Precedent decision reviews
Reacquisition of Turkish Citizenship Cancelled in Case Opened After 27 Years: Danıştay
In this article 17 headings
- Short Answer: Reacquisition of Turkish citizenship
- Citation of the Council of State 10th Chamber Decision
- How Did the Dispute Begin? The Letter from Austria and the 1995 Decision
- The Plaintiff Said 'I Did Not Consent', the Administration Relied on the Application: What Did the Parties Argue?
- When Does the Filing Deadline Start if the Decision Was Not Served?
- Why Did the Council of State Annul the Decision on Reacquisition of Citizenship?
- Did the Council of State Decide That the Signature Was Forged?
- Why Did Similar Lawsuits Have Different Outcomes?
- Are Becoming Aware of the Act, Its Consequence, and Its Illegality the Same Thing?
- Dual Citizenship: How Is the Risk of Losing Austrian Citizenship Addressed in the Decision?
- Where Is a Lawsuit Filed Against a Decision on Reacquisition of Citizenship, and What Are the Legal Remedies?
- What Happens After an Annulment Decision? Consequences Present and Absent in the Decision
- What Should Be Examined in the File of a Person Who Learns Years Later That They Were Made a Citizen?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion: What Is Decisive Is Not the Years That Have Passed, but the Traces in the File
- Legal Resources and Related Reviews
- Author and Legal Information
Publication: · Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.
Short Answer: Reacquisition of Turkish citizenship
This may be possible, but the outcome is not the same in every file; it is not the number of years that have passed, but when the decision was learned and what the administration investigated that are decisive. In a file where there was no document proving that the decision for re-acquisition of Turkish citizenship had been served and published in the Official Gazette, and where it could not be shown that it had been learned earlier, the Danistay 10. Daire (10th Chamber of the Council of State of Turkiye) considered a lawsuit filed after 27 years to be within the time limit.
In its decision dated 2 February 2026, the Chamber in E. 2022/5461, K. 2026/297 It unanimously annulled the part of the Council of Ministers Decree dated 23 May 1995 concerning the plaintiff, an Austrian citizen; the decision stated that the avenue of cassation appeal is open. According to the reasoning, the administration did not verify the signature on the petition, did not provide information regarding the consequences if the signature belonged to the plaintiff, did not investigate the currency of the request, and did not examine the conditions under the repealed Law No. 403, Article 6.
This result does not mean that a lawsuit can be filed against a citizenship action at any time; the 60-day filing period commences upon awareness. The same Chamber, In file E. 2022/5460 rejected the lawsuit on the grounds of statute of limitations by accepting from the Mernis records that the plaintiff had become aware of the action long before. The Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers of the Danistay also upheld decisions rejecting lawsuits on the grounds of time limits in files where awareness was understood from the petition or the power of attorney.
This analysis is based on the published text of the decision and addresses not the state's annulment of citizenship, but the lawsuit filed by the individual against the decision that re-granted them citizenship. For actions by the state, to our guide on the annulment and withdrawal of citizenship acquired by investment, for the steps to be followed against these actions article on what persons whose citizenship has been cancelled should do can be consulted.
Citation of the Council of State 10th Chamber Decision
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Title | Information |
|---|---|
| Court | Danistay 10. Daire (first instance) |
| Basis and decision number | E. 2022/5461, K. 2026/297 |
| Decision date | 02.02.2026 |
| Subject of the lawsuit | The part of the Council of Ministers Decree dated 23.05.1995 and numbered 95/6904 concerning the plaintiff |
| The legal basis of the action | Repealed Turkish Citizenship Law No. 403, Art. 8 |
| Date of lawsuit | 02.09.2022 |
| The accepted date of awareness | 12.07.2022 |
| Rapporteur judge's opinion | Cancellation |
| Conclusion | Unanimous annulment of the part concerning the plaintiff |
| Legal remedy | Appeal to the Council of State Plenary Assembly of Administrative Chambers within 30 days following the notification date |
How Did the Dispute Begin? The Letter from Austria and the 1995 Decision
The plaintiff renounced Turkish citizenship on 28 June 1994, having obtained permission in accordance with Article 20 of the repealed Turkish Citizenship Law No. 403 so as not to lose Austrian citizenship. According to the administration, the plaintiff applied to the Vienna Consulate General with a petition of the same date, and the Council of Ministers, relying on Article 8 of Law No. 403, re-granted the plaintiff Turkish citizenship on 23 May 1995.
According to the plaintiff's account, the situation came to light 27 years later upon receiving an official letter from a state authority in Austria stating that a full extract from the Turkish population records was requested. The plaintiff stated that upon going to the Vienna Consulate General, they learned they were still a Turkish citizen, requested to be removed from citizenship, and filed the lawsuit upon the implied rejection of the application, alleging that the petition was forged.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Date | Development | Legal Significance |
|---|---|---|
| 18.05.1993 | Permission to renounce was granted by Council of Ministers Decree No. 93/4436. | Law No. 403, Art. 20 permission. |
| 28.06.1994 | The certificate of renunciation was served; the petition for re-acquisition also bears the same date. | The validity of the petition is in dispute. |
| 23.05.1995 | The plaintiff was re-granted citizenship by Council of Ministers Decree No. 95/6904. | This is the action subject to the lawsuit. |
| 29.06.2022 | According to the plaintiff's statement, the letter was received from the Austrian authority. | The Chamber did not start the time limit from this date. |
| 12.07.2022 | A petition for renunciation of Turkish citizenship was submitted to the Vienna Consulate General. | The Chamber accepted the date of awareness as this day. |
| 02.09.2022 | The lawsuit has been filed. | It is the 52nd day since 12 July. |
The Plaintiff Said 'I Did Not Consent', the Administration Relied on the Application: What Did the Parties Argue?
The plaintiff argued that they had no request for re-acquisition of citizenship, were not informed, and did not consent to the application made without their knowledge, thereby asserting the action was null and void. They also argued that due to Austria's non-recognition of dual citizenship, their citizenship would be terminated and they would lose their job. The defendant administrations, on the other hand, requested the dismissal of the lawsuit, stating that re-acquisition of citizenship was requested with a petition of the same date and that the decision was given upon this request.
The Danistay prosecutor proposed the annulment of the implied rejection of the 12 July 2022 application along with the relevant part of the decision, noting that the administration did not provide information, did not respond for nearly a year, and did not investigate the currency of the request. The judgment, however, was limited only to the Council of Ministers Decree.
When Does the Filing Deadline Start if the Decision Was Not Served?
Pursuant to the provisions of the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577 If there is no specific period provided under Article 7, the period for filing a lawsuit before the Danistay (Council of State of Turkiye) is 60 days, and it begins on the day following the written notification. Article 45 of the repealed Law No. 403 stipulated the publication in the Official Gazette for those "deemed necessary" among those granted citizenship, and Article 17 of the repealed Regulation stipulated that the decision would be served to the relevant person.
If there is no written notification, the Chamber does not rely on the wording of Article 7, but on the case law of the Danistay. Accordingly, if the nature and legal consequences of the administrative act are learned subsequently, acquiring information as a rule produces the results of a written notification and initiates the time limit. The limit of this exception is drawn as follows:
“...the acceptance of this exceptional situation, in clearer terms, taking the acquisition of information as the basis for the commencement of the time limit for filing a lawsuit, is subject to the condition that it is clearly demonstrated by the plaintiffs that the administrative act was learned at a later date due to its nature and the legal consequences it produced; whether this condition is met can only be decided by the administrative judicial authority in the administrative lawsuit filed. In other words, a general acceptance that any kind of acquisition of information (becoming aware) shall be taken as the start of the time limit for filing an administrative lawsuit would not be compatible with Article 125 of the Constitution and Law No. 2577.”
The Chamber deemed the written notification of decisions affecting the citizenship relationship as a requirement of the freedom to seek legal remedies and applied the criterion according to the response given to the interlocutory decision dated 17 October 2022:
- Notification: The Ministry of Interior submitted the letter requesting the announcement of the decision from the Consulate General in Vienna; however, it did not submit any document showing that the service was carried out upon this letter.
- Publication: Information and documents regarding the publication of the decision in the Official Gazette were not present in the file.
- Usage trace: The Chamber also asked whether the plaintiff had exercised rights in the capacity of a citizen and did not see any data in Mernis movements regarding a transaction performed by the plaintiff.
With these findings, the Chamber accepted the date of learning as 12 July 2022, the date of application, which coincides with the statement in the petition, and did not find a time-limit issue in the lawsuit filed 52 days later. Although the expression “burden of proof” does not appear in the decision, the basis for the result is that the document showing early learning is not in the file.
This approach does not grant a right to file a lawsuit without a time limit. In the file No. E. 2020/134 upheld by the Board, the Chamber stated that the date of learning shall be determined by the judicial body within the framework of good faith rules, taking into account the characteristics and nature of the incident. The Board, however, did not write its own criterion in the decisions reviewed and upheld the Chamber’s grounds with brief reasoning.
Two points remain open. 65 days have passed from 29 June 2022, when it was stated that the letter was received, until the date of the lawsuit, but whether the letter informed about the act and the effect of the administrative application on the time limit were not discussed. There is also no clear evaluation regarding the plaintiff’s characterization of the act as void; the Chamber solves the time-limit problem not with the concept of nullity but with the date of learning.
Why Did the Council of State Annul the Decision on Reacquisition of Citizenship?
The Chamber defined citizenship as a bond creating mutual rights and obligations between the State and the individual, counted the right not to be arbitrarily deprived of it among human rights, and established a duty of care directed towards the State:
“In this respect, the State must show the necessary attention and care, and if necessary, inform the person about the matter so that the relevant person does not suffer any grievance, including statelessness, while carrying out the aforementioned actions.”
The reasoning continued thereafter with two separate grounds; the first four steps relate to the application and will, the latter relates to citizenship requirements:
- Application requirement: It is clearly understood from the legislation that there must be an application or request for naturalization by a Council of Ministers decision.
- Signature comparison: The administration should have compared the signature in the petition with documents such as the application for permission to renounce citizenship, revealed whether there was a “clear and obvious difference that could be understood at first glance,” and should not have processed the application if the signature did not belong to the plaintiff.
- Information: If the signature belongs to the claimant, the administration should have also taken the Austrian Citizenship Act into account and informed the claimant of the consequences that the acceptance of the application would entail.
- Currency of the request: Approximately eleven months had passed between the application and the decision, no response had been given to the claimant, the claimant had not renewed their application, and whether the request was still valid had not been investigated.
- Conditions for citizenship: According to the Chamber, the application petition is insufficient with regard to Article 8 of Law No. 403. In addition to residence, the requirements under Article 6—such as being of full age, confirming the intent to settle through conduct, good moral character, general health, sufficient Turkish language proficiency, and means of subsistence—are also sought. Since this examination was not performed, the decision was found not to be in accordance with the law “in this respect as well.”
These provisions belong to the repealed Law No. 403, which was in force at the date of the transaction; the Law, Article 31 of the Turkish Citizenship Law No. 5901 was repealed on 12 June 2009 by Article 47. According to the text of the decision, it is written only that the residence requirement shall not be sought in Article 8; seeking other requirements is the Chamber's interpretation. The Chamber added to its reasoning that an annulment decision it rendered in another case of similar nature was upheld by the Board.
Did the Council of State Decide That the Signature Was Forged?
No. The Chamber stated that the legal validity of the petition was a matter of dispute, did not determine to whom the signature belonged, and there is no information in the decision regarding an expert examination. The basis for the annulment is not forgery, but the administration's failure to conduct the examination it was required to perform during the transaction. There is no assessment in the decision regarding the plaintiff being required to prove forgery. It is understood from the construction of the reasoning that even if the signature were found to belong to the plaintiff, the transaction would not be saved on its own; because the grounds of information, currency, and Article 6 were sought separately.
The administration objected to the same reasoning in a similar case; the Ministry of Interior argued that the allegation of signature forgery was not investigated by an expert, that there was no duty of information, and that Austrian legislation was not taken into account during the issuance of the transaction. The Board in its decision No. E. 2025/712, K. 2025/1600 did not find these claims of a nature to require reversal and upheld the annulment decision unanimously and definitively.
Since the Board gave a brief upholding decision, it did not explain the limits of the duty to inform. The Chamber used the proviso “if necessary” and established this duty in conjunction with the determination regarding the purpose of the permission to renounce citizenship. Based on the evaluation of this examination, it cannot be concluded from these decisions that foreign law must be investigated in every citizenship application.
Why Did Similar Lawsuits Have Different Outcomes?
In a search conducted in the UYAP Precedent Decision database on 3 November 2026 with the phrase “to be re-admitted to Turkish citizenship,” 25 Council of State decisions, some of which pertained to other topics, were listed. The table summarizes the decisions selected from this search and targeted queries; it covers only published decisions and should not be read as a success rate. In the table, IDDK denotes the Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State. E. 2022/5468 is the second case filed by the same plaintiff after the case that concluded with E. 2021/3604; the appeal stage of this decision and the decision No. E. 2022/5460 could not be accessed in UYAP.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Ruling | Foreign connection | Decisive fact in learning | Application petition | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10th Chamber, E. 2022/5461, K. 2026/297 (02.02.2026) | Austria | No record of service document, publication information, or Mernis trace; learning was accepted as 12.07.2022 | Petition dated 28.06.1994 is disputed; signature not compared | Annulment, unanimous; appeal open |
| IDDK E. 2025/712, K. 2025/1600 (10.09.2025) | Austria | Time limit is not discussed in the Board's decision | Petition dated 22.09.1995 is disputed; signature not compared | Annulment of the refusal decision upheld, unanimous, definitive |
| IDDK E. 2024/1771, K. 2025/323 (12.02.2025) | Austria | 2018 renunciation permission did not initiate the time limit; the Austrian letter dated 12.11.2018 was taken as the basis | Application was not submitted to the file | Annulment upheld, majority vote, definitive |
| IDDK E. 2024/517, K. 2024/2472 upheld by (21.10.2024) 10th Chamber E. 2021/7162, K. 2023/6724 | Germany | No service document; it was accepted that it was learned within the lawsuit period | Not submitted despite the interlocutory decision | Annulment upheld, unanimous, definitive |
| 10th Chamber E. 2022/5460, K. 2023/2792 (25.05.2023) | Vienna mission | Population transactions in Mernis since 13.08.2008 | Application dated 04.12.1996 understood from the file | Refusal due to statute of limitations, unanimous; appeal open |
| 10. D. E. 2022/5468, K. 2023/702 (22.02.2023) | Germany | Second lawsuit; claim of becoming aware of the unlawfulness on 10.07.2022 | Not examined (rejection on procedural grounds due to time limit) | Refusal due to statute of limitations, unanimous; appeal open |
| İDDK E. 2021/3604, K. 2021/3420 (29.12.2021) | Germany | No date in the petition; power of attorney dated 25.09.2019 | Not examined (rejection on procedural grounds due to time limit) | Rejection due to statute of limitations upheld, unanimous vote, final |
| İDDK E. 2020/134, K. 2020/1452 (13.07.2020) | Austria | Declaration in the petition of becoming aware in 2003 and the permit for renunciation of citizenship in the same year | Not examined (rejection on procedural grounds due to time limit) | Rejection due to statute of limitations upheld, majority vote, final |
According to this review, three conclusions can be drawn from the decisions:
- Years without supporting documents: In lawsuits filed after 27 years in E. 2022/5461 and after 22 years in E. 2021/7162, no time-bar was found as there was no service document and no earlier awareness was established.
- The individual's own conduct: Population registration (Mernis) transactions, statements in the petition, exit permit, and power of attorney were considered evidence of awareness in three separate files.
- Unsubmitted application: In files E. 2024/1771 and E. 2021/7162, the administration could not provide the application to the file; the Chamber concluded that there was no statement of intent, and the Board upheld these decisions.
Are Becoming Aware of the Act, Its Consequence, and Its Illegality the Same Thing?
These are not considered the same, and this is where the decisions diverge. The Chamber's criterion examines the awareness of the administrative act in terms of its “nature and the legal consequences it produces.” The following three distinctions were not made in the decisions and represent the assessment of this review:
- Existence of the administrative act: Refusal decisions E. 2022/5460, E. 2020/134, and E. 2021/3604 are based on this stage. In E. 2022/5460, although the service of the notice could not be established, the Chamber found the claim of unawareness “lacking in good faith and seriousness” in light of Mernis records.
- Consequence of the administrative act: In file E. 2024/1771, the plaintiff had obtained an exit permit in 2018 pursuant to Article 25 of Law No. 5901. The Chamber, taking the view that the decision “could not be fully and definitively known” at that date and its consequences had not yet manifested, started the limitation period from the date of the letter notifying the loss of Austrian citizenship, and the Board upheld this.
- Unlawfulness: In file E. 2022/5468, after the previous time-bar refusal decision was upheld, the plaintiff claimed to have become aware of the unlawfulness on 10 July 2022. The Chamber deemed this an attempt to revive the limitation period and stated that no information or document was submitted to allow the lawsuit to be heard within the time limit; it did not establish a general rule regarding the awareness of unlawfulness.
This discussion is different from the issue of subsequent awareness in files where the State has withdrawn citizenship; in that case, the question is about when the administration became aware, whereas here, it is about when the individual became aware.
Do Two Board Decisions Contradict Each Other?
At first glance, the Board's decisions E. 2020/134 and E. 2024/1771 provide different outcomes for similar events. Both plaintiffs obtained an exit permit and learned of the loss of Austrian citizenship in 2018, but in the first file, the lawsuit was rejected due to the time-bar, whereas in the second, the act was annulled.
According to this review, the primary difference observed from the texts is the statement of the plaintiffs. In E. 2020/134, the plaintiff explicitly wrote in the petition that they learned of the act in 2003, whereas in E. 2024/1771, they declared that they could not examine their file at the Vienna Embassy and could not see the act against them. The Board did not compare the two decisions and did not cite the 2020 decision in the 2025 decision; therefore, it cannot be said that there is a change in case law.
The dissenting opinion in E. 2020/134 argued that the plaintiff's interest was only affected in 2018 and that the limitation period should start from the Austrian letter. The dissenting opinion in E. 2024/1771 concerns the merits rather than the limitation period; it proposed a reversal based on the petition attached to the diplomatic mission letter relied upon by the administrations, as well as the State's sovereign power.
Dual Citizenship: How Is the Risk of Losing Austrian Citizenship Addressed in the Decision?
The decision contains limited information on this matter. The Chamber acknowledged that the plaintiff requested the exit permit in order not to lose their Austrian citizenship and expected the administration to provide information by taking the Austrian Citizenship Law into account. It considered the forgery allegation and the lawsuit to be the result of the fact that dual citizenship is not permitted under that law, with some exceptions.
There is no finding that the claimant has effectively lost their Austrian citizenship; the loss and employment risk are the claimant's own assertions, and the letter also requests a civil registry extract based on their own account. The articles of the law have not been quoted, and how the Turkish annulment decision will be evaluated by the Austrian authorities has not been addressed. In file E. 2024/1771, however, the claimant was notified in writing that they had lost their Austrian citizenship.
Does Obtaining a Permit to Renounce Turkish Citizenship Replace a Lawsuit?
The files examined show that this may not be sufficient. In files E. 2020/134 and E. 2024/1771, the plaintiffs lost their Austrian citizenship even after obtaining a permit to exit; according to the dissenting opinion in E. 2020/134, the reason for this was that they also held Turkish citizenship between 1998 and 2003. The exit procedure may also serve as evidence of becoming aware; conversely, in E. 2024/1771, the 2018 permit did not initiate the period. Therefore, the choice between an exit application and an action for annulment must be evaluated by considering the dates together in the specific file.
Where Is a Lawsuit Filed Against a Decision on Reacquisition of Citizenship, and What Are the Legal Remedies?
In the files examined, the lawsuits against the Council of Ministers' decisions were heard by the 10th Chamber of the Danistay (Council of State of Turkiye) as a court of first instance, and the Presidency and the Ministry of Interior were the defendants; for general rules, the section on litigation period and competent court. one may refer to. In the main decision, the Council of Ministers' Decision was challenged, while in file E. 2025/712, the transaction of the Ministry of Interior rejecting the application was challenged.
Applying to the administration does not automatically resolve the issue of the statute of limitations; in file E. 2022/5460, the application dated 14 June 2022 and the implied refusal did not make the lawsuit filed within the time limit. According to Articles 10 and 11 of Law No. 2577, if no response is given within 30 days, the request is deemed to have been refused; however, if the application mentioned in Article 11 is made within the litigation period, it stops the running period. In the main decision, the period was calculated not from the implied refusal, but from the date of awareness on 12 July 2022. Therefore, the period must be monitored from the earliest date that can be considered as the date of awareness. Pursuant to Article 27 of the same Law, filing a lawsuit does not automatically stay the execution of the administrative act; justification of the request the stay of execution section. has been addressed.
An avenue of appeal to the Board is open against the Chamber's decision within 30 days following service; the Board decisions examined were issued as final.
In the search conducted at the beginning of November 2026, no amendments were detected after the decision in Law No. 5901 and Article 7 of Law No. 2577. On the other hand, Law No. 7589 (O.G. 31.07.2026) amended Articles 45 and 46 of Law No. 2577. No provision abolishing the avenue of appeal to the Board against the final decisions of the Danistay's litigation chambers was seen in the reached summaries and partial texts; the current text must be checked separately for a new lawsuit.
What Happens After an Annulment Decision? Consequences Present and Absent in the Decision
In the judgment, the part of the Council of Ministers' Decision regarding the plaintiff was annulled, the expenses were imposed on the defendant administrations, and the avenue of appeal was indicated. Most of the other questions are not answered in the text.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Question | Included in the decision | The unresolved point |
|---|---|---|
| Is the person considered to have exited Turkish citizenship? | Only the part of the decision regarding the plaintiff was annulled. | It is not written as of which date and how the status will be determined. |
| Is the annulment retroactive? | There is no explicit evaluation regarding retroactive effect. | It cannot be understood how the legal situation after 1995 will be affected. |
| What happens to the civil registration, is a new decision required? | There is no provision regarding the correction of the registration, a new transaction, or an exit certificate. | No separate provision was established regarding the application dated 12 July 2022, and it was not specified by which transaction the registration would be corrected. |
| Are the spouse and children affected? | There is no information regarding the spouse or children in the decision. | The status of family members must be examined separately. |
Article 28 of Law No. 2577 stipulates that the court decision must be executed within 30 days at the latest from the date of service; however, this general provision does not show how the registration will be corrected. In file E. 2022/5460, the plaintiff also requested the correction of the civil registration in their application to the administration, and there is no evaluation regarding this request in the refusal decision based on the statute of limitations.
It cannot be understood from the text whether the decision has been appealed and whether it has become final, and no Board decision regarding this file could be reached on UYAP. An affirmation in a similar file does not guarantee the result of the appeal for this file; an appeal application does not automatically stay the execution of the decision either. The decision does not automatically produce results for other persons; since its grounds pertain to the repealed Law No. 403, it must also be specifically evaluated whether they can be directly transposed to decisions rendered during the period of Law No. 5901.
What Should Be Examined in the File of a Person Who Learns Years Later That They Were Made a Citizen?
The first step is to distinguish between the decision date, the date the administrative act was learned, and the date the result emerged. Furthermore, the following matters may affect the outcome:
- Mernis tracking record: The main difference between E. 2022/5460 and the merits decision arose from this record; the individual’s civil registration (nüfus) records must be checked.
- Petition and signature: In file No. E. 2021/7162, the application petition was not submitted despite an interlocutory decision, and the merits decision required a signature comparison.
- Previous lawsuit: In file No. E. 2022/5468, the new date of awareness asserted after the refusal decision on grounds of time became final could not be documented.
Frequently Asked Questions
When Does the Filing Deadline Start if I Was Made a Turkish Citizen Again Without Applying?
According to the 10th Chamber of the Council of State, if there is no written notification regarding a decision on reacquisition of Turkish citizenship, the deadline, as a rule, starts when the nature and legal consequences of the act are learned; the date of learning must be clearly demonstrated. In case file E. 2022/5461, this date was accepted as 12 July 2022, the date of application to the administration, and the 60-day period was calculated from there.
Can a Lawsuit Against a Citizenship Act Always Be Filed?
The decisions of the Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State do not support this; even if there is no written notification, the 60-day period runs after one becomes aware of the act. In case file E. 2021/3604, the plaintiff argued that citizenship is a fundamental right and its annulment could be requested at any time, but the Plenary Session did not find these claims to be grounds for overturning the decision and unanimously upheld the decision regarding the expiry of the deadline.
Does a Mernis Record or Civil Registry Transaction Count as the Date of Awareness?
It may be counted. In case file E. 2022/5460, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State accepted that the plaintiff had long known about the act based on civil registry excerpts, residence documents, and marriage and birth transactions carried out since 2008. In case file E. 2022/5461, however, no Mernis transaction carried out by the plaintiff was observed.
Can the Decision on Reacquisition of Citizenship Be Annulled if the Signature on the Application Belongs to Me?
This possibility is not excluded, but in decision E. 2022/5461, it was not determined to whom the signature belonged. The 10th Chamber of the Council of State stated that if the signature belongs to the person concerned, the administration must notify them of the results of the application, and also found it contrary to law that the current request and the conditions in Article 6 of the repealed Law No. 403 were not investigated.
Will a Person Who Is Made a Turkish Citizen Again Lose Their Austrian Citizenship?
The decisions of the Council of State do not answer this question from the perspective of Austrian law. In decision E. 2022/5461, the risk of loss is the plaintiff's claim, and the Chamber did not establish an actual loss. In the Plenary Session's case file E. 2024/1771, however, the plaintiff was notified by a letter dated 12 November 2018 that they had lost their Austrian citizenship.
Is the Civil Registry Record Automatically Deleted if the Decision on Reacquisition of Citizenship Is Annulled?
Decision E. 2022/5461 of the 10th Chamber of the Council of State does not contain a ruling on this matter. The ruling only annulled the portion of the Council of Ministers' decision concerning the plaintiff; it did not specify the retroactive effect of the annulment, how the civil registry record would be corrected, or whether a new act is required.
Conclusion: What Is Decisive Is Not the Years That Have Passed, but the Traces in the File
The decision of the 10th Chamber of the Danistay (Council of State of Turkiye) dated 2 February 2026 demonstrates that a lawsuit filed years later against a re-acquisition of Turkish citizenship process, for which service could not be proven, may be considered to have been filed in due time, but this is conditional upon clearly establishing the date of awareness. On the merits, however, requirements regarding the signature, information provided, the timeliness of the request, and the conditions set forth in Article 6 of Law No. 403 were examined.
In refusal decisions on grounds of time, civil registration (nüfus) records in Mernis, the application for renunciation, and the power of attorney were considered evidence of awareness against the individual. The retroactive effect of the annulment, its reflection on the civil registry, and its impact on Austrian citizenship are clear, and the outcome of the cassation appeal is unknown.
Legal Resources and Related Reviews
Legislation
- Abditory Procedure Law No. 2577, in particular Arts. 7, 10, 11, 27, 28, 46 and 52.
- Repealed Turkish Citizenship Law No. 403, Arts. 6, 8, 20 and 45 (from the decision text).
- Regulation on the Implementation of the Repealed Law No. 403, Art. 17 (from the decision text).
- Turkish Citizenship Law No. 5901, Arts. 25 and 47 (from the decision text).
- Constitution, Art. 125.
- Law No. 7589 on Amendments to Certain Laws for the Effective and Efficient Operation of the Judiciary, Official Gazette 31.07.2026, 33326.
Council of State Decisions
The list contains the decisions mentioned in the article and does not represent all search results. Similar decisions Council of State decision search can also be searched from the page.
- 10th Chamber, E. 2022/5461, K. 2026/297, T. 02.02.2026
- Board of Administrative Litigation Chambers, E. 2025/712, K. 2025/1600, T. 10.09.2025
- Board of Administrative Litigation Chambers, E. 2024/1771, K. 2025/323, T. 12.02.2025
- Board of Administrative Litigation Chambers, E. 2024/517, K. 2024/2472, T. 21.10.2024
- 10th Chamber, E. 2021/7162, K. 2023/6724, T. 09.11.2023
- 10th Chamber, E. 2022/5460, K. 2023/2792, T. 25.05.2023
- 10th Chamber, E. 2022/5468, K. 2023/702, T. 22.02.2023
- Board of Administrative Litigation Chambers, E. 2021/3604, K. 2021/3420, T. 29.12.2021
- Board of Administrative Litigation Chambers, E. 2020/134, K. 2020/1452, T. 13.07.2020
Related articles
Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008
This text is a legal decision analysis based on the decision of the 10th Chamber of the Danistay dated 02.02.2026, E. 2022/5461, K. 2026/297. The analysis is limited to the published text of the decision; it does not imply that the same result will be obtained in other files.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.