Precedent decision reviews

Foreign Heir and Reciprocity: Property Limit Disregarded, Yargıtay 7. Civil Chamber Overturns

In this article 16 headings
  1. Short Answer: Foreign heir and reciprocity
  2. Citation of the Decision of the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation
  3. How Did the Dispute Begin? An Inheritance Opened in 1982 Had Been Transferred to the Treasury in a 1999 Certificate
  4. What Did the Treasury Argue, and Why Did the Court of First Instance Accept the Lawsuit?
  5. How Does the Court Investigate Reciprocity Through Ministerial Correspondence?
  6. Why Did the 7th Civil Chamber of the Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) Overturn the Judgment?
  7. Which Rule Applies to Which Date of Death? The Effect of Article 35 of the Land Registry Law on Inheritance
  8. How Did the Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) Rule in Cases Involving Different Countries and Dates of Death?
  9. How Are Movable and Immovable Property Distinguished in a Certificate of Inheritance?
  10. Where to Apply for a Certificate of Inheritance, Should the Treasury Be Shown as the Defendant?
  11. Reversal Did Not End the Lawsuit: Consequences and Limits of the Decision
  12. Which Matters Should Be Examined in a Similar Inheritance File?
  13. Frequently Asked Questions
  14. Conclusion: The Foreign Heir's First Question Is the Date of Death, the Second Is the Content of the Estate
  15. Legal Resources and Related Reviews
  16. Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Written and reviewed by: Atty. Batın Yılmaz (Istanbul Bar Association, Reg. No: 77008)
Publication:  ·  Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.

Short Answer: Foreign heir and reciprocity

foreign heir and reciprocity

No, according to the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), regarding foreign heirs and reciprocity, the absence of reciprocity only affects the acquisition of immovable property; the status of heir continues with respect to movable property in the estate. There is no legal impediment for a foreign national to be an heir regarding movable property, money, and other rights.

The Chamber applied this criterion in its decision dated 18 November 2025, numbered E. 2025/3813, K. 2025/4834. It accepted that on 18 November 1982, the date the inheritance opened, there was no legal or de facto reciprocity between Turkiye and Bulgaria regarding the inheritance-based transfer of immovable property. Upon the Treasury's appeal, it overturned the Regional Court of Appeal's decision and unanimously reversed the first-instance decision "with final effect." The reason for the reversal was that a certificate of inheritance had not been issued while observing the legal restrictions on immovable property.

The decision does not yield the same result for every foreign heir. Reciprocity is examined as of the date of the decedent's death; since the amendment that entered into force on 18 May 2012, the reciprocity requirement is no longer present in Article 35 of the Land Registry Law (Tapu Kanunu). The main decision does not state that the foreign heir will receive a share from the immovable property or receive a payment or compensation. Reversal is not the end of the lawsuit, and the fate of the immovable properties in the estate is not explained in the decision.

This review is based on the published text of the decision; the party information in the text has been redacted. For the general framework, our guide on the inheritance rights of foreigners,for the different function of reciprocity in the enforcement of foreign decisions, our review of enforcement proceedings. can be consulted.

Citation of the Decision of the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation

Title Information
Court 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation
Basis and decision number E. 2025/3813, K. 2025/4834
Decision date 18.11.2025
First instance court Istanbul 10th Civil Court of First Instance, E. 2020/60, K. 2021/540
Appeal (Istinaf) Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal 55th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/1280, K. 2024/1000
Subject of the lawsuit Annulment of the certificate of inheritance and issuance of a new certificate
Date the inheritance opened 18.11.1982
Provisions relied upon Article 35 of the Land Registry Law No. 2644, which was in force on the date the inheritance opened; Article 20 of Law No. 5718
Conclusion Setting aside the Regional Court of Justice decision, reversing the first-instance decision
Vote and finality Unanimous, "with final effect"

How Did the Dispute Begin? An Inheritance Opened in 1982 Had Been Transferred to the Treasury in a 1999 Certificate

The plaintiff requested the annulment of a certificate of inheritance dated 7 December 1999 issued by a civil judgeship of peace and the issuance of a new one. According to the decision, it was stated in this certificate that the decedent had no heirs, and the Treasury was shown as the heir in accordance with Article 501 of the Turkish Civil Code. The plaintiff, however, claimed that they were the sole heir of the decedent and that the certificate was therefore erroneous.

Date Development Legal Significance
18.11.1982 Inheritance opened Reciprocity was evaluated as of this date
07.12.1999 The civil judgeship of peace issued the certificate showing the Treasury as the heir Certificate requested to be annulled
2021 (K. 2021/540) The court of first instance accepted the lawsuit It was accepted that reciprocity does not prevent succession
2024 (K. 2024/1000) The Regional Court of Appeal rejected the appeal application on its merits The first-instance decision was found to be in accordance with procedure and law
23.07.2025 Correspondence from the Ministry of Justice was prepared The correspondence entered the file upon the Chamber's decision to return the file
18.11.2025 The Chamber issued a decision to lift and reverse the ruling The file was sent to the court of first instance

The nationality of the decedent and the plaintiff is not explicitly written in the published text; the reciprocity discussion was conducted between Turkiye and Bulgaria.

What Did the Treasury Argue, and Why Did the Court of First Instance Accept the Lawsuit?

In its statement of defence, the Treasury requested the dismissal of the lawsuit based on the principle of reciprocity, arguing that the plaintiff's documents should be verified and that the lawsuit was not filed within the statute of limitations. In the cassation stage, it asserted that there was no reciprocity with Bulgaria at the date of death, that the translated documents had not been verified, that the mother and father's names of the testator were written incorrectly, and that the sole heir was the Treasury.

The court of first instance accepted the lawsuit on the grounds that there is no impediment to succession by inheritance in the application of the principle of reciprocity and that the plaintiff is the sole heir. The Regional Court of Appeal also rejected the appeal on its merits, stating that the decision was based on an expert report suitable for review.

The Chamber found the court of first instance's decision proper regarding the cancellation of the document. It stated that it was understood from the apostilled civil registry copies that the claimant was an heir, and it found no fault in the cancellation of the 1999 document. For the use of foreign records, to the apostille letter you may consult [ ]. The decision regarding the statute of limitations defense does not contain an explicit assessment; however, Article 598 of the Turkish Civil Code stipulates that the invalidity of a certificate of inheritance may be asserted at any time.

How Does the Court Investigate Reciprocity Through Ministerial Correspondence?

The decisive step in the main decision was taken during the cassation stage. The Chamber issued a decision to remand the case, and the letter dated 23 July 2025 from the Ministry of Justice, Directorate General of International Law and European Union Affairs, was added to the file. According to the decision, the letter stated that when a Bulgarian citizen died in 1982, the real property in the estate was transferred to heirs of Bulgarian nationality, and there was no reciprocity between the two countries regarding real property acquisition at that date.

Based on this response, the Chamber concluded that there was no legal or de facto reciprocity. The full text of the letter is not included in the published decision, and no treaty between the two countries is mentioned. Other decisions illustrate the scope of the inquiry:

  • Date of response: In the Romania file the 2nd Civil Chamber considered it incomplete examination to rely on a general-purpose letter from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs without taking into account the dates of death. In the Saudi Arabia file while the Ministry's response addressed the year 2003, the death in 1943 was not researched, and the judgment was reversed for this reason as well.
  • Absence of a treaty: In the decision E. 2022/1744 the Chamber stated that the absence of a reciprocity treaty would not mean that reciprocity does not exist, and requested the determination of the legal or de facto situation.
  • Method of inquiry: In the same decision, it was requested that reciprocity be inquired from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs through the Ministry of Justice, and in the file E. 2017/2136 the response was obtained through this method.

Why Did the 7th Civil Chamber of the Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) Overturn the Judgment?

The Chamber's reasoning proceeds in five steps:

  1. The text to be applied: According to the Chamber, Article 35 in force at the date the inheritance was opened makes the acquisition of real property by foreign natural persons conditional upon the existence of reciprocity and compliance with legal restrictions. The Chamber also stated that the legal and de facto situation would be taken as the basis in determining reciprocity.
  2. Scope of the restriction: The restriction relates only to real property; there is no legal impediment to a foreign national being an heir regarding movable assets, money, and other rights.
  3. Location of reciprocity: In certificates of inheritance containing foreign elements, assets in the estate are divided into movables and real property. The Chamber considered legal restrictions and reciprocity as essential elements in determining capacity to inherit.
  4. The reference date: Reciprocity regarding the acquisition of real property is sought as of the date the estate is opened upon the death.
  5. The deficiency in this file: Since there was no reciprocity on the date the inheritance was opened, a document should have been issued by observing the legal restrictions regarding real property. It was not deemed correct to rule solely for the cancellation of the document and the determination of shares.

In the third step, the Chamber referred to the decision of the Law General Assembly dated 28 December 1994, E. 1994/2-625, K. 1994/905. As the General Assembly decision could not be found in our searches, it was not evaluated separately in this review. The essence of the decision is in the following sentence:

“The absence of reciprocity shall be applied regarding the acquisition of the decedent's real property by foreign heirs, and it is indisputable that the status of heirship will continue regarding the movables in the estate.”

According to this sentence, the absence of reciprocity does not entirely eliminate the right of inheritance, but it imposes a legal limitation on the heir with respect to real property. The grounds for reversal are based on this limitation concerning real property; however, the determination that the plaintiff is an heir was found to be appropriate by the Chamber.

Which Rule Applies to Which Date of Death? The Effect of Article 35 of the Land Registry Law on Inheritance

The decision states that it applies the provision "in effect at the date when the inheritance was opened." This expression defines the scope of the decision, as Article 35 has been amended several times from 1934 to the present. In the decision numbered E. 2024/4288, the Chamber also requested that the reciprocity status at the dates of death be evaluated in conjunction with the effective dates of the legal regulations.

Period The essence of Article 35 Meaning for a foreign heir
Initial text of 1934 Subject to other legal restrictions, the right to acquire real property and the right of inheritance were granted "on the condition of reciprocity" (E. 2024/4288; Constitutional Court E. 1986/18). The 1982 death in the main file falls within this period; no changes are observed in the reviewed sources before 1984.
1984 and 1986 Laws No. 3029 and 3278 granted the Council of Ministers the authority to introduce exceptions to the reciprocity condition. Constitutional Court (Anayasa Mahkemesi) annulled both regulations (E. 1984/14, K. 1985/7; E. 1986/18, K. 1986/24). These amendments occurred after the 1982 death and are not mentioned in the main decision.
2003-2008 Amendment made by Law No. 4916 Annulled by the Constitutional Court (E. 2003/70, K. 2005/14). Subsequently, the text introduced by Law No. 5444 was also partially annulled by the decision numbered E. 2006/35, K. 2007/48. The text to be applied to deaths occurring in this interval must be determined separately according to the effective dates.
Law No. 5782 (2008) According to the text cited by the Constitutional Court "The legal and factual situation is taken as the basis in determining reciprocity." In the statutory inheritance of citizens of states where there is no reciprocity, a transfer is made, and a liquidation is foreseen. If there is no reciprocity, the provision explicitly regulates the liquidation.
Law No. 6302 (18.05.2012) Reciprocity was abolished; citizens of countries determined by the Council of Ministers became able to acquire real property by complying with legal restrictions. The Constitutional Court with the decision numbered E. 2012/75, K. 2013/88 rejected the requests for annulment regarding the rules subject to the lawsuit. Real property acquired through inheritance outside of these restrictions shall be converted into cash if the owner does not liquidate it within the period granted to them, which does not exceed one year, and the proceeds shall be paid to the right holder.
Post-2018 and today According to the account of the 14th Civil Chamber, the authority to determine countries passed to the President with the regulation dated 2 July 2018. There is a limit of thirty hectares per person nationwide and ten percent of the surface area of the district subject to private ownership. The question is not reciprocity, but country determination and legal restrictions.

In the main decision, the "legal and factual situation" criterion was used for the 1982 death. The Chamber linked this expression to the text on the date when the inheritance was opened but did not cite that text. According to the author's assessment, the expression of Karaca's is not in the initial text cited, but in the texts introduced by Laws No. 5444 and 5782. However, the Constitutional Court stated in its 1986 decision that Turkish law adopts the "principle of factual and legal reciprocity." Therefore, the observation does not relate to the content of the criterion, but to which text the expression was taken from.

For a person who died today, the question has changed. As cited by Üçüncü the Council of Ministers decision dated 25 June 2012 and numbered 724 and its annexed country list were classified as "secret" and were not disclosed until the date the study was completed. The current content of the list and the situation of Bulgaria could not be verified in this review; the country situation must be determined from an official source in the concrete file. Indeed, in the file numbered E. 2025/2291 the death occurred in 2019, the court of first instance accepted that reciprocity would not be sought and evaluated the situation of the spouse who is a Georgian citizen with the response from the Ministry of Justice. The Chamber upheld the Regional Court of Appeal's decision but did not write a separate reasoning on this matter. For other consequences of the spouse's death, see the article on foreign spouses can be consulted.

Can the Price of the Real Property Be Received if There Is No Reciprocity?

The answer to this question also depends on the date of death. Since 2012, the text explicitly provides for the price. Ertaş and Öztürk it mentions that the text of Law No. 4916, which was subsequently annulled, envisaged the liquidation and conversion into monetary value of real property acquired through statutory inheritance by nationals of countries where there is no reciprocity. In cases of earlier deaths, the decisions we have read do not use the same language. In the Romanian decision, E. 2017/4849, it was stated that the case should be dismissed regarding the real property, and no mention was made of the monetary value. In contrast, in the decision E. 2022/1744 concerning deaths in 1960 and 1961, the Chamber added the following:

“Moreover, since ownership is not recognized in this case …, the property inherited in this manner is liquidated and the inheritance share is compensated.”

The ellipsis in the quotation belongs to the published text, and the scope of the sentence cannot be fully understood due to the hidden part. The Chamber did not indicate in this sentence under which provision and how the liquidation would be carried out. In the case file E. 2024/4288, the local court accepted that reciprocity would only be sought at the registration stage and that even if it were absent, the real property would be liquidated and the proceeds paid to the foreign heirs. Without explicitly discussing this view, the Chamber overturned the judgment because the formation of the parties and the research into reciprocity on the dates of death were incomplete.

In the main decision, however, the expression liquidation, compensation, or monetary value does not appear. Therefore, it cannot be inferred from the main decision whether the monetary value will or will not be paid for the real property in the 1982 inheritance.

What Happens to the Share Remaining to the Treasury?

The Chamber found no fault in the annulment of the 1999 document designating the Treasury as an heir. The decision does not contain an explicit assessment regarding whether real property subject to statutory restrictions remains with the Treasury. Article 20 of Law No. 5718 regulates that an estate without heirs in Turkiye shall remain to the State, but this paragraph is not mentioned in the main decision.

Other files show the limits of the Treasury. In the decision E. 2009/2196, it was accepted that although Bulgarian citizens could not be heirs regarding real property, the inheritance could not remain to the Treasury as the final heir because there were Turkish citizen relatives capable of being heirs. In the decision E. 2017/2136, as reciprocity was determined, the allocation of a share to the Treasury was seen as lacking legal basis.

How Did the Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) Rule in Cases Involving Different Countries and Dates of Death?

A search conducted on 3 November 2026 in the UYAP Precedent Decision database with the phrase “in inheritance cases with foreign elements” yielded 11 Yargitay decisions. The result only covers published decisions and should not be interpreted as an acceptance rate. The table below summarizes the decisions selected from this search and additional queries.

Ruling Country Year of death Reciprocity Yargitay's result
7th Civil Chamber E. 2025/3813, K. 2025/4834 Bulgaria 1982 None Lifting and overturning: A certificate must be issued by observing the restrictions regarding real property
7th Civil Chamber E. 2025/2291, K. 2025/5467 Georgia 2019 Court of first instance accepted it would not be sought Upholding, unanimous
7th Civil Chamber E. 2024/4288, K. 2024/5906 Saudi Arabia 1943 and 2003 Ministry said “none” for 2003, 1943 was not researched Overturning: Incomplete examination regarding the formation of parties and dates of death
7th Civil Chamber E. 2022/1744, K. 2023/4294 Hidden in the text 1960 and 1961 Absence of agreement was not considered sufficient Lifting and overturning: Re-investigation; heirship status and shares must be indicated
14th Civil Chamber E. 2017/2136, K. 2021/797 Greece 1942 Yes Overturning: A certificate must also be issued regarding real property, allocation of a share to the Treasury is wrong
14th Civil Chamber E. 2017/4849, K. 2019/1595 Romania 1928 and 1951 None Overturning: Rejection regarding real property, acceptance regarding movables and receivables
7th Civil Chamber E. 2009/8087, K. 2010/1666 Testator with Bulgarian citizenship, heirs with Turkish citizenship 1942 Restriction cannot be applied Overturning: A certificate showing all heirs and shares must be issued
7th Civil Chamber E. 2009/2196, K. 2010/377 Heirs with Bulgarian citizenship 1967 and 1994 None Overturning: Previous document should only be annulled regarding real property, Treasury's case should be dismissed

Three conclusions can be drawn from these decisions:

  • If there is no reciprocity: The entire estate is not affected. The 2009 reversal decision in the Romania file stated that the plaintiff has the right to file a lawsuit regarding movable property and receivables.
  • If there is reciprocity: Real property is also included in the certificate. In the Greece file, the Chamber stated that when reciprocity is established for the date of 1942, a certificate must also be issued for real properties.
  • Determining nationality: According to decision E. 2009/8087, the limitation applies only to heirs who are foreign nationals; the nationality of the decedent as either foreign or Turkish is of no significance.

How Are Movable and Immovable Property Distinguished in a Certificate of Inheritance?

There is no single template for how a certificate is to be established when there is no reciprocity in the decisions we have read:

  • Separate assessment: In the Romania file, it was stated that the request should be refused with regard to real properties, while it should be accepted with regard to movables and receivables.
  • Limited annulment: In decision E. 2009/2196, it was requested that the previous certificate be annulled only with regard to real properties, and that a new certificate be issued valid only with regard to movable property, money, and other rights.
  • Registered certificate: In the main decision, it was requested that the certificate be issued with regard to real properties "by observing the limitations brought by the Law on Forbidden Military Zones and Security Zones, the Village Law, and Article 35 of the Land Registry Law."

The third template does not exclude real property from the certificate but ties it to legal limitations. How this annotation is to be applied in the land registry is not explained in the decision. In decision E. 2022/1744, it was also not considered correct not to show the heirship status and shares of the foreign heirs.

Are the Applicable Law and the Limit on Real Property Acquisition the Same Thing?

No. According to Article 20 of Law No. 5718, succession is subject to the national law of the decedent, and Turkish law is applied to real properties in Turkiye. The opening, acquisition, and partition of an inheritance are also subject to the law of the country where the estate is located. According to the author's assessment, reciprocity does not determine the applicable law; the Chamber considers it an essential element in the determination of legal capacity.

According to the author's assessment, there is also a question of time here. The Chamber has referred to Article 20 of Law No. 5718; this Law entered into force on 12 December 2007. Decision E. 2024/4288 conveys that a similar rule existed in Article 22 of the repealed Law No. 2675. Law No. 2675 entered into force on 22 November 1982, in accordance with its Article 47, i.e., four days after the opening of the succession, and repealed the Provisional Law (Kanunu Muvakkat) dated 23 February 1330 with its Article 46. The private international law rule at the date the succession opened was not specifically discussed in the main decision. The effect of this observation on the judgment is not understood from the decision.

Where to Apply for a Certificate of Inheritance, Should the Treasury Be Shown as the Defendant?

A request for a certificate of inheritance is a non-contentious legal matter. Therefore, the 5th Civil Chamber of the Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye), in its decision dated 9 February 2026, E. 2025/12017, K. 2026/1820, resolved a jurisdictional dispute concerning a decedent of Iraqi nationality using the rule of jurisdiction in non-contentious matters. The civil courts of peace of Mersin and Ankara rendered decisions of lack of jurisdiction, while the Chamber deemed the court of the place of residence of the petitioner or one of the interested parties competent in accordance with Article 384 of Law No. 6100 and designated the Mersin 9th Civil Court of Peace as the venue. The decision relates only to jurisdiction and does not examine reciprocity. The Mersin court relied on Article 43 of Law No. 5718, while this article was not included in the Chamber's assessment.

A request for the annulment of a certificate and a new certificate is a separate lawsuit. According to Article 11 of Law No. 6100, the court of the place of residence of each of the heirs is also competent in these lawsuits. The main file was heard in the civil court of first instance.

Whether the Treasury is shown as a defendant depends on the dispute. In decision E. 2017/2136, the Chamber stated that there is no provision requiring the Treasury to be a party in cases involving a foreign element, and in that file, it deemed it necessary to reject the lawsuit for lack of standing regarding the Treasury. In the main file, however, the Treasury was shown as an heir in the document for which annulment was sought, and the lawsuit was conducted against it.

In decision E. 2017/4849, it was stated that it is mandatory to obtain a certificate of inheritance from Turkish courts for real property. Regarding the effect of foreign decisions in Turkiye, to our article on foreign court decisions can be consulted.

Reversal Did Not End the Lawsuit: Consequences and Limits of the Decision

A reversal decision is not the end of the dispute:

  • Retrial: The expression "final and binding" relates to the review by the Yargıtay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) and does not indicate the outcome of the retrial. No decision pertaining to the next stage was found in UYAP.
  • Repeated reversal: In the Romanian file, the lawsuit was filed in 1988, and reversal decisions were issued in 1991, 1994, 2009, and 2019.
  • Unresolved questions: The composition of the estate, how the restrictions apply to these assets, and the matter of the value were not addressed in the decision.
  • Other files: The decision does not automatically produce consequences for other individuals. Regarding Bulgaria, it has been accepted in the reviewed decisions that there was no reciprocity for the dates of 1967, 1982, and 1994. Other dates must be evaluated according to the specific response from the Ministry.
  • Change in law: In the scan conducted in November 2026, no regulation amending Article 35 was detected after the decision. Law No. 7579 It added an additional article to the Land Registry Law regarding valuation reports, but it did not amend Article 35.

Which Matters Should Be Examined in a Similar Inheritance File?

In the file of a foreign heir, the first step is to distinguish the date of death from the content of the estate. In addition to this, the following issues should be evaluated separately in the specific case file:

  • Each date of death: If there is a chain of deaths, each date must be investigated separately, as in the decision No. E. 2024/4288.
  • Citizenship of the heir: In the Romanian file, the measure is not being a Turkish citizen as of the date of death. These decisions do not contain an explicit assessment regarding the effect of subsequently acquired citizenship.
  • Scope of the Ministry's response: The response must explicitly address the date of death and the acquisition of real property through inheritance (E. 2022/1744).
  • Will: There is no assessment regarding the disposition upon death in the reviewed decisions; will executed abroad it requires a separate examination.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Foreign Heir Inherit a Share of Movable Property if There is No Reciprocity?

According to the Yargıtay 7. Civil Chamber, they can. The limitation in Article 35 of the Land Registry Law (Tapu Kanunu) applies only to real property. There is no legal impediment to foreign nationals being heirs to movable property, money, and other rights, and the status of heir continues with respect to these assets.

As of Which Date is Reciprocity Investigated for a Foreign Heir?

The Yargıtay 7. and 14. Civil Chambers seek reciprocity as of the date of the death of the decedent. In the case of successive deaths, each date carries separate importance. The Yargıtay deemed relying on a general-purpose letter from the Ministry that did not take into account the dates of death to be an incomplete examination.

Does the Reciprocity Requirement Still Exist in the Land Registry Law Today?

The reciprocity requirement in Article 35 of the Land Registry Law was abolished by Law No. 6302, which entered into force on 18 May 2012. Under the current text, citizens of countries determined by the President may acquire real property by complying with legal limitations. For earlier deaths, the text in effect on the date the inheritance was opened is applied.

If There is No Reciprocity, Is the Value of the Real Property Paid to the Foreign Heir?

The text of the Land Registry Law as amended by Law No. 6302 stipulates that if real property acquired through inheritance—excluding those subject to limitations—is not liquidated by the owner within the given time, it shall be converted into value and the value shall be paid to the right holder. The situation is not clear for deaths that occurred in the past; while a 2023 decision of the Yargıtay 7. Civil Chamber mentions liquidation and compensation, this issue is not addressed in its 2025 decision.

If There is a Turkish Citizen Heir, Does the Inheritance Revert to the Treasury?

The Yargıtay 7. Civil Chamber, in its decision E. 2009/2196, stated that it would not. Although persons of Bulgarian nationality could not be heirs with respect to real property, since there were relatives who were Turkish citizens capable of being heirs, the inheritance did not revert to the Treasury as the final heir, and it was accepted that the Treasury's lawsuit should be rejected due to lack of legal interest.

If the Decedent is a Turkish Citizen, Is Reciprocity Sought for a Foreign Heir?

According to the Yargıtay 7. Civil Chamber, the limitation is linked to the nationality of the heir; it is irrelevant whether the decedent is a foreign or Turkish citizen. Reciprocity was also observed with respect to heirs of Bulgarian nationality of decedents who immigrated from Bulgaria and became Turkish citizens. This limitation does not apply to Turkish citizen heirs.

Where is the Certificate of Inheritance Obtained for a Foreign Decedent?

Since the certificate of inheritance is a matter of non-contentious jurisdiction, the Yargıtay 5. Civil Chamber, in a dispute regarding jurisdiction concerning an Iraqi decedent, deemed the court of the place of residence of the applicant or one of the interested parties to be competent. Reciprocity was not examined in this decision. The Yargıtay 14. Civil Chamber, however, stated that it is mandatory to obtain a certificate from Turkish courts for real property located in Turkiye.

Did the Bulgarian Decision of the Yargıtay 7. Civil Chamber Terminate the Lawsuit?

No. The Yargıtay 7. Civil Chamber, with its decision dated 18 November 2025, overturned the first-instance judgment with final effect and sent the file back to the first-instance court. The result of the retrial is not understood from the published text, and the fate of the real property is not explained in the decision.

Conclusion: The Foreign Heir's First Question Is the Date of Death, the Second Is the Content of the Estate

The decision of the 7th Civil Chamber of the Yargıtay dated 18 November 2025 shows that the absence of reciprocity does not entirely exclude the foreign heir from the inheritance in Turkiye. The restriction relates to the acquisition of real property; the status of heir continues with respect to movable property, money, and other rights.

In this file, since there was no reciprocity with Bulgaria as of 1982, the document must be prepared by observing the legal restrictions regarding real property. For deaths occurring after 18 May 2012, the question is not reciprocity, but rather the determination of the country and legal restrictions. Whether the value of the real property will be paid if there is no reciprocity is an open question in deaths occurring at an earlier date and must be evaluated separately in each file.

Legal Resources and Related Reviews

Legislation

Court of Cassation Decisions

The list contains the decisions mentioned in the letter and does not represent all search results.

Constitutional Court Judgments

Other Resources and Related Articles

Author and Legal Information

Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008

This text is a legal analysis based on the decision of the 7th Civil Chamber of the Yargıtay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) dated 18 November 2025, with merits number E. 2025/3813 and decision number K. 2025/4834. The analysis is limited to the published decision text and does not imply that the same result will be obtained in other cases.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Author

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Founding attorney of Batın Yılmaz Law Office. Handles litigation and consultancy in foreigners and citizenship law, as well as criminal, corporate, administrative, real estate, enforcement, and compensation law.

About our office