Precedent decision reviews
Decision Declaring Extradition Request Admissible Reversed: Court of Cassation 5th Criminal Chamber
In this article 17 headings
- Short Answer: Does the Court of Cassation Reverse an 'Extradition Request Admissible' Decision?
- The Details of the 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation's Decision
- How Did the Dispute Begin? From Israel's Request to the High Criminal Court's Decision
- What Objections Did the Defense Counsel Raise at the Court of Cassation?
- Why Did the Court of Cassation Reverse the Decision? Human Rights Risk, Family Ties, and Missing Documents
- Did the Chamber Identify the Risk, or Did It State That It Was Not Investigated?
- In What Situations Does the Court of Cassation Reverse, and in What Situations Does It Uphold?
- Does an International Protection Application or Citizenship Lawsuit Suspend Extradition?
- To What Extent Can the Court and the Court of Cassation Examine the Evidence?
- Where is the Appeal Filed, and What are the Stages from the Court Decision to Handover?
- Does a Reversal Eliminate Pre-trial Detention and the Red Notice?
- Consequences and Limits of the Decision
- What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion: The Type of Reversal and Subsequent Proceedings Are Decisive
- Legal Resources and Related Reviews
- Author and Legal Information
Publication: · Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.
Short Answer: Does the Court of Cassation Reverse an 'Extradition Request Admissible' Decision?
Yes, it can overturn it; however, the reversal does not happen automatically and does not always end the extradition process. The Court of Cassation, which reviews the High Criminal Court's decision that the “extradition request is admissible” on appeal, does not review whether the crime was committed, but rather whether the conditions for extradition and obstacles to extradition were properly examined.
The 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation provided a clear example of this review in its decision dated March 23, 2026, file no. 2026/2109, decision no. 2026/5026, The Chamber unanimously overturned the decision regarding Israel’s extradition request. In its reasoning, it evaluated the potential human rights violations the individual might face alongside their family ties in Türkiye and stated that the court should have decided that the request was not admissible. Under the heading of “Even according to the admission,” it added that the decision was made with incomplete investigation without obtaining a certified translation of the indictment and that the dates of the crimes were incorrectly indicated.
A reversal is not the end of the case and does not automatically close the path to extradition, because the file is returned to the court. In one examined file, a new decision was corrected and upheld, while in another file, the 8th Criminal Chamber found the court's resistance to be appropriate and lifted its own reversal decision. The review is also not one-sided, as a decision rejecting the request was also overturned upon the public prosecutor's appeal.
This analysis is based on published decision texts and only addresses the Court of Cassation review after the High Criminal Court decision. For the path to follow regarding the bulletin, to the request for the removal of the red notice, for the criminal law framework of the subject, to the red notice and Interpol searches article can be consulted.
The Details of the 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation's Decision
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Title | Information |
|---|---|
| Court | 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation |
| Basis and decision number | File no. 2026/2109, Decision no. 2026/5026 |
| Decision date | 23.03.2026 |
| Appealed decision | Istanbul 15th High Criminal Court, 02.12.2025, File no. 2022/172, Decision no. 2025/392 |
| Requesting state | Israel, extradition request dated 05.04.2022 |
| Subject of the request | Criminal investigation and execution of the arrest warrant for detention |
| Appellant | Defense counsel of the person whose extradition is requested |
| Opinion of the Prosecutor’s Office (Tebliğname) | Reversal |
| Provisions relied upon | Law No. 6706 Art. 11/1-b, 11/4 and 18/2; European Convention on Extradition (ECE) Art. 3/2 and 12/2 |
| Conclusion | Unanimous reversal pursuant to Law No. 5271 Art. 302/2 |
How Did the Dispute Begin? From Israel's Request to the High Criminal Court's Decision
The Israeli Ministry of Justice requested the extradition of a person in Türkiye with a request dated April 5, 2022. The request was based on a criminal investigation initiated regarding allegations of crimes concerning the period before October 10, 2019, and the execution of an arrest warrant for detention. The Istanbul 15th High Criminal Court decided on December 2, 2025, that the request was admissible, and the person's defense counsel appealed this decision.
The details of the allegations are not the subject of this analysis, because although the word “criminal” appears in the name of the Convention, the extradition proceedings do not make a determination of guilt. Since there is no evaluation regarding the proof of the allegations in the decision text, the phrase “the person whose extradition is requested” has been used in this analysis.
What Objections Did the Defense Counsel Raise at the Court of Cassation?
According to the summary of the decision, there were four main objections on appeal:
- That the accusations were abstract and unsubstantiated, and the evidence regarding the acts was not sent by the requesting state.
- That the danger of being subjected to ill-treatment, arbitrary detention, and unfair trial in case of extradition was not discussed in the decision, and that extradition would violate the prohibition of refoulement.
- That the person has been living in Türkiye with their family for over five years.
- That the decision made without waiting for the outcome of the lawsuit filed against the rejection of the citizenship application would lead to consequences that are difficult to reverse.
The Chamber generally found the grounds of appeal well-founded; the main reason for reversal coincides with the second and third objections. The finding regarding the translation of the indictment touches upon the first objection, and there is no explicit evaluation in the decision regarding waiting for the citizenship lawsuit.
Why Did the Court of Cassation Reverse the Decision? Human Rights Risk, Family Ties, and Missing Documents
Apartment, Law No. 6706 on International Judicial Cooperation in Criminal Matters and established its reasoning step by step based on ECE provisions:
- Mandatory obstacle. The existence of “strong grounds for suspicion” that a person will be subjected to investigation, prosecution, or punishment, or to torture or ill-treatment due to their race, ethnic origin, religion, citizenship, social group, or political views, is a ground for refusal under Article 11/1-b of the Law. Article 3/2 of the SİDAS also provides for a similar obstacle regarding race, religion, nationality, or political opinion.
- Unconditional obligation. The Chamber, summarizing the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) and the Constitutional Court, stated that a person must not be extradited in cases where a real risk is demonstrated with serious grounds. According to the cited ECtHR judgments, this obligation applies even to individuals who pose a risk to public order or security, and there is no exception even in cases involving the danger of international terrorism.
- Meticulous investigation. The authenticity of the claims regarding the risk and the reasonableness of the explanations must be "meticulously investigated by national authorities." The examination must take into account the foreseeable consequences of extradition, the general situation in the destination country, the personal situation of the individual, and whether the treatment reaches the minimum threshold of severity; it is also required to utilize reports from national or international organizations and other sources ex officio.
- Personal circumstances. According to the fourth paragraph of Article 11 of the Law, the request may be denied if extradition would cause disproportionate grievances to the individual or their family given the severity of the act, due to circumstances such as long-term residence in Türkiye or marriage.
The Chamber conveyed the consequence of failing to conduct an investigation under the ECtHR and Constitutional Court case law with the following words:
“…it concludes that the failure to conduct an investigation as described regarding whether the relevant foreigner will face a real risk of being subjected to ill-treatment or a violation of the right to life in the event of deportation from the country constitutes a violation of the Convention or the Constitution in itself…”
While applying this framework to the concrete file, the Chamber noted that the individual has two children who are Turkish citizens and that he himself has been living in Türkiye for approximately five years with the Turkish citizen mother of these children. The first pillar of the reversal was established with the following sentence:
“…even though the person whose extradition is requested is an Israeli citizen and is not a political offender, considering his statement that he is of Palestinian descent, an Arab Muslim, the human rights violations he may encounter if extradited to the requesting state, and the fact that he has been living in Türkiye for approximately 5 years with a Turkish citizen woman who is the mother of these children, a ruling of inadmissibility should have been made instead of issuing a judgment in the written form…”
Under the heading "Furthermore, regarding the acceptance," two additional violations were listed. This expression explains that even if the court’s primary premise is accepted, the decision is unlawful, distinct from the first pillar. The first is that the decision was made with an incomplete investigation, contrary to Article 12/2 of the SİDAS and the second paragraph of Article 18 of the Law, without obtaining a certified translated copy of the indictment. The second is that the dates of the offense were incorrectly shown as "2022" in the heading of the decision.
Did the Chamber Identify the Risk, or Did It State That It Was Not Investigated?
This is the most important open question of the decision because a large part of the reasoning explains the duty to investigate. Indeed, in the decision numbered E. 2025/6495, the Chamber requested that the claims be evaluated by "investigating" them. Here, however, it did not ask the court in the first pillar to conduct a risk investigation but to decide that the request was inadmissible; it used the expression "incomplete investigation" only for the translation of the indictment under the "Furthermore, regarding the acceptance" heading.
In contrast, the decision does not indicate which report, document, or country information the risk is based on, nor does it make a separate determination regarding the general situation in the destination country. It is also not understood from the text whether the requesting state has provided guarantees; the Chamber reaches its conclusion by evaluating the individual’s statement and his family situation in Türkiye together.
Therefore, the decision cannot be read as if a declaration of a specific origin or religion precludes extradition in every file. Regarding France's request In file E. 2026/6453, K. 2026/8074 The defense counsel raised the risk of discrimination based on origin and religion, but the reversal was based on the issue of absence. Regarding the request of the Czech Republic In file E. 2024/24515, K. 2026/3314 the allegation of religion-based oppression was not included among the grounds for reversal. In both decisions, there is no explicit assessment regarding these allegations.
The nature of the two obstacles is also different, because the Law uses the expression “shall not be accepted” in clause (b), and “may not be accepted” in the fourth paragraph. The Chamber has linked these two provisions to the same result and has not distinguished which one would be sufficient on its own. Since the Chamber also uses the expression “even if not a political offender,” the result is not based on the political offender obstacle; it is instructive that the observed risk can constitute an obstacle even without an allegation of a political crime.
In What Situations Does the Court of Cassation Reverse, and in What Situations Does It Uphold?
The expression “the extradition request is acceptable” returned 144 Court of Cassation decisions in the UYAP Precedent Case database on November 3, 2026. The number only covers published decisions; a distribution of results has not been extracted and should not be read as a reversal rate. The decisions below were selected to demonstrate different outcomes, and all belong to the 5th Criminal Chamber.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Ruling | Requesting state | Main issue | The Chamber's approach | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| File no. 2026/2109, Decision no. 2026/5026 (23.03.2026) | Israel | Risk of human rights violation, family ties, incomplete indictment | The request should have been found unacceptable | Reversal |
| E. 2026/6453, K. 2026/8074 (13.07.2026) | France | Convictions rendered in absentia that have not become final | If a guarantee for retrial is provided, an acceptance decision can be rendered | Reversal |
| E. 2025/6495, K. 2025/11186 (20.10.2025) | Russia | Long-term residence and family claim | An investigation should have been conducted regarding Article 11/4 | Reversal |
| E. 2026/1898, K. 2026/5025 (23.03.2026) | Russia | New acceptance decision after reversal in file E. 2025/6495 | Discretion is accurate, only the term “extradition” was corrected | Upholding with correction |
| E. 2026/2983, K. 2026/6578 (18.05.2026) | Turkmenistan | The court had rejected the request, and the prosecutor had appealed | Evidence is not examined; the request should have been found acceptable | Reversal |
| E. 2026/7826, K. 2026/8346 (07.09.2026) | Germany | Objections regarding ill-treatment, discrimination, statute of limitations, age, and health | It was accepted that there was no cause for suspicion | Upholding |
Four conclusions can be drawn from these decisions:
- A reversal for investigation leaves the result open. In file E. 2025/6495, the Chamber rejected the objections to evidence but requested the investigation of residence and family claims. The court complied with the reversal and reached the same result, weighing the fact that the person settled in Türkiye after the date of the alleged crime against their family ties. The Chamber did not find any inaccuracy in this discretion in its decision numbered E. 2026/1898.
- In a reversal for an absentia case, the result depends on the guarantee. In file E. 2026/6453, since the convictions were not final, the Chamber evaluated the second paragraph of Article 10 of the Law together with Article 3/1 of the Additional Second Protocol and stated that an acceptance decision could be rendered if a guarantee were provided that a hearing would be opened and rights of defense would be granted.
- The reasoning for reversal can indicate the result. It was written in the main decision that the request was not acceptable, while in the decision numbered E. 2026/2983, it was written that it should be decided that it was acceptable. In this second decision, the Chamber, also considering the guarantees, found the public prosecutor's appeal well-founded; both files were sent to their respective courts.
- A risk objection does not yield results in every file. In file E. 2026/7826, similar objections were rejected, and the Chamber concluded that there was “no cause for any suspicion” regarding ill-treatment.
Does an International Protection Application or Citizenship Lawsuit Suspend Extradition?
According to Article 11, paragraph 1, clause (a) of the Law, the person being a Turkish citizen is an obstacle to extradition; obligations required by being a party to the International Criminal Court are outside of this. For this reason, the pending case gains importance for persons whose citizenship is revoked or whose citizenship application is rejected. However, a settled answer to the question of waiting is not seen in the decisions examined. The Çankırı file regarding Belgium's request shows why a reversal is not the final word and how the answer given in the same file changes:
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Date | Authority and decision | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| 19.02.2024 | Çankırı High Criminal Court, E. 2023/410, K. 2024/41 | The request was found acceptable. |
| 15.10.2024 | 8th Criminal Chamber, E. 2024/18054, K. 2024/7673 | Unanimous reversal in accordance with the notification |
| 11.12.2024 | Çankırı High Criminal Court, E. 2024/407, K. 2024/449 | Resistance against the reversal |
| 14.07.2025 | 8th Criminal Chamber, E. 2025/12, K. 2025/6153 | Revocation of the reversal decision and unanimous upholding |
The 2024 reversal had four grounds. The Chamber [addressed] the citizenship case at the 10th Chamber of the Council of State and the [application] made to the provincial directorate of migration management for international protection deemed the failure to await the outcome as insufficient investigation. It also found it unlawful that evidence details were not requested to substantiate the acts, that the investigation under Article 11/4 regarding the child who is a Turkish citizen and commercial activities was not conducted, and that there was no commitment in accordance with the fourth paragraph of Article 10 of the Law and Article 14/1 of the SİDAS.
While the court resisted, it stated that the person was not a Turkish citizen and that the Council of State had rejected the request for a stay of execution. It added that if citizenship is acquired, this could be asserted, and the outcome of the protection application could also be asserted until the “final delivery stage” and would be taken into account by the relevant authorities. It found the documents sufficient, the commitment unnecessary, and concluded that there was no disproportionate victimization in light of the gravity of the act regarding family ties. The 8th Criminal Chamber found this justification to be accurate and withdrew its own reversal. The 10th Chamber of the Council of State, however, had rejected the citizenship case numbered E. 2023/4836 on December 24, 2024, after the resistance, with the right to appeal (K. 2024/6781). Regarding this decision, in the first article of the series has been mentioned; however, it is not referred to in the 8th Criminal Chamber’s decision.
However, the line is not closed, because the 8th Criminal Chamber, in its decision dated March 5, 2026, numbered E. 2024/24515, unanimously reversed the decision of the Antalya 3rd High Criminal Court regarding the Czech Republic’s request, contrary to the opinion of the prosecutor’s office to uphold the decision. The reasons were again the failure to await the outcome of the citizenship case, the failure to substantiate the acts, and the absence of a commitment. The decision did not refer to the decision dated July 14, 2025, and the reason for the difference was not explained. The Antalya decision stated that the case was pending and did not include the outcome of the request for a stay of execution; nor was a distinction based on these points made in the decision. Since the international protection application was not mentioned in the decision, the 2026 reversal does not answer the protection question.
The reversal ground requiring the protection application to be awaited is seen in the examined decisions only in the 2024 decision which was subsequently withdrawn; while relying on this decision, the development dated July 14, 2025, must also be checked. However, this withdrawal is specific to the file and does not establish a general rule that the protection application should not be awaited in any file. The pending citizenship case was made a ground for reversal again in the 2026 decision; the course of that file after the reversal is not understood from the published text and is not within the scope of this examination.
To What Extent Can the Court and the Court of Cassation Examine the Evidence?
Two approaches stand side by side in the decisions. In the decision numbered E. 2026/2983, it was stated that “the court does not have the duty and authority regarding the establishment of the crime subject to the extradition request or the evaluation of evidence related to the crime,” and it was deemed sufficient to explain the act “within the limited scope” of the extradition proceedings. In the decision numbered E. 2025/6495, the “limited scope” criterion was also used. In the 8th Criminal Chamber’s 2026 reversal, however, it was requested that where, when, and how the acts were committed and what the evidence consists of be explained.
In our assessment, these two approaches do not completely exclude each other. The court does not weigh the evidence to decide whether the person is guilty; however, it may seek the entry of documents into the file to an extent that it can audit what the accusation is and the conditions for extradition. The second paragraph of Article 18 of the Law also allows the court to request additional information and documents if the documents are not considered sufficient. The lack of an indictment translation in the main decision also falls into this area; however, this distinction was not clearly established in the decisions, and the 8th Criminal Chamber found the resistance that deemed the documents sufficient in the Çankırı file to be accurate.
Where is the Appeal Filed, and What are the Stages from the Court Decision to Handover?
Upon the request of the public prosecutor's office, the decision is rendered by the High Criminal Court, and the remedy against this decision is not an objection or appeal (istinaf), but an appeal on points of law (temyiz). The fourth paragraph of Article 18 of the Law contains the provision: "The decision of the court may be appealed on points of law (temyiz)." The Chamber also, in conjunction with this paragraph, the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK) No. 5271, is based on Article 285.
The paragraph does not state a separate deadline for the application. In its decision numbered 8th Criminal Chamber, E. 2024/18054, the court based its review of the deadline on the first paragraph of Article 291 of Law No. 5271. According to the current text of this paragraph, the application is made to the court that rendered the judgment, and the deadline is two weeks from the service of the judgment together with its reasoning. It is stipulated in the fourth paragraph of Article 18 that the Court of Cassation shall conclude the applications within three months.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Stage | Authority | Legal Basis | Scope |
|---|---|---|---|
| Extradition proceedings | High Criminal Court | Law No. 6706, Art. 15, 18/1 | Extradition conditions and obstacles |
| Appeal on points of law (cassation) | Yargıtay | Law No. 6706, Art. 18/4; Law No. 5271, Art. 285 | Review of legality |
| After reversal | High Criminal Court | Law No. 5271, Art. 307 | Compliance or insistence; insistence is subject to direct appeal on points of law (cassation) |
| Execution | Minister of Justice and the President | Law No. 6706, Art. 19/1 | Ministry opinions, proposal and approval |
| Notification and delivery | Central Authority; relevant ministries | Law No. 6706, Art. 19/2, 20/1 | Notification of the result, execution of delivery |
The court's decision is not an order for delivery; the finalized decision is sent to the Central Authority together with the extradition documents. According to the first paragraph of Article 19 of the Law, the execution of the decision is subject to the opinion of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Ministry of the Interior, the proposal of the Minister of Justice, and the approval of the President. As the discretion at this stage is not discussed in the examined decisions, no criterion can be derived regarding the approval stage.
Does a Reversal Eliminate Pre-trial Detention and the Red Notice?
No, it does not automatically remove it. In decisions E. 2024/18054 and E. 2024/24515, the 8th Criminal Chamber rejected the request for release due to the fact that “there is no change in the conditions for pre-trial detention” upon reversal. Similarly, in decision E. 2025/6495, the request for release was rejected by considering the nature of the accusation, even though the monthly review required by the second paragraph of Article 16 had not been performed. The Law also provides for a separate deadline regarding protective measures. According to the third paragraph of the article, if an extradition decision is not rendered pursuant to Article 19 within one year from the finalization of the acceptance decision, the protective measures are lifted.
As for the Red Notice, in the Çankırı and Antalya files, the connection of the request to the notice was explained, but no provision was established regarding the removal of the notice. The effect of the reversal on the notice record is not understood from the published texts. For this separate process, to the letter regarding the withdrawal of the extradition request and to the Red Notice letter in the context of the High Criminal Court decision can be consulted.
The administrative process may also proceed separately, because in the Çankırı file, deportation and administrative detention decisions are mentioned, and in the Antalya file, the status of administrative detention is mentioned, but the legality of these actions is not discussed. For the legal remedy against these actions, to the deportation decision guide can be consulted.
Consequences and Limits of the Decision
- Finalization: The reversal is not the end of the case and the decision did not finally reject the extradition request. The Chamber did not change the provision itself via Article 303 of Law No. 5271; it decided to send the file to the court of origin. The court may comply with the reversal or insist; the path to appeal on points of law (cassation) against the new decision comes to the agenda again. The course of events after the reversal is not understood from the published text, and this review does not cover subsequent decisions.
- Other files: The decision does not have automatic consequences for other persons. Personal status, the requesting state, guarantees, and documents are examined separately in each file.
- Matters not addressed in the decision: Individual applications made after the Court of Cassation's upholding are not the subject of these decisions. The criteria in the context of deportation in the review of individual applications has been addressed.
- Change in law: In the resources accessed during the November 2026 check, no amendments to the extradition provisions of Law No. 6706 were detected following the decision; the latest observed amendment dates back to 2018. The accessed lists of amendments for Law No. 7589, published in the Official Gazette dated July 31, 2026, and numbered 33326, do not include Law No. 6706 or Articles 291 and 307 of Law No. 5271. Since Article 247 regarding the fugitive defendant is present in these lists, the grounds for trial in absentia in the previously rendered decision numbered E. 2026/6453 must be read in conjunction with the current text.
What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?
The first question for every file is whether the request is based on an investigation or a conviction. In addition, the following matters may affect the outcome:
- Trial in absentia and finalization: If the conviction has not become final or was rendered in absentia, the issue of guarantees in the decision E. 2026/6453 arises.
- Risk documents: The lead decision points to national and international reports regarding the target country and the individual's situation; for this method, a letter of inquiry regarding the country of origin can be consulted.
- Content of the guarantee: As central authority guarantees are taken into account in decisions E. 2025/6495 and E. 2026/2983, what the guarantee covers must be read separately.
- Family and residence: The nationality of children, duration of cohabitation, commercial activity, and the relationship between the date of the alleged crime and the date of settlement were highlighted in the lead decision and in decisions E. 2024/18054 and E. 2026/1898.
- Commitment: Decision E. 2024/24515 sought a commitment; in decision E. 2025/12, the insistence upon overturning a decision that deemed a letter of commitment unnecessary was upheld.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Did the 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation Decide in File No. E. 2026/2109?
The 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation, with its decision dated March 23, 2026, and numbered K. 2026/5026, unanimously reversed the decision of the Istanbul 15th High Criminal Court that found the extradition request admissible. The Chamber stated that the request should have been found inadmissible in the face of the risk of human rights violations and family ties in Türkiye. Since the file has been returned to the court, the reversal is not the end of the case.
Is an Objection or an Appeal Filed Against an Extradition Admissibility Decision?
The appeal procedure (temyiz) is used against the decision of the High Criminal Court regarding an extradition request. The basis for this is the fourth paragraph of Article 18 of Law No. 6706. In its decision numbered E. 2024/18054, the 8th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation audited the deadline according to Article 291 of Law No. 5271; in the current text of this article, the deadline is two weeks from the notification of the reasoned judgment.
Does the Court of Cassation Examine Whether the Crime Was Committed in Extradition Proceedings?
No. In the decision numbered E. 2026/2983, the 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that the extradition court does not have the duty or authority to evaluate the establishment of the crime and the evidence. However, the concreteness of the charges in the request and the sufficiency of the documents can be subject to review.
Is an Extradition Request Denied if a Risk of Ill-Treatment is Alleged?
A claim of risk does not produce the same result in every file. Article 11 of Law No. 6706 seeks grounds for strong suspicion. The Court of Cassation issued a reversal decision in file E. 2026/2109 and an upholding decision in file E. 2026/7826. Assurances and the individual's specific situation may affect the result.
Can an Extradition Decision Be Made Before the International Protection Application is Concluded?
In a 2024 reversal, the 8th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation sought to await the outcome of the application but overturned this reversal on July 14, 2025, by finding the court's insistence justified. According to the justification for insistence, the outcome of the application can be put forward until the final handover stage. As this overturning does not establish a general rule, the matter must be evaluated separately in the specific file.
Is the Person Released if the Court of Cassation Reverses the Admissibility Decision?
A reversal by the Court of Cassation does not automatically terminate detention. In decisions E. 2024/18054 and E. 2024/24515, the 8th Criminal Chamber rejected requests for release following the reversal. Detention is evaluated separately while the file is being re-tried.
Is the Person Immediately Handed Over if the Court of Cassation Upholds the Decision?
No. According to Article 19 of Law No. 6706, a finalized court decision is also subject to an enforcement phase. The opinions of the Ministries of Foreign Affairs and Interior are obtained, the Minister of Justice proposes it, and the President approves it. The Central Authority notifies the result to the requesting state and the individual.
Conclusion: The Type of Reversal and Subsequent Proceedings Are Decisive
The decision of the 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated March 23, 2026, demonstrates that extradition proceedings do not consist solely of a formal review of documents. The Chamber reversed the acceptance decision by evaluating the risk of human rights violations alongside family ties, and under the heading "even in case of acceptance," it also found the lack of an indictment translation to be unlawful.
The compared decisions reveal that one must look at the nature of the reversal. After a reversal for further investigation, the same result could be rendered again; in the Çankırı file, the reversal was lifted upon insistence, while in the Antalya file, similar justifications were used again in 2026. Therefore, the first point to check in similar files is the document upon which the alleged risk and deficiency are based, and the second is the type of reversal and the subsequent course of the cited decision.
Legal Resources and Related Reviews
Legislation
- Law No. 6706 on International Judicial Cooperation in Criminal Matters, especially Articles 10, 11, 15, 16, 18, 19, and 20.
- Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271, especially Articles 247, 285, 291, 302, 303, and 307.
- European Convention on Extradition, Articles 3, 12, and 14; Additional Second Protocol, Article 3.
- Law No. 7589 (Official Gazette, 31.07.2026, No. 33326).
Court of Cassation Decisions
The list contains the decisions mentioned in the letter and does not represent all search results.
- 5th Criminal Chamber, E. 2026/2109, K. 2026/5026, D. 03.23.2026
- 5th Criminal Chamber, E. 2026/6453, K. 2026/8074, D. 07.13.2026
- 5th Criminal Chamber, E. 2026/2983, K. 2026/6578, D. 05.18.2026
- 5th Criminal Chamber, E. 2026/7826, K. 2026/8346, D. 09.07.2026
- 5th Criminal Chamber, E. 2026/1898, K. 2026/5025, D. 03.23.2026
- 5th Criminal Chamber, E. 2025/6495, K. 2025/11186, D. 10.20.2025
- 8th Criminal Chamber, E. 2024/24515, K. 2026/3314, D. 03.05.2026
- 8th Criminal Chamber, E. 2025/12, K. 2025/6153, D. 07.14.2025
- 8th Criminal Chamber, E. 2024/18054, K. 2024/7673, D. 10.15.2024 (overturned by the decision dated 07.14.2025)
Other Resources and Related Articles
Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008
This text is a legal case analysis based on the decision of the 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 03.23.2026, E. 2026/2109, K. 2026/5026. The analysis is limited to the published decision text; it does not mean that the same result will be obtained in other cases.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.