Precedent decision reviews
Child Abduction Under the Hague Convention: Constitutional Court Found Violation of Rights
In this article 15 headings
- Short Answer: Child abduction under the Hague Convention
- Citation of the Constitutional Court's Ş.G. Decision
- How Did the Dispute Start? The Return Case Filed When the Return from Vacation Did Not Occur
- What Did the Mother, Father, and the Ministry of Justice Argue?
- What Do the Hague Convention and Law No. 5717 Regulate in Return Cases?
- Why Did the Constitutional Court Find a Violation in the Return Decision?
- Was It Not Proven, or Was It Not Investigated? The Main Distinction in the Grave Danger Exception
- How Did the Same Criterion Yield Results in Different Files?
- My Child Was Brought to Türkiye, How Is a Return Requested and How Long Does the Case Take?
- What Results Does the Constitutional Court's Violation Decision Produce?
- What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion: Return Is the Rule, But a Decision That Does Not Investigate Risk May Not Stand
- Legal Resources and Related Reviews
- Author and Legal Information
Publication: · Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.
Short Answer: Child abduction under the Hague Convention
Under the Hague Convention, a Turkish court, as a rule, orders the immediate return of a child to their habitual residence in return requests. Return may only be denied if one of the limited exceptions in the Convention occurs, specifically if a serious risk is identified that the return would expose the child to physical or psychological danger.
The First Section of the Constitutional Court, in its decision dated March 4, 2026, in the application of Ş.G. (App. No: 2025/16250) ruled unanimously that the right to respect for family life was violated in the decision concerning the return of the children to the Netherlands. According to the Court, the father's living conditions in the Netherlands and the risks in the event of return were not investigated, and the consequences of separating the children from their mother, their siblings, and the conditions they were accustomed to were not demonstrated.
The decision does not constitute a guarantee for the parent holding the child in Türkiye. The Constitutional Court did not reject the return request; it sent the file back to the family court for a retrial and reiterated that familiarization with the environment and young age are not sufficient reasons on their own to avoid return. Moreover, the same Court did not find a violation in three Hague applications in 2025, concerning one return and two rejection decisions.
This review is based on the published decision texts; details that could identify the children are not included, and the Court of Cassation reversal in the Ş.G. file was read from its full text in UYAP. Since the child being taken from Türkiye without permission is a separate question, for this topic, see the article on the foreign parent taking the child from Türkiye without permission, for the effect of a divorce or custody decision in Türkiye alone, see the article on the validity of foreign court decisions can be consulted.
Citation of the Constitutional Court's Ş.G. Decision
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Title | Information |
|---|---|
| Court | Constitutional Court First Section |
| Application | Ş.G., App. No: 2025/16250 (identity kept confidential ex officio) |
| Decision date | 04.03.2026 |
| Official Gazette | 08.06.2026, 33274 |
| Subject | Decision for the return of children to their habitual residence in the Netherlands |
| Right examined | Article 20 of the Constitution, right to respect for family life |
| Conclusion | Violation of the right to respect for family life, unanimous |
| Remedy | Retrial in family court (ruling D); children not to be returned until the trial is concluded (ruling E) |
How Did the Dispute Start? The Return Case Filed When the Return from Vacation Did Not Occur
The applicant mother and father divorced in 2018 while living in the Netherlands. The recognition of the divorce decree was decided in the summer of 2022, and the mother arrived in Türkiye with the children during the same period. The date of September 5, 2022, was set for the return, but the return did not take place.
The father applied to the Dutch authorities, claiming that the children were being held against his will. Upon the notification of the Dutch authorities and the correspondence from the Ministry of Justice, the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office filed a return lawsuit.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Date | Development | Legal Significance |
|---|---|---|
| 05.09.2022 | The agreed-upon return date has passed. | According to the petition, the children have been held against the father's will since this date. |
| 28.02.2023 | A return lawsuit was filed. | The Chief Public Prosecutor's Office filed the lawsuit. |
| 15.06.2023 | The family court rejected the return request. | It relied on social investigation reports, the children's desire to stay with their mother, and the danger that could arise from being deprived of the mother's affection. |
| 01.02.2024 | The regional court of appeal rejected the appeal. | It stated that the children came for a vacation with the father's consent and were not brought illegally; it accepted that the refusal conditions in Article 13/1-b of the Convention were met due to the best interests of the child. |
| 18.04.2024 | 2nd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation E. 2024/2653, K. 2024/2670 reversed the decision unanimously. | It considered the breach of the right to non-refoulement, stated that the grounds for avoiding extradition could not be proven, and that the case should be accepted. |
| 20.02.2025 | The Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) upheld the extradition decision rendered after the reversal. | The decision has gone through legal remedies. |
| 07.04.2025 | Individual application was filed. | The final decision was served on 28.03.2025. |
| 30.04.2025 | The Constitutional Court issued an interim injunction. | It was noted that extradition could lead to irreparable consequences while information and documents were being gathered. |
| 13.05.2025 | The decision was made in accordance with the protocol in the custody case. | Joint custody was accepted; it was stipulated that the children would live with the mother in practice. |
Since the enforcement decision did not contain a provision regarding custody, custody remained in limbo; a separate proceeding was conducted upon the notification of the Population Directorate, and the decision dated June 6, 2023, which granted custody to the mother, was overturned on appeal.
What Did the Mother, Father, and the Ministry of Justice Argue?
The father's attorney argued that the mother had abducted the children, that the father had not given his consent, and that the mother had placed the children under pressure and prevented communication. He added that the mother's allegations were unfounded and that a decision of non-prosecution had been rendered regarding the investigation concerning the father. In the appeal, he also asserted that the Dutch courts had rejected the change of residence and granted custody to him.
The mother, on the other hand, claimed that she remained in Türkiye with the father's consent and could not return to the Netherlands due to threats from the father and his family. She stated that if returned, the children would be separated from their newborn sibling, that the father's living conditions had not been investigated, and that there was a risk of institutional care if the father were unable to care for the children. She also argued that the children's negative statements regarding the father and the social inquiry reports had not been taken into account. The decision text does not contain a finding regarding the truth of these claims; the court bases its decision on the fact that the allegations were not investigated.
The Ministry of Justice stated that since the parties had agreed on joint custody, it should be examined whether the victimization was still ongoing. The mother, in response, claimed that the interim injunction had not been served on her, and therefore, she was forced to accept the agreement.
What Do the Hague Convention and Law No. 5717 Regulate in Return Cases?
An abduction case is not a custody case. The question is not who the child will stay with, but in which country the custody dispute will be resolved. The Constitutional Court also explains the purpose of the Convention as the immediate return of abducted or wrongfully retained children and states that return is the rule, except for a "limited number of exceptional cases" (Ş.G., § 21). Fundamental provisions Turkish text of the Convention and Law No. 5717 is summarized below accordingly.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Subject | Ruling | Regulation |
|---|---|---|
| Wrongful removal or retention | Article 3 of the Convention | A breach of rights of custody according to the law of the state of habitual residence must be sought; the rights must have been exercised in fact or would have been so exercised. |
| Age limit | Article 4 of the Convention | The application of the Convention ceases when the child reaches the age of 16. |
| Six weeks | Article 11 of the Convention | If the authority "does not reach a decision within 6 weeks," the reason for the delay may be requested. |
| One-year period | Article 12 of the Convention | If an application is made before one year has elapsed, the return is ordered immediately; in a subsequent application, the return is ordered unless it is understood that the child has "settled into its new environment." |
| Consent or acquiescence | Article 13/1-a of the Convention | The failure to actually exercise the right of custody, or consent to the removal or subsequent acquiescence, makes the return non-mandatory. |
| Grave risk | Article 13/1-b of the Convention | A serious risk is sought that the return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an "intolerable" situation. |
| Child's views | Article 13/2 of the Convention | If the child, who is of an age and degree of maturity which makes it appropriate to take account of their views, does not wish to return, the return may be refused. |
| Fundamental rights | Article 20 of the Convention | The return may be refused if it is contrary to the principles of the requested state relating to human rights and fundamental freedoms. |
| Custody basis | Articles 16, 19 of the Convention; Articles 12-14 of Law No. 5717 | A return decision does not affect the merits of the right of custody; if a return is ordered, a separate custody decision is not rendered, and the custody case filed during the return proceedings is stayed. |
According to the Marcus Frank Cerny judgment, the serious danger exception is not equivalent to the concept of the best interests of the child and cannot be a means to assess the merits of the right of custody; classic examples are allegations of child abuse and domestic violence (§ 59).
Why Did the Constitutional Court Find a Violation in the Return Decision?
Regarding children abducted in violation of custody rights, the rule is that children must be immediately returned to their habitual residence (§ 23). The exception is a finding that the return would expose the child to physical or psychological danger or otherwise place them in an intolerable situation. The Court stated that it can review whether judicial authorities considered the guarantees under Articles 20 and 41 of the Constitution when applying the Convention (§ 22).
According to the Court, in return cases, the conditions of the parties must be examined in detail, and a balance must be struck between the interests of the parties and the best interests of the child. For children at an age dependent on their mother, this examination includes the child’s age, the place and duration of their residence with the mother, the extent to which the child has adjusted to the mother's living conditions, the mother's ability to live with the child in the country to which the child is to be returned, and the risks in the event of a return (§ 24). The Court explains this criterion by referring to the Dilek Tsakırıdıs decision (§ 46), the text of which is inaccessible, and the reasoning proceeds hereafter in four steps:
- Reports were in the file. The social investigation reports established that the mother had assumed care, the children had a warm relationship with the mother, no risk was observed with the mother, and the father had no clear plan for living with the children. According to the Court, it was possible to conclude from these findings that separation from the mother and siblings could have traumatic consequences for the development of their psychosocial identity (§ 25).
- Conditions in the habitual residence were not investigated. Despite the mother's allegations regarding abuse, threats, and living conditions, the father's living conditions and whether there would be any danger in the event of a return were not independently investigated (§ 26).
- Sibling unity was not evaluated. The issue of whether the return would separate the children from their sibling born from the mother's new marriage was not discussed, and the child's best interests were not considered together with the Convention (§ 27).
- Age and adjustment are not sufficient; risks must be examined concretely. Adjustment and tender age are not in themselves grounds to avoid a return. However, the risks to be faced by children dependent on their mother must be evaluated based on the circumstances of the specific case, and if the conditions in the place of return have not been investigated, the risks of changing the existing circumstances carry greater weight (§ 28).
The concluding paragraph lists age, dependency on the mother, the duration of coexistence since birth, adjustment, and living with siblings together, and states that the consequences of separation were not established by the judicial authorities (§ 29). The Court's conclusion is as follows:
“Consequently, it is concluded that no assessment was made with relevant and sufficient reasoning and investigation within the scope of the right to respect for family life, taking into account the circumstances of the specific case, the principle of the best interests of the child, and the Hague Convention together...”
The finding that the failure to return from a holiday violated the right to protection belongs to the Court of Cassation's reversal; the Constitutional Court's evaluation does not contain an explicit examination on this matter, as the reasoning focuses on the consequences of the return.
Was It Not Proven, or Was It Not Investigated? The Main Distinction in the Grave Danger Exception
The value of the Ş.G. decision is seen in the Court of Cassation and the Constitutional Court reaching different results from similar propositions. According to the reversal by the Court of Cassation, the existence of a serious risk and other reasons for avoiding return has not been "proven," and adaptation to the environment and age were not considered grounds for avoiding return under the Convention; the fact that the return would pose a serious risk must be "demonstrated." The reversal does not contain an explicit evaluation regarding the report relied upon by the family court or the reasoning for separation from the mother. The Constitutional Court did not reject the proposition of adaptation and age, but reiterated it with the note "standing alone" (§ 28). Separation is a step preceding the proposition rather than the proposition itself; the decisive question is whether the risk has been sufficiently investigated.
This distinction raises the question of who must demonstrate the danger. The Turkish text of the Convention mentions 'the person, institution or organization objecting to the return' in the introduction of Article 13, but the subject of the phrase 'if it determines that there is a serious risk' in subparagraph (b) is not explicit. In the English text, the verb is linked to the party objecting to the return. Therefore, at first glance, the Convention imposes a burden of proof on the objector. The word 'proof' does not appear in the Ş.G. judgment; the expression 'could not be proven' appears only in the summary of the Court of Cassation's reasoning (§ 10), and there is no explicit evaluation regarding the burden of proof. The Court of Cassation's reversal decision also does not explicitly state by whom the risk must be demonstrated.
In this file, the mother put forward concrete allegations, reports were included in the file, and the Court expected an investigation to be conducted. From this, it cannot be concluded that an abstract allegation of danger would also necessitate the same investigation; the boundary between them cannot be fully understood from the decision.
The second open question is the duration. In the T.S. judgment, The Court considered the proceedings, which lasted approximately three years, a violation of the right to respect for family life. The Ş.G. judgment, however, demands further research; since investigating living conditions abroad takes time, the two expectations may conflict in the same file. The decision does not provide a method for addressing this conflict.
Where Does the Joint Custody Protocol Stand in the Reasoning?
After the return decision passed through legal remedies, the parties agreed on joint custody and the children actually living with the mother in a protocol dated May 12, 2025. In the assessment section of the court's decision (§ 25-30), there is no explicit evaluation regarding the protocol, joint custody, or the Ministry's opinion.
From this silence, it cannot be concluded that the protocol prevents or renders the return ineffective. Moreover, since Article 13 of Law No. 5717 states that a custody decision rendered after a return application does not 'constitute grounds' for the dismissal of the return request, the effect of the protocol can be discussed separately during the retrial. Similarly, the new marriage that created sibling unity occurred in January 2023, that is, after the agreed date of return. The decision did not dwell on the effect of this timing; this is also a point that could be discussed in terms of the father.
How Did the Same Criterion Yield Results in Different Files?
The following table is selected from Constitutional Court judgments accessed via web search and read in November 2026. This is not a complete scan and should not be interpreted as a success rate; Court of Cassation judgments are discussed after the table.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Ruling | Habitual residence and applicant | Lower court result | Constitutional Court result | Decisive factor |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ş.G., 2025/16250 (04.03.2026) | Netherlands; mother | Return after reversal | Violation, unanimous | Risks and consequences of separation were not investigated |
| T.S., 2022/31535 (30.04.2024) | Germany; mother | Return after reversal | Violation: unanimous regarding duration, majority vote regarding other claims | Approximately three years of proceedings; the review was found formalistic |
| Marcus Frank Cerny, 2013/5126 (02.07.2015) | Allegation of removal from the USA; father | Refusal of return | Violation, majority vote; no legal interest found in retrial | Grounds for refusal were not associated with the exceptions of the Convention |
| A.H., 2022/53856 (07.01.2025) | Bulgaria; father | Return | No violation, unanimous | Consent was withdrawn; danger could not be proven |
| C.B., 2022/58462 (04.02.2025) | USA (applicant's claim); left-behind parent | Refusal of return | No violation, unanimous | Investigation and reasoning were found sufficient |
| E.B., 2022/103758 (14.05.2025) | Germany; father | Return at first instance; dismissal at appeal stage, upholding by the Court of Cassation | No violation, unanimous | Child's maturity, opinion, and finding of serious risk |
Four conclusions can be drawn from these decisions:
- The review is directed not at the result but at the reasoning. A violation was found in both return decisions (Ş.G., T.S.) and the refusal decision (Cerny). In the Cerny file, the refusal based on the child's age and dependence on the mother was deemed insufficient because it was not explained why the Convention conditions were not met (§ 87). In files where no violation was found, there are also both returns (A.H.) and refusals (C.B., E.B.).
- Difficulty in adaptation is not a danger in itself. In the supplementary report of the A.H. case, it was stated that the child would have difficulty adjusting because they do not know the language, and that separation from the father could negatively affect their psychosocial development. The family court did not consider the language issue a psychological danger, and the Constitutional Court found the justifications sufficient. In that case, the return order stipulated the delivery of the child to their mother; whereas in the Ş.G. case, separation from the mother and siblings was not discussed despite being a concrete allegation.
- The child’s opinion gains meaning with maturity. In the E.B. case, the appellate court reached a conclusion of serious risk based on the child's maturity, their statements, and findings regarding the father's life; the non-finalized acquittal decision did not prevent this result. The Constitutional Court did not make a separate determination regarding the criminal file. In the T.S. case, the majority noted that the allegation that the decision was made without taking the children's statements was not addressed; the dissenting opinion stated that there was no observation requiring the children's views to be taken into account due to their age.
- The limits of the exception are discussed in the dissenting opinions. According to two members in the T.S. decision, there is no determination of danger preventing the return in the report, and the majority relied on findings not present within the scope of the file and the mother's statements instead of the justifications of the judicial authorities.
Under Which Law Is the Right of Custody Determined?
The C.B. case leaves an open question on this matter. It was stated that custody was jointly regulated in the USA, while the family court accepted that the applicant had no legal right over the child based on the Turkish Civil Code. Article 3 of the Convention links the right of custody to the law of the state of habitual residence. The Constitutional Court found the justifications sufficient but did not make a clear assessment as to which law determines custody and where the habitual residence is. Therefore, the C.B. decision should not be read as a general criterion for the interpretation of Article 3.
Do Current Decisions of the Court of Cassation Reflect This Criterion?
No decision demonstrating this has been seen among the published rulings; the reasoned line of the Court of Cassation prior to Ş.G. also differs from this criterion. The patterns of "cannot be proven" and "to be demonstrated" in the Ş.G. reversal are also seen in the reversal dated June 26, 2025 (E. 2025/4753, K. 2025/6540) before the Ş.G. decision. The Constitutional Court, however, expects an investigation into the conditions in the habitual residence and the consequences of the separation.
On November 3, 2026, the queries for "return to habitual residence" and "return to habitual residence" (in varying Turkish spelling) on UYAP returned 99 and 126 Court of Cassation decisions, respectively. Of these, eight of the 15 decisions after March 4, 2026, are from after the publication in the Official Gazette, 11 are upholdings (one partial), and none of them discuss the grave danger criterion or the Ş.G. decision. It cannot be concluded from short upholding decisions whether the Court of Cassation has adopted or rejected this criterion. The numbers only cover published decisions and should not be read as a success rate.
The only reasoned decision during this period that touches upon the conditions for return relates to the age limit. The Chamber, in its decision dated 10.09.2026, E. 2026/9458, K. 2026/7952, stated that the scope of the Convention was exited because the child had turned sixteen before the date of the first-instance decision. The Chamber unanimously reversed the decision on the grounds that a decision of no grounds for a ruling should have been issued regarding the case that became moot. The first-instance court will issue the new decision. As the trial drags on, the case may end up without a result for this reason as well.
The result of the E. 2025/4753 file is also unknown. After the reversal, the family court rejected the case again with new evidence, and the Chamber, with its decision numbered E. 2026/5200, K. 2026/6437, sent the file to the General Assembly of Civil Chambers on June 11, 2026; the General Assembly decision was not seen in this scan.
My Child Was Brought to Türkiye, How Is a Return Requested and How Long Does the Case Take?
The remaining parent may, in accordance with Article 7 of Law No. 5717, apply to the central authority of the country where the child's habitual residence is located, to the central authority of another state party to the Convention, or directly to the Central Authority in Türkiye. The Central Authority is the Ministry of Justice pursuant to Article 3 of the Law; the unit performing the duty in Circular No. 65/2 has been determined.
- Location of the child and settlement: The Central Authority determines the child's location through the office of the public prosecutor and seeks a resolution through voluntary return or amicable settlement (Art. 4, 5).
- Lawsuit: Lawsuits regarding the return of a child are filed by the local office of the public prosecutor on behalf of the Central Authority (Art. 7). The competent court is the family court; jurisdiction is determined by the location of the child or the place where they were placed under protection at the time of the application (Art. 6).
- Trial: The case is heard "primarily and urgently according to the simple trial procedure" (Art. 9) and continues during the judicial recess (Art. 16).
- Legal remedy: The Central Authority, the applicant, or the defendant may apply for legal remedies (Art. 17).
- Enforcement: Return decisions are enforced once they become final (Art. 17).
- Individual application: Duration It is 30 days and the application does not automatically stay the return decision. In the S.G. file, the return was stayed by the Court's injunction; the same result cannot be expected in every file.
In the S.G. file, approximately two years passed from the lawsuit until the upholding by the Court of Cassation.
What Results Does the Constitutional Court's Violation Decision Produce?
- The return request has not been rejected: The file has been sent to the family court for a retrial to eliminate the consequences of the violation (§ 32; ruling D). A return or rejection decision may be issued during the retrial.
- Return will not be executed temporarily: According to paragraph E of the judgment, the children will not be returned to their habitual residence until the trial is concluded.
- Custody has not been resolved: The return trial does not determine the merits of custody. In this file, custody was regulated by the decision dated May 13, 2025, issued in a separate proceeding; it is not clear from the text whether this decision has become final.
- There is no automatic effect on other files: The criterion depends on the circumstances of the specific case. The evaluation of "dependency on the mother" does not mean a rejection of return in every mother's file; in the S.G. file, the Court attributed the result not to the return itself, but to the lack of investigation and reasoning.
- Change in law: According to the current text on Lexpera, the latest amendment to Law No. 5717 is dated November 30, 2021. In the search conducted in November 2026, no changes to the Law or the Convention were identified after the decision.
What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?
Regarding the Parent Keeping the Child in Türkiye
- Concrete risk: Acclimatization and age alone are not sufficient (S.G., § 28). The risk must be demonstrated in connection with the conditions at the habitual residence.
- Conditions at the habitual residence: An investigation into the opposing party's living conditions and the care plan after the return must be explicitly requested (S.G., § 26).
- Consent document: Written consent is not a permanent guarantee; in the A.H. file, the family court deemed the retention after the withdrawal of the notarial consent to be unlawful.
- Custody decision: A custody decision rendered after the return application does not count as a justification for rejection (Law No. 5717, Art. 13). Divorce case of foreigners in Türkiye should therefore be evaluated separately from the return file.
Regarding the Left-Behind Parent
- Fast application: An application before one year has elapsed prevents the integration argument in Article 12 from the outset.
- Return plan: Living conditions, care arrangements, and relationships with siblings must be documented from the beginning. In the S.G. decision, the father's lack of a clear plan became part of the reasoning (§ 25).
- Foreign documents: Documents showing custody and protection rights apostille and legalization procedures must be completed in advance.
Frequently Asked Questions
In What Case Is the Return of a Child Under the Hague Convention Refused?
A Turkish court may refuse return under the Hague Convention if custody rights were not exercised, or in cases of consent, a serious risk of grave danger, the objection of a mature child, the child's integration after a one-year period, or violation of fundamental rights. According to the Constitutional Court, these exceptions are limited, and the rule is the immediate return of the child.
Is Taking a Child on Vacation with Permission and Not Returning Considered Wrongful Retention?
It can be considered so. In its reversal decision dated 18.04.2024 regarding the Ş.G. file, the Court of Cassation 2nd Civil Chamber considered the failure to take children back to the Netherlands at the end of the vacation as a violation of custody rights; however, the regional court of appeal did not see a violation due to the father's consent. The Constitutional Court's assessment does not contain a clear review on this matter.
Does the Child's Attachment to Their Mother Prevent Return?
It does not prevent it by itself. In the Ş.G. decision, the Constitutional Court stated that attachment and young age are not, by themselves, reasons to avoid return. Nevertheless, it required an investigation into the risks the child would face if separated while at an age dependent on the mother in the specific case.
Are the Child's Views Taken into Account in a Hague Case?
Yes, if the child's age and maturity require their views to be considered, the return may be refused pursuant to Article 13 of the Convention. In the E.B. file reviewed by the Constitutional Court, the court of appeal also relied on the child's maturity and statements, and the Constitutional Court found no violation in this assessment.
Does a Custody Decision Taken in Türkiye Stay the Return Case?
As a rule, it does not. According to Article 13 of Law No. 5717, a custody decision made after the return application does not constitute grounds for rejecting the return request; according to Article 14, a custody case filed during the return proceedings is stayed. The Court of Cassation 2nd Civil Chamber also stated in its decision dated 28.06.2021, E. 2021/3482, K. 2021/5347, that granting custody to the mother as a precautionary measure in a divorce case cannot prevent the return.
My Spouse Abducted the Child to Türkiye, How Can I Request Their Return?
The remaining parent may apply to the central authority of the country where the child's habitual residence is located, to the central authority of another state that is a party to the Convention, or to the Ministry of Justice, which is the Central Authority in Türkiye. If no settlement is reached, the lawsuit is filed by the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office on behalf of the Central Authority in the family court where the child is located, in accordance with Law No. 5717.
Conclusion: Return Is the Rule, But a Decision That Does Not Investigate Risk May Not Stand
The Constitutional Court's S.G. decision does not change the Hague system. The immediate return of the child to their habitual residence remains the rule, and exceptions remain limited.
What the decision adds is the way in which the exception is examined. In a file containing concrete allegations and reports, if the court issues a return order without investigating the conditions in the habitual residence and the consequences of the separation, the right to respect for family life may be violated. This criterion does not operate one-sidedly against the remaining parent; in the Cerny decision, a rejection decision with insufficient justification was also considered a violation. Therefore, what is decisive for both parties is the concreteness of the allegations and whether the court addressed them in its reasoning.
Legal Resources and Related Reviews
Legislation
- Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (The Hague Convention), especially articles 3, 4, 11, 12, 13, 16, 19 and 20. The provisions of the Convention were taken from the Turkish text on the Ministry of Justice website.
- Law No. 5717 on the Legal Aspects and Scope of International Child Abduction, Official Gazette 04.12.2007, 26720, particularly articles 3-14, 16-23, and 25.
- Constitution of the Republic of Turkey, articles 20 and 41.
- Circular on the Legal Scope and Application of International Child Abduction, No: 65/2, 16.11.2011.
Constitutional Court Judgments
Links lead to the pages where the text of the decision is read. In cases where Official Gazette information is not included, this information is not found on the page being read.
- Ş.G., App. No: 2025/16250, 04.03.2026, Official Gazette 08.06.2026, 33274.
- T.S., App. No: 2022/31535, 30.04.2024, Official Gazette 06.02.2025, 32805.
- A.H., App. No: 2022/53856, 07.01.2025, Official Gazette 02.10.2025, 33035.
- C.B., App. No: 2022/58462, 04.02.2025.
- E.B., App. No: 2022/103758, 14.05.2025. The applicant's name has been abbreviated for the protection of the child.
- Marcus Frank Cerny [GK], App. No: 2013/5126, 02.07.2015, Official Gazette 12.08.2015, 29443.
- Dilek Tsakırıdıs, App. No: 2018/35068, 09.06.2020. The decision has been used only to the extent reported by the Ş.G. and T.S. decisions.
- Asiye Kovancı, App. No: 2022/25700, 06.03.2024. The text of the decision could not be accessed; it is cited in the Ş.G. and T.S. decisions.
Court of Cassation Decisions
The following decisions were read from the full text on UYAP. The upholding decision dated 20.02.2025 in the Ş.G. file and the Court of Cassation's upholding decision in the E.B. file were used only to the extent reported by the Constitutional Court texts.
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2024/2653, K. 2024/2670, 18.04.2024. Reversal decision in the Ş.G. file, unanimous.
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2021/3482, K. 2021/5347, 28.06.2021. Reversal regarding the request for return to Germany, unanimous.
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2025/4753, K. 2025/6540, 26.06.2025. Reversal regarding the request for return to Germany, unanimous.
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2026/5200, K. 2026/6437, 11.06.2026. Referral to the Plenary Assembly of Civil Chambers, unanimous.
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2026/9458, K. 2026/7952, 10.09.2026. Reversal due to sixteen years of age, unanimous.
İlgili Yazılar
Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008
This text is a legal decision analysis based on the decision of the Constitutional Court First Section dated 04.03.2026, App. No: 2025/16250, regarding Ş.G. The analysis is limited to the published decision text; it does not imply that the same result will be obtained in other files.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.