Real Estate Law
Failure of a Cooperative to Deliver a Flat and Expulsion from Membership: Legal Remedies
In this article 17 headings
- Short Answer: Cooperative
- Legal Nature of Cooperative Membership
- Grounds and Procedure for Expulsion
- Three-Month Period for the Expulsion Decision
- Being Treated as a Member After Expulsion
- Transfer of Membership and Cancellation of the Transfer
- If the Flat Is Not Delivered or the Title Deed Is Not Given
- Drawing Lots, Allocation, and Changing Housing Preference
- Payment to a Member Who Has Withdrawn or Been Expelled
- Annulment of Board of Directors and General Assembly Decisions
- Liability of Managers and Liquidation
- Court, Mediation, and Evidence
- What to Do Step-by-Step When an Expulsion Decision Arrives?
- 2026 Court of Cassation Decisions
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
- Sources
Publication: · Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.
Written and reviewed by: Lawyer Batın Yılmaz, Istanbul Bar Association · Legislation and case law status: November 2026
Short Answer: Cooperative

If a building cooperative does not provide the title deed for the flat allocated to a member who has fulfilled their financial obligations, the member may file a lawsuit against the cooperative for cancellation of title deed and registration. If registration is not possible, they may claim compensation.
If the cooperative has removed the member from membership (expulsion), the member may, against this decision, within three months from the service object to the general assembly or file an action for annulment (Law No. 1163, Law on Cooperatives, Art. 16). This period is a limitation period. However, the period begins with service in accordance with the procedure. If service has not been performed, the expulsion decision does not become final and the rights of membership continue (6th Civil Chamber, 13 May 2026, E. 2026/489, K. 2026/2102).
The competent court for these cases is, as a rule, the civil court of first instance. At the Court of Cassation, they are heard by the 6th Civil Chamber.
5 Key Points
- The three-month period begins with service. If it has been served by a notary and the period has expired, the case will be rejected (6th Civil Chamber, 04 May 2026, E. 2025/2806, K. 2026/1854).
- If the cooperative continued to accept you as a member after the expulsion, the decision may have become void. Being present on the general assembly attendance lists has resulted in this outcome (6th Civil Chamber, 20 May 2026, E. 2026/942, K. 2026/2195).
- An action for annulment may also be filed against board of directors decisions (6th Civil Chamber, 04 June 2026, E. 2026/1430, K. 2026/2415).
- An irregular membership transfer can be cancelled. A transfer made before the expulsion becomes final does not bind the member.
- Rights of ownership in disaster housing and expulsion are subject to separate rules (6th Civil Chamber, 20 May 2026, E. 2026/939, K. 2026/2205).
Legal Nature of Cooperative Membership
A member of a building cooperative is not a customer of the cooperative but a member. The member pays the dues and contribution shares determined by the articles of association and general assembly decisions. The cooperative distributes the housing it constructs to the members by drawing lots or allocation. Therefore:
- The relationship is governed not by the Law on the Protection of Consumers, but by the Law on Cooperatives No. 1163,the articles of association, and the general assembly resolutions.
- Expenses incurred by the cooperative are distributed among the partners. As a rule, late delivery or cost increases are not grounds for compensation against the cooperative, but rather a matter of distribution among the partners. However, the faulty actions of the management also give rise to liability.
- The transfer of cooperative membership is subject to the conditions in the articles of association and the approval of the board of directors.
If you purchased an apartment not from the cooperative, but from a contractor or a subcontractor that the cooperative contracted with: What Happens If the Contractor Does Not Deliver the Apartment?
Grounds and Procedure for Expulsion
According to Article 16 of the Law on Cooperatives, a partner may be expelled from the partnership for reasons explicitly stated in the articles of association. The most common reasons are:
- failure to pay dues and participation shares,
- behavior contrary to the articles of association and the decisions of the general assembly,
- actions that cause damage to the cooperative.
Procedural conditions:
- The warning condition in the articles of association: For expulsion due to non-payment of financial obligations, the warnings foreseen in the articles of association must be issued in the prescribed time and manner (in practice, via a notary). A single missing warning may be sufficient for the annulment of the expulsion decision.
- Authorized body: The expulsion decision is taken by the board of directors in accordance with the articles of association.
- Justification and service: The decision must be justified and must be served to the partner via a notary must be served.
- Finalization: Expulsion does not become final until the period for objection or filing a lawsuit has passed, or until the objection and lawsuit have been concluded. Until that date, the partner's rights and obligations continue (Art. 16/final).
Three-Month Period for the Expulsion Decision
The partner may object to the general assembly or file an annulment lawsuit directly in court within three months from the notification of the expulsion decision. This period is a statute of limitations (hak düşürücü süre).
- If the period has expired: The expulsion decision was served to the partner via a notary on 06.08.2015, and the lawsuit was filed on 30.06.2016. The court of first instance rejected the case due to the statute of limitations. The partner argued that the period should have started from the subsequent general assembly decision. The Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) did not accept this defense and upheld the rejection decision (6th Civil Chamber, 04.05.2026, Case No. 2025/2806, Decision No. 2026/1854).
- If there is no service, the period does not run: In a case where a partner's membership was deleted on the grounds of transfer of membership, there was no document proving that the board of directors' decision had been served to the partner. The court accepted that the three-month period would start with the service and that there could be no mention of a finalized expulsion decision. It ruled that the partner's rights and obligations continued until the expulsion decision was finalized. The Yargitay upheld the decision by a majority of votes (6th Civil Chamber, 13.05.2026, Case No. 2026/489, Decision No. 2026/2102).
- Heirs: If the partner has died, the heirs may file a lawsuit against the expulsion decision rendered against their decedent. The period is evaluated based on when the heirs learned of the decision and the status of the service.
Being Treated as a Member After Expulsion
In one of the remarkable decisions of 2026, the cooperative had expelled a partner on 16.10.2001 on the grounds that they did not fulfill their financial obligations. However, the partner's name continued to appear in the attendance lists (hazirun cetvelleri) of the general assemblies between 2003 and 2012, and the partner had participated in and signed for the 2005 general assembly.
The court of first instance rejected the case, stating that the partner had not been interested in the cooperative for a long time and had implicitly accepted the expulsion decision. The Regional Court of Appeal reached a different conclusion. It stated that the presence of the name and signature in the attendance lists did not mean that the partner accepted the expulsion, but rather showed that the cooperative had implicitly re-accepted them as a partner. Stating that the conditions for expulsion were not met and that the lawsuit was filed within a reasonable time, it annulled the expulsion decision. The Yargitay upheld this decision (6th Civil Chamber, 20.05.2026, Case No. 2026/942, Decision No. 2026/2195).
Lesson: If you believe you have been expelled but the cooperative continues to call you to general assemblies, request dues, or show you on the draw list, keep these documents. It is the strongest proof that the expulsion has become void.
Transfer of Membership and Cancellation of the Transfer
- Conditions of transfer: Transfer of membership is subject to the approval of the board of directors in accordance with the articles of association. The transferee assumes all rights and obligations of the transferor.
- Transfer without the shareholder's knowledge: A transfer made before the expulsion is finalized or without the consent of the shareholder does not bind the former shareholder. Cancellation of the transfer and determination of membership may be requested (case subject to the decision of the 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/2102).
- Transfer after the notary drawing: In a lawsuit filed on the claim that an independent unit assigned to a member via notary lottery was transferred to another person without the member's knowledge, the requests for the annulment of the expulsion decision, cancellation of the title deed and registration, and, in the alternative, compensation were evaluated together. The decision was upheld on the grounds that issues not raised during the appeal proceedings (istinaf) cannot be heard during the cassation proceedings (temyiz) (6th Civil Chamber, 21.01.2026, E. 2025/2721, K. 2026/256). It is therefore important that the claims be presented in full at the first instance and appeal stages.
If the Flat Is Not Delivered or the Title Deed Is Not Given
- Completion of financial obligations: The cooperative may refuse to transfer the title deed to a member who is in debt. Document first that dues and participation shares have been paid, or be prepared to deposit the remaining debt.
- Warning notice: Grant the cooperative a deadline via a notary public for the title deed transfer.
- Title deed annulment and registration: If the independent unit assigned to you by lottery or allocation is registered in the name of the cooperative, you should request registration; if it is registered in the name of a third party, you should request annulment and registration or compensation, depending on whether that party is in good faith. Request an injunction (ihtiyati tedbir) be placed on the title deed record.
- Possession of housing units allocated by the cooperative: Even if the title deed transfer has not been performed, a member residing in a housing unit allocated by the cooperative may protect their possession against the cooperative and third parties.
- Disaster housing: The transfer of beneficiary status and expulsion in cooperative housing for disaster victims who have incurred debt to the public are subject to special legislation. The Yargitay upheld a refusal decision in such a file regarding a request for title deed cancellation and registration arising from cooperative membership (6th Civil Chamber, 20.05.2026, E. 2026/939, K. 2026/2205). After being expelled, the member had claimed that they could neither obtain the housing nor had to pay the loan debt. Filing a lawsuit against the expulsion in a timely manner is decisive in these cases.
Drawing Lots, Allocation, and Changing Housing Preference
Can the cooperative management unilaterally change the housing type of a member (for example, from a twin villa to a 2+1 apartment)? In a file that came before the Yargitay, a member had been both expelled and had their allocation changed on the grounds of unpaid dues. The member requested the annulment of both the expulsion decision and the board of directors decision that changed the housing preference. They argued that they had declared their set-off statements in their warning notices and lawsuit petitions. The courts rejected the requests, and the Yargitay upheld the decision (6th Civil Chamber, 09.04.2026, E. 2025/3145, K. 2026/1381).
Conclusion: A member who falls into debt faces the risk of both expulsion and allocation change. Payments must be made within the notice period with proper descriptions, and set-off claims must be asserted with documentation and in a timely manner.
Payment to a Member Who Has Withdrawn or Been Expelled
- Rule: To a member who has resigned or has been definitively expelled, the capital share and the payments made are refunded based on the balance sheet of the year in which they left, in accordance with the articles of association and Article 17 of the Law on Cooperatives. If the cooperative incurred a loss in that year, the share of the loss may be deducted.
- Timing: As a rule, the refund is made after the balance sheet for the relevant year is approved by the general assembly.
- Inflation: In long-term cooperatives, the refund of payments at their nominal amount can create a significant loss. Therefore, objecting to the expulsion decision and maintaining the membership is often more advantageous than requesting a refund of what was paid.
Annulment of Board of Directors and General Assembly Decisions
- General assembly decisions: Members who cast a dissenting vote at the meeting or were summoned to the meeting irregularly may file an annulment lawsuit against general assembly decisions that are contrary to the law, the articles of association, or the rule of good faith. The time limit is short and is a preclusive period (Law No. 1163, Art. 53).
- Board of directors decisions: The Yargitay accepts that an annulment lawsuit can be filed against board of directors decisions that directly affect the rights of members (6th Civil Chamber, 04.06.2026, E. 2026/1430, K. 2026/2415).
- Void decisions: Decisions that eradicate the essence of membership rights or are clearly contrary to the mandatory provisions of the law may be void, regardless of any time limit. A determination may be requested from the court.
Liability of Managers and Liquidation
- Management liability: Members of the board of directors and supervisory board who cause damage to the partners through their faulty actions (irregular transfers, off-the-books expenditures, undocumented payments) may be held liable together with the cooperative.
- Criminal path: Actions by cooperative managers amounting to breach of trust or embezzlement may constitute crimes within the scope of the Law on Cooperatives and the TCK.
- Liquidation and erasure from the registry: Even if the cooperative has been liquidated and removed from the trade registry, a lawsuit can be filed claiming the invalidity of the expulsion or claiming partnership rights. The cooperative subject to the decision of the 6th Civil Chamber, No. 2026/2195, entered liquidation in 2009 and was removed from the registry in 2012. In this case, the re-registration of the cooperative in the registry (revival) may be necessary.
Court, Mediation, and Evidence
- Competent court: As a rule, the commercial court of first instance is the competent court for disputes involving cooperatives. The lawsuit subject to the decision No. 2026/1381 was heard at the Antalya 3rd Commercial Court of First Instance.
- Mediation: In commercial lawsuits where the subject matter is the payment of a certain amount of money, this is a condition precedent to litigation (Article 5/A of the Turkish Commercial Code). Claims for the annulment of an expulsion decision and for the cancellation and registration of title deeds do not fall within this scope.
- The competent chamber at the Yargitay: 6th Civil Chamber.
- Evidence: Articles of association, partnership records, dues receipts, warning notices and their proof of service, general assembly invitations, attendance lists, lottery minutes, board of directors resolution book.
What to Do Step-by-Step When an Expulsion Decision Arrives?
- Note the date of service. The date on the notary's proof of service is the start of the three-month period. Immediately mark the last day on the calendar.
- Request the articles of association. Check whether the reason for expulsion is clearly included in the articles of association and verify the requirements for the warning notice (number, duration, form).
- Compare the warning notices. Each warning notice must contain the debt amount, payment period, and a warning that you will be expelled if it is not paid. A warning notice containing a missing or incorrect amount may invalidate the expulsion decision.
- Document your payments. Collect bank statements, receipts, and your set-off requests in one file. Continuing to pay dues even after the expulsion demonstrates your intent to maintain the partnership.
- Record the cooperative's subsequent actions. General assembly invitations, attendance lists, dues requests, and lottery lists may demonstrate the invalidity of the expulsion.
- Objection to the general assembly or a lawsuit? Objection to the general assembly allows for internal audit of the cooperative but prolongs the process. If you are on bad terms with the management, filing an annulment lawsuit directly is usually more effective.
- Request an interim injunction. To prevent the independent unit belonging to you from being transferred to someone else, request an interim injunction along with the lawsuit.
2026 Court of Cassation Decisions
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Chamber, date, merit no., and decision no. | Subject | Principle and outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 6th Civil Chamber, 21.01.2026, E. 2025/2721, K. 2026/256 | Expulsion, notary lottery, transfer | Issues not raised in the appeal (istinaf) cannot be heard in the cassation (temyiz) proceedings; affirmed. |
| 6th Civil Chamber, 09.04.2026, E. 2025/3145, K. 2026/1381 | Dues debt, expulsion, allocation change | Requests for the annulment of board of directors decisions regarding expulsion and housing preference were rejected; affirmed. |
| 6th Civil Chamber, 04.05.2026, E. 2025/2806, K. 2026/1854 | Three-month period | The period has expired after service by a notary; rejection affirmed. |
| 6th Civil Chamber, 13.05.2026, E. 2026/489, K. 2026/2102 | Expulsion without service, membership transfer | The period does not start running without service; the expulsion does not become final; affirmed (by majority vote). |
| 6th Civil Chamber, 20.05.2026, E. 2026/942, K. 2026/2195 | Attendance lists after expulsion | The cooperative implicitly re-accepted [the member]; expulsion decision annulled; affirmed. |
| 6th Civil Chamber, 20.05.2026, E. 2026/939, K. 2026/2205 | Disaster housing, expulsion, registration | Claim for title deed cancellation and registration arising from cooperative membership; affirmed. |
| 6th Civil Chamber, 04.06.2026, E. 2026/1430, K. 2026/2415 | Annulment of board of directors resolution | An annulment lawsuit against board of directors resolutions is possible; affirmed. |
Selection method: The decisions were selected in November 2026 by searching the UYAP Precedent Decision Search using the phrases "annulment of expulsion decision", "expulsion from cooperative membership" and "allocated by the cooperative", and by reading the texts of the 2026 decisions of the Yargitay 6th Civil Chamber.
Frequently Asked Questions
The cooperative has removed me from membership; within what period must I file a lawsuit?
You must object to the general assembly or file an annulment lawsuit within three months from the date the expulsion decision is served to you via a notary. The period is a preclusive time limit (Law No. 1163, Article 16).
The expulsion decision was not served to me; what happens?
If no service has been made, the three-month period does not begin to run and the expulsion decision does not become final. Your partnership rights and obligations continue (6th Civil Chamber, 13.05.2026, E. 2026/489, K. 2026/2102).
Can the cooperative expel me due to my unpaid dues?
It can do so if the warnings stipulated in the articles of association have been made in accordance with the procedure and payment has not been made within the given period. If any of the warnings are missing or irregular, the annulment of the expulsion decision may be requested.
The cooperative is not giving the title deed to my flat; what can I do?
Document that you have fulfilled your financial obligations and send a notarial warning notice. If the title deed transfer is not executed, you may file a lawsuit for the cancellation of the title deed and registration with the commercial court of first instance, and you may request that a precautionary injunction be placed on the title deed record.
I was called to the general assembly after being expelled; is the expulsion valid?
The fact that the cooperative continues to treat you as a member after your expulsion may indicate that the expulsion has become void. The Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) has upheld the annulment of an expulsion decision for a member whose name and signature were present on the attendance sheets (6th Civil Chamber, 20.05.2026, E. 2026/942, K. 2026/2195).
If I withdraw from the cooperative, can I get my payments back?
The withdrawing member shall be refunded their share and payments calculated according to the balance sheet of the year in which they withdrew, in accordance with the articles of association and Article 17 of the Law on Cooperatives. Due to inflation, continuing the membership is often more advantageous than withdrawing.
Conclusion
The most frequent losses of rights in cooperative disputes arise from missing the three-month deadline and failing to document dues payments. When an expulsion decision is served, calculate the deadline immediately, check whether the warnings comply with the procedure, and document the cooperative's behavior after the expulsion. If the title deed is not provided, document your payments and request an injunction on the title deed when filing a lawsuit for registration.
Related articles
- What Happens If the Contractor Does Not Deliver the Apartment?
- Promise of Sale Agreement at the Notary: Registration Lawsuit If the Title Deed Is Not Granted
- Risks When Purchasing Share-Based Land and Fields
- All real estate law articles
Sources
- but by the Law on Cooperatives No. 1163,, Art. 8 et seq., 16, 17, 53
- Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, Art. 5/A
- Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, Art. 2
- The Court of Cassation decisions included in the table above (Supreme Court Decision Search)
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.