Precedent decision reviews

Deadline for Legal Remedies During Judicial Recess: The General Assembly of Criminal Chambers Ruled That It Does Not Run Even in Cases Involving Detainees

In this article 16 headings
  1. Short Answer: How Does the Time Limit for Legal Remedies Run During the Judicial Recess?
  2. Details of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers Decision
  3. How Did the Dispute Begin? The 25 July Service and 29 September Objection
  4. What Did the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office and the Chamber Argue?
  5. Why Did the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers Consider the Objection Timely?
  6. How Is the Time Limit Calculated on the Calendar? Examples with Dates from Decisions
  7. Does “Time Does Not Run” Mean a Suspension in Every Case?
  8. Does the Judicial Recess Rule Change in Cases Involving a Defendant in Pre-Trial Detention?
  9. Can the Same Calculation Be Applied in a Civil Lawsuit?
  10. Did the Law Change After the Decision?
  11. Did the Decision of the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers End the File?
  12. What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?
  13. Frequently Asked Questions
  14. Conclusion: First the Type of File, Then the Date of Service
  15. Legal Resources and Related Reviews
  16. Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Written and reviewed by: Atty. Batın Yılmaz (Istanbul Bar Association, Reg. No: 77008)
Publication:  ·  Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.

legal remedy period during judicial recess

Short Answer: How Does the Time Limit for Legal Remedies Run During the Judicial Recess?

In criminal cases, the time limit for legal remedies does not run during the judicial recess, and this rule does not change in cases involving detainees. According to the Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) General Assembly of Criminal Chambers, if a decision is served during the judicial recess and the entire duration of the time limit falls within the recess, the time limit restarts from 1 September. If service is made before the recess and the time limit expires during the recess, the time limit is extended by three days from the day the recess ends.

The Board established these rules in its decision dated 1 April 2026, E. 2023/558, K. 2026/205 brought together. The Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber had rejected the Yargıtay Public Prosecutor's Office's objection against the defendant on procedural grounds of time; the Plenary Session unanimously annulled this decision and sent the file to the Chamber for a decision to be rendered regarding the grounds of the objection.

The decision concerns the avenue of appeal period in criminal proceedings and does not mean that no period runs during the judicial recess. In civil proceedings, for urgent matters and enforcement court proceedings, a period may expire during the recess; in a criminal file, a period that runs after 1 September may also be missed. The issue of the second recidivism, which is the actual dispute, was not resolved, the file was not closed and it returned to the Chamber.

This review is based on published decision texts and does not replace a personal calculation of the final date. For the general topic of the subject, see the article on when the judicial recess isfor another file where the Criminal General Assembly reached a conclusion from a procedural point the review on employing illegal immigrants can be consulted.

Details of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers Decision

Title Information
Court General Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation
Basis and decision number E. 2023/558, K. 2026/205
Date of deliberation 01.04.2026
Annulled decision Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber's decision dated 01.11.2023, numbered 16557-9301, rejecting the objection on time grounds
The confirmation subject to objection Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber's decision dated 21.06.2023, numbered 17305-5827
Objecting party Yargıtay Public Prosecutor's Office, dated 29.09.2023, numbered 95415, against the defendant
Legal Basis Law No. 5271, Art. 308 and Art. 331
Conclusion Annulment of the Chamber decision; sending the file to the Chamber to be decided upon the grounds of objection
Vote status Unanimous
Unresolved issue Conditions for the application of second-time recidivism provisions for the defendant

How Did the Dispute Begin? The 25 July Service and 29 September Objection

In the conviction judgment against the defendant, it was also decided that the sentence be served according to the special execution regime for recidivists. Appeals were rejected on the merits, and upon cassation, the Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber confirmed the judgment on 21 June 2023; in the confirmation decision, it deemed it possible to observe the non-applicability of second-time recidivism provisions at the execution stage.

The Chamber decision reached the Public Prosecutor's Office during the judicial recess, and the Public Prosecutor's Office objected against the defendant after the recess, on 29 September 2023. The Chamber did not examine this objection on the merits, rejected it on time grounds and sent the file to the First Presidency of the Yargıtay.

Date Development Legal Significance
21.06.2023 The Chamber confirmed the judgment. It is the subject of the objection.
18.07.2023 Electronic signature phase completed. The date is before the recess, but the Assembly tied the period to the delivery date.
25.07.2023 The decision was delivered to the Public Prosecutor's Office. Delivery is during the judicial recess.
29.09.2023 The Public Prosecutor's Office filed an objection against the defendant. It is the subject of the time period dispute.
01.11.2023 The Chamber rejected the objection on time grounds. It is the decision that the Assembly annulled.
01.04.2026 The Assembly annulled the Chamber decision. The file returned to the Chamber for the grounds of objection.

Note on the text: In the Chamber's decision dated 01.11.2023, the delivery date is mentioned as 27.07.2023, while in the events and evaluation sections of the Assembly decision, it is mentioned as 25.07.2023. The Assembly tied this date to the barcode scan; the Assembly's date was taken as the basis in the review, and since both dates are during the recess, no difference arises regarding the Assembly's rule. The Assembly text also makes a reference to the decision dated 22.04.2026, numbered 621-265. Since the first deliberation date is 25.03.2026 and the decision date is 22.04.2026 in the text of the decision E. 2025/621, K. 2026/265 itself, the reference indicates a date after the 01.04.2026 deliberation of the main decision. The reason for this sequence is not understood from the texts. The context of the term "CMK Art. 311" in the doctrinal transfer suggests Art. 331, but no comparison was made with the original work.

What Did the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office and the Chamber Argue?

According to the Public Prosecutor's Office's objection regarding the merits, it was not important that the first crime was committed before 1 June 2005 for second-time recidivism, and the defendant's previous convictions constituted the basis for second-time recidivism. Even if it were to be accepted that the conditions were not met, the decision should have been corrected by removing the relevant part from the judgment; a confirmation that would create hesitation in execution should not have been made.

Without addressing the grounds for the objection, the Chamber accepted that the objection was made after the period specified in Article 308/1 of the CMK, once the periods suspended due to the judicial recess were added; the published text does not show the details of this calculation. For this reason, although the Board stated that the dispute concerned a second instance of recidivism, it prioritized two preliminary questions. Was the objection filed within the time limit, and could the Board conduct an examination before the Chamber made a decision regarding the objection?

Why Did the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers Consider the Objection Timely?

The reasoning begins with the fourth paragraph of Article 331 of the Turkish Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK) No. 5271, which is quoted in the Board's text as follows:

“Periods falling within the judicial recess do not run. These periods shall be deemed to have been extended by three days from the day the recess ends.”

The Board has applied this provision in four steps:

  1. There is a general rule. The fourth paragraph establishes a general rule that time periods do not run during the judicial recess. According to the Board, the purpose is to prevent the loss of rights of the concerned parties during the period when courts are on recess.
  2. There is no exception for cases involving detainees. There is no exception in the law for cases heard during the recess, and the Board considers this a conscious choice by the legislator. Hearing cases involving detainees during the recess is a safeguard; this safeguard cannot be used to impose unnecessary and disproportionate burdens on the concerned parties regarding access to the court.
  3. Established rules of time periods apply. If service was made before the recess and the period expires during the recess, the period is extended by three days from the day the recess ends, regardless of the portion that elapsed before the recess. If the entire period coincides with the recess due to the decision being served during the recess, the period starts running from 1 September; service performed during the recess is valid, but the period does not run during the recess.
  4. These rules also cover prosecutors. The Board stated that these rules are also valid for the periods granted to public prosecutors and considered the Office of the Supreme Court of Appeals Chief Public Prosecutor as one of the authorities handling criminal cases.

After quoting its previous decisions and the R.S. decision of the Constitutional Court, the Board concluded as follows:

“Accordingly, it should be understood that the rule that periods do not run during the judicial recess pursuant to Article 331/4 of the CMK must be applied to all cases without distinction between those involving detainees or not.”

According to the Board, which overcame the issue of time limits, pursuant to Article 308/3 of the CMK, the objection is first examined by the Chamber whose decision is objected to; if it finds the objection well-founded, it corrects its decision; if not, it sends the file to the Board. Since the Chamber did not evaluate the grounds for the objection, the Board did not enter into the merits, but set aside the Chamber's decision and sent the file back.

How Is the Time Limit Calculated on the Calendar? Examples with Dates from Decisions

The Board only stated that the period would start from 1 September and that the objection was filed in due time, but did not write the final date or the simplified calculation; the intermediate calculations below belong to this analysis.

  1. According to the Board's determination of the facts, the judicial recess is between 20 July and 31 August, and the judicial year begins as of 1 September.
  2. The judgment was delivered on 25.07.2023, that is, during the recess; delivery is valid, but the period does not run during the recess.
  3. If the one-month period were calculated as if there were no recess, it would have expired on 25.08.2023, and since this date is also within the recess, the entire period coincides with the recess.
  4. The period starts to run from 1 September 2023, and the objection dated 29.09.2023, filed 28 days after 1 September, is within the one-month period.

The table below shows the actual dates in criminal decisions; the “simplified calculation” column is the count made as if there were no recess, without considering the effect of weekends and public holidays. The periods are the ones applied on those dates.

Ruling Service or delivery Duration Simplified calculation Rule Application Conclusion
CGK E. 2023/558 25.07.2023, during the recess One month 25.08.2023 Starts from 1 September 29.09.2023 In due time
CGK E. 2021/319 21.07.2020, during the recess 15 days 05.08.2020 Period does not run during the recess 02.09.2020 In due time
CGK E. 2018/566 27.07.2017, during the recess 7 days 03.08.2017 Calculated from the end of the recess; the last day indicated by the Board is 07.09.2017 11.09.2017 Period expired
1st CD E. 2022/4127 06.07.2020, before the recess 15 days (assumption) 21.07.2020 No calculation in the judgment 04.08.2020 Rejection of the time period was set aside, the cassation appeal was rejected on its merits

The date of 05.08.2020 in the file numbered E. 2021/319 is the calculation of the Regional Court of Appeal, and other simplified calculations belong to this analysis. The 1st Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation did not write the period as days in its judgment and did not make the three-day calculation; the 15 days in the last row is an assumption taken from the period in the file numbered E. 2021/319 related to the same year.

According to the current Article 273/1 and Article 291/1 of the CMK, the period for filing an appeal and a cassation appeal is two weeks from the date on which the verdict is served together with its grounds; Article 263 is reserved for the defendant in pre-trial detention. As the commencement and calculation of the periods are regulated in Article 39, as stated by the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers, the start date and the end date must be calculated separately in each file; the dates in the table are not a guarantee of the last day for any other file.

Does “Time Does Not Run” Mean a Suspension in Every Case?

No, although the law states that it "does not run," the rules listed by the Assembly produce two different results. If the service was performed during the judicial recess and the entire period falls within the recess, the period starts from 1 September. If the service was performed before the recess and the period ends during the recess, the part that runs before the recess is not considered; the period is extended by only three days from the day the recess ends.

The difference can be seen through an assumption. If the 15-day cassation appeal period in 2020 is counted from 31 August, the three-day rule points to 3 September for a service on 6 July, and the period running from the beginning points to 15 September for a service on 21 July. This count is consistent with the date of 7 September in the file numbered E. 2018/566 regarding the seven-day period, but these two dates were not calculated in the decisions, and the effect of the weekend and public holidays was not taken into account.

Questions Left Open by the Decision

  • If the service is performed during the judicial recess and the period expires after the recess: The Assembly's rule is applied when the "entirety of the period" falls within the recess, whereas in the case of service performed in the final days of the recess, the two-week period carries over to September by simple calculation. Although the Assembly's reasoning that the period runs from the day the recess ends and the Unification of Case Law decision dated 1934 it cited suggest the same result, this situation is not the subject of the dispute in the main file.
  • In whose interest the rule works: The reasoning is based on the aim of preventing the loss of rights of the parties concerned and the defendant's access to the court in pre-trial detention, while the concrete result is that the objection filed against the defendant is deemed to be within the time limit. This result is supported by the finding that the rules also cover prosecutors, and there is no explicit evaluation in the decision regarding this tension.
  • Whether the file involves a defendant in pre-trial detention: The Assembly linked the basis of the dispute to cases involving defendants in pre-trial detention; however, there is no explicit finding in the facts section regarding the pre-trial detention status of the defendant.
  • The limit of the phrase "in all cases": The Assembly's evaluation of the period relates to the period for legal remedies; there is no explicit evaluation in the decision regarding periods such as the period for filing a criminal complaint or the statute of limitations.

Does the Judicial Recess Rule Change in Cases Involving a Defendant in Pre-Trial Detention?

No, but the practice has reached this point by passing through different decisions. The former view accepted that the period also runs for cases that can be heard during the judicial recess. In the file numbered E. 2021/319 The dissenting opinion of the Regional Court of Appeal, the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office and a member of the Chamber was based on this view. The 1st Criminal Chamber of the Yargitay also decided to reject the request for cassation appeal in a case involving a defendant in pre-trial detention due to the time limit in its decision dated 17 May 2021, by referring to the decision of the CGK numbered E. 2018/1-161, K. 2020/243; the decision referred to was not read in this analysis.

The line followed by the main decision is seen in the decision dated 10 June 2021, in the decision numbered E. 2018/566, K. 2021/274 it is observed; it is not explicitly stated in the examined decisions that this is a change in case law. The Assembly stated that, unlike the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK), there is no explicit regulation in the CMK stating that the period shall run in cases that can be heard during the judicial recess, it did not find the interpretation against the party to be in accordance with the law, and it evaluated the different decisions of the criminal chambers as a problem of certainty. The decision was rendered by majority vote, and one member dissented with the view that the period runs in cases involving defendants in pre-trial detention. In the decision dated 27 December 2022 numbered E. 2021/319, K. 2022/846, the same principle was reached unanimously and the cassation appeal was deemed to be within the time limit.

the annulment decision rendered by In the application of R.S. The decision is also to the same effect and arose from the criminal case. The appeal decision was served to the defence counsel on 21 July 2020, the cassation petition was filed on 31 August 2020, and the Yargıtay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) 1st Criminal Chamber issued a decision of rejection on procedural grounds due to the case involving a detained defendant. The Court found that considering Article 331/3 as an exception to Article 331/4 was unforeseeable and, on the grounds that the interference lacked a legal basis, it unanimously decided that the right of access to a court had been violated.

The court stated that a retrial is necessary and added that the violation decision does not imply a position regarding the merits of the dispute. The consequences of a violation decision in a different field of individual applications have been addressed in a previous review. Four conclusions can be drawn from these decisions:

  • The distinction between detainees and non-detainees is not used in calculating time limits. The main decision states this explicitly using the phrase "in all matters."
  • The removal of a time limit barrier does not indicate that the application is well-founded. Dated 2 June 2022 In the decision No. E. 2022/4127, K. 2022/4369 The Chamber accepted the Public Prosecutor's Office's objection in favor of the defendant, lifted its previous decision, and subsequently dismissed the appeal on its merits and unanimously upheld the judgment.
  • The rule does not provide unlimited protection. In the case file No. E. 2018/566, although the service occurred during the judicial recess, the Board indicated the last day of the then-valid seven-day period as 7 September 2017 and deemed the application made on 11 September to be made after the time limit had expired.
  • The starting moment at the Public Prosecutor's Office is a separate issue. The Board, In the decision No. E. 2025/621, K. 2026/265 it accepted that the time limit starts not when the judgment is uploaded to UYAP, but on the date when the physical file barcodes are also scanned. This decision was issued with the dissenting opinion of four members who argued that the objection was made after the time limit, and the main decision conveys the same criterion.

Can the Same Calculation Be Applied in a Civil Lawsuit?

No, the rule that the time limit starts over from September 1 is based on Article 331/4 of the CMK and should not be transposed to civil case files. The main decision does not cite the HMK; it established the distinction based on Article 104 of the HMK in the decisions of the Criminal General Assembly No. E. 2021/319 and E. 2018/566. According to this provision, for "cases and matters subject to judicial recess," if the expiration of time limits falls during the recess, the time limits are considered extended by one week from the day the recess ends, and the Board stated that it is understood from this that time limits run in matters not subject to judicial recess.

The 12th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, however, stated that pursuant to Article 18 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (IIK), matters submitted to the enforcement court are urgent and shall be heard during the judicial recess pursuant to Article 103/1-h of the HMK. According to the common rule in three decisions of the Chamber, if the expiration of the time limit falls during the judicial recess, the time limit expires during the recess and is not extended by one week from the end of the recess.

In the case file No. E. 2026/4903, K. 2026/4122 the decision was served on 6 August 2024 and the two-week appeal period expired on 20 August in a straight calculation; the petition filed on 29 August, before the recess ended, was still not considered to be within the time limit. In the case file No. E. 2025/9758, K. 2026/776 the service was on 17 August 2025, the application was on 5 September 2025, and the result is the same. Whereas in the criminal case file No. E. 2021/319, an application made on 2 September 2020 against a service on 21 July 2020 was found to be within the time limit.

In the case file No. E. 2026/3323, K. 2026/2901 the same rule was repeated for an application for the annulment of a tender made to the civil court of peace because the IIK is applied. Since the chronological order of dates in that text is not clear, only the rule has been taken from here. All three files relate to the annulment of a tender; however, the phrase "matters submitted to the enforcement court" is general and in files arising from exchangeable instrument proceedings urgency must also be checked separately.

Case type Is it heard during the judicial recess? If the time limit falls during the recess Legal Basis
Criminal, non-detention matter The regional court of appeal and the Court of Cassation only review matters in Art. 331/3 Time limit does not run; three-day extension or start from September 1 CMK Art. 331/4; CGK E. 2023/558
Criminal, detention matter Yes Same rule, no exception CGK E. 2023/558; Constitutional Court R.S.
Time limit of the public prosecutor According to the type of file Same rules apply CGK E. 2023/558
Civil, matter subject to judicial recess No If the time limit expires during the recess, it is extended by one week HMK Art. 104
Civil, urgent matter Yes If the end of its time limit falls during the recess, it expires within the recess and does not extend HMK Art. 103/1-h; 12th Civil Chamber decisions
Enforcement court matter Yes If the end of its time limit falls during the recess, it expires within the recess and does not extend IIK Art. 18; 12th Civil Chamber E. 2026/4903

Administrative jurisdiction is outside the scope of this review. On the civil side, no decision at the level of the General Assembly of Civil Chambers has been examined; the results above are limited to the three Chamber decisions transferred via Article 104 of the HMK.

Did the Law Change After the Decision?

No change was detected in the provision regarding the judicial recess, but the objection period applied by the decision has changed. Published in the Official Gazette dated 31 July 2026 and numbered 33326 of Law No. 7589 Article 17 has amended Article 308/1 of the CMK. In the new text, the period for the Yargıtay Public Prosecutor to file an objection is three months from the date the file is delivered to them, and no time limit is sought for objections in favor of the defendant.

According to the transitional provision (temporary Article 1/8), the amendment applies to files delivered after the effective date; however, the main decision is based on the old one-month text in terms of the delivery dated 2023. The HAGB regulation of Law No. 7589 is the subject of a separate article.

The amendment also raises a new question, because since the three-month period does not fit within the judicial recess, the Board's “entire period” rule does not literally cover this period. Will the period start from September 1 for a file delivered during the recess, and will the days falling within the recess be included in the calculation? No decision resolving this question has been seen in this review.

In the text of Law No. 7589 reached, no amendment regarding CMK Articles 273, 291 and 331 and HMK Articles 103 and 104 was seen. According to the summary list reached, the CMK articles of Law No. 7571 published before the decision are Articles 128/A, 250, 253, 280 and temporary Article 8. Law No. 7593 adds a clause to Article 174 of the CMK in the text reached. No provision changing the judicial recess or the appeal and cassation period was identified in these laws.

The scan is limited to these three laws and was conducted in November 2026 based on publications that convey the texts of the laws; therefore, the phrase “not identified” does not mean absolute absence. Since copies of the Official Gazette and consolidated legislation could not be accessed directly, a summary list for 7571 and a text with missing final articles for 7593 were seen, and the current text should be checked separately in the specific file.

Did the Decision of the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers End the File?

No, the Board's decision only removed the time-limit impediment. Its consequences and limits are as follows:

  • The Chamber will examine the grounds for the objection. If it finds it well-founded, it will correct its decision; if not, it will send the file to the Board.
  • The question of recidivism remains open. Since the Board did not make an assessment regarding the conditions of recidivism for the second time, the decision does not express a substantive outcome against or in favor of the defendant.
  • The next stage is unknown. In two searches conducted in UYAP in November 2026 with the references “558-205” and “17305-5827”, no decision regarding the continuation of this file was identified; this finding is limited to published decisions and these searches.
  • Its effect on other files is not automatic. Each file is examined according to its own date of service, duration, and type of work; the validity of the service is also a separate issue.

What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?

  • Compliance of the service with the procedure: Decisions No. E. 2021/319 and E. 2018/566 were based on service in accordance with the procedure. Another file regarding the investigation of service and excuse shows the effect of this issue on the outcome.
  • The status of the service according to the judicial recess: The main decision attaches different consequences to whether the service was made before or during the recess.
  • Type of the file: Whether it is a criminal case, a legal case subject to the recess, or an urgent case determines the difference in the decisions No. E. 2021/319 and E. 2026/4903.
  • The period valid on that date: Since decision No. E. 2018/566 is based on the period “valid on the date of the decision”, the number of days in old decisions should not be transferred to the present.
  • Date of delivery to the Public Prosecutor's Office: In file No. E. 2025/621, the UYAP date is 27.12.2024, the barcode date is 14.01.2025, and the objection date is 07.02.2025; which date was taken as the basis changed the result.

Frequently Asked Questions

When Does the Time Limit for Legal Remedies Start for a Criminal Decision Served During the Judicial Recess?

According to the Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) General Assembly of Criminal Chambers, service effected during the judicial recess is valid, but the time limit does not run during the recess. If the entire period falls within the recess, the time limit begins to run from 1 September. The last day must be calculated separately based on the dates of the specific case file.

What Happens If Service Is Effected Before the Judicial Recess and the Time Limit Expires During the Recess?

Regardless of the portion that expired before the recess, in a criminal case, the time limit is extended by three days starting from the day the judicial recess ends. The Yargitay General Assembly of Criminal Chambers established this rule as settled practice in its decision no. E. 2023/558, K. 2026/205.

Does the Time Limit for Legal Remedies Run During the Judicial Recess in Cases Involving a Defendant in Pre-Trial Detention?

According to the Yargitay General Assembly of Criminal Chambers, it does not, because there is no exception for cases involving pre-trial detention in Article 331/4 of the CMK, and the rule applies to all cases regardless of whether the defendant is in pre-trial detention or not. The Constitutional Court also deemed an opposing interpretation in its R.S. decision to be a violation of the right of access to a court.

Does the Judicial Recess Rule Also Apply to Public Prosecutors?

Yes, the Yargitay General Assembly of Criminal Chambers stated that the rules regarding time limits during the judicial recess also apply to the time limits granted to public prosecutors. In file no. E. 2023/558, the Chief Public Prosecutor's objection against the defendant was thus accepted as timely.

Does the Time Limit in Civil Lawsuits Also Start from Scratch from 1 September?

Since the 1 September rule of the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers is based on Article 331/4 of the CMK, it should not be transferred to civil lawsuits. According to Article 104 of the HMK, if the expiration of a time limit falls during the recess in cases subject to the judicial recess, the time limit is extended by one week from the day the recess ends; there is no such extension for urgent matters not subject to the recess.

Does the Appeal Period for an Enforcement Court Decision Extend During the Judicial Recess?

According to the 12th Civil Chamber of the Yargitay, it does not, because matters submitted to the enforcement court are considered urgent and, if the expiration of the time limit falls during the recess, the time limit expires within the recess. In file no. E. 2026/4903, an appeal petition filed on 29 August against service effected on 6 August 2024 was found to be untimely.

Does No Time Limit Run During the Judicial Recess?

No, the rule in the Code of Criminal Procedure does not apply to urgent matters in civil justice, and in a criminal case, the time limit begins to run after the recess. In file no. E. 2018/566, the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers considered an appeal request dated 11 September 2017 to be untimely, even though the service took place during the recess.

Did the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers Resolve the Issue of Second-Time Recidivism?

No, the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers only accepted that the objection was timely and annulled the decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargitay to refuse the time limit. Since the Chamber must first evaluate the grounds for the objection, the file was sent to the Chamber, and the issue of second-time recidivism remained open.

Conclusion: First the Type of File, Then the Date of Service

The decision of the Yargıtay General Criminal Board dated 1 April 2026 shows that the judicial recess rule in criminal files will be applied without distinguishing between detained and non-detained defendants and that this also applies to public prosecutors. For this reason, the Board deemed the objection dated 29 September 2023 to be within the time limit, but sent the file to the Chamber without resolving the question of recidivism for the second time.

The first point to consider in calculating a time limit is the nature of the file; while a similar calendar might protect a time limit in a criminal case, it might exhaust it in an enforcement court matter. The second point is whether service was effected before or during the judicial recess. Any assessment that “time limits do not run during the judicial recess” made without clarifying these distinctions remains incomplete. The new three-month time limit in Article 308 of the CMK, however, raises the question of how the Board's rules will be applied to long time periods.

Legal Resources and Related Reviews

Legislation

  • Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271, especially articles 39, 263, 273, 291, 308, and 331. The texts of articles 308 and 331 are taken from the decision texts, and the texts of articles 273 and 291 are taken from publications reproducing the law text.
  • Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, article 103/1-h and article 104. The provisions are taken from the reproduction in the Yargıtay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) decisions.
  • Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004, article 18 and article 364/2. The provisions are taken from the reproduction in the Yargıtay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) decisions.
  • Law No. 7589, article 17 and provisional article 1/8, Official Gazette 31.07.2026, 33326. Text from the Memurlar.net copy has been read.
  • Law No. 7593, Official Gazette 18.08.2026, 33344. Text from the Alomaliye copy has been read; the final articles could not be viewed.
  • Law No. 7571, Official Gazette 25.12.2025, 33118. It has been verified through the list of articles.

Decisions

The full text of the Yargıtay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) decisions has been read from the UYAP Emsal Karar database. This review is limited to nine decisions and does not constitute the entirety of the search results.

Other Resources and Related Articles

Author and Legal Information

Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008

This text is a legal decision review based on the decision of the Yargıtay General Assembly of Criminal Chambers dated 01.04.2026, E. 2023/558, K. 2026/205. The review is limited to the published decision text; it does not mean that the same result will be obtained in other cases.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Author

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Founding attorney of Batın Yılmaz Law Office. Handles litigation and consultancy in foreigners and citizenship law, as well as criminal, corporate, administrative, real estate, enforcement, and compensation law.

About our office