Precedent decision reviews

G-82 Entry Ban and Family Life: Constitutional Court Found a Violation, Did Not Lift the Ban

In this article 16 headings
  1. Short Answer: Entry ban and family life
  2. Case Citation of the Bılal Padalı Chasanoglou Decision
  3. How Did the Dispute Begin? Being Turned Away at the Border, Marriage Seven Months Later
  4. The Administrative Court Cancelled It, Why Did the Regional Administrative Court Reject the Case?
  5. Why Did the Constitutional Court Decide That the Right to Respect for Family Life Was Violated?
  6. If the Marriage Was Concluded After the Ban, On What Date Is Family Life Looked For?
  7. Why Did the Dissenting Opinion Not See a Violation? The Possibility of the Family Living in Another Country
  8. What Does the G-82 Code Mean, Where Does Article 9 of Law No. 6458 Stand?
  9. In Which File Did the Claim of Family Ties Yield a Result, and in Which Did It Not?
  10. Where Is a Case Against an Entry Ban Filed, and What Legal Recourse Remains After the Regional Administrative Court?
  11. Did the Constitutional Court Lift the Ban? Consequences and Limitations of the Decision
  12. Which Aspects Should Be Examined in the Case of a Foreigner with a Turkish Spouse?
  13. Frequently Asked Questions
  14. Conclusion: Marriage Does Not Erase a Ban, It Forces the Court to Weigh Family Life
  15. Legal Resources and Related Reviews
  16. Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Written and reviewed by: Atty. Batın Yılmaz (Istanbul Bar Association, Reg. No: 77008)
Publication:  ·  Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.

Short Answer: Entry ban and family life

entry ban and family life

No, marriage does not automatically lift a ban; the Constitutional Court did not lift the ban either, but instead sent the case back for retrial. In this case, where the entry ban and family life conflict, the Court required the lower court to evaluate the claims regarding family life and to strike a balance between public interest and family life.

The First Section reached this conclusion on in the decision of Bılal Padalı Chasanoglou, App. No: 2021/14332 The applicant, a Greek citizen who was turned back at the border on 13 March 2018 with a G-82 code, had married a Turkish citizen on 22 October 2018. The Court, without further discussing the timing of the marriage, accepted that a family life existed at the date of the lawsuit. It determined that the Ankara Regional Administrative Court had not evaluated the family life claims and had not discussed whether there was sufficient and serious information, and thus ruled by a majority vote that the right to respect for family life had been violated.

The Court did not rule on whether the applicant was dangerous, noting that the violation decision is independent of the outcome of the dispute; the case could still be rejected upon retrial. Two members, in their dissenting opinion, argued that there was no serious obstacle preventing the family from living in Greece or another country. Therefore, marriage does not mean that the ban will be lifted.

This review is based on the published decision text and focuses on the relationship between marriage and the ban. The general path to be followed against a ban in the article on lifting an entry ban, the nature of the codes in the deportation/restriction code guide explained in the article on the open prison execution process.

Case Citation of the Bılal Padalı Chasanoglou Decision

Title Information
Court Constitutional Court, First Section
Application Bılal Padalı Chasanoglou, App. No: 2021/14332 (spelled “Bılal” in the decision, “Bilal” in secondary sources)
Application date 22.03.2021
Decision date 28.01.2026
Restriction code G-82 (Those Engaged in or Suspected of Engaging in Activities Against National Security)
First instance decision Ankara 1st Administrative Court, Case No. 2019/1693, Dec. No. 2020/855, cancellation
Appellate decision Ankara Regional Administrative Court 10th Administrative Litigation Chamber, Case No. 2020/2100, Dec. No. 2021/39, reversal and rejection
Right examined Article 20 of the Constitution, right to respect for family life
Conclusion Admissible and violation; both by majority vote
Dissenting opinion İrfan Fidan and Yılmaz Akçil
Remedy Retrial and 40,487.60 TL litigation expenses; there is no compensation provision in the decision

How Did the Dispute Begin? Being Turned Away at the Border, Marriage Seven Months Later

The applicant, a Greek citizen, was working in Turkey under a work permit before the ban. In the petition, he stated that he had resided with a legal work permit for approximately five years, that he was one of the Western Thrace Turks, and that he visited his family in Greece in March 2018. On 13 March 2018, when he arrived at the Pazarkule Land Border Gate, he was not allowed to enter the country due to the G-82 code; according to the narrative in the dissenting opinion, an inadmissible passenger form was issued against him.

The applicant married his Turkish citizen fiancée in Greece with a formal civil marriage on 22 October 2018. He filed a lawsuit in administrative court on 25 July 2019 for the cancellation of the ban and the removal of the restriction code.

Date Development Legal Significance
12.12.2017 Secret report from the Presidency of the National Intelligence Organization It was cited as the justification for the restriction entry.
13.03.2018 Entry into the country was denied at Pazarkule. The ban was imposed before the marriage.
22.10.2018 Marriage in Greece The majority and the dissenting opinion evaluated this fact differently.
25.07.2019 An annulment lawsuit was filed. This is the date on which the court determined family life existed.
09.04.2020 Ankara 1st Administrative Court annulled the administrative act. It was accepted that there was no concrete evidence found.
28.01.2021 The Regional Administrative Court overturned the decision and dismissed the case. This is the reasoning that the Constitutional Court found insufficient.
25.02.2021 The applicant learned of the final judgment and filed an individual application on 22.03.2021. It is significant in terms of the individual application time limit.

The date when the restriction entry was recorded in the system is not included in the chronology as it does not appear in the decision.

The Administrative Court Cancelled It, Why Did the Regional Administrative Court Reject the Case?

Ankara 1st Administrative Court annulled the act on April 9, 2020. According to the court, the restriction entry was not based on concrete evidence, and no investigation had been conducted into whether the applicant engaged in activities against national security. The confidential document lacked concrete findings regarding the nature of the activities carried out, and there was no information, documentation, investigation, or prosecution indicating a connection to terrorist organizations.

Upon the administration's appeal, the 10th Administrative Litigation Chamber of the Regional Administrative Court overturned this decision on January 28, 2021, and dismissed the case. The Chamber concluded that, given the determination that "reports from state security units were taken into account," there was "no violation of national or international texts in the act subject to the lawsuit, which was established within the scope of sovereign authority."

In the individual application, the applicant alleged that he was dismissed from his job without receiving severance pay, could not find work in Greece, that they could not register their marriage in Türkiye, and that his spouse could not meet with her family in Türkiye. He also relied on his spouse's mother's illness, argued that the ban was initially imposed for five years and then extended by another five, and claimed that it was based solely on intelligence. Alongside family life, he mentioned the freedom of settlement and travel, the right to work, and the right to a fair trial; the Court examined the application under the right to respect for family life.

The summary of the lawsuit petition in the decision only mentions a fiancé and does not refer to the marriage; it is unclear from the text when the marriage was raised during the lower court proceedings. Nevertheless, the Court determined that the allegations regarding family life were not evaluated in the Regional Administrative Court's decision.

Why Did the Constitutional Court Decide That the Right to Respect for Family Life Was Violated?

The Court acknowledged the State's authority to control the entry and residence of foreigners and delineated the limits of this authority through judicial reasoning. The reasoning proceeds in four steps:

  1. There is family life and an interference. The Court accepted that a family life existed at the time of the lawsuit without separately debating the timing of the marriage, and that the ban constituted an interference with this right (§ 13).
  2. The interference has a legal basis and a legitimate aim. The Court stated that the interference was based on Law No. 6458 and had the legitimate aim of ensuring national security; therefore, the violation did not stem from this stage (§ 16).
  3. The criteria have been reiterated. The State may control the entry of foreigners, but a fair balance must be struck in cases where strong family ties exist. In measures taken related to terrorist activities and for the purpose of national security, public authorities must present "sufficient and serious information" to judicial authorities, and judicial authorities must show their "reasoning in their decisions" (§ 15).
  4. The reasoning of the Regional Administrative Court did not meet this criterion. The decision did not contain an evaluation regarding the scope of family life or the allegations concerning family life. The Court expressed the second deficiency as follows:

“In addition, it is understood that no further assessment was made regarding the suspicion in question concerning the applicant, and that it was not discussed whether there existed sufficient and serious information, which is required to be presented when examining the lawfulness of an administrative act that could directly affect the applicant’s family life. It is assessed that the judgment was established without considering the negative effects the act would have on the applicant’s family life and without providing relevant and sufficient grounds in this sense.” (§ 18)

For this reason, the Court concluded that no balancing was performed between the public interest and family life, and that the elements of the decision were not relevant and sufficient enough to allow for such a balancing (§ 19). The findings of the first-instance court regarding the lack of concrete findings were quoted in § 17, but the Constitutional Court did not state that it adopted these as its own findings. There is no finding in the decision regarding whether the applicant is dangerous in terms of national security.

If the Marriage Was Concluded After the Ban, On What Date Is Family Life Looked For?

According to the author’s assessment, this is the most debatable point of the decision; the Court did not declare the date of the lawsuit as a general rule. In § 12, the Court stated that the first issue to be resolved in applications concerning deportation or entry ban decisions is whether the foreigner had a private and/or family life in the country “at the date the deportation process was established.” This sentence does not specify a separate date for an entry ban. The date mentioned in § 13 is July 25, 2019, when the lawsuit was filed in the administrative judiciary.

The Court stated that on this date, “it is clear that a family life established with a Turkish citizen is in question.” The reason for the difference between the two paragraphs is not explained in the reasoning of the decision, and the fact that the marriage took place after the ban is not discussed separately. The dissenting opinion repeated the same expression, stating that the applicant was not married to a Turkish citizen before the ban was implemented and did not have a family life during the period he lived in Turkey, and it also examined the obstacles to living in another country for the period after the marriage.

Therefore, the result that “every marriage after a ban is protected” cannot be drawn from the decision, because the decision relates to a specific combination of facts. The marriage took place after the ban but before the lawsuit was filed, and the Regional Administrative Court’s decision did not contain any assessment regarding family life. The main questions left open by the decision are as follows:

  • Marriage after the filing of the lawsuit: The decision does not contain an assessment regarding this situation.
  • Rejection of the application for removal: In this file, the lawsuit is directed directly at the ban. In the Council of State’s (Danıştay) file numbered E. 2020/4631 however, the rejection of the application for removal was sued. If the rejection process is after the marriage, it can be argued that family life also existed at the date of the process; the Constitutional Court did not examine this possibility.
  • Location of family life: The Court did not make a determination that they lived together in Turkey, nor did it state where the spouse lived.
  • Genuineness of the marriage: Neither the majority nor the dissenting opinion discussed this issue. In a file where the administration objects to the genuineness of the marriage, the same assessment would not automatically apply.

Why Did the Dissenting Opinion Not See a Violation? The Possibility of the Family Living in Another Country

İrfan Fidan and Yılmaz Akçil argued that the application should be found inadmissible for being manifestly ill-founded, and that even if the merits were examined, the justifications of the Regional Administrative Court were relevant and sufficient, and no violation had occurred. At the heart of this view lies the burden of providing detailed information regarding family life and substantiating the complaint in order to establish a fair balance.

According to the dissenting opinion, the applicant was not married to a Turkish citizen before the ban, and the claims regarding the illness of the spouse's mother were not raised during the trial stage, nor were any documents attached to the individual application. There was no persuasive justification for why residing in Turkey with the spouse was based on a compelling necessity, nor was there evidence demonstrating an abuse of discretion; it was also observed in the spouse's civil registry that the marriage had been recorded in Turkish records. The sentence summarizing the view is as follows:

“However, the applicant, who established his matrimonial union in Greece, has not submitted information and findings to the application file regarding the existence of serious obstacles to him and his spouse going to Greece or another country and continuing their family life there.” (Dissenting opinion, § 6)

This view is not without precedent in case law. The Court, in its unanimous decision in the Majid Momtaz judgment, observed that no serious obstacle had been shown for the applicant, who has a Turkish citizen spouse and two children, to live with his family in Iran or another country (§ 51). However, this counter-example relates to a deportation proceeding, not an entry ban; the applicant had not resided lawfully and had received prison sentences for the crime of using forged documents (§§ 47-50). Therefore, the outcome cannot be directly transferred to the Chasanoglou file. The examination of family life in deportation files was addressed in the previous article of the series.

The majority decision does not contain a separate assessment regarding the family's possibility of living in Greece. According to the author's assessment, it cannot be concluded that this criterion has been abandoned because the Court did not establish the balance itself, but rather found that the balance had not been established; for this reason, the issue may come to the agenda in a retrial.

What Does the G-82 Code Mean, Where Does Article 9 of Law No. 6458 Stand?

In the decision, G-82 is defined as a restriction code concerning persons “who are engaged in activities against national security or are suspected of being so engaged” (§ 2), and the same definition is also valid in the G.M.T. judgment. According to the author's assessment, since the definition also covers suspicion, it is particularly important for this code that the Court seeks further evaluation regarding the “suspected activities in question.”

The Chasanoglou judgment indicated Law No. 6458 as the basis for the intervention but did not specify the article number, whereas in the G.M.T. judgment, this Law was not cited at all. For this reason, a clear match between the G-82 code and Article 9 cannot be derived from the read decisions. The Council of State, on the other hand, in the file numbered E. 2024/1506 used the expression “entry ban with G-82 restriction code” and also mentioned the deportation process issued in accordance with subparagraph (b) of the first paragraph of Article 54 due to the same record.

The text of Article 9 was quoted as it stood at the time of the transaction in the decision numbered E. 2020/4631 concerning the G-87 code. According to the third paragraph, “The duration of the entry ban to Turkey is five years at most,” and this period may be increased by up to ten years in case of a serious threat to public order or public security. According to the sixth paragraph, the administration “may lift the entry ban or allow the foreigner to enter Turkey for a certain period of time without prejudice to the entry ban.” In Lexpera’s legislation record, the third and sixth paragraphs are not shown among the amendments of Law No. 7196.

The applicant's claim regarding the five-year period and the extension, as well as the objection that the ban was indefinite, were not evaluated in the decision. G-87 is a separate code; for this code G-87 guide can be consulted.

In Which File Did the Claim of Family Ties Yield a Result, and in Which Did It Not?

The following decisions were selected to demonstrate the difference in outcomes. The table is not statistical and should not be read as a success rate. Momtaz is an example in the opposite direction, but it relates to deportation proceedings, not an entry ban.

Ruling Action and reasoning Family ties Conclusion Defining point
Chasanoglou, 2021/14332 (28.01.2026) G-82, national security Marriage to a Turkish citizen, after the ban Violation of Art. 20, majority vote Family life was not evaluated, no balancing test was performed.
Musa Polat, 2021/2290 (27.11.2024) Ç-138 and Ç-141, public order risk Mother, father, and siblings stated to reside in Turkey; former Turkish citizen Violation of Art. 20 (private and family life), unanimous vote The accuracy of intelligence information was not investigated, and the impacts on private and family life were not balanced.
G.M.T., 2021/17696 (05.11.2025) G-82, unlawfulness of the action was previously established 2012 marriage and a child, before the ban Violation of Art. 40 in conjunction with Art. 20, unanimous vote The refusal of non-pecuniary damages was found to be abstract and general; the full remedy action (tam yargı) was ineffective.
Majid Momtaz, 2017/24261 (30.09.2020) Deportation, public order, crimes involving forged documents Turkish citizen spouse and two children No violation of Art. 20, unanimous vote Public order outweighed the interest, no serious obstacles were demonstrated in another country.
Council of State 10th Chamber, E. 2016/2616, K. 2021/2318 (17.05.2021) Ç-120, visa violation Turkish citizen spouse and a minor child Cancellation upheld, unanimous vote The first-instance court relied on family ties and ECHR Art. 8; the record had already been removed by the administration.
Council of State 10th Chamber, E. 2020/4631, K. 2024/5214 (21.11.2024) G-87, refusal of the removal application, intelligence Claim of having lived with spouse and children for 15 years Refusal decision overturned, unanimous vote No concrete information could be provided; the grounds for the removal of the codes will be investigated.

According to the author's assessment, four conclusions can be drawn from these decisions:

  • In the Chasanoglou and Polat decisions, the weight lies not in the name of the bond itself, but in whether it was examined or not. In the Polat decision, the spouse is not mentioned; the applicant's account emphasizes the mother, father, and siblings. The Court determined that no examination or balancing test was performed regarding the effects of the action on private and family life (§§ 20-21), and it also required the applicant to demonstrate the negative effects 'based on concrete data' (§ 13).
  • The justification for the ban may influence the balance. In file no. E. 2016/2616, the ban was based on a visa violation; the first-instance court considered family ties and the removal of the record by the administration, while the Chamber upheld the decision with a brief justification, finding the appeal grounds unfounded. This result cannot be directly transferred to a record justified by national security.
  • Family ties alone are not always sufficient. In the Momtaz file, despite the applicant's statement of approximately 30 years of residence in Turkey, a Turkish citizen spouse, and two children, the Court did not find a violation in the face of illegal residence and forgery crimes.
  • Concrete information can be tested via an interim decision. In file E. 2020/4631, the court of first instance also found the action to be lawful by “taking into account the reports of state security units,” and this expression is very close to the reasoning in the Chasanoglou file. The Chamber determined that no concrete information or document justifying the restriction code was presented in response to the correspondence requested, and upon the administration's notification that the codes were removed, it reversed the decision by stating that the justification for their removal should also be investigated. There is no explicit assessment in the decision regarding the applicant's family claims.

In the Danıştay decisions in the table, the remedy of correction of decision is shown as available, and their finality is not understood from the text; a reversal is also not the end of the case. For the general view of previous Danıştay decisions to the restriction code precedent decisions article can be consulted.

Where Is a Case Against an Entry Ban Filed, and What Legal Recourse Remains After the Regional Administrative Court?

Jurisdiction: of the Danıştay In the decision numbered E. 2025/3880, K. 2025/3927 A lawsuit was filed against the implied rejection of the application made to the Istanbul Provincial Directorate of Migration Management for the removal of the Ç-120 code. As the application was not forwarded to the Presidency of Migration Management, the Chamber deemed the administrative court in Istanbul, where the authority that performed the action is located, as competent pursuant to Article 32 of Law No. 2577. Competence in this file was determined according to the authority that performed the transaction subject to the lawsuit, not according to the code name. For details to the competent and authorized court section can be consulted.

Timeframe: There is no assessment regarding the litigation period in the Chasanoglou decision; this silence does not mean that the period is unimportant. For the calculation to the period section in restriction code lawsuits must be examined.

If there is a deportation decision: In file E. 2024/1506, the Chamber decided that the two lawsuits regarding the deportation action based on the G-82 record and the entry ban to the country are related because the result of one will affect the other. For the deportation lawsuit to the deportation decision article can be consulted.

Finality: In the decision numbered E. 2025/2376, K. 2025/2781 The Chamber rejected the request for appeal by stating that the G-87 code lawsuit is not listed in Article 46 of Law No. 2577, and therefore the decision of the Regional Administrative Court is final. In the Polat file, the Regional Administrative Court also rendered a final decision. In the Chasanoglou file, an individual application was made after the final verdict. In files E. 2016/2616 and E. 2020/4631, the administrative court decisions were examined by the Danıştay upon appeal and reference was made to provisional Article 8 of the same Law; therefore, those files should not be shown as examples of the current legal remedy. For the principles regarding individual application to the application procedure section can be consulted.

Did the Constitutional Court Lift the Ban? Consequences and Limitations of the Decision

No. There is no clause in the judgment regarding the removal of the restriction code or the admission of the applicant to Türkiye. The results are as follows:

  • Retrial: According to the judgment, the decision will be sent to the Ankara 1st Administrative Court to be forwarded to the Ankara Regional Administrative Court 10th Administrative Litigation Chamber for the purpose of a retrial. What is expected from the authority is to render a new decision by remedying the reasons for the violation of rights (§ 22).
  • The outcome of the case is not certain: According to the court, the decision of violation is “independent of the results of the dispute,” and the authority to draw conclusions from the evidence belongs to the lower courts (§ 23). In the retrial, the action may be annulled, or the case may be dismissed again.
  • Current situation: The result of the retrial and the current status of the ban are not understood from the text of the decision.
  • Monetary result: The applicant requested a finding of violation and a retrial; in the decision, compensation was not awarded, only 40,487.60 TL in litigation costs was adjudicated.
  • Other files: The decision does not automatically have consequences for other individuals. Each file is examined with its own dates, family ties, and security information.

In the limited web scan and Lexpera record of November 2026, no regulation amending Article 9 after the date of the decision was encountered. As the official text of the legislation could not be accessed, this finding does not mean that there are no amendments.

Which Aspects Should Be Examined in the Case of a Foreigner with a Turkish Spouse?

The first step is to separate four dates: the date of the ban, the date of marriage, the date of the rejection of the removal application (if any), and the date of the lawsuit. In addition, the following issues may affect the outcome:

  • Entering the marriage into the case file: The case petition summary of the Chasanoglou decision only mentions the fiance. Marriage, civil registry records, and the status of the spouse must be explicitly written during the litigation phase.
  • Presenting the facts before the lower court: The dissenting opinion evaluated the failure to raise the claim of illness during the trial to the detriment of the applicant.
  • Obstacles to living in another country: The spouse's job, family, care obligations, and the status of the children must be documented in a way that answers the question in the Momtaz decision.
  • Supporting documents: As in file no. E. 2020/4631, it may be requested that the concrete basis of the record be demanded via an interim decision.
  • Removal application: In file no. E. 2025/3880, the applied authority determined the authorized court, and the deficiency in the power of attorney led to the petition not being processed.
  • Temporary solution: The sixth paragraph of Article 9 and the administrative remedies in the guide can also be evaluated. For the stay after the ban is lifted, family residence permit the conditions must be examined.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Marrying a Turkish Citizen Automatically Lift an Entry Ban?

No, the Constitutional Court's Bılal Padalı Chasanoglou decision does not state that marriage lifts the ban. The Court did not lift the ban, but acknowledged the existence of family life on the date of the lawsuit and sent the file for retrial. It required the lower court to evaluate family life and establish a balance with the public interest; the ban may be maintained in the retrial.

Is a Marriage Entered Into After the Ban Considered Family Life?

The majority of the Constitutional Court accepted that there was family life on the lawsuit date of 25 July 2019, regarding a marriage concluded on 22 October 2018, following a ban applied at the border on 13 March 2018. The Court did not discuss the timing separately, while the dissenting opinion emphasized that no marriage existed before the ban. The decision does not include an assessment for marriages contracted after the lawsuit was filed.

What Does the G-82 Restriction Code Mean?

In Constitutional Court decisions, G-82 is defined as a restriction code for persons who are "Engaging in Activities Against National Security or Suspected of Doing So." The Chasanoglou decision cited the Law No. 6458 as the basis, but did not specify the article number; G-87 is a separate code.

Does the Fact That We Can Live in Another Country With My Spouse Affect the Case?

This matter can affect the case. In the Majid Momtaz decision regarding deportation proceedings, the Constitutional Court considered the absence of serious obstacles to the family living in another country. The dissenting opinion in the Chasanoglou decision also relied on the same point, while the majority did not make a separate assessment on this issue.

Can the Decision of the Regional Administrative Court in an Entry Ban Case Be Appealed to the Council of State?

The Tenth Chamber of the Council of State rejected the appeal request in the G-87 case with File No. E. 2025/2376, stating that the case is not listed in Article 46 of Law No. 2577 and that the decision of the Regional Administrative Court is final. In the Chasanoglou file, the applicant filed an individual application after the final decision.

Can a Temporary Entry Permit to Turkey Be Obtained While an Entry Ban Is in Effect?

The sixth paragraph of Article 9 of Law No. 6458, quoted in the Council of State's decision, provides that the administration may lift the ban or allow entry for a specific period while the ban remains in effect. Since the provision uses the term "may grant," it should not be read as a right, and this avenue was not specifically discussed in the Chasanoglou decision.

Can Compensation Be Requested if the Entry Ban Is Cancelled?

In the G.M.T. file, after the illegality of the G-82 action was established, the non-pecuniary compensation awarded by the administrative court in the full remedy action was overturned in the appellate stage. The Constitutional Court found the justification abstract and general, and by stating that the full remedy path was ineffective in practice, it unanimously decided that the right to an effective remedy linked to family life was violated; it did not award compensation itself but sent it for retrial.

Conclusion: Marriage Does Not Erase a Ban, It Forces the Court to Weigh Family Life

The Constitutional Court's decision dated January 28, 2026, does not open for debate the authority to control the entry of foreigners and the legitimacy of the national security objective. The decision, for the purposes of this file, shows that a general reference to the reports of security units and sovereign power is not considered sufficient without evaluating family life claims and discussing sufficient and serious information.

In this file, the existence of family life was accepted, but the ban was not lifted, and the possibility of the family living in another country was also at the center of the dissenting opinion. For this reason, in similar files, the first question is the order of the dates, the second question is how concretely family life has been introduced into the file, and the third question is what information the administration can present to the judicial authority.

Legal Resources and Related Reviews

Legislation

Constitutional Court Judgments

The links go to the pages where the text of the decision is read. Decisions can also be searched by application number in the Constitutional Court Decision Database.

Council of State Decisions

The list contains the decisions mentioned in the text, it is not a complete set of scanning results. All decisions belong to the 10th Chamber. Similar decisions Council of State decision search can also be searched from the page.

Other Resources and Related Articles

Author and Legal Information

Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008

This text is a legal case analysis based on the decision of the First Section of the Constitutional Court dated 28.01.2026, Bılal Padalı Chasanoglou, App. No: 2021/14332. The analysis is limited to the published text of the decision; it does not imply that the same result will be obtained in other cases.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Author

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Founding attorney of Batın Yılmaz Law Office. Handles litigation and consultancy in foreigners and citizenship law, as well as criminal, corporate, administrative, real estate, enforcement, and compensation law.

About our office