What is Violation of Domestic Inviolability (TCK 116)?

Violation of domestic inviolability refers to entering a person's home, the appurtenances of their home, or, in certain cases, their workplace without consent or remaining inside despite a request to leave after having entered with permission is an offense committed under these circumstances. This crime is regulated under Article 116 of the Turkish Penal Code.

The value protected here is not solely the right to property. The primary legal interest protected is an individual's private living space,, peace,, security, and right to live freely in their residence. Therefore, the offense may sometimes be committed without breaking down the door or causing property damage. Because what matters is the unlawful entry into or remaining within an individual's private space. unlawful entry into or remaining within an individual's private space.

The Crime of Violation of Domestic Inviolability Within the Scope of TCK 116

According to the Turkish Penal Code, this crime may manifest in various forms. While assessing whether the offense has been committed, consideration is given to the nature of the incident, consent status, whether the entered premises constitute a residence or its appurtenances, and the conditions under which the act was committed.

Entering a Residence Without Consent

Entering a person's home without their permission constitutes the most basic form of the offense. Here, the term "residence" refers to the area where an individual permanently or temporarily lives and maintains their private life.

For example:

• Entering a home by forcing the door,
• Entering the premises despite the homeowner's objection,
• Entering an outbuilding or storage area with a private use area without authorization
  may be evaluated within the scope of violation of the inviolability of the residence.

Entering with Consent and Failing to Leave Afterwards

The crime does not occur solely through unauthorized entry. The person may have initially entered the home with permission. However, if they continue to stay inside despite being asked to leave by the homeowner or the occupant, the crime may also occur in this case.

From this perspective, lawful initial entry is not always sufficient. Once consent is withdrawn, continuing to remain inside becomes unlawful.

Appurtenances of the Residence Are Also Protected

The law protects not only the interior of the home but also the appurtenances of the residence. An appurtenance refers to areas that complement the use of the residence and are connected to it.

Places That May Be Considered Appurtenances

Depending on the specific circumstances of the case, the following areas may be considered appurtenances:

• garden
• garage
• warehouse
• shed
• courtyard
• appurtenance

Therefore, not only entering the apartment itself, but also unauthorized entry into protected areas connected to the residence may constitute a crime.

Elements of the Crime of Violation of Domestic Inviolability

For an incident to truly crime of violation of domicile be considered as such, certain legal elements must be evaluated together.

The Protected Area Being a Residence or Appurtenance

First of all, the entered location must be a legally protected area. This area is usually a residence or an appurtenance of the residence. In some cases, workplaces are also protected within this scope.

What is a Residence?

In terms of criminal law, a residence is a place where a person dwells, lives, and maintains their private life. This place does not necessarily have to be registered as a dwelling on the title deed. A summer house, rented apartment, student housing, or any other place actually used for habitation may be considered a residence in the specific case.

Under What Circumstances Do Workplaces Fall Within the Scope?

According to TCK Article 116/2, unlike areas that everyone can freely enter, workplaces and their appurtenances into which entry is not customary without explicit consent is under protection. In other words, the same offense may also come into question regarding certain closed, private, or restricted-access workplaces.

Absence of Consent

The element of consent lies at the center of the offense. If there is valid consent, the offense does not constitute in most cases. However, this consent must be explicit, genuine, and legally valid.

Consent:

• may not have been given at all from the outset,
• may have been subsequently withdrawn,
• may have been obtained through fraud.

It is also accepted in the precedents of the Yargıtay that consent vitiated by fraud may not be deemed valid.

Consent in Co-Occupied Residences

According to the law, if there is consent from one of the family members in a marital union, or from one of the users in a commonly used residence or workplace, the offense may not occur in certain cases. However, there is an important limitation here: Consent must be directed toward a legitimate purpose.

Why Is a Legitimate Purpose Important?

If a person invites a third party to a shared home with the intent to harm, exert pressure on, or for an unlawful purpose against the other occupant, the consent given may not be legally protected. Therefore, every consent given in shared use is not automatically deemed valid.

Penalty for Violation of Domestic Inviolability

The penalty for violation of domicile varies depending on whether the crime is in its basic or qualified form.

Basic Penalty

A person who enters another's residence or its annexes against the consent of the occupant, or who fails to leave despite having entered with consent, imprisonment from six months to two years shall be punished.

Penalty Regarding Workplaces

If the act is committed against workplaces or workplace annexes that are not customarily entered without explicit consent, the perpetrator shall face imprisonment from six months to one year or a judicial fine may be imposed.

Qualified Form: Force, Threat, or Nighttime

Circumstances requiring a heavier penalty are stipulated in the 4th paragraph of the Law. If the act is committed:

• by using force,
• by using threats,
• or during nighttime committed,

penalty imprisonment from one year to three years shall apply as.

Why Is Commission at Night Considered an Aggravating Factor?

Violations committed at night disrupt an individual's sense of home security and privacy much more intensely. Therefore, the legislator has subjected acts committed at night to heavier sanctions.

At What Stage Are Force and Threat Important?

According to the practice of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), force or threat must be used while entering the residence or in order to continue staying inside. Without establishing this connection, not every incident is automatically considered an aggravated circumstance.

Is Violation of Domicile Subject to a Complaint?

Yes. The basic form of the crime is, as a rule, subject to complaint. In other words, the investigation and prosecution process begins upon the victim's complaint in most cases.

Why is a Complaint Important?

As explicitly stated in the law, a victim's complaint is required for the basic form. Therefore, it is important for the person who experienced the incident to resort to legal remedies without wasting time.

In Which Situations Does the Incident Yield Heavier Consequences?

If there is also a threat, injury, property damage, or another crime involved in the incident, the case may be evaluated not only within the framework of TCK Article 116, but also in terms of other offenses. Therefore, it is necessary to examine the entirety of the specific incident.

Frequently Asked Questions

1) What is the violation of the inviolability of domicile?

It is entering a person's home, its appurtenances, or in certain cases, their workplace without consent, or failing to leave after entering with permission.

2) What is the penalty for violating the inviolability of domicile?

The basic penalty is imprisonment from six months to two years. If the act is committed through force, threat, or during nighttime, the penalty may range from one to three years of imprisonment.

3) Does a crime occur if a person invited into a home refuses to leave?

Yes. Even if the initial entry was permissive, a crime may be constituted if the person continues to stay despite being asked to leave.

4) Does entering a garden or garage also constitute this crime?

Yes, depending on the specific circumstances of the case, unauthorized entry into areas considered appurtenances of the residence may also constitute this crime.

5) Is the consent of one person sufficient in a shared home?

In some cases  yes. However, for this to be valid, the consent given must be directed toward a legitimate purpose .

6) Is the penalty increased if committed at night?

Yes. Commission during the night is an aggravating circumstance under Article 116/4 of the TCK.

7) Is this offense subject to a complaint?

Yes, as a rule, its basic form is subject to a complaint.

8) Is being the title deed holder sufficient on its own?

No. In criminal law, actual use, the sphere of privacy, and the element of consent are also evaluated separately.

Conclusion

Violation of home inviolability is an important type of offense that protects an individual's private living space. Unauthorized entry, failing to leave despite permission, unlawfully entering the appurtenances of a residence, and acts committed at night or using threats may entail serious legal consequences under this scope.

Therefore, in a specific case, the nature of the residence, the existence of consent, whether the consent was withdrawn, whether the incident occurred at night, and its connection to other offenses must be carefully evaluated.

For more information 0532 669 34 90 and https://batinyilmaz.av.tr/iletisim/ you can contact us via our addresses.

Atty. Batın YILMAZ