Precedent decision reviews

In-Vehicle Footage Recorded by an Undercover Agent Ruled Unlawful: Yargıtay Overturns Conviction

In this article 13 headings
  1. Short Answer: Can the In-Vehicle Footage of an Undercover Investigator Be Used as Evidence?
  2. Citation of the Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber Decision
  3. How Did the Dispute Start? From the Undercover Investigator's Recording to Trial
  4. Why Did the Yargıtay Deem the Video Recording Unlawful?
  5. The Second Pillar of Reversal Due to Incomplete Investigation: A Verdict Cannot Be Rendered Without Identification
  6. Undercover Investigator Evidence: Lawful and Unlawful Scenarios
  7. Where and How Was the Case Tried?
  8. Consequences and Scope of the Reversal Decision
  9. Which Points Should Be Examined in a Similar Case File?
  10. Frequently Asked Questions
  11. Conclusion: The Authority of the Undercover Investigator Is Not Unlimited, Technical Recording Requires a Separate Decision
  12. Legal Resources and Related Reviews
  13. Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Written and reviewed by: Atty. Batın Yılmaz (Istanbul Bar Association, Reg. No: 77008)
Publication:  ·  Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.

Short Answer: Can the In-Vehicle Footage of an Undercover Investigator Be Used as Evidence?

A video recording taken by an undercover investigator inside a vehicle cannot be used as a basis for conviction if the manner in which it was obtained is unlawful; the defendant viewing these images and confirming the event does not change the legal nature of the evidence. The 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay addressed the debate on acquittal in drug offenses involving undercover investigators from this perspective in its decision dated February 2, 2026, numbered E. 2025/6185, K. 2026/821. The defendant had been tried and convicted of drug trafficking at the İstanbul Anadolu 24. Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi. The conviction judgment was upheld during the appeal review by the 16th Criminal Chamber of the İstanbul Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi. However, the Yargıtay overturned both decisions based on unlawful video recording and incomplete investigation.

Two fundamental points in the Chamber's reasoning complement each other. The first is that the video recording made inside the vehicle was found to be unlawful. The second is that the court's rendering of a judgment without hearing the undercover investigators and the responsible law enforcement officers as witnesses, and without having the defendant identified by these individuals, constituted an incomplete investigation. For the general framework of the subject, you may refer to the article on acquittal for drug trafficking.for evidentiary rules in criminal proceedings, to the article on evidence collection, and to the article examining the concepts of digital evidence, For the penalty, elements, execution of the crime, and its consequences for foreigners, please refer to the guide on the crime of drug trafficking. can be consulted.

Citation of the Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber Decision

Title Information
Court 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation
Basis and decision number E. 2025/6185, K. 2026/821
Decision date 02.02.2026
First instance court İstanbul Anadolu 24. Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi
Regional Court of Justice İstanbul BAM 16. Criminal Chamber, rejection of the appeal on the merits
Subject of the lawsuit Drug trafficking (TCK 188)
Conclusion Reversal
Request for release Rejected (on the grounds that there was no change in detention conditions)
Vote status Unanimous

How Did the Dispute Start? From the Undercover Investigator's Recording to Trial

At the basis of the case lies a covert investigation operation initiated upon intelligence regarding drug trafficking. The undercover investigator made a video recording inside a vehicle as part of the operation. These recordings were used as one of the main pillars of the conviction judgment during the trial process. The İstanbul Anadolu 24. Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi convicted the defendant of drug trafficking, and the 16th Criminal Chamber of the İstanbul Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi rejected the appeal on the merits.

Stage Development Legal consequence
Investigation An undercover investigator was assigned based on intelligence. It is a measure carried out within the scope of CMK 139.
Video recording The undercover investigator made a video recording inside the vehicle. The Yargıtay classified this recording as unlawful evidence.
Trial The İstanbul Anadolu 24. Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi convicted the defendant. The conviction was also based on the in-vehicle video recording.
Appeal (Istinaf) The İstanbul BAM 16th Criminal Chamber rejected the appeal on the merits. The conviction judgment was upheld.
Appeal on points of law (cassation) The defense counsel for the defendant appealed. The 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay overturned the judgment unanimously.

A procedural step that draws attention during the trial process is the court's act of having the defendant watch the images obtained by the undercover investigator. After watching the images, the defendant made a confirmation regarding the incident. The court evaluated this confirmation as additional data supporting the lawfulness of the video recording. The Yargıtay determined that this evaluation had no legal basis. In addition to this, it was also among the findings of the Yargıtay that the undercover investigators and responsible law enforcement officers were not heard as witnesses in the file and the defendant's identity was not identified by these individuals.

Why Did the Yargıtay Deem the Video Recording Unlawful?

The overturning reasoning of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay is built upon two independent legal findings. Both findings are of a nature to constitute a reason for overturning on their own; when evaluated together, it was concluded that the conviction judgment could not stand.

The first finding is that the video recording made by an undercover investigator inside a vehicle is considered unlawful. Pursuant to CMK 139/1, the appointment of an undercover investigator can only be decided by a judge, and this measure is subject to the conditions of strong suspicion based on concrete evidence and the impossibility of obtaining evidence through other means. The legal framework explains the Chamber's conclusion as follows: According to the sentence added to CMK 139/4 in 2023, the judge may permit the investigator to make audio or video recordings in public places and workplaces in cases of drug trafficking offenses. The interior of a vehicle does not qualify as a public place or a workplace; therefore, the recording made inside the vehicle falls outside the recording areas permitted by law. The Chamber determined that these images were obtained by unlawful means and cannot be taken as the basis for a verdict pursuant to CMK 217/2.

The second finding is that the defendant's confirmation of the incident by watching the footage does not make the unlawful evidence lawful. This finding corrects a common misconception in trial practice. Some courts assume that if an unlawful piece of evidence is shown to the defendant and the defendant makes a confession or confirmation in response to this evidence, the legal nature of the evidence changes. The Yargıtay, with an approach parallel to the fruit of the poisonous tree doctrine, has established that all information derived from an unlawful piece of evidence shares the same legal fate. The defendant's confirmation of the incident after watching the footage cannot be evaluated as a declaration of intent independent of the unlawfulness of the video recording; because this confirmation is a direct result of presenting the unlawful evidence to the defendant.

It has been understood that the video recording made by the undercover investigator inside the vehicle is unlawful. Showing these images to the defendant and the defendant's confirmation of the event does not make the unlawful evidence lawful; the recording cannot be used as the basis for a verdict.

When both findings are evaluated together, the conclusion is reached that one of the fundamental grounds of the conviction verdict is unlawful and that this unlawfulness cannot be remedied by subsequent trial procedures. For this reason, the Chamber has unanimously reversed the decision of the İstanbul BAM 16. Ceza Dairesi and has remitted the case file to be sent to the İstanbul Anadolu 24. Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi pursuant to CMK 304/2-a.

The Second Pillar of Reversal Due to Incomplete Investigation: A Verdict Cannot Be Rendered Without Identification

The second leg of the Chamber's reasoning for reversal is that the court passed a verdict without hearing the undercover investigators and the responsible law enforcement officers as witnesses. An undercover investigator assigned under CMK 139 is an official whose identity is kept confidential; however, this situation does not prevent the investigator from being heard as a witness during the trial stage. On the contrary, the information and observations obtained by the undercover investigator can only gain the status of lawful evidence by being entered into the file as witness testimony.

In the concrete case, the court, while evaluating the video recording obtained by the undercover investigators, did not hear these individuals as witnesses in the hearing. More importantly, it was determined that the defendant's identity was not identified by the undercover investigators, meaning that the investigators did not confirm the defendant at the hearing as the person in the footage. This deficiency is not merely a procedural formality; it is directly related to the protection of the defendant's right to defense and the necessity for the judge's conscience to be based on concrete evidence in the file. Indeed, as highlighted in the article examining the concept of unlawful search, the lawfulness of evidence is not limited only to the moment of its acquisition; how the evidence is used during the trial process is equally decisive.

This determination by the Chamber sets a standard for files where an undercover agent is utilized: before establishing a verdict, the court must hear the undercover agents and the law enforcement officers responsible for the operation as witnesses, have the defendant identified by these individuals in a proper manner, and evaluate all evidence in the file together. Skipping these steps results in the conclusion that the verdict was established with incomplete investigation and constitutes grounds for reversal.

Undercover Investigator Evidence: Lawful and Unlawful Scenarios

The effect of the findings obtained by the undercover agent on a conviction depends both on the manner in which the finding was obtained and how it is evaluated during the trial process. The table below compares the framework drawn by the examined decision with two different scenarios.

Scenario Source of evidence Use in the trial Legal nature Possible outcome
Examined decision (E. 2025/6185) In-vehicle footage from an undercover investigator Shown to the defendant, verification obtained; investigators were not heard Unlawful evidence; verification does not save it Reversal
Investigator is heard as a witness Observation and statement of the undercover agent Heard in the hearing, identification is performed, evidence is evaluated together Lawful witness statement Conviction is possible if other conditions are met
Recording in a public place with CMK 139/4 permission or CMK 140 decision Camera recording based on a judge's decision Recording is submitted to the file, investigators are also heard Lawful recording evidence Depends on the content of the evidence and other evidence

The fundamental distinction revealed by the table is this: the witness statement regarding what the undercover agent personally saw and heard is lawful evidence when obtained in accordance with the procedure. However, the undercover agent's taking of audio or video recordings is limited to public places and workplaces where the judge grants permission pursuant to CMK 139/4. CMK 140, which regulates monitoring with technical means, also provides the opportunity for recording only for activities in public places and workplaces. In the examined file, the recording was taken inside a vehicle, and the Chamber deemed this recording to be unlawful evidence.

The reflection of this distinction in practice emerges at the planning stage of undercover agent operations. If a recording is to be made during the operation, the scope of the permission granted by the judge pursuant to CMK 139/4 and the nature of the place where the recording will be taken must be determined in advance. Otherwise, the recordings obtained will remain in the file as evidence that cannot be used as a basis for conviction. This subject also has a connection with the article addressing drug detection periods as the legal validity of the detection method is a common factor that directly affects the result in both files.

Where and How Was the Case Tried?

The crime of drug trafficking falls within the jurisdiction of the high criminal court. The first-instance trial was conducted at the Istanbul Anadolu 24th High Criminal Court, and the defendant was convicted. The Istanbul Regional Court of Justice 16th Criminal Chamber dismissed the appeal on its merits. The file reached the Court of Cassation 10th Criminal Chamber upon the appeal application of the defendant's counsel. The Chamber conducted an examination on the file and unanimously issued a reversal decision.

The reversal decision required the file to be sent to the Istanbul Anadolu 24th High Criminal Court in accordance with CMK 304/2-a. This path is applied in cases where the Court of Cassation deems a retrial in the first-instance court necessary; the reversal also covers the decision of the regional court of justice. The defendant's request for release was evaluated separately and denied on the grounds that there was no change in the conditions of detention. This denial decision shows that although the reversal decision removes the conviction verdict, the release of the defendant is not automatic; the evaluation of release is an independent subject of examination.

The issue of duty and jurisdiction in files where an undercover investigator is used requires additional attention. According to CMK 139/1, the judge decides on the assignment of an undercover investigator; during the investigation phase, this decision is made by the criminal judgeship of peace. The scope of the assignment decision and, if any, the recording permit granted pursuant to CMK 139/4, determine which actions the investigator may perform. In a similar file, the first documents a defense counsel must check are the content of the assignment decision and recording permit, and the nature of the place where the recording was made.

Consequences and Scope of the Reversal Decision

The reversal decision of the Yargıtay has registered that an unlawful video recording cannot be used as a basis for conviction and that a verdict cannot be established based on incomplete investigation. However, it must be clearly stated that this decision does not directly mean an acquittal. The file will return to the court of first instance, and a retrial will be conducted. The following are what the court must do in the retrial:

  • It must remove the in-vehicle video recording found to be unlawful from the file and refrain from making any assessment based on this recording.
  • It is mandatory to hear the undercover investigators and the responsible law enforcement officers as witnesses and to have the defendant's identity identified by these individuals.
  • It must evaluate all the evidence in the file together, excluding the video recording found to be unlawful.
  • It is expected to treat the confirmation previously made by the defendant as a statement based on unlawful evidence and not to include this statement in the grounds for conviction.

The limit of the decision is also clear: The Chamber did not find the use of an undercover investigator entirely unlawful. The unlawfulness was identified in the investigator's use of technical equipment to record and the manner in which this recording was used in the trial. A witness statement based on the observations and declarations of an undercover investigator continues to be lawful evidence if the proper procedure is followed. Therefore, in the retrial after the reversal, if the investigators are heard as witnesses, the evidentiary status of the file may change, and the outcome may shift towards either conviction or acquittal.

Which Points Should Be Examined in a Similar Case File?

  • The scope of the undercover investigator assignment decision must be examined; it must be determined whether the judge granted a recording permit pursuant to CMK 139/4 and whether the recording was made in a public place or a workplace. If these conditions are not met, it is unlawful for the investigator to make a video or audio recording.
  • The type of findings obtained by the investigator must be separated; direct observation and testimony are subject to a different legal regime than recordings made with technical equipment, and the validity of each must be evaluated separately.
  • It should be checked whether the unlawful evidence was shown to the defendant; if it was, it should be discussed whether the defendant's statements in response to this evidence can be used as a basis for the verdict. According to the examined decision, confirmation does not save the evidence.
  • It must be investigated whether the undercover investigators were heard as witnesses in the hearing and whether the identity of the defendant was identified by these individuals; the absence of these steps is in itself a reason for reversal.
  • Effective remorse The applicability of the provisions should also be evaluated; the difference between the defendant voluntarily providing information in contact with the undercover investigator and the confirmation made in the face of unlawful evidence differentiates the criminal reduction mechanisms.
  • It must be determined whether the other evidence in the file is independent of the unlawful video recording; if independent evidence exists, a conviction may still be possible even if the video recording is excluded.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the footage captured by an undercover investigator be used as evidence?

According to the examined decision of the Yargıtay 10th Penal Chamber, the imaging performed by an undercover investigator inside a vehicle using technical devices is unlawful evidence and cannot be used as a basis for conviction. CMK 139/4 stipulates that the judge may only grant the investigator permission to record in public places and workplaces. Recordings taken outside these areas exceed the limits permitted by law.

Does the defendant watching and confirming the images change the legal nature of the evidence?

According to the examined decision, it does not. Showing the unlawful evidence to the defendant and the defendant confirming the event in the face of this evidence does not eliminate the unlawfulness of the recording; the confirmation statement is also information derived from unlawful evidence.

What powers does CMK 139 grant an undercover investigator?

CMK 139 allows the undercover investigator to act with a changed identity, conduct research, and collect evidence. In cases of drug trafficking, the judge may also authorize the investigator to record audio or video in public places and workplaces. Recordings taken outside these areas exceed the limits permitted by law.

Can an undercover investigator be heard as a witness in court?

Yes, they can and, according to the examined decision, should be heard. It is possible to obtain the statement of the undercover investigator in the capacity of a witness while protecting the confidentiality of their identity. The court's rendering of a verdict without hearing these individuals and having them identify the defendant was considered an incomplete investigation.

Is a conviction possible if unlawful video recording is excluded?

If there is other sufficient evidence independent of the unlawful recording in the file, a conviction is possible. In the examined file, the reversal decision necessitated a retrial, the hearing of the investigators, and the evaluation of the evidence as a whole; a direct acquittal was not granted.

Does a reversal decision ensure the release of the defendant?

It does not always ensure it. In the examined file, although the Yargıtay issued a reversal decision, it rejected the defendant's release request. Release is the subject of a separate assessment regarding whether detention conditions persist and is examined independently of the reversal decision.

Under what conditions is an undercover investigator assigned in a drug trafficking case?

In accordance with CMK 139, the assignment of an undercover investigator requires the presence of strong suspicion based on concrete evidence, the inability to obtain evidence through other means, and the crime being among the catalog crimes listed in the law. Drug trafficking is included in this catalog, and only a judge may authorize the assignment.

Conclusion: The Authority of the Undercover Investigator Is Not Unlimited, Technical Recording Requires a Separate Decision

The decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay dated February 2, 2026, has once again demonstrated that the powers of an undercover investigator remain within the boundaries drawn by CMK 139. The law allows the investigator to make recordings only in public places and workplaces where the judge has granted permission; images captured inside a vehicle fell outside this limit and were considered unlawful evidence. The defendant confirming the incident by watching these recordings does not change the legal nature of the evidence; as the confirmation statement is a direct product of the unlawful evidence being presented to the defendant.

The second dimension of the decision, the determination of incomplete investigation, is equally instructive. In cases where an undercover investigator is used, the court must hear the investigators as witnesses and have the defendant identified by these individuals; a trial that skips these steps will result in the reversal of the verdict. When both findings are evaluated together, it is seen that the mere presence of an undercover investigator is not sufficient for a conviction, and the findings obtained are subjected to separate audits both in terms of legality and trial procedure.

Legal Resources and Related Reviews

Legislation

Court of Cassation Decisions

The list contains the decision examined in this article; for all compared and cited decisions, the relevant articles of the same series can be consulted.

  • Court of Cassation 10th Criminal Chamber, E. 2025/6185, K. 2026/821, T. 02.02.2026

İlgili Yazılar

Author and Legal Information

Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registration No: 77008

This text is a legal decision review based on the decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay dated 02.02.2026, E. 2025/6185, K. 2026/821. The review is limited to the published decision text; it does not imply that the same result will be obtained in other files.

The contents on this page are for general information purposes and are open for use by all our colleagues. However, in accordance with the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, if all or a portion of this text is used, we kindly request that you provide a citation in the form of 'Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr' and include a link to the relevant article.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Author

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Founding attorney of Batın Yılmaz Law Office. Handles litigation and consultancy in foreigners and citizenship law, as well as criminal, corporate, administrative, real estate, enforcement, and compensation law.

About our office