Precedent decision reviews

Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments: Acquittal Was Not Considered a Barrier to Public Policy in This Case, Yargıtay HGK

In this article 16 headings
  1. Short Answer: On What Grounds Is the Enforcement of a Foreign Judgment Refused by the Yargıtay?
  2. Reference Information of the General Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
  3. How Did the Dispute Begin? From Shareholders Agreement to Two ICC Decisions
  4. What Are the Conditions for Enforcement, Can the Judge Enter the Merits of the Foreign Judgment?
  5. Why Did the General Assembly Not Consider Criminal Acquittal an Enforcement Barrier?
  6. The Liability Judgment Proceeded, Why Was the Compensation Judgment Stuck?
  7. What Happens When the Public Policy Justification Is Based on Law and the Law Is Repealed?
  8. In Which File Did the Yargıtay Refuse, and in Which Did It Protect Enforcement?
  9. Are Lack of Justification, Costs, Interest, and Attorney Fees Contrary to Public Policy?
  10. How Are Reciprocity and Actual Practice Proven?
  11. Where Is the Enforcement Lawsuit Filed, How Long Does It Take, Has the Law Changed?
  12. What Should the Creditor and Debtor Examine in a Similar File?
  13. Frequently Asked Questions
  14. Conclusion: What Is Examined in Enforcement Is Not the Accuracy of the Judgment, But Its Effect in Turkey
  15. Legal Resources and Related Reviews
  16. Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Written and reviewed by: Atty. Batın Yılmaz (Istanbul Bar Association, Reg. No: 77008)
Publication:  ·  Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.

enforcement of a foreign judgment

enforcement of a foreign judgment

Short Answer: On What Grounds Is the Enforcement of a Foreign Judgment Refused by the Yargıtay?

According to the read decisions, the enforcement of a foreign judgment is not denied simply because the Turkish judge disagrees with the decision. For a denial, a specific obstacle listed in the law or the New York Convention must be concretely established; the most prominent obstacles are the actual restriction of the right to defense and a clear violation of public policy.

The General Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Yargıtay, in its decision dated November 8, 2023, numbered E. 2022/11-660, K. 2023/1066, demonstrated this boundary through two ICC arbitral awards. The Assembly did not consider the acquittal decision of the High Criminal Court as an obstacle to the enforcement of the liability decision and overturned the resistance decision for denial by a majority vote. Regarding the compensation decision, it rejected the plaintiff's appeal due to a lack of legal interest; the grounds for refusal regarding that decision had been found appropriate by the 11th Civil Chamber due to the right to defense.

The overturning of the resistance decision is not an enforcement decision; the path for rectification of the decision remains open. Five months ago, in another case, the General Assembly found the recognition of a German court decision based on a legal provision that was subsequently repealed to be clearly contrary to public policy. In 2025, the 6th Civil Chamber upheld the appellate decision maintaining the dismissal of the case regarding a German decision on the erasure of debts, while in 2026, the 11th Civil Chamber upheld a decision maintaining the enforcement of a German judgment on the same debt.

This analysis is based on the published texts of the decisions; party names have not been included. For the general framework the guide on foreign court decisions, and for the effects of the decisions in Türkiye see the article on the validity of foreign court decisions can be consulted.

Reference Information of the General Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

Title Information
Court Yargıtay Hukuk Genel Kurulu
Basis and decision number E. 2022/11-660, K. 2023/1066
Decision date 08.11.2023
Subject of the lawsuit Recognition and enforcement of two arbitral awards issued in International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) arbitration
Previous decisions Istanbul 8th Civil Court of First Instance, E. 2021/390, K. 2021/797; 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2019/2417, K. 2021/1051
Applied provisions New York Convention Art. 1 and Art. 5; Law No. 5718 Art. 60-63; Constitution Art. 90; Turkish Code of Obligations Art. 74
Result (Decision dated 19.06.2013) Dismissal of the plaintiff's appeal objections due to lack of legal interest, unanimous
Result (Decision dated 13.12.2012) Overturning of the resistance decision based on the reasons for overturning by the Special Chamber, majority vote
Legal remedy The path for rectification of the decision was left open; there is no information on finalization in the decision

How Did the Dispute Begin? From Shareholders Agreement to Two ICC Decisions

The plaintiff company was a 50 percent partner in a holding, and the parties signed a shareholders' agreement dated January 16, 2007. The plaintiff initiated ICC arbitration, claiming that it had suffered damages due to the fraudulent actions of the defendant and a company not party to the case.

In the first decision, the arbitral tribunal deemed the defendant's actions an “Event of Default Not Cured” under the contract and held it jointly and severally liable for the loss in value of the plaintiff's shares. In the second decision, it ruled on compensation, arbitration, and litigation costs. Since collection could not be achieved, the plaintiff requested the recognition and enforcement of both decisions pursuant to the New York Convention.

Date Development Legal Significance
13.12.2012 The arbitral tribunal ruled on the defendant's liability. This is the decision to which the discussion on acquittal is directed.
19.06.2013 The arbitral tribunal ruled on compensation and costs. This is the decision to which the discussion on the right to defense is directed.
20.01.2014 Istanbul 7th High Criminal Court issued an acquittal decision for the defendants; the decision was upheld by the 23rd Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay and became final. The defendant was the accused, and the plaintiff company was in the position of the complainant.
30.06.2016 Istanbul 8th Civil Court of First Instance dismissed the case. The court relied on the acquittal decision and the violation of the right to a fair trial.
29.11.2018 The 11th Civil Chamber overturned the decision. The Chamber accepted that no concrete evidence was presented regarding the procedural violation.
10.02.2021 In the decision rectification phase, the Chamber lifted the previous reversal, separated the two arbitral awards, and reversed the decision again with different reasoning. The reasoning for refusal was not found appropriate in the liability decision, but it was found appropriate in the compensation decision.
11.11.2021 The court resisted. The dispute was referred to the General Assembly of Civil Chambers (Hukuk Genel Kurulu).

The defendant, on the other hand, argued that they were not a partner at the date of the dispute, that mediation should have been sought first, and that the arbitral tribunal exceeded its authority. They also argued that their access to the report was blocked, that the obligation was fulfilled, and that the decision was contrary to public policy as it conflicted with Turkish decisions.

What Are the Conditions for Enforcement, Can the Judge Enter the Merits of the Foreign Judgment?

A foreign court judgment and a foreign arbitral award are not subject to the same regime. According to the third paragraph of According to Article 50, the enforcement of a court judgment in Turkey is 'subject to an enforcement (tenfiz) decision by the competent Turkish court.' In the case of arbitral awards, according to the General Assembly, the fundamental regulation is Articles 60-63 of the Law; however, pursuant to the second paragraph of Article 1 of the Law and Article 90 of the Constitution, the Convention is applied first for decisions within the scope of the New York Convention.

There is no reference to the International Arbitration Law No. 4686 in the ICC decision. According to Altan, this Law applies to disputes that contain a foreign element and have their seat of arbitration in Turkey or are subject to the Law; in decisions within this scope, an enforceability decision is obtained instead of an enforcement (tenfiz) decision. Therefore, the first question is whether the arbitral award is truly considered foreign.

Obstacle Court judgment (MOHIP Art. 54) Arbitral award (New York Convention) Type of review
Reciprocity Paragraph (a) seeks an agreement, a legal provision, or 'actual practice'. According to Turkey's reservations, a decision rendered in a country party to the Convention and a commercial dispute are sought (first instance decision upheld in 6th Civil Chamber E. 2025/3784). It is required for the enforcement (tenfiz) of a court judgment, but not for its recognition (E. 2022/800).
Jurisdiction Paragraph (b) requires that it be rendered on a matter 'not subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of Turkish courts'. In the reasoning of the ICC decision, this clause is not included as a condition for an arbitral award. In a court judgment, exclusive jurisdiction is reviewed ex officio, while review of excessive jurisdiction depends on the defendant's objection (E. 2017/11-52).
Public policy Paragraph (c) imposes the condition that 'the provision is not clearly contrary to public policy'. It is within the scope of Article 5/2-b. According to the 11th Civil Chamber, it can be taken into account by the court ex officio in an arbitral award.
Right to defense Paragraph (ç) creates an obstacle subject to objection if the person was not 'properly' summoned or represented. It is within the scope of Article 5/1-b. According to the 11th Civil Chamber, the burden of asserting and proving this in an arbitral award belongs to the party against whom enforcement is requested.

In both regimes, the judge cannot enter into the merits. According to the General Assembly, 'the enforcement judge cannot examine the foreign arbitral award on its merits and cannot review its compliance with the law'. In the decision numbered E. 2022/800, K. 2023/607 the same rule was reiterated for court judgments, and it was stated that the 'revision' system is not accepted in Turkish law. According to the same decision, a judge 'cannot refuse the enforcement of a foreign decision by deeming it contrary to public policy merely because it was rendered by applying substantive and procedural rules different from those in Turkish law.' What is reviewed is not the content of the decision, but the consequences of its execution and whether the operative part is contrary to the fundamental principles of the Constitution or the legal system, or to general customs and morals.

Why Did the General Assembly Not Consider Criminal Acquittal an Enforcement Barrier?

While the first instance court was resisting, it had accepted that the findings of material facts in the acquittal decision bound the civil judge pursuant to Article 74 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, and therefore the liability decision conflicted with the finalized criminal judgment. The General Assembly rejected this approach in four steps:

  1. The concept is interpreted narrowly. According to the Board, “the concept of public policy in domestic law and the concept of public policy in the field of private international law are different from each other.”
  2. It is not enough for the case to be heard in Türkiye. If a foreign judgment contains a “contradiction at a level incompatible” with Turkish court decisions, a public policy obstacle may arise. However, “it cannot be said that the fact that the dispute is heard in Turkish courts will constitute a violation of public policy in every case and prevent the recognition and enforcement of a foreign arbitral award.”
  3. Criminal and civil proceedings are different. The parties, evidence, and investigation methods of the two proceedings are separate. According to Article 74 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, the civil judge is not bound by an acquittal decision; however, the material facts determined by the criminal judge and the illegality of the act bind the civil judge.
  4. A concrete acquittal does not contain such a determination. The criminal court acquitted the defendants on the grounds that “no evidence other than the allegations was obtained sufficient for conviction and the alleged crimes did not occur in terms of their elements,” and also stated that the resolution of the matter belonged to civil litigation. The arbitral tribunal, on the other hand, made its decision not regarding a tort or fault, but regarding the state of default under the contract.

The criterion of the Board is summarized in the following sentence:

“On the other hand, the existence of a finalized criminal court decision that does not contain a determination clear enough to leave no room for doubt regarding the illegality of a material fact does not constitute an obstacle to the recognition and enforcement of a foreign arbitral award concerning the same material fact on the grounds of violation of public policy.”

The note in the text pertains to a criminal decision that does not contain a clear determination; according to the author's assessment, if the criminal judge has definitively determined that the act was not committed, a different result may arise. During the deliberations, it was argued that there was a public policy obstacle due to the acquittal and that the resistance decision should be upheld, but this view was not adopted by the majority.

The Liability Judgment Proceeded, Why Was the Compensation Judgment Stuck?

Two decisions arising from the same arbitration did not receive the same result. In its 2018 reversal, the 11th Civil Chamber had stated that “concrete evidence was not presented” regarding the procedural violation. In its 2021 rectification of decision, it changed its view regarding the compensation decision and found the justification for rejection to be appropriate by a majority vote.

The facts relied upon by the Chamber are concrete. The arbitral tribunal had permitted the concealment of the names of those who prepared the March 2010 report, which served as the basis for the judgment, as well as the section regarding the financial model and method in the valuation calculation. The report could not be examined by the defendant principals themselves, but only by their lawyers and those conducting the valuation study on behalf of the defendant party; furthermore, sharing the draft report prepared by the defendant party with the principals had been prohibited. The Chamber further stated that cross-examination was prevented, the confidentiality lacked a reasonable and legal basis, and it violated the agreed-upon procedural rules. The Chamber deemed this contrary to Articles 5/1-b and 5/2-b of the Convention and clauses (b) and (d) of the first paragraph of Article 62 of Law No. 5718 regarding arbitral awards:

“The restriction of the right to defense and, consequently, the violation of the right to a fair trial also clearly constitute a violation of Turkish public policy.”

According to the author's assessment, the difference between the two decisions lies in the subject of the objection. The discussion regarding acquittal is directed at the outcome of the arbitral award, and the outcome cannot be reviewed on its merits. The discussion regarding the report, however, is directed at how the proceedings were conducted; the judge does not inquire whether the debt was calculated correctly while examining this.

The General Assembly's reasoning regarding the compensation decision must be read narrowly. The Assembly stated that since this decision "remained outside the scope of the reversal decision, there is no legal interest in the plaintiff's appeal regarding the aforementioned foreign arbitral award under the current circumstances." The justification concerning the right to defense was discussed in the Special Chamber's decision, and the Assembly's conclusion in this section was based on the lack of legal interest. The Assembly also found it contrary to procedure to establish a single judgment for two arbitral awards.

What Happens When the Public Policy Justification Is Based on Law and the Law Is Repealed?

In case file No. E. 2022/800, a Turkish company requested the recognition of a decision by the Duisburg court regarding the dismissal of a debt lawsuit filed against it in Germany due to the statute of limitations. The court accepted the case, the 11th Civil Chamber reversed it twice, and the court insisted on its original decision.

On June 7, 2023, the General Assembly unanimously and definitively overturned the resistance decision, stating that the case should be dismissed. According to the reasoning, Provisional Article 4 added to Law No. 3332 by Law No. 7194, deemed certain payments as equivalent to shares and retroactively established a partnership relationship and property rights. The foreign decision, however, had not considered the defendant a shareholder; the Assembly found this contrary to the Constitution regarding property rights and the fundamental principles of the legal system. It also stated that contradictory results in cases of persons in the same situation would be contrary to legal certainty and Article 36 of the Constitution. The incompatibility with Turkish court decisions was conveyed as a general rule, and the evaluation of a specific Turkish decision was not included in the judgment.

According to the General Assembly decision No. E. 2023/780, K. 2024/189, the Constitutional Court repealed Provisional Article 4 with its decision dated May 18, 2023, No. E. 2020/11, K. 2023/98. The repeal decision entered into force upon its publication on September 12, 2023. The Constitutional Court's decision and the reasoning for the repeal were not read separately. In this file regarding the enforcement of the Cologne court decision, the Special Chamber had accepted that enforcement was contrary to public policy based on the same article, and the court had resisted. On April 17, 2024, the General Assembly did not enter into the merits and decided to send the file to the 11th Civil Chamber "in view of the new situation created by the Constitutional Court's repeal decision"; it also left the path for correction of decision open.

The remaining question is the author's assessment. Decision No. E. 2022/800 was rendered after the date of the repeal decision but before its publication, and the decision does not contain a reference to the repeal decision. The General Assembly defines public policy as a concept that "changes according to time and place." Therefore, if it is based on an obstructive statutory provision, the status of this provision at the date of the decision must be reviewed separately. Since the result reached by the 11th Civil Chamber in the Cologne file could not be found in the UYAP search, the effect of the repeal on the public policy assessment is not understood from these decisions.

In Which File Did the Yargıtay Refuse, and in Which Did It Protect Enforcement?

The table summarizes nine decisions selected from the full texts read in UYAP; it is not a census and should not be read as a success rate.

Ruling Foreign decision Discussed obstacle Yargıtay outcome Defining point
HGK E. 2022/11-660, K. 2023/1066 (08.11.2023) Two ICC arbitral awards Acquittal and right to defense Reversal of resistance regarding one decision (majority vote), dismissal of appeal regarding the other (unanimous) There was no explicit finding on acquittal; the compensation decision remained outside the reversal
11. HD E. 2025/6280, K. 2026/3123 (02.06.2026) German regional court's 50,000 Euro debt decision Subsequent bankruptcy and discharge of debts, public policy Affirmation of the appellate decision protecting recognition and enforcement, unanimous, final The regional court of justice did not consider the subsequent bankruptcy as an obstacle
6. HD E. 2025/3784, K. 2026/1634 (21.04.2026) Provision for costs and attorney fees in the UNCITRAL arbitral award rendered in Stockholm Reciprocity, commercial nature, public policy Affirmation of the appellate decision upholding recognition and enforcement, unanimous The Chamber stated that the payment made through the protocol shall be taken into account during the enforcement phase
6th Civil Chamber E. 2025/3678, K. 2025/4288 (10.12.2025) Essen court decision on debt discharge via bankruptcy Public policy Affirmation of the appellate decision upholding the dismissal of the case, unanimous The court of first instance accepted that bankruptcy does not terminate debt under Turkish law
9th Civil Chamber E. 2024/12327, K. 2025/346 (13.01.2025) Saudi Arabian court decision on employee receivables Finalization, type of case, legal interest Overturning of the regional court of justice decision and reversal of the first instance decision, unanimous The certificate of finalization was missing; for a performance judgment, enforcement (tenfiz) rather than recognition would have been possible
General Assembly of Civil Chambers E. 2023/780, K. 2024/189 (17.04.2024) Cologne court decision Provisional Article 4 and public policy Referral of the file to the Special Chamber, unanimous, decision correction path open The Constitutional Court's cancellation decision was considered a new situation
General Assembly of Civil Chambers E. 2022/800, K. 2023/607 (07.06.2023) Duisburg court decision (recognition) Public policy Reversal of the resistance decision, unanimous, final Foreign decision did not align with Provisional Article 4 and fundamental principles regarding property
11th Civil Chamber E. 2021/8592, K. 2023/104 (10.01.2023) GAFTA arbitral award Public policy, scope of the arbitration agreement Affirmation of the partial enforcement decision, unanimous Parts other than the costs of the Turkish case were enforced
General Assembly of Civil Chambers E. 2017/11-52, K. 2021/671 (03.06.2021) Düsseldorf court decisions on cost assessment Territoriality and public policy Affirmation of the resistance decision regarding enforcement, majority vote, decision correction path open The original decision only provided protection within Germany

There are four outcomes:

  • The result of acceptance may be partial. In the GAFTA file, the court of first instance rejected the part related to the costs of the case in the Turkish court, considering it as 'separable from the remainder of the arbitral award.' The Chamber's affirmation does not contain a separate assessment regarding the separability.
  • Protection specific to a foreign country was not considered an obstacle when it remained within that country. The General Assembly concluded that the protection concerning the German patent remained within Germany and that the enforcement would not prevent the use of the patent in Turkey, thus finding that the decision was 'not clearly contrary to Turkish public policy.' The dissenting opinion argued that territoriality is bidirectional and the case should have been dismissed.
  • The judgment for receivables was enforced; the judgment discharging the debt was not recognized. The rulings of the 6th and 11th Civil Chambers mention the same German judgment as well as Antalya 3rd Commercial Court of First Instance file no. 2021/256 E. The debtor's lawsuit was dismissed at the first instance on the grounds of public policy. In the creditors' lawsuit, the court of first instance noted that there was no ruling or lawsuit demonstrating that the decision regarding bankruptcy had been recognized, whereas the regional court of justice did not consider the subsequent bankruptcy as an obstacle. According to the author's assessment, the open question is the objection regarding an "obstacle to enforcement" under Article 55 of the Law; neither decision contains an evaluation regarding this provision.
  • The criteria in the affirmation decision are read from the lower court. The 6th Civil Chamber's decision lacks a separate assessment regarding public policy, the reasoning of the regional court of justice, and the phrase "with final effect." The 11th Civil Chamber also merely stated that there was no inaccuracy. Therefore, these decisions should not be generalized to mean that every foreign bankruptcy decision will be rejected.

Are Lack of Justification, Costs, Interest, and Attorney Fees Contrary to Public Policy?

Lack of reasoning. The General Assembly of Civil Chambers for the Unification of Jurisprudence, with a majority vote exceeding two-thirds, in its decision dated February 10, 2012, no. E. 2010/1, K. 2012/1 ruled that "the mere absence of reasoning in foreign court decisions shall not constitute an obstacle to the enforcement of a finalized foreign court decision." According to the Assembly, the failure to provide an opportunity to exercise the right to defense requires the intervention of public policy.

Expenses. According to the General Assembly (E. 2017/11-52), expense determination decisions are ancillary to the main judgment and their conditions are examined in relation to the main judgment.

Interest and attorney fees. The GAFTA decision does not contain a separate public policy assessment regarding the 4% annual interest compounded quarterly. The first instance decision, affirmed by the 6th Civil Chamber's decision no. E. 2025/3784, did not consider the arbitration costs and attorney fee provisions to be contrary to public policy, and the objection regarding excessive amounts was not considered a ground for reversal.

How Are Reciprocity and Actual Practice Proven?

This condition is sought in the enforcement of foreign court judgments and is met through an agreement, a legal provision, or the "existence of factual practice." There is no current standard of proof in the examined Yargıtay decisions. In the file concerning expense determination decisions, the General Assembly stated that in federal structures, "reciprocity is to be sought not with the federal state, but with the federated state where the court that issued the decision is located."

In file no. E. 2016/4409, the Chamber did not address the defendant's objection regarding the bilateral agreement because it reversed the decision on jurisdictional grounds. However, in the file affirmed by the 6th Civil Chamber, Gündoğancriticizes the lack of focus on reciprocity by stating that "factual reciprocity should have been investigated."

The following rules of proof are taken from doctrine. According to Aygül, the judge investigates reciprocity ex officio and requests information from the Ministry of Justice. The parties may also submit decisions showing that Turkish decisions are enforced in the foreign country; if the condition cannot be determined ex officio, the claimant may be asked to prove factual reciprocity, and if they fail to do so, the lawsuit is dismissed.

Where Is the Enforcement Lawsuit Filed, How Long Does It Take, Has the Law Changed?

  • Court: Regarding foreign judgments, Article 51 of the Law designates the civil court of first instance. In 2017, the 11th Civil Chamber overturned the decision ex officio, stating that the commercial court of first instance had jurisdiction over commercial receivables (the provision referred to as "Article 5" in the UYAP text is Article 51).
  • Type of lawsuit: The 9th Civil Chamber stated that for a decision rendered as a result of a performance lawsuit, "it may be possible to enforce this decision rather than recognize it." The distinction between recognition and enforcement in our examination regarding the recognition of foreign decisions has been addressed.
  • Documents: Finalization is a prerequisite and is observed by the court. The Chamber considered the rendering of a decision without granting time for the submission of apostilled documents to be an incomplete investigation. For preparation to the apostille letter can be consulted.
  • Timeframe: Although the law provides for a simple trial procedure, the Köln file was still at the Yargıtay in 2024 after the initial first-instance decision in 2009. This example is not a general indicator of duration.

As of November 2026, no new regulation amending articles 50-63 of Law No. 5718 or Law No. 4686 has been encountered in the accessible sources; this check is not an official Official Gazette search. Regarding Law No. 7589, in the summary of changes in LegaPro these two laws are not included. According to the same summary, of the Code of Civil Procedure (Hukuk Muhakemeleri Kanunu), to Article 362, a paragraph has been added that ties the appeal of decisions re-rendered after the acceptance of an appellate review (istinaf) to a monetary threshold.

What Should the Creditor and Debtor Examine in a Similar File?

For the creditor, enforcement (tenfiz), collection of receivables in Türkiye by foreign companies is only one path of the process. For the effect of the jurisdiction and arbitration clause in the contract, to the article on competent court and applicable law can be consulted.

  • Parts of the judgment: The creditor must request each arbitral award and each severable part separately and determine from the outset which decision contains the compensation (HGK E. 2022/11-660; 11. HD E. 2021/8592).
  • Call and defense records: The creditor must have the service and report access records from the foreign proceedings ready (HGK E. 2022/11-660).
  • Concrete violation: Instead of general allegations, the debtor must show the inaccessible document and the content of the restriction; the 2018 and 2021 decisions of the Chamber demonstrate this distinction.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Monetary Claim Judgment Obtained from a Foreign Court Be Directly Enforced in Turkey?

No. According to Article 50 of Law No. 5718, the enforcement of a foreign court judgment is subject to an enforcement order from a competent Turkish court. The 9th Civil Chamber of the Yargıtay has stated that for a judgment resulting from a performance lawsuit, only enforcement (tenfiz) and not just recognition (tanıma) is possible.

Can the Enforcement Judge Review the Merits of a Foreign Judgment?

No. According to the Yargıtay General Assembly of Civil Chambers, the enforcement judge cannot review the merits of a foreign court or arbitral award, nor can they audit its compliance with the law. The judge examines only the obstacles enumerated in the law or the New York Convention and whether the operative part of the judgment is clearly contrary to the fundamental principles of Turkish law.

Does an Acquittal Issued in Turkey Prevent the Enforcement of a Foreign Arbitral Award?

It does not prevent it in every case. The Yargıtay General Assembly of Civil Chambers, in its decision E. 2022/11-660, accepted that a finalized criminal judgment that does not contain explicit findings regarding the illegality of the material fact does not constitute a public policy barrier to enforcement. In the file reviewed, since the arbitral award was based on contractual liability and the acquittal was based on insufficiency of evidence and the failure of criminal elements to occur, no contradiction was observed.

When Does the Right to Defense Become Grounds for Refusal in the Enforcement of a Foreign Arbitral Award?

The 11th Civil Chamber of the Yargıtay found the grounds for refusal appropriate in an ICC file where the identities of the preparers of the report forming the basis of the judgment and the calculation method were hidden, and the defendant principals could not see the report. Asserting and proving the grounds in Article 5/1-b of the New York Convention belongs to the party against whom enforcement is sought; a general claim was not found sufficient in the reversal dated 2018.

Did the General Assembly of Civil Chambers Decide on the Enforcement of ICC Decisions?

No. In the file E. 2022/11-660, the Yargıtay General Assembly of Civil Chambers only reversed the resistance decision regarding the refusal of the liability decision and dismissed the appeal regarding the compensation decision due to a lack of legal interest. The path for rectification of the decision (karar düzeltme) has been left open.

Can a Creditor Judgment Against a Person Whose Debts Were Discharged in Germany Be Enforced in Turkey?

In its decision dated June 2, 2026, E. 2025/6280, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Yargıtay upheld the appellate court decision which did not consider bankruptcy in Germany after a foreign court judgment as an obstacle to recognition and enforcement. The request for recognition of the debt discharge decision regarding the same German judgment, however, was rejected by a decision upheld by the 6th Civil Chamber. The result is not automatically applied to other files.

Conclusion: What Is Examined in Enforcement Is Not the Accuracy of the Judgment, But Its Effect in Turkey

The decision of the Hukuk Genel Kurulu dated 8 November 2023 shows that public policy cannot be a tool for the retrial of a foreign decision. An acquittal decision that does not contain an explicit finding was not considered an obstacle to enforcement. As for the defendant whose access to the report was concretely restricted, the Special Chamber found the grounds for rejection to be appropriate, and this part remained outside the scope of the reversal.

A contradiction based on a provision of law prevented recognition, but the annulment of this provision brought a similar file back to the Special Chamber. For this reason, the first question in similar files is not whether the decision is correct, but which obstacle can be shown with which document. Decisions do not automatically produce results for other files.

Legal Resources and Related Reviews

Legislation

Court of Cassation Decisions

The list contains the decisions mentioned in the text; links lead to the full texts on UYAP.

Other Resources and Related Articles

Author and Legal Information

Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008

This text is a legal decision analysis based on the ruling of the Yargıtay Hukuk Genel Kurulu dated 08.11.2023, E. 2022/11-660, K. 2023/1066. The analysis is limited to the published text of the decision; it does not guarantee that the same result will be obtained in other cases.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Author

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Founding attorney of Batın Yılmaz Law Office. Handles litigation and consultancy in foreigners and citizenship law, as well as criminal, corporate, administrative, real estate, enforcement, and compensation law.

About our office