Criminal Law
Recidivism, Chain Offenses, and Concurrence: Second Recidivism, Resolution of Concurrence
In this article 15 headings
- Short Answer: What Do Recidivism, Chain Crime, and Concurrence Mean?
- First-Time Recidivism (TCK 58)
- Execution Regime Specific to Recidivists (Law No. 5275 Art. 108)
- Second-Time Recidivism
- Chain Crime (TCK 43)
- Concurrence of Crimes
- Aggregation of Sentences (Concurrence in Execution)
- Dissolution of Aggregation
- The Relationship Between Recidivism, Suspended Sentences, HAGB, and Alternative Sanctions
- Foreign Nationals and Foreign Court Decisions
- Which Points Should Be Examined in a File Regarding Recidivism and Concurrence?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
- Legal Resources and Related Reviews
- Author and Legal Information
Publication: · Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.
Short Answer: What Do Recidivism, Chain Crime, and Concurrence Mean?
Recidivism is when a person commits a new crime after a conviction for a previous crime has become final, and it results in the subsequent sentence being served under a more severe execution regime. According to Article 58 of the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237, recidivism is not a reason for sentence increase; as a rule, the sentence of a recidivist is executed at a rate of two-thirds pursuant to Article 108 of the Law on the Execution of Sentences and Security Measures No. 5275, and a probation period of at least one year is applied after execution. If a person punished as a recidivist commits another crime, second-time recidivism occurs; following Law No. 7550 dated June 4, 2025, these individuals may also be conditionally released, but the rate for fixed-term imprisonment is applied as three-fourths.
According to TCK 43, a chain crime is when the same crime is committed against the same person multiple times at different times within the scope of a single decision to commit a crime; in this case, a single sentence is imposed, and it is increased from one-fourth to three-fourths. Concurrence of crimes is the set of rules that determine how many sentences will be imposed when a person commits multiple crimes: with the exception of compound crimes (TCK 42), chain crimes (TCK 43), and ideal concurrence (TCK 44), the principle is that a separate sentence is imposed for each crime. Sentences in multiple finalized judgments are aggregated during the execution stage pursuant to Article 99 of Law No. 5275; in practice, the re-regulation of this aggregation decision due to subsequently changed circumstances is called the dissolution of aggregation.
This guide explains each concept under separate headings with the text of the law, decisions rendered by the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers and Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation between 2021-2026, and sample calculations.

First-Time Recidivism (TCK 58)
Concept and Legal Nature
According to TCK 58/1, if a new crime is committed after the conviction for a previously committed crime has become final, recidivism provisions apply; it is not required for the previous sentence to have been executed. The former Turkish Criminal Code No. 765 resulted in an increase of the sentence due to recidivism, whereas Law No. 5237 has abandoned this system and transformed recidivism into a system of execution. According to TCK 58/6, the sentence pronounced in case of recidivism is served according to the execution regime specific to repeat offenders, and a probation measure is applied to the repeat offender after the execution of the sentence.
The fact that recidivism pertains to the execution regime also has implications in terms of time of application. According to TCK 7/3, provisions regarding the execution regime are applied immediately, except for those related to the suspension of imprisonment, conditional release, and recidivism. In other words, a change in law regarding recidivism is not applied automatically if it comes into force after the date of the crime; it is evaluated according to the principle of the more favorable law in TCK 7/2.
Conditions of Recidivism
- Finalization of the previous conviction: The new crime must have been committed after the previous judgment became final. Recidivism does not apply to crimes committed while the previous case is ongoing or before the judgment has become final.
- The previous judgment must be a conviction: A decision for the deferral of the announcement of the verdict (HAGB) does not constitute a conviction and therefore cannot be a basis for recidivism. The subsequent removal of a judgment leads to the same result. The Court of Cassation 7th Criminal Chamber's decision dated June 2, 2025, E. 2021/28919, K. 2025/8482,found it unlawful to apply recidivism without considering that the theft conviction, which was taken as the basis for recidivism, was removed as a result of an adaptation proceeding based on mediation, resulting in the dismissal of the public case; thus, the clause regarding recidivism was removed from the verdict.
- Expiration of the recidivism period: According to TCK 58/2, in case of a conviction to imprisonment of more than five years for the previous crime, recidivism does not apply to crimes committed after five years from the date of execution of such sentence; for convictions to imprisonment of five years or less or judicial fines, it does not apply after three years have passed. The period is calculated from the date of the execution of the sentence, not from the date the judgment became final.
- Compatibility of the nature of the crimes: According to TCK 58/4, recidivism does not apply between intentional crimes and negligent crimes, nor between purely military crimes and other crimes.
- Age of the perpetrator: According to TCK 58/5, crimes committed by individuals who have not reached the age of eighteen at the time of the act cannot be a basis for recidivism.
Suspended Sentences and Sentences Converted into Judicial Fines
A suspended prison sentence is also a conviction and may serve as a basis for recidivism. When the probation period is spent with good behavior, the sentence is deemed executed in accordance with TCK 51/8; the recidivism period begins to run from this date. The Court of Cassation 10th Criminal Chamber's decision dated September 17, 2026, E. 2022/8112, K. 2026/11714,determined that the five-month prison sentence, which was taken as the basis for recidivism for the first time, was suspended and deemed executed with the completion of the one-year probation period on May 22, 2014. Short-term prison sentences converted into judicial fines and judicial fines imposed directly may also be a basis for recidivism within the scope of TCK 58/2-b; in this case, the period is three years.
Which Judgment is Taken as the Basis for Recidivism?
If there is more than one conviction in the defendant's criminal record that could serve as a basis for recidivism, as a rule, the judgment containing the heaviest sentence is taken as the basis. This preference has a direct result in terms of execution due to the limitation in Article 108/2 of Law No. 5275. The Court of Cassation 2nd Criminal Chamber's decision dated May 7, 2026, E. 2024/4280, K. 2026/8660, it has been stated that among the convictions in the defendant's criminal record that may be taken as a basis for recidivism, the most severe is the four-year and two-month imprisonment sentence given for the crime of theft, and that this judgment should be taken as the basis for recidivism.
The judgment used as the basis for recidivism must be clearly indicated in the verdict, including the court, date, case and judgment number, the crime, the penalty, and the finalization date. In accordance with Article 58/7 of the TCK, the conviction judgment must state that the execution regime specific to recidivists and the probation measure after the execution of the sentence will be applied to the convict. In the aforementioned decision, the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation corrected the provision of the judgment, individually listing the court, date, number, crime, penalty, finalization, and execution dates of the judgment serving as the basis for recidivism, and ruled for the application of the execution regime specific to recidivists pursuant to Article 58/6 of the TCK and probation after the execution of the sentence pursuant to the seventh paragraph of the same article.
Prohibition of Reformatio in Peius
Recidivism is a result disadvantageous to the defendant. If the court of first instance has not applied the provisions of recidivism and the judgment has been appealed only by the defendant, the Court of Cassation cannot use this omission as a ground for reversal. In the decision of the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated June 2, 2026, in its decision numbered E. 2024/4111, K. 2026/5873it was explicitly stated that the failure to apply recidivism provisions for a defendant with a criminal record serving as a basis for recidivism was not made a ground for reversal since there was no appeal against the defendant. This rule is a consequence of the principle that no disadvantageous outcome can be generated in files where an appeal has been filed in favor of the defendant, i.e., the prohibition of reformatio in peius expressed in Article 307/5 of the CMK.
Alternative Penalties and Specially Dangerous Offenders
According to Article 58/3 of the TCK, in the case of recidivism, if the law article for the subsequent crime prescribes imprisonment and a judicial fine as alternative penalties, imprisonment shall be imposed. This is the only case where recidivism affects the type of penalty rather than the amount. Article 58/9 of the TCK provides that the execution regime specific to recidivists and probation after execution shall also be applied to habitual offenders, professional criminals, or members of an organization; these individuals are executed as recidivists even if they have no prior conviction.

Execution Regime Specific to Recidivists (Law No. 5275 Art. 108)
According to Article 108/1 of Law No. 5275, in the case of recidivism, conditional release can be granted if thirty-nine years of an aggravated life sentence, thirty-three years of a life sentence, a maximum of thirty-two years in case of conviction for multiple definite sentences, and two-thirds of a definite sentence are served in good standing in the penal institution. In crimes where the conditional release rate is already higher than two-thirds, for example, in drug trafficking, the rate of that crime is applied.
Article 108/2 introduces an important limitation: the amount to be added to the conditional release period due to recidivism cannot exceed the heaviest of the sentences used as the basis for recidivism. This rule prevents the execution period of a subsequent heavy sentence from being disproportionately extended due to a minor prior conviction.
For a recidivist, the execution judge determines a probation period, which shall not be less than one year, to begin after the completion of the execution of the sentence; this period may be extended up to a maximum of five years. A recidivist who acts in violation of obligations and prohibitions during the probation period is subject to disciplinary imprisonment of not less than fifteen days and not more than three months by the decision of the execution judge.
Second-Time Recidivism
Concept
Second-time recidivism is when a person who has previously been convicted as a recidivist through the application of recidivism provisions commits a new crime after that conviction has become final and within the recidivism periods. The concept is not separately defined in Article 58 of the TCK, and its consequences are regulated in Articles 108/2 and 108/3 of Law No. 5275. For second-time recidivism to be applied, both the judgment used as the basis for the first-time recidivism and the judgment used as the basis for the second-time recidivism must independently satisfy all the conditions in Article 58 of the TCK.
Amendment made by Law No. 7550
According to the previous text of Article 108/3 of Law No. 5275, in cases where the provisions of second-time recidivism were applied, the convict could not be granted conditional release; that is, they had to serve their entire sentence in a penal institution. With Article 14 of Law No. 7550 dated June 4, 2025, this phrase was changed to “the conditional release periods in the first paragraph shall be applied,” and a sentence was added to the paragraph stating that for definite prison sentences, the conditional release rate shall be applied as three-quarters. According to the sentence added to 108/2 by the same Law, in the case of second-time recidivism, the rule regarding limiting the additional period to the sentence forming the basis of the recidivism does not apply. According to the last sentence of 108/3, it is stated in the judgment that the provisions of second-time recidivism shall be applied to the convict.
This amendment is clearly favorable for second-time recidivists who were previously required to serve their entire sentence. Since the more favorable law applies retroactively in accordance with Article 7/2 of the TCK, an application may be made within the scope of Article 98 of Law No. 5275 for the new rate to be applied even to sentences finalized before the amendment.
Conditions for Second-Time Recidivism in Court of Cassation Practice
The Court of Cassation strictly oversees the conditions for second-time recidivism. In the decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 17.09.2026, E. 2022/8112, K. 2026/11714,it was determined that the offense forming the basis for the second-time recidivism was committed after the three-year period stipulated in TCK 58/2-b had passed from the execution of the sentence forming the basis for the first-time recidivism; accordingly, the judgment was corrected on the grounds that the conditions for second-time recidivism were not met, and it was decided that only the execution regime specific to first-time recidivists be applied to the defendant.
In the decision of the 2nd Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 07.05.2026, E. 2024/4280, K. 2026/8660 on the other hand, in a theft case where the court of first instance applied second-time recidivism, it was determined that the offense that had been taken as the basis for first-time recidivism in the verdict taken as the basis for the current recidivism had been committed by the defendant before reaching the age of eighteen. The Chamber stated that this conviction could not form the basis for recidivism pursuant to TCK 58/5, therefore second-time recidivism did not apply to the defendant, and reversed the judgment. This decision shows that every link in the chain must be examined separately in the evaluation of second-time recidivism.
Sample Calculation
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Status | Applied rule | Time to be spent in the institution for a 6-year prison sentence |
|---|---|---|
| Not a recidivist | 5275 Art. 107/2: half | 3 years |
| First-time recidivism, base sentence 2 years | 5275 Art. 108/1-d: two-thirds; 1 year to be added, below the 2-year limit | 4 years |
| First-time recidivism, base sentence 5 months | 5275 Art. 108/2: added period limited to 5 months | 3 years 5 months |
| Second-time recidivism (after 7550) | 5275 Art. 108/3: three-quarters; 108/2 limit does not apply | 4 years 6 months |
| Second-time recidivism (text before 7550) | No conditional release | 6 years |
As seen in the table, the amount of the previous sentence forming the basis of the recidivism directly affects the execution period in first-time recidivism. For this reason, the correct selection of the verdict serving as the basis for recidivism is as important for the defense as the amount of the sentence itself. Conditional release and open prison processes in penal institutions explained in the article on the open prison execution process. is also explained.
Chain Crime (TCK 43)
Concept and Purpose
According to TCK 43/1, in the event that the same offense is committed more than once against a person at different times within the scope of the execution of a decision to commit a crime, a single penalty is imposed; however, this penalty is increased by one-fourth to three-fourths. The basic form of an offense and its qualified forms requiring a heavier or lighter penalty are considered the same offense. This provision also applies to crimes where the victim is not a specific person. Consecutive offense is an exception to the rule of real concurrence: while normally a separate penalty should be imposed for each act, the legislator has accepted repeated actions under the same decision as a single crime and has sufficed with a penalty increase.
Conditions
- Multiple acts: There must be separate acts committed at different times, each of which contains all the elements of the crime.
- Same crime: The acts must violate the same type of crime. The basic form and the aggravated form of theft are the same crime; however, theft and fraud are not the same crime.
- Same victim: The acts must be committed against the same person. This requirement is not sought in crimes where the victim is not specific.
- Single intent to commit a crime: The actions must be in the nature of the execution of a single, pre-existing decision. This decision is inferred from objective facts such as the time interval between the actions, the similarity in the manner of commission, and the relationship between the victim and the perpetrator.
- Absence of legal interruption: If there is a legal interruption between the actions, such as the preparation of an indictment or the rendering of a verdict, the action following the interruption is considered the product of a new decision to commit a crime.
Legal Interruption
In the practice of the Court of Cassation, a legal interruption generally occurs with the preparation of an indictment concerning previous actions. In the decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 17.09.2026, E. 2022/8112, K. 2026/11714,it was determined that the action subject to appeal was committed on 04.07.2018, after an indictment dated 12.06.2018 in another file, and it was decided that the provisions for chain crimes could not be applied to actions that have a legal interruption between them.
If there is no legal interruption, actions that have been heard in separate files and even those that have become final may be part of a chain crime. In the decision of the 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 10.09.2026, file no. 2023/4416, decision no. 2026/8719,it was determined that no legal interruption had occurred between the embezzlement for usage actions, which consisted of the defendant, an enforcement manager, depositing the collected money late, and the qualified embezzlement actions that had become final in other files, based on the dates of the crimes and the indictments. The Chamber overturned the verdict, stating that embezzlement under TCK 247 is regulated as a single crime under one heading, therefore the provisions for chain crimes must be applied, and that previously finalized sentences must be deducted from this sentence, with a penalty being imposed for the difference. This decision demonstrates that chain crimes can also be applied across different files and prevents the defendant from receiving multiple full sentences for actions under the same decision.
Crimes with No Specific Victim and Crimes Where the Public is the Victim
The last sentence of TCK 43/1 stipulates that the provisions for chain crimes shall also apply to crimes where the victim is not a specific person. Crimes committed against the public, such as drug trafficking, smuggling, and forgery of documents, fall within this scope. In the decision of the 11th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 10.02.2025, in its decision numbered E. 2022/11238, K. 2025/1639referencing the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers decision dated 22.04.2014, file no. 2013/11-397, decision no. 2014/202, it was stated that in forgery crimes, the victim is the public, a person who suffers damage due to a forged document is considered someone harmed by the crime rather than the victim, and that in the event the forged document is used against different people at different times, the provisions for chain crimes must be evaluated. The application in forgery crimes in the guide on forgery of official documents .
Another limit to chain crimes is purchases directed by law enforcement. In the decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 23.09.2026, file no. 2023/18497, decision no. 2026/12118,it was stated, based on the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers decision dated 28.04.2015, file no. 2014/462, decision no. 2015/135, that an undercover investigator purchasing drugs from the defendant more than once does not constitute a separate crime and that, as there is no genuine sale, the provisions for chain crimes cannot be applied.
Crimes Committed Against Multiple Persons with a Single Act (TCK 43/2)
According to TCK 43/2, the provisions of the first paragraph also apply in cases where the same crime is committed against more than one person with a single act. In this instance, referred to in legal doctrine as identical concurrence (ayni nevden fikri içtima), for example, if multiple people are insulted with a single statement or if the personal data of multiple people are disseminated with a single post, a single penalty is imposed and then increased. For this provision to apply, the act must be singular in a legal sense. The Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers decision dated 06.03.2024 in its decision numbered E. 2019/258, K. 2024/109Since there is no evidence that personal data belonging to two different individuals were seized simultaneously with a single act, it has been accepted that Article 43/2 of the TCK cannot be applied and that a separate offense is constituted for each victim. In the same decision, it was stated that the dissemination of different types of data belonging to the same person at different times constitutes a single chain offense pursuant to Article 43/1 of the TCK.
Offenses to Which Chain Offense Provisions Do Not Apply
According to TCK 43/3, provisions for chain crimes do not apply to the crimes of intentional homicide, intentional injury, torture, and robbery. In these crimes, a separate penalty is imposed for each act. The legislator has accepted that each attack on a person's physical integrity and life constitutes a separate injustice. The practical consequences of this rule in the crime of robbery in the robbery crime guide has been explained.
Consequences of Chain Crimes in Terms of Procedure and Statute of Limitations
According to TCK 66/6, the statute of limitations for chain crimes begins to run from the day the last crime was committed. According to CMK 12/2, the court at the place where the last crime was committed has jurisdiction in chain crimes. The date of the last act is also taken as the basis for assessing the law favorable to the offender and determining the date of the crime. If a chain crime is committed along with its aggravated forms, the penalty is determined according to the most severe form, and the increase is applied over this penalty. The increase rate is adjudicated between one-fourth and three-fourths; the court must provide a justification by taking into account the number and duration of the acts.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Example | Calculation | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| Simple theft from the same workplace on three separate days | TCK 141/1: 1 year; 1 year and 6 months with a half increase under TCK 43/1; one-sixth reduction under TCK 62 | 1 year 3 months imprisonment |
| Two simple thefts and one aggravated theft against the same victim | Penalty according to TCK 142 for the most severe form; TCK 43/1 increase | A single chain aggravated theft penalty |
| Intentional injury against the same victim on two separate dates | TCK 43/3: chain crime does not apply | Two separate injury penalties |
| New theft against the same victim after the indictment | There is a legal interruption | Separate crime and separate penalty |
Evaluation of chain crime and aggravated forms in the crime of theft together in the theft crime guide explained in the article on the open prison execution process.
Concurrence of Crimes
General Rule: Real Concurrence
The fundamental rule of criminal law is that as many penalties are imposed as there are crimes. This rule, known as real concurrence in legal theory, does not have a separate article in the law; it is inferred from these regulations that a separate penalty is given for each crime, except for the exceptions in TCK 42, 43, and 44. For example, if a person first injures someone and then commits theft elsewhere, they receive two separate penalties for two separate crimes. In real concurrence, each penalty maintains its independence; how the penalties will be combined at the enforcement stage is regulated in Article 99 of Law No. 5275.
Compound Crime (TCK 42)
According to TCK 42, a crime that is considered a single act because one of them constitutes an element or an aggravating factor of the other is called a compound crime, and concurrence provisions do not apply to such crimes. The crime of robbery is a compound crime consisting of theft and threat or force; the perpetrator is not punished separately for theft and threat. In aggravated robbery, threat with a weapon does not additionally constitute the crime of threat with a weapon. However, in some cases, the law explicitly provides for the separate punishment of a crime within a compound crime: According to TCK 149/2, if the aggravated consequences of the crime of intentional injury occur during the commission of the crime of robbery, a penalty is also imposed according to the provisions of intentional injury.
Ideal Concurrence (TCK 44)
According to TCK 44, a person who causes more than one different crime with a single act is punished for the crime that requires the most severe penalty among them. This rule, referred to as ideal concurrence of different types in theory, has three conditions: the act must be legally singular, more than one different crime must be formed with this single act, and there must be no explicit provision in the law preventing the application of ideal concurrence.
Dated 08.12.2022 of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers in its decision numbered E. 2018/611, K. 2022/784In the case where the defendant shared the complainant's name and phone number on a social media account along with an insulting statement, the local court had imposed sentences for two separate crimes. The Plenary Assembly unanimously decided that a single post constitutes a single act in the legal sense, that the requirement of a single intent to commit a crime is not sought for the application of TCK Article 44, and that a single sentence should be imposed under TCK Article 136, which requires the most severe penalty, for the crimes of unlawfully disseminating personal data and public insult. Other concurrence issues in personal data crimes in the guide on personal data crimes has been addressed.
Legal Exceptions to Intellectual Concurrence
The law expressly excludes intellectual concurrence for certain crimes. The most well-known example is TCK 212: if a forged official or private document is used during the commission of another crime, a separate penalty is imposed for both the forgery and the relevant crime. The Court of Cassation 11th Criminal Chamber's decision dated 09.09.2026 in its decision No. E. 2022/712, K. 2026/7699, the acquittal decision given for the defendant who was appointed as a teacher and received a salary by submitting a fake diploma was reversed, and it was accepted that the act constituted aggravated fraud to the detriment of public institutions and organizations; forgery and fraud are punished separately in such cases pursuant to TCK 212. Similarly, TCK 106/3, which stipulates a separate penalty for the crimes of intentional killing, intentional injury, or property damage committed for the purpose of threat in addition to TCK 149/2, is among the provisions that exclude intellectual concurrence. The relationship between fraud and forgery in the guide on the crime of fraud has been explained.
Apparent Concurrence: Competition of Norms
Sometimes an act appears to fit multiple crime definitions, but in reality, only one of these definitions is applied. In this situation, referred to in legal doctrine as apparent concurrence or concurrence of norms, the special norm takes precedence over the general norm, the principal norm over the accessory norm, and the severe norm over the lighter norm. Unlike intellectual concurrence, in apparent concurrence, there are not actually multiple crimes; there is a single crime, and it is determined which norm to apply.
of the Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers dated 10.06.2026 Decision No. E. 2025/124, K. 2026/365 is a current example of this distinction. In the case where a judge subsequently changed the witness statements in the trial transcript, it was stated that the crime of abuse of office in TCK 257 is an accessory norm regarding crimes specific to public officials, that the accessory norm loses its applicability in cases where the act constitutes another crime such as TCK 204/2, and it was decided that the act should be punished as the crime of a public official's aggravated forgery of an official document. The Assembly further emphasized that in cases where multiple crimes are committed with a single act in the legal sense by a public official, the issue should be resolved in accordance with the principles of the concurrence of crimes (TCK 42, 43, 44, 212) or the concurrence of norms.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Institution | Number of acts | Number of crimes | Conclusion | Legal Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Real concurrence | More than one | More than one | Separate penalty for each crime | General rule |
| Chain crime | More than one | Same crime, single decision | Single penalty, increase by 1/4 to 3/4 | TCK 43/1 |
| Intellectual concurrence of the same type | Single | Same crime, multiple victims | Single penalty, increase by 1/4 to 3/4 | TCK 43/2 |
| Intellectual concurrence of different types | Single | Different crimes | Penalty for the most severe crime | TCK 44 |
| Compound crime | Legally single | One crime is an element of another | Penalty for only the compound crime | TCK 42 |
| Apparent concurrence | Single | Single crime, multiple norms | Special or principal norm applied | Doctrine and jurisprudence |
| Legal exception | Single or multiple | More than one | Separate penalties | TCK 149/2, 212, etc. |
Aggregation of Sentences (Concurrence in Execution)
A person may have multiple final convictions from different case files. According to Article 99/1 of Law No. 5275, each penalty imposed on a person is independent of the others, and they maintain their existence separately. However, if there are different final judgments against a person, a consolidation decision is requested from the enforcement judgeship for the purpose of applying Article 107, which is conditional release. Imprisonment sentences converted from judicial fines that reach the stage of being executed in a penal institution are also included in the consolidation decision. In practice, this decision is called a concurrence decision, and the prepared calculation sheet is called an execution schedule (müddetname).
According to Article 101/2 of Law No. 5275, the authority authorized to issue the consolidation decision is the enforcement judgeship where the court that imposed the highest penalty is located; in this case, if more than one enforcement judgeship has jurisdiction, the enforcement judgeship where the court that rendered the final judgment is located has jurisdiction. Decisions are made without a hearing.
The most important feature of the aggregation decision is that it does not eliminate the independence of the sentences. Each sentence is calculated according to its own conditional release rate, and the results are aggregated. However, Article 107/3 of Law No. 5275 stipulates that in the case of conviction for multiple definite prison sentences, the time required to be spent in the penal institution for conditional release shall not exceed twenty-eight years, and for repeat offenders, it shall not exceed thirty-two years in accordance with Article 108/1-c.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Finalized judgment | Criminal | Conditional release rate | Time to be served in the institution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Theft (TCK 142) | 2 years | Half (Law No. 5275 Art. 107/2) | 1 year |
| Disseminating personal data (TCK 136) | 3 years | Two-thirds (Law No. 5275 Art. 107/2-f) | 2 years |
| Fraud, recidivism for the first time | 1 year | Two-thirds (Law No. 5275 Art. 108/1-d) | 8 months |
| Total | 6 years | Each sentence at its own rate | 3 years 8 months |
The Court of Cassation accepts that all sentences whose execution has not been completed must be included in the consolidation decision and that the convict cannot exclude a sentence from the consolidation based on their own preference. In the Court of Cassation 1st Criminal Chamber's decision dated 27.05.2021 in the decision for reversal in the interest of the law numbered E. 2020/2374, K. 2021/9268, the decision to accept the convict's request to exclude the four-month and fifteen-day prison sentence for sexual harassment from the consolidation, on the grounds that they could not be transferred to regular wards due to its consolidation with other sentences, was reversed. The Chamber stated that all sentences for which the actual release dates have not yet arrived and whose execution has not been completed must be consolidated and a new duration certificate (müddetname) must be issued.
Dissolution of Aggregation
Concept
Dissolution of consolidation is not a concept separately defined in the law; in practice, it is used to mean the revocation of a previously issued consolidation decision due to a subsequent development affecting one of the consolidated sentences, the separation of the consolidated sentences, and the issuance of a new consolidation decision according to the new situation. The provision in Article 99 of Law No. 5275 that every sentence maintains its independence is the legal basis for this procedure: Since sentences never merge into one another, a change occurring in one only affects that sentence, and the consolidation is recalculated.
Situations Requiring Dissolution of Consolidation
- Favorable change in law: If the definition of a crime or the amount of the penalty regarding one of the consolidated sentences subsequently changes in favor of the perpetrator, an adaptation decision is requested from the court that issued the verdict in accordance with TCK 7/2 and Article 98/1-a of Law No. 5275, and the consolidation is recalculated based on the adapted sentence.
- Abolition of the verdict: If one of the consolidated sentences is abolished due to reversal in the interest of the law, retrial, dismissal of the case or acquittal as a result of adaptation proceedings, or a retrial conducted upon a decision by the Constitutional Court or the European Court of Human Rights, that sentence is removed from the total.
- Change in the conditional release rate: Regulations that change the rates, such as the granting of conditional release to recidivists for the second time by Law No. 7550, require a recalculation of the consolidation decision.
- Finalization of a new verdict: If a new conviction against the convict becomes final, the previous consolidation decision is revised to include the new sentence as well.
- Presence of a sentence that should not be included in the consolidation decision: In the event that a sentence for which the execution has been completed, has become statute-barred, or is covered by amnesty is included in the consolidation decision, this sentence is removed and a new decision is issued.
- Set-off due to chain crime: In the event that actions finalized in separate files are subsequently accepted as a single crime within the scope of a chain crime, as stated in the 2026 decision of the Court of Cassation 5th Criminal Chamber, previous sentences are set off against the new verdict; in this case, the consolidation decision must also be revised according to the new verdict.
Procedure and Legal Remedies
If there is hesitation in the interpretation of the conviction verdict or if a subsequently enacted legal provision needs to be evaluated within the scope of TCK 7, a decision is requested from the court that issued the verdict; if there is hesitation in the calculation of the sentence to be served or if it is alleged whether the sentence can be executed partially or entirely, a decision is requested from the execution judge. This distinction is explicitly made in Article 98/1 of Law No. 5275. The request for dissolution of consolidation is made to the court that issued the consolidation decision or to the competent execution judge according to Article 101/2. Court of Cassation 5th Criminal Chamber's decision dated 06.02.2024 in its decision No. E. 2023/12366, K. 2024/1023, upon the request for the resolution of concurrence of crimes, the negative conflict of jurisdiction that arose between two execution judgeships has been resolved, and the decision of the execution judgeship that had rendered a decision of lack of jurisdiction has been overturned and the file has been returned to that judgeship.
According to Article 98/2 of Law No. 5275, these applications do not stay the execution of the sentence; however, the court or the execution judge may decide to stay or suspend the execution depending on the specifics of the case. A challenge may be filed against the decision of the execution judge in accordance with the provisions of the CMK; the challenge period in CMK 268/1 was extended from seven days to two weeks in 2024 by Law No. 7499. Against an erroneous decision on the aggregation of sentences that has become final, the remedy of reversal for the benefit of the law may be exercised. In practice, decisions regarding the aggregation of sentences and the dissolution of such aggregation are served to the convicted person; as the judgements aggregated are shown separately in each of these decisions, the convicted person must track which sentences are being executed and at what ratio through these decisions.
The Relationship Between Recidivism, Suspended Sentences, HAGB, and Alternative Sanctions
A previous conviction affects other favorable institutions in addition to recidivism. According to TCK 51/1-a, in order for a prison sentence to be suspended, the person must not have been previously sentenced to more than three months of imprisonment for an intentional crime. According to CMK 231/6-a, for the deferral of the announcement of the verdict (HAGB), it is required that the defendant has not been previously convicted of an intentional crime; the details of this provision, which was reorganized by Law No. 7589 dated July 16, 2026, in the 12th Judicial Package HAGB regulation article have been explained. For this reason, a defendant with a criminal record constituting a basis for recidivism is often unable to benefit from the opportunities of suspended sentences and HAGB.
Conversely, recidivism does not absolutely prevent a short-term prison sentence from being converted into alternative sanctions pursuant to TCK 50, provided that the conditions are met; however, the court takes the defendant's past into account when exercising its discretion under TCK 50/1. Pursuant to TCK 58/3, it is mandatory to impose a prison sentence on a recidivist in crimes that provide for alternative sentences.
Foreign Nationals and Foreign Court Decisions
According to the second sentence of TCK 58/4, rulings given by foreign courts do not, as a rule, constitute a basis for recidivism. However, rulings given by foreign courts for the crimes of intentional homicide, intentional injury, robbery, fraud, manufacture and trade of narcotics or stimulants, and counterfeiting of money or valuable stamps may be taken as a basis for recidivism. In this case, it is necessary to bring into the file through official documents that the foreign ruling has become final, when the sentence was executed, and that the act constitutes the same crime under Turkish law. Foreign criminal records are often obtained through diplomatic correspondence or international legal assistance and require translation.
A foreigner convicted as a recidivist in Türkiye is subject to the same execution regime as Turkish citizens. Pursuant to TCK 59, a foreigner sentenced to imprisonment is notified to the Ministry of Interior for assessment regarding deportation procedures after a decision is made for their conditional release or execution through probation, and in any case, after the execution of their sentence is completed. Multiple convictions and recidivism aggravate the public order assessment within the scope of Article 54/1-d of Law No. 6458. The effects of the conviction on residency permit and citizenship applications explained in the article on what happens if a foreigner is arrested., and the application channels against a deportation decision are in the article on deportation decisions explained in the article on the open prison execution process.
Which Points Should Be Examined in a File Regarding Recidivism and Concurrence?
- Is the finalization date of the judgment taken as the basis for recidivism before the date of the new crime?
- Has the execution date of the previous sentence, or the end date of the supervision period if it was suspended, been correctly calculated, and has the three or five-year period in TCK 58/2 been calculated accurately accordingly?
- Was the previous crime committed before the age of eighteen; is there consistency between intentional and negligent crimes?
- Has the previous ruling been eliminated subsequently through an adaptation, amnesty, reversal for the benefit of the law, or retrial?
- Has the most severe judgment in the criminal record that could serve as a basis for recidivism been selected; is the judgment shown with all its details in the verdict?
- If recidivism has been applied for the second time, does the judgment that formed the basis for the first recidivism also meet all the requirements of TCK 58, and is this clearly stated in the verdict?
- Have the requirements for a chain offense, specifically the decision to commit a single offense, the same victim, and the absence of a legal interruption, been discussed in the reasoning?
- In cases where actions are tried in separate files but there is no legal interruption between them, have the possibilities for a chain offense and credit for time served (mahsup) been evaluated?
- If multiple crimes have occurred through a single act, has TCK 44 been applied correctly, and if there is a legal exception, have TCK 212 or 149/2 been applied correctly?
- Has each sentence in the aggregation decision been calculated with its own conditional release rate; is there any development requiring the resolution of the aggregation (içtima)?
Frequently Asked Questions
Does recidivism increase the sentence?
No. In the Turkish Penal Code No. 5237, recidivism is not a reason for sentence enhancement. The amount of the sentence imposed by the court does not change; however, the sentence is served under the special execution regime for recidivists, meaning it is generally executed at a rate of two-thirds, and at least one year of probation is applied after execution. The only exception is the mandatory imposition of imprisonment for crimes with optional sentences.
How is the recidivism period calculated?
The period is calculated not from the date the previous judgment became final, but from the date the sentence was executed. Recidivism is not applied for crimes committed after five years have passed for prison sentences of more than five years, and after three years for prison sentences of five years or less or judicial fines. For a suspended sentence, the end of the probation period is considered the execution date.
Can a HAGB decision be the basis for recidivism?
No. Since a decision of deferral of the announcement of the verdict (HAGB) is a judgment that does not produce legal consequences for the defendant, it is not considered a conviction and cannot be used as a basis for recidivism. If the verdict is announced and becomes final due to a new crime being committed during the probation period, this announced conviction may be used as a basis for recidivism for crimes committed thereafter.
What is second-time recidivism and what is its consequence?
It is the commission of a new crime that meets the conditions by a person who has already been sentenced as a recidivist. Before Law No. 7550, second-time recidivists could not be conditionally released. Since June 4, 2025, these individuals can also be conditionally released, but the rate for fixed-term imprisonment is applied as three-quarters, and the limitation rule based on the sentence for recidivism is not applied.
Can a conviction handed down in a foreign country be the basis for recidivism?
As a rule, no. However, pursuant to TCK 58/4, judgments rendered by foreign courts for crimes of intentional killing, intentional injury, robbery, fraud, production and trade of drugs, and counterfeiting of money or valuable stamps may be used as a basis for recidivism. The date on which the judgment became final and the date of execution must be proven with official documents.
By how much is the sentence increased in consecutive crimes?
Pursuant to TCK 43/1, a single sentence is imposed, and this sentence is increased by one-fourth to three-fourths. The court determines the rate of increase by taking into account the number, duration, and method of commission of the acts and must state its justification. If there are aggravated forms, the sentence is determined according to the most severe form and then increased.
In which crimes are consecutive crime provisions not applied?
Pursuant to TCK 43/3, consecutive crime provisions are not applied to crimes of intentional killing, intentional injury, torture, and robbery; a separate sentence is imposed for each act. Furthermore, if there is a legal interruption such as an indictment between the acts, or if the acts were committed against different victims through separate acts, a consecutive crime does not occur.
What is a legal interruption?
Legal interruption occurs when there is a judicial action, such as the preparation of an indictment regarding previous acts, between repeated actions of the same crime. According to the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), an act committed after this action is considered the product of a new decision to commit a crime and does not constitute a chain crime with previous acts; separate penalties are imposed for separate crimes.
What is the difference between intellectual concurrence and chain crime?
In a chain crime, there are multiple acts committed at different times and the sentence is increased. In ideal concurrence (fikri içtima), multiple different crimes are formed by a single act, and the sentence of the most severe crime is imposed without any increase. If the same crime is committed against multiple people through a single act, the sentence is increased as in a chain crime pursuant to TCK 43/2.
What does the aggregation of sentences (cezaların toplanması) mean?
If a person has multiple finalized convictions from different case files, the execution judge issues an aggregation decision pursuant to Article 99 of Law No. 5275. The sentences retain their independence, and each is calculated according to its own conditional release rate; the results are aggregated to prepare a sentence schedule (müddetname).
When is the dissolution of aggregation (içtimanın çözülmesi) requested?
It is requested when one of the aggregated sentences changes due to a more favorable law, is abolished through extraordinary appeal (kanun yararına bozma) or retrial, when conditional release rates change, or when a sentence that should not have been included in the aggregation decision is received. The request is made to the authorized execution judgeship, and the decision is reissued.
Can a convict remove a sentence from aggregation?
They cannot remove it by their own choice. The 1st Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation has overturned a decision for the sake of law (kanun yararına bozma) that accepted a convict's request to remove a sexual harassment sentence from aggregation for the purpose of changing wards, stating that all sentences for which execution has not been completed must be aggregated. Removal can only be based on a legal ground.
Conclusion
Recidivism, consecutive offenses, and the aggregation of offenses are legal institutions that determine the type, amount, and execution period of the sentence to be imposed in cases where the same person is involved in multiple offenses. Recidivism does not increase the penalty but aggravates the execution regime; for the first instance of recidivism, the conditional release rate increases to two-thirds, and after Law No. 7550, it increases to three-quarters for definite prison sentences in the second instance of recidivism. Consecutive offenses allow for a single penalty to be imposed for acts repeated under a single intent to commit a crime; however, legal interruption, different victims, and the crimes specified in TCK 43/3 constitute the limits of this rule.
In intellectual aggregation, the penalty for the most severe of the different crimes committed with a single act is imposed; whereas compound crimes and apparent aggregation indicate that there is actually only one crime involved. At the execution stage, penalties from different files are aggregated, but each penalty retains its independence; therefore, every development affecting one of the aggregated penalties requires the resolution of the aggregation and a recalculation. The rulings of the Court of Cassation in 2025 and 2026 demonstrate that the judgment forming the basis for recidivism and every condition of consecutive offenses are examined separately; this examination can change the execution period by years in most files.
Legal Resources and Related Reviews
Legislation
- Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237, Arts. 7, 42, 43, 44, 50, 51, 58, 59, 61, 62, 66, 149, 212.
- Law No. 5275 on the Execution of Penalties and Security Measures, Arts. 98, 99, 101, 107, 108.
- Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271, Arts. 12, 231, 268, 307, 309.
- Law No. 6458 on Foreigners and International Protection, Art. 54.
Court of Cassation Decisions
- Court of Cassation 10th Criminal Chamber, E. 2022/8112, K. 2026/11714, T. 17.09.2026
- Court of Cassation 10th Criminal Chamber, E. 2023/18497, K. 2026/12118, T. 23.09.2026
- Court of Cassation 5th Criminal Chamber, E. 2023/4416, K. 2026/8719, T. 10.09.2026
- Court of Cassation 11th Criminal Chamber, E. 2022/712, K. 2026/7699, T. 09.09.2026
- Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation, E. 2025/124, K. 2026/365, T. 06.10.2026
- Court of Cassation 11th Criminal Chamber, E. 2024/4111, K. 2026/5873, Date 02.06.2026
- Court of Cassation 2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2024/4280, K. 2026/8660, T. 07.05.2026
- Court of Cassation 7th Criminal Chamber, E. 2021/28919, K. 2025/8482, T. 02.06.2025
- Court of Cassation 11th Criminal Chamber, E. 2022/11238, K. 2025/1639, Date 10.02.2025
- Court of Cassation Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, E. 2019/258, K. 2024/109, Date 06.03.2024
- Court of Cassation 5th Criminal Chamber, E. 2023/12366, K. 2024/1023, T. 06.02.2024
- Court of Cassation Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, E. 2018/611, K. 2022/784, Date 08.12.2022
- Court of Cassation 1st Criminal Chamber, E. 2020/2374, K. 2021/9268, T. 27.05.2021
- Court of Cassation Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, E. 2014/462, K. 2015/135, T. 28.04.2015
- Court of Cassation Plenary Assembly of Criminal Chambers, E. 2013/11-397, K. 2014/202, Date 22.04.2014
Related Reviews
Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registration No: 77008
This guide has been prepared based on the legislation in force regarding recidivism, consecutive offenses, and the aggregation of offenses, as well as published Court of Cassation rulings. Legislative information was verified as of November 10, 2026. The outcome of each file depends on its own evidence and execution status; the explanations in this guide do not mean that the same result will be obtained in a specific file.
The contents on this page are for general information purposes and are open for use by all our colleagues. However, in accordance with the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, if all or a portion of this text is used, we kindly request that you provide a citation in the form of 'Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr' and include a link to the relevant article.