Precedent decision reviews
Divorce in Polygamous Foreign Marriages: Yargıtay 2nd Civil Chamber Overturned the Procedural Dismissal
In this article 16 headings
- Short Answer: Divorce in polygamous foreign marriage
- Citation of the 2nd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) Decision
- How Did the Dispute Begin? The Case Based on the Marriage in Egypt Was Dismissed on Procedural Grounds
- On What Grounds Did the First-Instance Court Dismiss the Case?
- Why Did the Yargıtay 2nd Civil Chamber Overturn the Procedural Dismissal?
- How Did the Chamber Determine the Applicable Law According to Article 14 of the MÖHUK?
- What Legal Questions Does the Phrase “My Spouse Has Another Spouse” Raise?
- If There Is No Civil Registry Record, What Document Does the Court Use to Search for the Marriage?
- Should the Court Investigate the Common National Law If the Spouses Are Citizens of the Same Country?
- Does Living in Turkiye Make the Turkish Court Competent?
- Does a Reversal Decision by the Yargitay Mean a Divorce?
- What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion: A Cause for Absolute Nullity Does Not Automatically Terminate a Divorce Case
- Legal Resources and Related Reviews
- Author and Legal Information
Publication: · Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.
Short Answer: Divorce in polygamous foreign marriage
In the file examined by the 2nd Civil Chamber of the Yargitay, no, but this answer does not mean that the divorce will be granted or that every case will be heard in a Turkish court. The Chamber, which reviewed the request for divorce in a polygamous foreign marriage, overturned by a majority vote the decision of rejection on procedural grounds issued for these two reasons, without rendering a decision on the divorce. According to the Chamber, even if there is a cause for absolute nullity, the marriage continues to exist as a valid marriage until the judge issues a nullity decision, and the court cannot evaluate the nullity on its own initiative in a divorce case. The Chamber deemed it sufficient for foreigners who have no connection with Turkish citizenship to document their identities and the fact that they are married to file a lawsuit, stating that it cannot be expected for this information to be registered in the civil registry in Turkiye.
The Chamber applied these criteria in its decision dated 21 April 2026, No. E. 2025/5548, K. 2026/4435. In the file, the woman was a citizen of Egypt and the man was a citizen of Saudi Arabia, and the parties had been living in Turkiye since 2012. Since there was no common national law, the law of Turkiye, which was their common habitual residence, was taken as the basis. The Chamber overturned the decision of the Bursa Regional Court of Appeal, which had dismissed the appeal on the merits, and overturned the procedural rejection decision of the Yalova 1st Family Court.
The decision does not state that a polygamous marriage is in accordance with the law. The Chamber accepted that marrying another person while already married is clearly contrary to Turkish public order, but stated that nullity requires a lawsuit filed for this purpose. It was decided to send the file to the court of first instance to be examined on its merits; it does not follow from the decision that the case will be granted. The document also remains important; in another file where there was no marriage certificate, the same Chamber requested the submission of supporting documents. If the spouses are citizens of the same country, the Chamber sought an investigation into their common national law in two of its 2026 decisions.
This review is based on the published decision text; party information is redacted in the text. For the general process, to our guide on divorce for foreigners in Turkiye,for the effect of divorce on the right to stay, to our article on the residence permit and citizenship of a foreign spouse can be consulted.
Citation of the 2nd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) Decision
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Title | Information |
|---|---|
| Court | 2nd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation |
| Basis and decision number | E. 2025/5548, K. 2026/4435 |
| Decision date | 21.04.2026 |
| Case type | Divorce based on the shaking of the foundation of the marital union |
| First instance court | Yalova 1st Family Court, E. 2024/722, K. 2024/1605 |
| Appeal (Istinaf) | Bursa Regional Court of Appeal 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2025/507, K. 2025/1220 |
| Appellant | Counsel for the plaintiff wife, regarding the entire judgment; the examination was conducted with a hearing |
| Provisions relied upon | Law No. 5718, Articles 2, 13, 14; Law No. 4721, Articles 145, 146, 156-158, 166; Law No. 6100, Article 114/1-h |
| Conclusion | Overturning of the Regional Court of Appeal decision, reversal of the first instance decision, sending the file to the court of first instance; no divorce decision was granted |
| Vote status | Majority vote; dissenting opinion without detailed reasoning, in the direction of upholding |
| Finalization | The decision does not contain the phrase 'definitively' or notification of legal remedies. |
How Did the Dispute Begin? The Case Based on the Marriage in Egypt Was Dismissed on Procedural Grounds
The plaintiff wife was an Egyptian citizen and the defendant husband was a Saudi Arabian citizen, and according to the decision, they had no connection with Turkish citizenship. According to the official document issued in Egypt, they were married on 4 April 2007, they had two common children, and they had been living in Turkiye since 2012. The plaintiff, pursuant to the first paragraph of Article 166 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, filed for divorce. The Chamber also determined that there was no foreign court decision recognized or enforced in Turkiye regarding the parties' divorce. The effect of such decisions is covered in our examination of the recognition of foreign divorce decisions has been addressed.
The published text does not indicate which spouse was married at the time of the marriage, nor the date and place of the previous marriage. The phrase "polygamous" also does not appear in the text; this characterization in the article originates from the reasoning of the court of first instance. The parties' claims and defenses regarding the grounds for divorce were not summarized; it was only stated that the attorneys of the two parties were heard at the hearing.
On What Grounds Did the First-Instance Court Dismiss the Case?
The family court's reasoning for rejection was based on three pillars:
- Civil registry record: Since the parties were foreign, they did not have civil registry records in Turkiye. The court cited Article 21 of the Regulation on the Implementation of Population Services regarding persons with multiple citizenships and stated that even if the marriage were to be registered, the registration would be unlawful.
- Absolute nullity: According to the court, the fact that one of the spouses was already married at the time of the marriage was a ground for absolute nullity pursuant to Article 145, paragraph 1 of the Turkish Civil Code.
- Public order: Even though the parties had concluded an official marriage according to Egyptian law, the court deemed the 'provision of the applicable foreign law allowing marriage with more than one woman or man' to be clearly contrary to Turkish public order, as it 'does not comply with the Turkish understanding of general decency and morality.'
From these three pillars, the court concluded that there was no 'marriage of a nature that could be recognized by the Turkish legal system' and dismissed the case on procedural grounds pursuant to Article 114/1-h and 115/2 of Law No. 6100. The Regional Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on the merits; the published text does not contain the reasoning for this decision.
The Chamber did not further discuss the basis for the Regulation. Author's assessment: Since the mentioned provision relates to the registration of persons with multiple citizenships in family registers, it cannot be read as a rule limiting the right to sue of spouses who do not hold Turkish citizenship.
Why Did the Yargıtay 2nd Civil Chamber Overturn the Procedural Dismissal?
The Chamber first distinguished the sanctions in marriage, then determined the applicable law, and finally evaluated the condition precedent to litigation:
- Non-existence (yokluk) and nullity (butlan) are different. A marriage that is non-existent is considered never to have come into existence, and the court takes this into account ex officio in any case filed. Nullity, on the other hand, is regulated in the Law with limited grounds.
- Turkish law applies. Since the parties are citizens of different countries, they do not have a common national law; since they have been living in Turkiye since 2012, their common habitual residence is Turkiye.
- A finding of public order does not end the case. A person marrying another while already married is a ground for absolute nullity under Turkish law and constitutes a clear violation of Turkish public order, yet the marriage continues to exist until a nullity decision is rendered.
- A separate lawsuit is required for nullity. There was no lawsuit in the file for the annulment of the marriage; the plaintiff had requested a divorce based on Article 166.
- There is a legal interest, there is no registration requirement. According to the Chamber, the plaintiff has a legal interest in filing a divorce case, and there is no legal regulation preventing the case from being heard.
The Chamber explained why the court cannot arrive at a dismissal of the case based on a finding of public order with the following sentences:
'However, even if a marriage is void due to absolute nullity, it continues to exist as a valid marriage until the nullity decision to be rendered by the judge (Law No. 4721, Article 156). It is not possible for the court to evaluate whether the marriage is void due to absolute nullity ex officio.'
The Chamber reached this conclusion by citing two doctrinal works and the majority decision of the General Assembly of Civil Chambers in its decision no. E. 2011/7-695, K. 2011/673. In that file regarding the cancellation of a certificate of inheritance, according to the Assembly, even if a judge determines grounds for nullity in another case, 'they cannot rule on nullity by considering these ex officio.' The Assembly also stated that the nullity decision produces effects prospectively from the date it becomes final.
The task falling to the court is to handle the case as a divorce lawsuit based on the ground of the breakdown of the marital union, to collect all evidence in line with the allegations and defenses, and to render a decision on the merits.
What does the dissenting opinion say?
The dissenting opinion only states that the decision of the Regional Court of Appeal, which was seen as in accordance with the law based on the collected evidence and the scope of the file, should be upheld. As the dissenting opinion does not contain detailed reasoning, it is not understood what view it relies on regarding nullity, public order, or civil registry records.
How Did the Chamber Determine the Applicable Law According to Article 14 of the MÖHUK?
Law No. 5718 on Private International Law and International Civil Procedure Article 14 establishes a hierarchical order. According to the provision in the decision, grounds and provisions for divorce and separation are subject to the parties' common national law. It continues, “If the parties are of different citizenship, the law of the common habitual residence shall be applied, and in the absence thereof, Turkish law shall be applied.”
The Chamber did not define the concept of habitual residence; it considered the fact of living in Turkiye since 2012 to be sufficient. There is no explicit assessment regarding the residence status of the spouses. The application of Turkish law here is a result of the difference in nationality and the common residence; for spouses who are citizens of the same country, the common national law is examined first.
Why is Article 13 of the MÖHUK a Separate Question?
According to Article 13 cited in the decision, the capacity and conditions for marriage are governed by the national law of each party at the time of marriage, while the formal validity of the marriage is governed by the law of the country where it was celebrated. The Chamber did not apply this provision to the concrete case and did not examine the marriage conditions according to Egyptian or Saudi Arabian law. The reason for this is not explained in the decision; according to the author's assessment, since there was no action for annulment, the validity of the marriage was not the subject of the dispute.
What Legal Questions Does the Phrase “My Spouse Has Another Spouse” Raise?
This sentence does not correspond to a single legal question. The distinction below was established by the author based on the reviewed decisions, and the judge's authority changes in each case.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Status | Qualification in the decisions | Position of the court | Legal Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| One of the spouses was married to another person at the time of marriage | Reason for absolute annulment according to Turkish law | In a divorce case, the court cannot decide on annulment by considering it ex officio; a lawsuit must be filed to this effect | E. 2025/5548; HGK E. 2011/7-695 |
| Foreigners performed only a religious marriage in Turkiye | With reference to the doctrine, it is invalid and void even if it complies with their own national law | The void nature of the marriage is taken into account ex officio in any case filed; a decision for the determination of nullity is rendered instead of divorce | E. 2025/7884; E. 2024/5848; E. 2025/5548 |
| It was alleged that the spouse had another unofficial marriage while the current marriage was ongoing | Fact of fault in divorce | Evaluated within the scope of fault and divorce conditions | E. 2023/350 |
The second line should be read narrowly, because E. 2025/7884 and E. 2024/5848 in the decisions numbered, this sentence was included as a general framework with reference to the work of Nomer and Şanlı, and in those files, the Chamber provided a reversal due to incomplete examination without determining that the marriage was religious and reaching the conclusion of nullity. For the form of marriage in Turkiye to the article on the marriage of foreigners in Turkiye can be consulted.
In the third line In the file numbered E. 2023/350 A Syrian national woman alleged that the man had entered into two more marriages unofficially. The court of first instance counted this fact among the man's faults, and the Chamber upheld the decision with general reasoning.
Did the Chamber Deem Polygamous Marriage Valid?
The Chamber did not state that the marriage was not flawed; it only stated that it would continue its existence as a valid marriage until an annulment decision is rendered; in this file, it did not examine whether a cause for annulment actually existed.
An action for absolute annulment is filed ex officio by the public prosecutor pursuant to Article 146 and may also be filed by anyone with an interest; there is no finding in the decision that prevents the filing of this lawsuit. There is no explicit assessment in the decision regarding the divorce court notifying the public prosecutor's office of such a fact. According to Articles 157 and 158 cited in the decision, if an annulment decision is rendered, the children are deemed to have been born within a marriage, the spouse in good faith retains their personal status; provisions of divorce regarding the matrimonial property regime, compensation, maintenance, and surname are applied.
Does Public Order Close the Case, or Does It Exclude Foreign Provisions?
Although the phrase "Turkish public order" appears in the main decision, Article 5 of Law No. 5718 is not cited. According to this article, if a provision of the competent foreign law applied to a specific case is clearly contrary to Turkish public order, that provision shall not be applied, and Turkish law shall be applied in cases deemed necessary.
The operation of the article in the Iranian national spouses' In the file numbered E. 2023/4599, K. 2024/1413 is observed. The court of first instance requested and obtained a translation of the regulation concerning the common national law, found the regulation that does not grant free will to the “female” spouse to be contrary to public order, and decided on divorce in accordance with Turkish law. The regional court of appeal rejected the appeal on its merits, and the Chamber upheld the decision without drafting a separate reasoning regarding public order.
Author's assessment: When the two files are read together, public order functions not as a condition precedent that terminates the lawsuit, but as a mechanism of review that excludes contrary foreign provisions. Since Turkish law was already applied to the divorce in the main file, there was no foreign divorce decree to exclude. The public order review in the recognition and enforcement of a foreign decision is a separate matter, and in the recognition and enforcement review has been addressed.
Which Law Applies If a Nullity Action Is Filed?
This question has remained open; the Chamber stated that it was necessary to address the “law applicable to divorce and nullity of marriage actions” and cited Articles 13 and 14, but did not separately clarify which provision the nullity action is subject to. The second paragraph of Article 14 mentions nullity in terms of maintenance claims. The Chamber's sentence on public order, however, was framed “according to Turkish law.” How a marriage permitted by national law is to be evaluated in a nullity action and how Article 5 operates here must be evaluated separately in the concrete case.
If There Is No Civil Registry Record, What Document Does the Court Use to Search for the Marriage?
The Chamber countered the court of first instance’s reasoning regarding the civil registry record with the following sentence:
“For foreigners who have no connection whatsoever with Turkish citizenship, certifying their identities and their marriage is sufficient for them to file a divorce lawsuit, and it cannot be expected that this information be registered in our country’s civil registry.”
The decisions do not provide an exhaustive list of documents. The criterion that emerges from the texts is that the identity and the marriage must be demonstrated in the file:
- Main file: The marriage was understood through an official document issued in Egypt. The type of document, its apostille and translation status are not included in the decision; general information in the apostille correspondence are available.
- E. 2025/7884, K. 2026/2629: The parties, who are Iraqi citizens, declared that they were married through an application to the municipality, but the marriage documents and the woman’s identity document were not found in the file, and the marital status was written as “single” on the man’s international protection identity document. The Chamber unanimously reversed the decision by requesting the submission of the supporting documents.
- E. 2024/5848, K. 2025/1941: In the file of Syrian citizens under temporary protection, the Presidency of Migration Management reported that the parties were married. The Chamber unanimously reversed the refusal decision by requesting that the basis of this determination be inquired into and that the plaintiff woman be given time to submit evidence; the grounds for the refusal are not cited in the text.
Author's assessment: The main decision does not consider the registry record a condition precedent, but it does not prevent an existing record from being used as evidence; the existence of the marriage continues to be a preliminary question of the divorce lawsuit.
Should the Court Investigate the Common National Law If the Spouses Are Citizens of the Same Country?
According to two reversal decisions of the 2nd Civil Chamber of the Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) dated 2026, the common national law must be researched and applied primarily; however, the application of Turkish law was upheld in the two previous files concerning Syrian citizens. This question did not arise in the main file because the spouses have different citizenships. Pursuant to Article 2 of Law No. 5718, the judge shall apply the competent foreign law ex officio and may request the assistance of the parties in determining its content. If the provisions of the foreign law regarding the event cannot be determined “despite all efforts,” Turkish law shall be applied.
The table below summarizes five selected decisions.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Ruling | Nationality of the spouses | Research in the file | Yargıtay outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| E. 2025/10230, K. 2026/5215 (06.05.2026) | Syria | Common national law not researched | Reversal, unanimous vote |
| E. 2025/6736, K. 2026/1694 (16.02.2026) | Iraq | Common national law not researched | Reversal, unanimous vote |
| E. 2023/9126, K. 2024/6791 (03.10.2024) | Syria, temporary protection | No research was conducted in this file; the regional court of appeal relied on the Ministry’s notification in similar files | Upholding, unanimous |
| E. 2023/4599, K. 2024/1413 (04.03.2024) | Iran | The regulation was obtained and translated; it was found to be contrary to public order | Upholding, unanimous |
| E. 2023/350, K. 2023/3236 (15.06.2023) | Syria, temporary protection | In this file, the Ministry was consulted; it was reported that the current legislation was not available at the Ministry | Upholding, unanimous |
Is It a Real Difference in Case Law or a Difference in the Files?
Author's assessment: There is no divergence in the rule itself; the difference largely arises from the nature of the research in the file. However, one of the decisions does not fully fit this explanation.
- If there is no research: In two files dated 2026, the Chamber issued a reversal, stating that if foreign law cannot be determined despite all research or if it is clearly contrary to Turkish public order, Turkish law shall apply.
- If the correspondence was conducted in this file: In file E. 2023/350, the Ministry stated that it did not have the current legislation, that operations at the Damascus Embassy and the Aleppo Consulate General had been suspended, and that difficulties in cooperation persisted; it conveyed the opinion that Turkish law should be applied if the legislation could not be obtained. This opinion belongs to the Ministry. The regional court of appeal found the investigation sufficient, and the Chamber upheld the decision with general reasoning; there is no criterion in the decision stating that futile correspondence makes it mandatory to revert to Turkish law in every file.
- A file that is difficult to explain: In file E. 2023/9126, the court of first instance did not conduct an investigation. The regional court of appeal found this to be erroneous but considered the result appropriate based on the notification made by the Ministry in “similar files.” The Chamber also upheld the decision with general reasoning and did not discuss this point separately.
Author's assessment: When the last file is read alongside the reversal decision E. 2025/10230, which also concerns Syrian citizens, a tension is evident. Nevertheless, since there is no criterion written in the 2024 upholding decision, it would not be correct to consider it a precedent that removes the obligation to investigate; the Ministry’s responses also belong to the period in which they were given.
Does Living in Turkiye Make the Turkish Court Competent?
This question cannot be answered from the main decision, because international jurisdiction was not discussed in the decision, and Articles 40 and 41 of Law No. 5718 were not mentioned. The fact of living in Turkiye was used for the applicable law, not for jurisdiction, and it is not understood from the text whether a jurisdictional objection was made. For this reason, the decision does not mean that a Turkish court will hear every case involving a foreigner.
According to Article 40, the rules of venue of domestic law determine the international jurisdiction of Turkish courts, while Article 41 regulates lawsuits concerning the personal status of Turkish citizens. The jurisdiction rule and procedural steps in Article 168 of the Turkish Civil Code are explained in the divorce guide for foreigners.
Does a Reversal Decision by the Yargitay Mean a Divorce?
No, the decision has removed the procedural obstacle to the hearing of the case, but it has not resulted in a divorce. Its consequences and limits can be summarized as follows:
- Status of the file: It has been decided to send the file to the court of first instance, and the Chamber has decided that “there is no need to examine other appeal requests for the time being.” It does not follow from the decision that the case will be accepted.
- Finalization and subsequent stage: The expression “final” (kesin olarak), the notification of the legal remedy, or a record of correction or rectification of the decision does not appear in the decision. With the distinctive expressions of the decision, no subsequent decision belonging to the same file was seen in the search conducted in the UYAP Precedent Decision database on 3 November 2026; this does not mean that there is no subsequent stage.
- Residence and citizenship: These consequences were not addressed in the decision.
- Other files: The decision, which was given by a majority of votes, is limited to the facts contained in the text and does not automatically produce results for other files.
Did the Law Change After the Decision?
In the limited search at the beginning of November 2026, no changes were detected in Law No. 5718 or in the provisions of the Turkish Civil Code regarding marriage, nullity, and grounds for divorce after the decision. In the Lexpera record, the latest amendment to Law No. 5718 is the regulation dated 4 June 2025 regarding Article 27. According to the accessed text of Law No. 7589 (Official Gazette 31.07.2026, 33326), only Articles 440 and 444 regarding sales transactions were amended in the Turkish Civil Code, and Law No. 5718 was not mentioned. This finding is not definitive as the official legislative text could not be accessed.
There is, however, development in the side consequences of divorce. The Constitutional Court, with its decision dated 4 June 2026, E. 2025/156, K. 2026/131 It has annulled the phrase “indefinitely” in the first paragraph of Article 175 of the Turkish Civil Code by a majority vote. The decision was published in the Official Gazette dated 30 September 2026 and numbered 33386, and it was decided that the annulment would enter into force nine months after its publication. For this reason, claims for spousal maintenance (yoksulluk nafakasi) must be monitored separately in cases where Turkish law is applied.
What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?
- Citizenship: If the spouses have the same citizenship, their common national law is investigated (E. 2025/10230); if they have different citizenships, their common habitual residence is examined (E. 2025/5548).
- Place and form of marriage: A marriage concluded abroad with an official document and a marriage concluded in Turkiye solely by a religious ceremony may not be subject to the same assessment (E. 2025/5548; E. 2025/7884).
- Documentary evidence and institution records: Missing supporting documents may be requested from the relevant authorities (E. 2025/7884), and the basis for the marriage information held by the Presidency of Migration Management may be inquired (E. 2024/5848).
- Previous marriage: The status as of the date of marriage and whether an annulment lawsuit has been filed must be determined (E. 2025/5548).
- Foreign law correspondence: It must be checked whether the response has been entered into this file and to which date it pertains (E. 2023/350; E. 2023/9126).
Frequently Asked Questions
What Did the Yargıtay 2nd Civil Chamber Decide in the Divorce Case Involving a Polygamous Foreign Marriage?
By its decision dated 21 April 2026, E. 2025/5548, K. 2026/4435, the Yargıtay 2nd Civil Chamber overturned the Regional Court of Appeal's decision and, by a majority vote, overturned the first-instance court's procedural dismissal. The court was instructed to collect evidence and render a decision on the merits; no divorce decree was granted. The decision does not contain the phrase “final” or a notification of legal remedies.
Can Foreigners Without a Civil Registry Record File for Divorce in Turkiye?
According to the Yargıtay 2nd Civil Chamber, for foreigners who have no connection to Turkish citizenship, documenting their identity and marriage status is sufficient to file for a divorce case. It cannot be expected that this information be registered in the Turkish civil registry. In file no. E. 2025/7884, it was accepted that if the marriage certificate is not in the file, the court must obtain the supporting documents. Jurisdiction and the merits of the case are examined separately.
Can a Turkish Court Dismiss a Divorce Case Because My Spouse Has Another Spouse?
In its decision E. 2025/5548, the Yargıtay 2nd Civil Chamber considered an existing marriage at the time of the wedding as a cause for absolute nullity, but overturned the procedural dismissal by a majority vote, stating that the court cannot evaluate this on its own motion in a divorce case. A separate lawsuit is required for a nullity decree. An informal marriage allegedly entered into while the marriage was ongoing was deemed a fault by the first-instance court in file no. E. 2023/350, and the decision was upheld.
Can Foreigners Married Only by Religious Ceremony in Turkiye File for Divorce?
In its decisions E. 2025/7884 and E. 2024/5848, the Yargıtay 2nd Civil Chamber, citing doctrine, stated that religious marriages contracted by foreigners in Turkiye are void, even if they comply with their own national laws. According to decision E. 2025/5548, in a divorce case, a judge who identifies the voidness should not grant a divorce but should instead issue a declaratory judgment of voidness. In the two aforementioned files, however, the conclusion of voidness was not reached, and the decision was overturned due to incomplete investigation.
If Foreign Law Cannot Be Determined for Spouses Who Are Citizens of the Same Country, Is Turkish Law Applied?
According to Article 2 of Law No. 5718, if the provisions of the applicable foreign law cannot be determined despite all research, Turkish law shall be applied. The Yargıtay 2nd Civil Chamber considered issuing a judgment without conducting research in 2026 cases involving Syria and Iraq as grounds for overturning, while it upheld the application of Turkish law in two previous Syria files.
Is a Divorce Case Dismissed if Foreign Law Conflicts with Turkish Public Order?
According to Article 5 of Law No. 5718, foreign provisions that are clearly contrary to public order shall not be applied, and Turkish law shall be applied where necessary. In the Yargıtay 2nd Civil Chamber's file E. 2023/4599, the first-instance court did not apply the regulation in Iranian law for this reason, and the divorce decree rendered according to Turkish law was upheld without a separate public order justification being written.
Conclusion: A Cause for Absolute Nullity Does Not Automatically Terminate a Divorce Case
According to the decision of the 2nd Civil Chamber of the Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) dated 21 April 2026, rendered by majority vote, the divorce lawsuit of foreign spouses who document their identity and marriage should not be dismissed on procedural grounds due to the absence of a civil registry record. Even if there is a cause for absolute nullity, the court cannot decide on annulment on its own motion when no such lawsuit has been filed.
The decision does not deem polygamy lawful, nor does it guarantee the outcome of a divorce. Upon reversal, it was decided that the file be sent to the court of first instance to be examined on the merits. In similar files, the first point to be examined is where and how the marriage was concluded and whether it was documented, and the second is the correct determination of the law applicable according to the citizenship of the spouses.
Legal Resources and Related Reviews
Legislation
- Law on Private International Law and Procedural Law No. 5718, especially Articles 2, 5, 13, 14, 40 and 41.
- Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, especially Articles 145, 146, 156-158, 166, 168 and 175.
- Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Art. 114 and 115.
- Regulation on the Implementation of Population Services, Article 21 as cited in the decision of the first instance court.
Court of Cassation Decisions
The list contains the decisions mentioned in the letter and does not represent all search results.
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2025/5548, K. 2026/4435, T. 21.04.2026
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2025/10230, K. 2026/5215, T. 06.05.2026
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2025/7884, K. 2026/2629, T. 09.03.2026
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2025/6736, K. 2026/1694, T. 16.02.2026
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2024/5848, K. 2025/1941, T. 24.02.2025
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2023/9126, K. 2024/6791, T. 03.10.2024
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2023/4599, K. 2024/1413, T. 04.03.2024
- 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2023/350, K. 2023/3236, T. 15.06.2023
- General Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2011/7-695, K. 2011/673, T. 02.11.2011
Other Resources and Related Articles
- Anayasa Mahkemesi (Constitutional Court of Turkiye), E. 2025/156, K. 2026/131, T. 04.06.2026, Official Gazette 30.09.2026, 33386.
- Lexpera, Law No. 5718 record.
- Transcription of Law No. 7589 text, memurlar.net.
- Divorce proceedings for foreign nationals in Turkiye
- Residence permit and citizenship of a foreign spouse after divorce
- Recognition of a foreign divorce decree
- Enforcement of a foreign judgment and public order
- Foreign heir and reciprocity: Examination by the 7th Civil Chamber of the Yargitay
Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008
This text is a legal decision analysis based on the decision of the 2nd Civil Chamber of the Yargitay dated 21.04.2026, E. 2025/5548, K. 2026/4435. The analysis is limited to the published decision text; it does not imply that the same result will be obtained in other files.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.