other aspects, sending the file to the local court
Vote status Unanimous

How Did the Dispute Begin? The File Extending from the Allegation of Illegal Employment to the Plenary Assembly

The incident can only be viewed in the published text through the Chamber’s admission, and this admission is not a final finding. According to the majority of the 4th Criminal Chamber the defendant employed Afghan nationals who entered Türkiye through illegal means, did not have residence or work permits, and had no intention of going to another country, despite knowing they were illegal immigrants. According to the Chamber, the defendant also acted as an intermediary for the migrants' displacement within the country.

The course of the file in the lower courts and the Court of Cassation is as follows:

Date Development Conclusion
28.09.2023 Ordu 1st Criminal Court of First Instance, judgment No. 401-630 2 years and 11 months of imprisonment and a judicial fine of 20,000 TL
04.12.2023 2nd Criminal Chamber of the Samsun Regional Court of Appeal, decision No. 1007-1215 Annulment of the judgment, decision that no penalty shall be imposed
16.04.2025 4th Criminal Chamber, Case No. 2024/3621, Decision No. 2025/6886 Reversal by majority vote, contrary to the public prosecutor’s opinion (tebliğname)
24.09.2025 2nd Criminal Chamber of the Samsun Regional Court of Appeal, decision No. 1782-1889 Resistance to reversal, decision identical to the previous judgment
19.11.2025 Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor at the Court of Cassation, public prosecutor’s opinion (tebliğname) No. 124293 Request for upholding
11.02.2026 4th Criminal Chamber, CMK Art. 307 review, decision No. 11692-3102 Resistance found not justified by majority vote
09.09.2026 Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, Case No. 2026/209, Decision No. 2026/463 Unanimous reversal

The published texts do not contain the date of the offense, the type of work, the duration of employment, or the reasoning of the Regional Court of Appeal. In the decision, the judgment is linked to “Article 223/2-d of the CMK,” whereas the dissenting opinion states it was issued pursuant to “TCK 30/4 and CMK 223/3.” For this reason, the exact reasoning behind the resistance cannot be determined from the text.

What Did the Majority of the Chamber, the Dissenting Opinion, and the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office Think?

The majority of the 4th Criminal Chamber, stating that it adopted the 2020 Plenary Assembly decision, accepted that the defendant enabled the migrants to remain in the country, gained benefits from the advantages of unregistered employment, and that the offense was satisfied with all its elements. According to the majority, the act also corresponded to the misdemeanor of employing a foreigner without a work permit; however, pursuant to Article 15/3 of the Misdemeanors Law, only TCK Art. 79/1-a should be applied. For this reason, the Chamber reversed the decision of no penalty.

Two members voted against. According to the dissenting opinion, the dispute centered on whether the defendant's act fell within the scope of the error of illegality (mistake of law) under Article 30/4 of the TCK. The members collectively evaluated the influx of many people into the country due to the civil war in Syria, the temporary protection regulation dated October 22, 2014, the employment of many individuals across various sectors, and the defendant's level of knowledge as well as their social and cultural circumstances. Based on these facts, they argued that the defendant had fallen into an inevitable error and that the ruling should be upheld. The dissenting opinion also stated that the error of illegality should be interpreted in a manner that does not conflict with Article 4 of the TCK.

The Yargıtay Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor also expressed an opinion in favor of upholding the decision in two stages; the grounds for these notices are not included in the published texts. The Regional Court of Appeal public prosecutor, in their appeal, argued that the elements of the crime had been established and that a judgment had been rendered without holding a hearing.

Why Did the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers Overturn the Verdict?

The Plenary Assembly stated that the dispute was 'related to determining whether the elements of the migrant smuggling crime imputed to the defendant had been established,' but, pursuant to Article 27 of the Yargıtay Internal Regulations, it first examined the procedural issue. According to the file, the reversal decision was read during the session on September 24, 2025, and the public prosecutor stated, 'It is requested that the decision be made to comply with the Yargıtay reversal decision, which is in accordance with procedure and the law,' after which the hearing was concluded. The Plenary Assembly based the reversal on three findings:

  1. There is no opinion on the merits. The prosecutor's request to comply with the reversal cannot be considered a valid and sufficient opinion on the merits of the case.
  2. The opportunity for defense was not granted. The defendant and their counsel, who were present, were not given the opportunity to present a defense on the merits.
  3. The final statement was not requested. The verdict was rendered without asking for the defendant's final statement, contrary to Article 216/3 of the CMK.

The distinction explained by the Plenary Assembly with reference to its previous decisions is as follows:

'The public prosecutor's notification of their statements against a reversal and the presentation of their opinion on the merits are, in principle, prosecutorial actions that have different functions and consequences.'

According to the Plenary Assembly, whether the trial court complies with the reversal or insists on its previous decision, it is a procedural requirement that the opinion on the merits must be 'of such clarity and sufficiency as to allow for the effective exercise of the right to defense.' Once it was accepted that the defendant's right to defense was restricted, the verdict was reversed without examining other aspects. The reversed verdict was for no sentence to be imposed, and the Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor had requested that it be upheld. The decision does not contain an explicit assessment regarding the effect of the outcome of the judgment on this reversal.

Does the New Decision Maintain the 2020 Criterion or Depart from It?

Neither can be inferred from the text of the decision. The 2020 decision appears only in the section relaying the Chamber's grounds for reversal. Since the Plenary Assembly reversed the verdict without examining other aspects, the decision does not contain an explicit evaluation regarding this ground, the discussion on petty offense and benefit, or the opinion on inevitable error. Whether the insistence (resistance) was justified has also not been decided.

How Does TCK 79 Cover Employing Illegal Migrants?

Of the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237, Article 79, paragraph 1, punishes anyone who 'directly or indirectly facilitates the entry of' a foreigner 'into the country or enables their stay in the country' through 'illegal means' for the purpose of 'obtaining material benefit.' Clause (b) of the same paragraph also covers enabling a Turkish citizen or a foreigner to go abroad. Regarding the employer's position, the debate is centered on the phrase 'enables their stay in the country'.

In the 2020 file, it was accepted that the defendant, working as a contractor, employed five individuals who had entered the country illegally at his construction site for several months and, upon the cessation of work, sent them to Istanbul through his nephew. The Chief Public Prosecutor's Office objected, arguing that the act constituted a misdemeanor under the repealed Law No. 4817. The Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers rejected the objection. In the first dispute, the decision was rendered by majority vote, with two members dissenting on the grounds that the act was a misdemeanor; unanimity was reached regarding the nephew's participation.

Element The Board's approach in its 2020 decision
Status of the foreign national A foreigner who has been brought in through illegal means or who, although having entered legally, does not meet the conditions for staying in the country
Providing the opportunity to stay Behaviors that prevent deportation; for example, providing a place to stay or employment, changing their location or hiding them in a way that makes it difficult for authorities to track them. In the concrete case, employment and facilitating relocation were evaluated together.
The purpose of the foreigner Having no intention to go to another country and wanting to stay in Türkiye permanently
The perpetrator's knowledge Employing them while knowing they are undocumented
Intent of material gain Absence of insurance and tax cost obligations, workers not being able to seek their rights due to fear of deportation, avoiding compensation obligations
Relationship with the misdemeanor Only criminal liability pursuant to Article 15/3 of the Misdemeanor Law

According to the Assembly, 'Providing opportunity also means preparing a favorable environment.' The Assembly used this expression in relation to providing the opportunity to go abroad. In the decision dated March 5, 2025, numbered E. 2022/206, K. 2025/106 repeated the same phrases, but did not mention the misdemeanor threshold. The decision of the 4th Criminal Chamber dated November 4, 2020 resolved the dispute where Erzurum Regional Court of Appeal chambers were divided between acquittal and conviction, in a way contrary to the request of the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office and unanimously. This decision is final in accordance with Article 35 of Law No. 5235. In the conclusion section, the Chamber based its decision on the fact that the working conditions lacked legal grounds and that the employer gained 'extra economic benefit'.

According to the Assembly, the temporary hiding of a foreigner to go abroad does not fall under the act of facilitating their stay in the country, but rather the act of facilitating their departure abroad. Therefore, the designation of 'undocumented' does not conclude the characterization on its own; the status and purpose of the foreigner must also be revealed in the case file.

Is Employing a Foreigner Without Permission the Same Thing as Employing an Illegal Migrant?

No. Unauthorized employment concerns the foreigner's lack of a work permit; whereas employing an undocumented immigrant concerns the illegality of the foreigner's presence in the country. According to the 2020 decision, the first question is not 'Did they have a work permit?', but 'How was the foreigner staying in the country?'; knowledge and the purpose of gain are also required. The Assembly drew the line as follows:

'Accordingly, if the perpetrator has employed a foreigner who is in the country through illegal means without a work permit, they have also realized one of the alternative acts of the crime of migrant smuggling, which is providing the opportunity for a foreigner to stay in the country. ... Therefore, the misdemeanor of employing a foreigner who does not have a work permit can only be applicable in terms of foreigners who are in the country through legal means.'

Status of the foreign national Characterization according to the 2020 decision Sanction
Legally in the country, no work permit Misdemeanor can only apply in this group; if there is no right to stay, look at the last line Law No. 6735, Article 23: administrative fine per foreigner
Entered the country illegally, employer knows this, there is a purpose of gain Crime; if the act also fits the misdemeanor, Misdemeanor Law Article 15/3 is applied TCK Article 79/1-a
Entered legally, later lost the conditions for staying Counted within the scope of providing opportunity to stay in an abstract narrative; there is no concrete evaluation regarding this fact in the decision Determined according to the facts of the file

International Labor Law No. 6735 the 2026 amount of the penalty based on Article 23 for the employer, According to the Ministry table is 102,503 TL per foreigner; the amount is re-evaluated each year and is increased by one fold in case of repetition of the act. of Law No. 6458 The sixth paragraph of Article 60 also refers to Law No. 6735 for the obligations of the employer who employs unauthorized workers. According to the announcement conveying the Ministry letter dated January 12, 2026 accommodation, return, and if necessary, health expenses covered by the Migration Administration budget may be collected from the employer in accordance with the ninth paragraph of Article 23 of this Law. For other consequences of unregistered employment regarding the employment of uninsured workers, for the conditions of the legal remedy to the foreigner work permit guide can be consulted.

On Which Side Does a Foreigner Who Has Lost the Right to Legal Entry and Stay Remain?

This is the question the decision leaves open. While the Board has on the one hand entered the legal domain, it has also considered foreigners whose visa has expired or who do not have a work or residence permit to be within the scope of the action of providing the means to stay. On the other hand, it has limited the offense to foreigners who are present through legal means. If this expression refers to the state of being present rather than the moment of entry, an employer hiring a foreigner whose visa has expired may also enter the discussion of the offense. However, the event in the 2020 file relates to illegal entry, and the Board has not concretely resolved this possibility. The reasoning of the article also mentions foreigners who have not been authorized to reside in Türkiye permanently; therefore, the status must be evaluated separately in each specific case. The right to work for persons under temporary protection and international protection is therefore a separate heading.

Does Paying a Wage Eliminate the Element of Benefit?

In the decisions examined, this defense has not been successful. In 2019, the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office argued that the employer's payment of wages and housing of the immigrant served the purpose of meeting labor needs and that the mental element was not established, but the 4th Criminal Chamber did not accept this view. According to the Board, the purpose of benefit is necessary and sufficient for the formation of the offense; it is not required that the benefit be obtained or that it be unjust, as stated in the 2023 and 2025 decisions. However, the 2020 decision explained the employer's benefit by linking it to insurance, tax, and severance pay advantages.

What is the Status of the Inevitable Error Defense?

The question is clear. The dissenting opinion relied on Article 30/4 of the TCK. The reasoning of the Chamber majority and the Plenary Assembly decision do not contain an explicit evaluation regarding the error of wrongfulness. While some of the facts in the dissenting opinion are based on the temporary protection regime for Syrian citizens, the immigrants in the file are of Afghan nationality. How this difference will be evaluated in a retrial cannot be foreseen from the text of the decision.

How Did the Court of Cassation Evaluate Similar Acts?

The table below summarizes eight decisions selected from the UYAP Precedent Decision database in November 2026 (CGK: Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, 4. CD: 4th Criminal Chamber). The selection is limited and should not be interpreted as a success or conviction rate. Among these decisions, there is no example where an acquittal in an employment file was upheld; this does not indicate that no such decision exists.

Ruling Act Point of Discussion Conclusion
CGK, E. 2018/116, K. 2020/279 Illegal employment at a construction site, provision of bus tickets Offense or misdemeanor; participation Objection rejected, conviction remained
4. CD, E. 2020/7843, K. 2020/14998 Uninsured employment, provision of food and housing Indirect benefit Within the scope of TCK 79/1-a, unanimous
4. CD, E. 2024/3621, K. 2025/6886 Intermediation for employment and relocation Elements; error of wrongfulness in dissenting opinion Reversal by majority vote; decision resisted
4. CD, E. 2023/8561, K. 2025/6055 Employing a person as a shepherd Benefit and intent Upholding by majority vote
4. CD, E. 2025/5703, K. 2025/12080 Housing in one's home and transportation to home Contact with smugglers, defense of food payment Upholding by unanimous vote
CGK, E. 2022/206, K. 2025/106 Transportation by minibus to an area near the coast for departure abroad Whether the offense is proven Rejection of objection by majority vote; president and eleven members in dissent
CGK, E. 2020/270, K. 2023/620 Transportation to the port by taxi Wage, knowledge, type of participation Rejection of objection by majority vote
4. CD, E. 2022/17102, K. 2025/5724 Transportation of passengers, some of whom have tickets, in the vehicle Knowledge of being an immigrant, providing means Reversal of conviction by unanimous vote

Four conclusions can be drawn from these decisions:

  • The line is being maintained in employment: The Board's approach has been maintained in the decisions of the 4th Criminal Chamber reviewed after 2020. In file No. E. 2023/8561, the act of employing an Afghan national migrant while knowing they were illegal was considered within this scope, and the conviction decision of the Regional Court of Appeal was upheld.
  • The divergence of opinion continues: The dissenting opinion in the same file stated that the defendant had employed the foreigner as a shepherd for twenty days without knowing their permit status or the manner in which they entered the country, and that there was no intent or personal gain.
  • Knowledge is a separate matter of proof: In case No. E. 2022/17102, the conviction was reversed on the grounds that there was no evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant knew the passengers in the vehicle were immigrants and that the defendant performed the act of facilitating their entry into the country or their stay. A reversal does not imply an acquittal. In contrast, in taxi and minibus cases, the Plenary Assembly has inferred knowledge from facts such as the time, route, and number of passengers.
  • The argument of a normal fare was not deemed sufficient: In case No. E. 2020/270, the immigrants had paid 2,000 Euros per person to a third party for the crossing. The Chief Public Prosecutor's Office argued that there was no evidence that a fee other than a normal taxi fare was received. The Plenary Assembly rejected the appeal, noting that the benefit does not have to be illegitimate, and by citing legal doctrine, also stated that there is no difference between whether the benefit is obtained from the immigrant or a third party.

Is Hosting an Illegal Immigrant or Renting a House to Them a Crime?

Hosting is among the examples of facilitating a stay in the Plenary Assembly's narrative. In case No. E. 2025/5703, the defendant's act of hosting immigrants who lacked temporary protection status in their home was evaluated together with their contact with those who brought them into the country and the acceptance of financial benefit; the appeal argument that the 100 TL was for food costs did not yield a result. Therefore, this case is not a direct precedent for hosting where there is no contact with smugglers.

Regarding renting a house, the following example is found in the Plenary Assembly's text: “...even if the landlord rents their house to immigrants they know to be illegal at the market rate, the crime will be considered committed even though the intended benefit is not illegitimate”. However, this sentence is an example provided by citing doctrine in 2023 and 2025 rulings; the facts of both files relate to transportation. In UYAP, as of November 2026, only these two appeared in the search for “at the market rate, they are illegal” as Court of Cassation rulings; this does not mean there are no other rulings. For this reason, renting a house to a foreigner cases require that what the landlord knew about the foreigner's legal status must be examined separately.

What Will Happen Next in the File?

With the reversal, the judgment of the lower court has been set aside. Since the Samsun Regional Court of Appeal issued this judgment, it is expected that the trial will continue there. According to the Plenary Assembly's decision, an opinion on the merits should be obtained, the defendant and their counsel should be granted the opportunity for defense, and the defendant must be given the final word.

The Plenary Assembly recalled the principle of freedom after reversal and one of its exceptions, the decision to resist, within the framework of CMK Article 307/4. According to the same paragraph, no resistance can be made against decisions given by the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers upon resistance; therefore, the procedural deficiency must be remedied. Since the Assembly did not examine the merits, the direction of the new judgment and its relationship with the 4th Criminal Chamber's reversal cannot be understood from the decision text. If the resulting judgment is appealed, the issue of elements may come before the Court of Cassation again.

What Are the Consequences and Limits of the Decision?

  • Finalization: A reversal is not the end of the case. There is no information in the text regarding the subsequent trial.
  • For the defendant: A reversal is not a conviction or an acquittal; it does not contain a finding as to whether the crime was committed or not.
  • For other cases: The decision does not automatically create consequences for other persons. Procedurally, this reveals that the prosecutor's statement requesting compliance with the reversal in this file does not substitute for an opinion on the merits.
  • Penalty amount: The lower limit depends on the date of the act. Law No. 7445, published in the Official Gazette dated April 5, 2023 Article 16, which entered into force on the date of its publication, amended the phrase “three years” in the first paragraph to “five years.” Since, pursuant to Article 7/2 of the TCK, the law in favor of the perpetrator is applied, the three-year lower limit is generally taken as the basis for acts committed before this date, and the five-year lower limit for acts committed after this date. The 2020 ruling of the 4th Criminal Chamber cites the article as starting from three years, while the ruling numbered E. 2020/270 cites it as imprisonment from five to eight years. The latter citation does not indicate that the five-year limit was applied to that act from 2014. Since the date of the crime is not included in the text of the main file, it cannot be determined which limit was applied.
  • Developments after the decision: No changes to Article 79 of the TCK were identified between September 9, 2026, and the beginning of November 2026. Prior to the decision, no provisions regarding this article were observed in the available summaries of Law No. 7589, published on July 31, 2026. It was not determined that the 13th Judicial Package was submitted to the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye (TBMM) as of the end of October 2026.

What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?

The first step, due to the limitation in the 2020 decision, is to distinguish the foreigner's mode of entry into the country and their status at the time of the act using identity, residence, and protection records. In addition to this, the following issues may directly affect the classification:

  • Employer's knowledge: Case File No. 2022/17102 regarding transportation demonstrates that knowledge must be proven with evidence beyond a reasonable doubt.
  • Source of benefit: Registered or unregistered employment, wages, and side obligations must be compared with the benefit justification in the 2020 decision.
  • Hearing after reversal: In accordance with the main decision, the prosecutor's opinion on the merits, the defense, and the final statement must be clearly tracked in the minutes.
  • Effect on the foreigner: Independent of the criminal file, regarding the foreigner deportation proceedings may come up.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation Decide Whether Employing Illegal Migrants is a Crime in 2026?

No. In its decision dated September 9, 2026, with E. 2026/209 and K. 2026/463, the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers overturned the verdict due to procedural reasons. The Assembly identified a lack of opinion, defense, and final statement regarding the merits and did not examine other aspects.

Does an Employer Who Employs an Illegal Migrant Receive a Sentence for Migrant Smuggling?

Depending on the specific file, they may. In the 2020 decision of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, it was accepted that the employer knowingly employed illegally entered foreigners informally and derived profit. Similar facts trigger the debate regarding TCK 79/1-a; the elements of knowledge and profit are evaluated separately in every file.

What is the Difference Between the Misdemeanor of Employing Illegal Workers and Migrant Smuggling?

According to the 2020 decision of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, the difference lies in the manner of the foreigner's presence in the country. The misdemeanor of employing a foreigner without a work permit can only be considered for foreigners legally present in the country. If the elements of TCK 79/1-a are met in the employment of an illegally present foreigner, liability arises only for the crime pursuant to Article 15/3 of the Law on Misdemeanors.

Does Paying Wages to an Illegal Migrant Eliminate the Crime of Migrant Smuggling?

In the reviewed Court of Cassation decisions, paying wages was not seen as sufficient on its own. The Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers does not require that the benefit be obtained and be unfair; in the 2020 decision, it explains the employer's benefit as the advantages of being relieved from insurance, tax, and severance obligations. The dissenting opinion in the decision numbered E. 2023/8561, however, stated that no benefit was provided.

What is the Penalty for the Crime of Migrant Smuggling?

The sentence stipulated in TCK 79/1, after the amendment made by Article 16 of Law No. 7445, which entered into force on April 5, 2023, is imprisonment from five to eight years and a judicial fine from one thousand to ten thousand days. For acts prior to this date, pursuant to TCK 7/2, the lower limit of three years is generally taken as the basis.

Does the Reversal Decision of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers Mean the Defendant Was Acquitted?

No. The Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers overturned the resistance ruling that there was no room for sentencing due to procedural reasons and sent the file to the local court. This result does not mean an acquittal or a conviction; the result of the retrial cannot be understood from the text of the decision.

Conclusion: The Assembly Resolved the Procedure; the Employer's Question Remains Subject to the 2020 Criteria

The decision of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation dated September 9, 2026, did not establish a new fundamental criterion regarding the employment of illegal immigrants. The decision did not consider the prosecutor's request for compliance with the reversal during the post-reversal hearing in this file as an opinion on the merits, and also made the omission of the defense and final statement a ground for reversal.

The definitive text on the fundamental question is the 2020 decision. According to this decision, knowingly employing a foreigner who is in the country illegally in an unregistered manner may give rise to a discussion under Article 79/1-a of the TCK when combined with the purpose of profit; however, the misdemeanor of unauthorized employment can only apply to foreigners who are in the country through legal channels. For this reason, the first point to look at in similar files before the work permit document is the manner in which the foreigner is present in the country, and the second is whether the employer was aware of this.

Legal Resources and Related Reviews

Legislation

Court of Cassation Decisions

Other Resources and Related Articles

Author and Legal Information

Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008

This text is a legal decision review based on the decision of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation dated 09.09.2026, E. 2026/209, K. 2026/463. The review is limited to the published decision text; it does not mean that the same result will be obtained in other files.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Author

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Founding attorney of Batın Yılmaz Law Office. Handles litigation and consultancy in foreigners and citizenship law, as well as criminal, corporate, administrative, real estate, enforcement, and compensation law.

About our office