What is Effective Remorse (TCK Art. 110)?

Effective remorse (TCK 110), for the perpetrator who commits the crime of "deprivation of liberty" (TCK 109), without state coercion and at an early stage in the event that the victim's liberty is restored, a significant reduction in sentence is a special provision that can provide.

The primary purpose of this provision is:

• To encourage the restoration of the victim's liberty
• To prevent harm to the victim
• To reward the perpetrator for demonstrating remorse through a concrete act

The General Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Yargıtay clearly establishes that effective remorse in the crime of deprivation of liberty constitutes a grounds for sentence reduction when the conditions required by law are met, and that these conditions must coexist.

What are the Conditions for Effective Remorse (TCK 110)?

In judicial practice, the most critical part of Article 110 of the TCK is the "conditions." These conditions are enumerated in a standardized manner in the case law of the Yargıtay.

1) The crime must be completed

Effective remorse comes into question after the crime is completed. In other words, the victim's liberty must have been unlawfully restricted, even if only for a certain period of time.

2) Release prior to the initiation of the investigation

The timing required by law is "release prior to the initiation of the investigation regarding this crime." serbest bırakmadır.

What does "prior to the initiation of the investigation" mean?

• Generally Prior to the Office of the Public Prosecutor learning of the incident and initiating investigative proceedings. (complaint/denunciation, law enforcement procedures, prosecutor's instructions, etc.) is understood.
• In the specific case, the assessment of "whether the investigation has commenced"; is made through evidence such as reports, time of denunciation, law enforcement records, prosecutor's actions .

3) No harm must be done to the person of the victim

For effective remorse (active cooperation), the condition that no harm is done to the person of the victim is required.

Here, the scope of "harm" can be controversial in practice. Especially in cases such as the victim sustaining injuries during abduction/detention that can be treated with simple medical intervention, some courts may not apply effective remorse.

Nevertheless, there are evaluations in the Yargıtay regarding how the condition of "without harming his/her person" will be interpreted:

Therefore, the following distinction is important in practice:

• Mağdurun şahsına zarar iddiası varsa, etkin pişmanlık automatic it would not be accurate to say that it applies.
• If there are allegations of injury, threats, and ill-treatment as well as forensic reports, whether TCK 110 will apply somut delil durumuna is debated accordingly.

4) Kendiliğinden serbest bırakma

“Kendiliğinden” unsuru şunu ifade eder:

• Fail mağduru since they will be apprehended, inevitably bırakmamalı,
• not by the coercion of third parties, of his/her own free will, must release.

The decisions of the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers and Chambers interpret the element of "spontaneously" without coercion as follows:

5) Release in a safe place

The place where the victim is released:

• must not be a place that risks his/her life/bodily integrity,
• where he/she cannot receive assistance,
• and where he/she will be exposed to danger once again.

should not be a place.

When evaluating a "safe place," elements such as the isolation of the location, whether it is nighttime, the victim's age/health, and communication availability (telephone, calling for help) gain importance.

---

How Much is the Effective Remorse (TCK 110) Sentence Reduction?

TCK 110 stipulates that when the conditions are met, the penalty may be "reduced by up to two-thirds" can be applied.

There are two important technical points here:

What does "up to" mean? (Discretionary power)

The phrase "up to two-thirds" grants the judge a discretionary margin :

• Depending on the specifics of the case, the court may apply the reduction at a lower rate as well,
• If the conditions are not met, it may not be applied at all.

Upon which sentence is the reduction calculated?

• First, the basic/aggravated form of the offense is determined (TCK Art. 109/1, 109/2, 109/3, etc.).
• Then, if the conditions under TCK Art. 110 are met, the reduction is evaluated over this sentence.

---

When is Effective Remorse Under TCK 110 Not Applicable?

The following situations frequently lead to the conclusion that "effective remorse shall not apply" in practice:

Release after the initiation of the investigation

If the time requirement stipulated by the law is missed, the reduction under TCK Art. 110 may not apply.

Infliction of bodily harm upon the victim

If evidence such as medical reports, witnesses, camera footage, or text messages supports the "harm to the person," the court may deny the reduction.

Release out of necessity rather than voluntarily

• Release upon seeing law enforcement arrive with the intent to flee,
• Release in panic upon realizing apprehension is imminent,
• Release through the intervention of third parties

such circumstances render the "voluntary" element debatable.

If the safe place criterion is not met

If the victim is left in a risky place, the conditions for effective remorse may not be fulfilled.

---

According to the Court of Cassation, Conditions for Effective Remorse Must Be Met Concurrently

The main principle in the decisions of the General Assembly of Criminal Chambers and chambers is as follows:
Effective remorse is like a "package"; the conditions must individually not, but rather altogether enumerated individually in the law must take place.

This approach is consistent in both the CGK 2011/231 decision and subsequent CGK decisions:

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1) What is effective remorse (TCK Article 110)?

In the crime of deprivation of liberty (TCK Article 109), it is the provision that provides a sentence reduction if the perpetrator before the investigation begins, automatically, in a safe place and without harming the victim's person releases the victim.

2) How much is the effective remorse reduction?

If the conditions are met, a reduction of up to two-thirds may be applied to the sentence. The rate of the reduction is determined by the court based on the specific circumstances of the case.

3) What does "voluntary release" mean?

It is the release of the victim by the perpetrator without any pressure or coercion, of his/her own free will, and without being subjected to any obligation such as apprehension. Yargıtay explains this as "without the presence of any coercion."

4) How is a "safe place" understood?

It is evaluated as a place that does not risk the victim's life/health, where they can receive help, and where they will not be endangered again. Factors such as location and time (nighttime/desolation) are taken into consideration.

5) Does effective remorse apply if the victim sustains minor injuries?

This issue may be controversial in practice. In some rulings, the condition of "without causing bodily harm" can be interpreted narrowly or broadly. Therefore, the forensic medical report and how the incident occurred are decisive.

6) If the victim is released after the investigation has commenced, does effective remorse apply?

With respect to TCK 110, the time condition is important. Release after the investigation has commenced may not be deemed sufficient in most cases regarding the TCK 110 sentence reduction.

---

Conclusion / Summary

• Effective remorse (TCK 110), in the offense of deprivation of personal liberty (TCK 109) in favor of the perpetrator a significant sentence reduction may provide.
• The conditions for the reduction must be met concurrently: the crime must have been consummated, the victim before the investigation begins, automatically, in a safe place and without sustaining any harm to the victim's person must be released.
• According to the Yargıtay, particularly "voluntarily", "safe place" and "time condition" are decisive in practice.
• Most critical emphasis: If any of the conditions are missing, the TCK 110 reduction may not be applied.

For more information 0532 669 34 90 and https://batinyilmaz.av.tr/iletisim/ you can contact us via our addresses.

Atty. Batın YILMAZ