Precedent decision reviews

Refusal of Certificate of Conformity Annulled: Official Deed and Preliminary Sales Contract, Council of State 10th Chamber

In this article 17 headings
  1. Short Answer: Can a Certificate of Conformity be Refused Because the Official Deed Price Falls Below the Threshold?
  2. Citation of the Council of State 10th Chamber Decision
  3. How Did the Dispute Begin? The Threshold Issue Emerged When the 2019 Preliminary Sales Contract Was Converted to a Title Deed in 2021
  4. What Did the Plaintiff and the Administration Argue?
  5. Why Did the Case Not Become Moot Even Though the Certificate of Conformity Was Granted Later?
  6. Why Was the Rule Requiring the Official Deed, Valuation, and Payment Receipt Together Not Annulled?
  7. Why Did the Chamber Find the Refusal of the Certificate of Conformity Unlawful?
  8. Which Questions Did the Interpretation of "Or" Leave Open?
  9. Is the $250,000 Threshold Still Valid Today?
  10. To What Extent Can This Decision Be Used in Current Applications?
  11. What Did the Council of State Consider in Similar Files?
  12. How to File a Lawsuit Against the Refusal of a Certificate of Conformity?
  13. What Issues Should Be Examined in a File Where the Title Deed Price Remains Below the Threshold?
  14. Frequently Asked Questions
  15. Conclusion: The Title Deed Price Is Not the Final Word Alone, But the Three-Value Rule Still Stands
  16. Legal Resources and Related Reviews
  17. Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Written and reviewed by: Atty. Batın Yılmaz (Istanbul Bar Association, Reg. No: 77008)
Publication:  ·  Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.

refusal of certificate of conformity

Short Answer: Can a Certificate of Conformity be Refused Because the Official Deed Price Falls Below the Threshold?

According to the Council of State 10th Chamber, if the value in the preliminary sales contract arranged at a notary satisfies the minimum investment amount, the refusal of a certificate of conformity cannot be based solely on the official deed price falling below the threshold. However, the rule requiring the official deed or preliminary sales contract value, the valuation report, and the payments to separately meet the threshold was not annulled.

The Chamber reached this conclusion in its decision dated December 4, 2025, numbered E. 2022/194, K. 2025/5781. The Chamber rejected the lawsuit regarding the first two paragraphs of the "D- Valuation" section and the "1-Exchange Rate" part of the Guide attached to General Circular No. 2019/5 of the General Directorate of Land Registry and Cadastre, while annulling the administrative action refusing the objection to the certificate of conformity request; the decision was given unanimously. The reasoning stated that the "or" conjunction in the "and/or" expression in the Guide grants an optional right between the official deed and the preliminary sales contract, that there was no situation such as fraud or tax evasion in the case, and that the negativity arising from the exchange rate difference cannot be imposed on the investor.

The decision belongs to a period when the $250,000 threshold was applied and cannot be automatically transferred to today's applications. For contracts after June 13, 2022, the threshold is $400,000; the phrase "equivalent in Turkish Lira" has been removed from the Regulation, and the Guide attached to General Circular No. 2019/5 has been repealed. As the right to appeal on points of law is indicated in the decision, it is not understood from the text whether it has become final.

This analysis is based on the published decision text; party information and some dates and numbers in the text have been concealed. For a general explanation of the conditions, citizenship by investment guide,and for the nature of the document and the application process, certificate of conformity article. can be consulted.

Citation of the Council of State 10th Chamber Decision

Title Information
Court Council of State 10th Chamber, first instance
Basis and decision number E. 2022/194, K. 2025/5781
Decision date 04.12.2025, with hearing
Subject of the lawsuit The action of rejecting the objection made against the refusal of the certificate of conformity request; the first two paragraphs of the "D- Valuation" section of the Guide attached to the Circular and the "1-Exchange Rate" part
Circular In the operative part, 2019/5 (1779), in the transfer of legislation and in other decisions of the same Chamber, 2019/5 (1799)
Legal Basis Law No. 5901 Article 12/1-(b), Regulation on the Implementation of the Turkish Citizenship Law Article 20/2-(b)
Reporting judge and prosecutor Both are of the opinion of rejection regarding the Circular and annulment regarding the individual administrative action
Conclusion Dismissal of the case regarding the circular, annulment of the individual transaction, unanimous vote
Legal remedy Appeal to the Council of State Plenary Assembly of Administrative Chambers within 30 days from the day following the notification

How Did the Dispute Begin? When the Promise to Sell in 2019 Turned into a Title Deed in 2021, a Threshold Problem Arose

The foreign national claimant acquired an independent unit under construction in the Bayraklı district of İzmir for the purpose of acquiring Turkish citizenship through the exceptional path. The price of the prepaid residential sales promise contract executed before a notary was stated in the decision as 1,430,000 TL (257,671.58 USD), and it was stated that the prepayment was made in 2019. The claimant paid a total of 1,440,000 TL through transfers on various dates; the real estate was purchased with an official deed dated August 16, 2021, for a price of 1,431,500 TL.

The claimant first applied to the 3rd Regional Directorate (İzmir) of the General Directorate of Land Registry and Cadastre for a certificate of conformity on August 17, 2021. The Regional Directorate rejected the request, stating that the value in the valuation reports and receipts met the 250,000 USD threshold, but the official deed price remained below this amount. After the objection dated October 12, 2021, was also rejected, a lawsuit was filed.

Date Development Legal Significance
2019 Sales promise contract with a price of 1,430,000 TL (257,671.58 USD) The Chamber accepted that the threshold was met with the exchange rate on the date of the contract.
16.08.2021 Official deed with a price of 1,431,500 TL According to the administration, the threshold was not met in terms of this value.
17.08.2021 Initial application for certificate of conformity The Regulation required 250,000 USD or its equivalent in Turkish Lira.
27.08.2021 Second property in Bornova with a price of 150,000 TL The total value of the two properties was also discussed in the decision.
12.10.2021 Objection to the rejection decision The decision to reject the objection became the subject of the lawsuit.
19.11.2021 Lawsuit filed Both the individual administrative action and the Circular were challenged in court.
11.10.2022 Certificate of conformity issued Issued because the claimant paid the missing title deed fee and penalty.
04.12.2025 Council of State decision Rejection regarding the Circular, cancellation regarding the individual administrative action.

The dates of the sales promise contract, the rejection decision, and the rejection of the objection are not shown in the chronology as they were hidden in the published text. The USD equivalent of the official deed price and the dates of the receipts are also not present in the decision.

What Did the Plaintiff and the Administration Argue?

The claimant argued that the Circular imposed a condition not found in the Regulation, and that requiring the official deed price to be above the threshold was contrary to the hierarchy of norms and Articles 2 and 16 of the Constitution. The claimant also argued that receipt values should be calculated based on the exchange rate on the date of the contract. The claimant stated that they did not include their property in Çeşme in the application upon the direction of the administration; this claim was not separately evaluated in the decision.

The administration argued that a value assessment could not be made within the scope of the Circular due to the submission of multiple receipts with different dates and extraordinary exchange rate fluctuations. It reported that to overcome this problem, the missing title deed fee and the penalty for the notice of remorse regarding the irregularity for the difference between the 1,431,500 TL in the official deed and the 1,440,000 TL paid had to be paid, and that a determination was possible only under this condition.

Why Did the Case Not Become Moot Even Though the Certificate of Conformity Was Granted Later?

The Regional Directorate issued a certificate of conformity in the name of the claimant on October 11, 2022, after the lawsuit was filed. The Chamber determined that this certificate was not issued by way of ex officio withdrawal of the administrative action subject to the lawsuit, but was issued after the claimant fulfilled the requirements of the action by paying the missing title deed fee and the penalties for the notice of remorse regarding the irregularity. For this reason, the Chamber accepted that the claims of illegality were not eliminated and proceeded to the merits.

This finding shows that complying with the correction requested by the administration does not terminate the right to sue in this case. There is, however, no provision in the decision regarding the refund of the paid fees and penalties.

Why Was the Rule Requiring the Official Deed, Valuation, and Payment Receipt Together Not Annulled?

The Chamber first accepted that the General Directorate of Land Registry and Cadastre is authorized to determine the investment, calculate the value of the real estate, and determine the foreign exchange rate to be taken into account in the documents. Paragraph 9, added to Article 20 of the Regulation while the lawsuit was ongoing, also stipulates that the procedures and principles shall be determined by the institution making the determination.

Regarding the merits, the Chamber explained the purpose of the rule as involving a two-fold risk. Valuation reports and payment receipts are audited to prevent the unfair acquisition of citizenship by showing the contract price as collusively high. If only the receipts were examined, tax evasion could occur by showing the price in the official deed as being below the actual value; therefore, the deed price is also taken into account. The Chamber found no violation of law or its underlying legislation in the regulation that audits the reality of the investment and the inflow of foreign currency into Türkiye.

Regarding the “1-Exchange Rate” section, it evaluated the practice of using the exchange rate on the receipt in cases of advance payment as a solution to prevent the investor from being unfairly affected by subsequent exchange rate increases, considering it the exchange rate for the promissory note or contract. The table below summarizes the exchange rate rules of the Guide, which was subsequently repealed.

Subject Exchange rate or criterion used as the basis
Receipt paid in TL CBRT effective selling rate of the last business day before the payment date
Promissory note or contract for which no advance payment was made Exchange rate of the last business day before the sales application or the contract at the notary
Single receipt or same-day receipts for advance payment Exchange rate used for the receipt meeting the threshold
Receipts with different dates for advance payment A separate dollar calculation may not be required for the promissory note or contract; the TL value cannot be lower than the TL total of the receipts meeting the threshold
Valuation report Exchange rate of the last business day before the report date

Why Did the Chamber Find the Refusal of the Certificate of Conformity Unlawful?

The persistence of the Circular did not result in an outcome against the plaintiff, as the Chamber interpreted the same text in the plaintiff's favor. The interpretation is summarized in the following sentence:

“...It was concluded that by including the ‘or’ conjunction between the sales price declared in the official deed and the value determined in the promise to sell, an optional right was granted regarding which of the values in the official deed and the promise to sell should be taken as the basis for meeting the 250,000 US Dollar condition; therefore, if the sales price in the official deed does not meet the 250,000 US Dollar condition, but the value determined in the promise to sell satisfies said amount, it must be accepted that the investment condition sought in the Circular and, consequently, in the Regulation, has been fulfilled.”

While applying this interpretation to the case file, the Chamber made three further findings:

  1. The value in the promise to sell met the threshold. The equivalent of 1,430,000 TL in the contract was 257,671.58 dollars, and the Chamber regarded this value as a value “equivalent to the official deed.”
  2. The administration's own letters supported the result. It was understood from the letters dated September 26, 2022, and October 11, 2022, that after the payment of the deficient fee and penalty, the Ministry of Interior was notified that the investment amount and commitment condition had been fulfilled.
  3. The purpose of the rule was not violated in this case. The Chamber stated that there was no situation such as fraud or tax evasion in the case, and that the dispute arose from the exchange rate increase between 2019 and 2021.

The final finding carries the decision's emphasis on equity:

“...in the period until the completion of the construction of the real estate purchased while it was incomplete, the negativity arising from exchange rate differences due to economic conditions cannot be attributed to the plaintiff, because the 250,000 US Dollar investment condition required by the legislation was met by the plaintiff at the exchange rate valid on the date the promise to sell contract was signed, and considering that construction requires a certain period of time, it is not found to be in accordance with the principles of legal security and certainty, nor with equity, to expect the plaintiff to make a new investment for every exchange rate increase during the period until the official sale takes place and the application to the defendant administration is made...”

The Chamber added that the expression “or” was used for this reason and did not find any compliance with the law in the decision to reject the objection.

What Questions Did the “Or” Interpretation Leave Open?

The value of the decision lies in changing the result without changing the rule. Since the Chamber interpreted the text in favor of the investor instead of canceling it, the limits of the interpretation must be drawn correctly.

First, the first paragraph of the “D- Valuation” section uses the term “and/or” rather than “or.” The Chamber, however, acknowledged an elective right by mentioning the phrase “official deed or sales promise contract”; there is no explicit assessment in the decision regarding the meaning of the “and” option. The second paragraph of the same section states that the valuation in a sales transaction shall be made based on the declared value in the official deed and that this value cannot be changed. This paragraph was not annulled either; the relationship between the paragraph and the elective right interpretation was not separately addressed in the decision.

Secondly, the interpretation depends on the existence of a second value. In a sale made directly at the title deed office without a preliminary sales contract, there is no other value to benefit from the 'or' conjunction. This possibility was not addressed in the decision, but since the rule requiring three values remains in effect, it is difficult to reach the same conclusion.

Thirdly, the Chamber explained the optional right with specific reservations. In its review of the circular, it used the phrase 'provided that the investment condition is met in terms of receipt exchange rates' and based its reasoning on the fact that the investor provided the necessary amount on the contract date and that the decline arose from a currency increase 'not caused by the investor.' By ignoring these reservations, it cannot be said that a preliminary sales contract is sufficient in every case. Whether the advance payment and registration record requirements sought by the regulation for the preliminary sales contract path were met in this case was also not evaluated in the decision.

Under-declaration or Currency Difference?

Two different narratives stand side-by-side in the decision. In the procedural section and the part where the administration's letters are quoted, the issue is expressed as the claimant under-declaring the value in the official deed. In the Chamber's purpose-based assessment, it is stated that there is no situation such as fraud or tax evasion in the case and that the dispute arose from the rise in the exchange rate. How these two narratives are reconciled is not explained in the decision.

From the amounts of 1,430,000 TL and 257,671.58 dollars in the contract, an exchange rate of approximately 5.55 TL per dollar is derived. The official deed value is 1,500 TL higher than the contract price and 8,500 TL lower than the total of the receipts. These three numbers do not appear in the decision; they have been calculated by the author from the amounts in the decision. The Chamber attributed the decrease to the rise in the dollar exchange rate, but did not show the dollar equivalent of the deed value. The administration, on the other hand, based the deficient fee on the difference between the deed and the total of the receipts. Since the guide requires that the deed value not be lower than the receipt total in receipts with different dates, this claim may have arisen from that rule. As the Chamber did not establish such a connection and the receipt dates are not in the text, this assessment also belongs to the author.

Do the Regulation and the Guide Say the Same Thing on the Date of the Exchange Rate?

Article 20, paragraph 6 of the Regulation stipulates that the TCMB effective selling rate and/or cross-currency rate on the 'date of determination' shall be taken as the basis for determining monetary values. This paragraph in the decision numbered E. 2020/3336 even if it is cited, it does not appear in the legislation section of the main decision. The Guide, however, takes the last business day before the payment, transaction, and report dates as the basis. Since the relationship between the two regulations is not addressed in the main decision, the question of which moment the phrase 'date of determination' points to should not be considered closed.

Is the $250,000 Threshold Still Valid Today?

For sales and preliminary sales contracts after June 13, 2022, no. The Chamber applied the text '250,000 US Dollars or its Turkish Lira equivalent' which was in effect on the dates of the contract, deed, and transaction. There is no evaluation regarding 400,000 dollars in the decision; the contract, deed, application, and lawsuit are prior to June 13, 2022. The rule regarding the real estate path changed as follows:

Effective Date Regulation Amendment
12.01.2017 Council of Ministers Decision No. 2016/9601 1,000,000 dollars
19.09.2018 Presidential Decree No. 106 250,000 dollars or its equivalent in foreign currency or Turkish Lira
07.12.2018 Presidential Decree No. 418 Advance payment and annotated preliminary sales contract path added
06.01.2022 Presidential Decree No. 5072 The phrase 'Turkish Lira equivalent' was removed, paragraphs 9 and 10 were added
13.06.2022 Presidential Decree No. 5554 The threshold became 400,000 dollars or its equivalent in foreign currency (Official Gazette 13.05.2022, effective one month after publication)
12.12.2023 Presidential Decree No. 7938 The condition of real estate with land status on which condominium or easement has been established or which has a structure on it was introduced

Official Your Key Türkiye guide requires 400,000 USD for sales and preliminary sales contracts signed after 13.06.2022. No new regulation changing this amount was observed during the screening conducted in November 2026; The valuation amendment that entered into force on September 28, 2026 did not affect the threshold.

The regulation raising the threshold was not examined on its merits in the lawsuit filed by the Union of Turkish Bar Associations. The Chamber, With the decision E. 2022/3885, K. 2025/3745 The court dismissed the case by a majority vote regarding legal standing, stating that the regulation was not related to the legal profession. In the dissenting opinion, it was argued that the Union had an interest in filing the lawsuit due to its duty to protect the rule of law and that the merits of the case should be examined. The right to appeal (cassation) is also indicated as open in this decision.

To What Extent Can This Decision Be Used in Current Applications?

The core idea of the decision is that if the investment is genuine and the threshold was met on the date of the contract, exchange rate fluctuations should not be imposed on the investor solely. When applying this idea to a new file, the following differences should be considered:

  • Currency: Pursuant to Article 20, paragraph 10, the foreign currency amount is sold to a bank before the transaction, and by the bank to the Central Bank. Therefore, the exchange rate issue arising from TL payments may not emerge in the same way in new files.
  • Circular: According to decision E. 2020/5861, the Guide annexed to Circular 2019/5 was first amended on November 27, 2023, and subsequently abolished by Circular No. 2024/4 dated June 13, 2024. This change was not mentioned in the main decision.
  • Current text: The Your Key Türkiye guide retains the phrase "and/or". The headings of the new Guide seen in Lexpera address the official deed and the promise of sale price together with the foreign exchange purchase document. Since the entire Guide was not reviewed in this examination, the text as of the date of application must be checked separately.
  • Promise of sale: According to the Your Key Türkiye guide, the remaining part of the investment cannot be completed with a promise of sale contract after February 1, 2023.
  • Old contracts: Files based on a promise of sale issued before June 13, 2022, where the title deed was received subsequently, are areas where the decision can be discussed more directly. Since this possibility was not addressed in the decision, it must be evaluated separately in the specific case.
  • Other files: The decision does not automatically produce consequences for other individuals.

What Did the Council of State Consider in Similar Files?

In a search conducted in the UYAP Precedent Decision database in November 2026 using the phrase "not sold for three years," 8 Council of State decisions were listed. The number covers only published decisions and should not be read as a success rate. The decisions in the table were selected through this search and other relevant searches on the subject.

Ruling Incident The Chamber's approach Conclusion
E. 2020/3336, K. 2024/3481 (30.09.2024) Purchase of shares on 08.10.2018, application on 12.02.2019; the administration required $1,000,000 per person Since $250,000 was sufficient at the date of application, this amount should be considered for the sake of equity Dismissal regarding Circular 2018/14, cancellation of transactions, unanimous
E. 2020/5861, K. 2024/6304 (12.12.2024) The Turkish citizen buyer requested the correction of the price in the title deed according to the value in the report The price can be determined lower than the report; the correction of the price falls under the jurisdiction of the judicial courts Dismissal based on jurisdiction, dismissal regarding regulatory acts, unanimous
E. 2024/405, K. 2026/361 (05.02.2026) Foreign exchange purchase documents were found to be untrue, the certificate of conformity was cancelled, and citizenship was revoked The fact existed before citizenship; no lawsuit was filed against the cancellation of the document Dismissal, by unanimous vote
E. 2022/555, K. 2022/2618 (17.05.2022) Both the Circular and the Guide were sued together with the rejection of the certificate of conformity It must be indicated which article is requested to be cancelled and for what reason Dismissal of the petition, final
E. 2025/4115, K. 2025/3865 (16.09.2025) In a citizenship revocation case, a guarantee was requested to be able to obtain a new certificate of conformity The request is incompatible with the plaintiff's part; furthermore, the judiciary cannot issue a decision in the nature of an administrative act Dismissal of the petition, final

Draw four conclusions from these decisions:

  • The transaction may be set aside while the rule remains standing: With the main decision and in the file E. 2020/3336, a decision was rendered dismissing the case regarding the Circular but cancelling the individual transaction. The Chamber relied on equity in both files but did not find the regulatory rule to be unlawful. In the file E. 2020/3336, the issue was not the exchange rate difference, but the threshold that fell after the purchase.
  • Exchange rate protection assumes a genuine investment: The main decision was established with the finding that there was no equity assessment, forgery, or tax evasion. In file numbered E. 2024/405, however, the foreign currency purchase documents were found to be contrary to the truth; the Chamber stated that the prerequisite is “to make an investment in accordance with the truth and the law” and deemed the revocation process lawful. Equity was not discussed in this decision.
  • The low promissory note amount and the threshold are separate issues: In the case with file No. E. 2020/5861, the buyer was a Turkish citizen and had no citizenship application; the Chamber based the possibility of the price being lower than the report on freedom of contract. The three-value rule was not examined in this file. The fact that the report does not replace the deed or contract value follows from the separate threshold rule that was not annulled in the main judgment.
  • Correcting the deed amount is a separate path: In the same judgment, it was accepted that a request to correct the price, which is not considered a simple clerical error, falls under the jurisdiction of the judicial courts. In the main file, the problem was resolved through the payment of fees and penalties accepted by the administration; this solution should not be considered valid for every file.

How to File a Lawsuit Against the Refusal of a Certificate of Conformity?

In the main file, the plaintiff objected to the rejection decision, and the Regional Directorate also rejected the objection; the Chamber examined the filed lawsuit as a first-instance matter together with the Circular. If only an individual transaction is to be challenged, the competent jurisdiction must be determined separately. In the file with No. E. 2020/3336, the stages of the Land Registry Office, Regional Directorate, and General Directorate of Land Registry and Cadastre were followed. The Chamber evaluated the lawsuit filed on July 12, 2019, after the final implementation process dated June 17, 2019, within the 60-day period under Article 7 of Law No. 2577.

If the Circular is to be challenged together with the action, the petition must clearly indicate the target. In the file with No. E. 2022/555, the petition was rejected to be renewed within 30 days because it did not specify which articles were requested to be annulled and the grounds for illegality concerning the entire Circular. In the main file, however, the paragraphs subject to the lawsuit were indicated separately.

An annulment decision does not replace the document either. As stated in the decision with No. E. 2025/4115, judicial authorities cannot issue decisions in the nature of an administrative act; in the main judgment, it was ruled to annul the decision to reject the objection, not to issue a document. If the document is subsequently annulled, it may be necessary to follow a separate procedure against that action. In the file with No. E. 2024/405, the plaintiff did not file a lawsuit against this annulment, and the lawsuit filed against the revocation of citizenship was also rejected. Correspondence from the land registry regarding control reports must therefore be monitored separately.

What Issues Should Be Examined in a File Where the Title Deed Price Remains Below the Threshold?

  • Contract: Whether there is a sales promise arranged at a notary, its date, and the exchange rate used to meet the threshold (E. 2022/194).
  • Other two values: Whether the valuation report and the payment receipts each meet the threshold separately with their own exchange rates (E. 2022/194).
  • Price difference: Whether the difference between the deed amount and the receipt arises from exchange rate increases or the declaration, and the status of the three-year non-sale annotation (E. 2022/194).
  • Authenticity of payment: The accuracy of foreign exchange purchase documents (E. 2024/405).
  • Scope of the petition: Which part of the underlying regulation is challenged and for what reason (E. 2022/555).

Frequently Asked Questions

What Did the Council of State 10th Chamber Annul and What Did It Reject in the Conformity Certificate Lawsuit?

The Council of State 10th Chamber, with its decision dated December 4, 2025, No. E. 2022/194, K. 2025/5781, rejected the lawsuit regarding the first two paragraphs of the 'D- Value Determination' section of the Guide annexed to Circular No. 2019/5 and the '1- Exchange Rate' part. It annulled the decision to reject the objection regarding the conformity certificate request; the decision was given unanimously.

Is the Conformity Certificate Rejected If the Official Deed Price Stays Below the Threshold?

According to the Council of State 10th Chamber, if the value in the sales promise arranged at a notary meets the threshold, the rejection cannot be based solely on the official deed price. An evaluation regarding sales without a sales promise is not included in the decision. The valuation report and payments must also meet the threshold.

Can the Official Deed Price Be Lower If the Valuation Report Meets the Threshold?

In case No. E. 2020/5861, which did not involve a citizenship application, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State (Danıştay) based its ruling that the sale price may be determined lower than the valuation report on the principle of freedom of contract. However, since the decision in E. 2022/194 deems it lawful to require three separate values for citizenship by investment, the report value does not replace the value stated in the deed or the promise of sale agreement.

What is the Current Real Estate Threshold in Dollars for Turkish Citizenship by Investment?

According to Article 20 of the Regulation on the Implementation of the Turkish Citizenship Law, the current threshold for the real estate investment path is $400,000 or its foreign currency equivalent. This amount, introduced by Presidential Decree No. 5554, entered into force on June 13, 2022. In the case reviewed by the 10th Chamber of the Council of State, the $250,000 threshold was applied due to the contract and official deed predating this date.

Does the Lawsuit Become Moot if the Certificate of Conformity is Issued Subsequently?

In file E. 2022/194, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State did not consider the case moot because the administrative act was revoked ex officio, but rather because the certificate was issued as the plaintiff paid the outstanding fees and penalties. In cases where the administration revokes an act on its own initiative, the outcome must be evaluated separately.

Is the Council of State's Decision on the Certificate of Conformity Finalized?

It is not clear from the published text whether the decision of the 10th Chamber of the Council of State, E. 2022/194, K. 2025/5781, has been finalized. The decision states that an appeal to the Plenary Assembly of Administrative Chambers of the Council of State is open within 30 days from the day following its notification.

Conclusion: The Title Deed Price Is Not the Final Word Alone, But the Three-Value Rule Still Stands

The decision of the 10th Chamber of the Council of State dated December 4, 2025, demonstrates that when the value threshold is met in a preliminary sales contract, the refusal of a certificate of conformity cannot be based solely on the official deed price. The Chamber reached this conclusion by combining the interpretation of the 'or' conjunction, the administration's own correspondence, the absence of forgery or tax evasion, and the finding that exchange rate fluctuations cannot be attributed to the investor.

The same decision did not cancel the rule requiring three values to be met collectively or the exchange rate procedure. For contracts after June 13, 2022, the threshold is $400,000, the foreign currency must be sold to a bank prior to the transaction, and the application is based on Circular No. 2024/4. Therefore, in similar cases, the first question is the existence of a preliminary sales contract, and the second is which text and which threshold apply at the date of the contract and the application.

Legal Resources and Related Reviews

Legislation

Council of State Decisions

The list contains the decisions mentioned in the text, it is not a complete set of scanning results. All decisions belong to the 10th Chamber. Similar decisions Council of State decision search can also be searched from the page.

Other Resources and Related Articles

Author and Legal Information

Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008

This text is a legal decision analysis based on the decision of the 10th Chamber of the Council of State dated 04.12.2025, E. 2022/194, K. 2025/5781. The analysis is limited to the published decision text; it does not mean that the same result will be obtained in other cases.

The content on this page is for general information purposes and is open for use by all our colleagues. However, in accordance with the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, we kindly request that if the whole or any part of the article is used, the source must be cited as 'Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr' and a link to the relevant article must be provided.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Author

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Founding attorney of Batın Yılmaz Law Office. Handles litigation and consultancy in foreigners and citizenship law, as well as criminal, corporate, administrative, real estate, enforcement, and compensation law.

About our office