Real Estate Law
Incomplete and Defective Work in Construction Agreements for Land Shares: Rights of the Landowner
In this article 17 headings
- Short Answer: Construction for land shares
- Nature and Form of Construction for Land Share Agreements
- Difference Between Incomplete and Defective Work
- Notice of Defects: When and How?
- Landowner's Alternative Rights
- How Are Incomplete and Defective Work Costs Calculated?
- Occupancy Permit (Structure Usage Permit) and Security Units
- Delay: Loss of Rental Income and Penalty Clause
- Termination: With Retroactive or Prospective Effect?
- Third Parties: Those Who Bought from the Contractor and the Landowner
- Statute of Limitations
- Evidentiary Assessment, Court, and Mediation
- Checklist Before Signing an Agreement
- 2026 Court of Cassation Decisions
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
- Sources
Publication: · Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.
Written and reviewed by: Lawyer Batın Yılmaz, Istanbul Bar Association · Legislation and case law status: November 2026
Short Answer: Construction for land shares

If the contractor performs the work incompletely or defectively under a construction agreement for land shares, the landowner's primary rights are as follows:
- to claim the cost of the incomplete and defective work,
- to demand the free rectification of the defect,
- to claim loss of rental income for the delay and a penalty clause,
- to terminate the agreement in severe cases.
These rights are based on the provisions for works contracts under TBK Art. 470 et seq. Defects must be notified after delivery without delay . Hidden defects must be notified immediately upon discovery.
Rights arising from defects in immovable structures, as of delivery, five years, if the contractor is grossly negligent, twenty years may be exercised within (Article 478 of the TBK).
If an occupancy permit has not been obtained and deficiencies have not been remedied, the landowner may refuse to transfer the title deeds of the independent units reserved for them in the contract as security. However, if the security held is sufficient to cover the deficiencies, withholding the title deeds of other independent units to which the contractor is entitled may not be considered justified (6th Civil Chamber, 03.06.2026, E. 2025/3570, K. 2026/2345).
5 Key Points
- The chamber in charge at the Yargitay (Court of Cassation of Turkiye) is the 6th Civil Chamber. This is understood from the decision of the Plenary Session of the Yargitay on the division of work dated 29.06.2026 and numbered 2026/1 (1st Civil Chamber, 24.09.2026, E. 2026/6877, K. 2026/6411).
- Determination of evidence is very important. Have the determination carried out by the civil court of peace before having the deficiencies completed. In 2026 decisions, calculations were based on these determination reports.
- Security units must be used proportionately. If sufficient security is held, other title deeds must be transferred (6th Civil Chamber 2026/2345).
- Those who purchased a unit from the landowner cannot file a lawsuit directly against the contractor. They must take over the landowner's rights by assignment (6th Civil Chamber, 10.06.2026, E. 2025/3351, K. 2026/2508).
- The type of termination determines the result. If construction is at an advanced stage, termination is effective for the future, and the contractor becomes entitled to payment in proportion to the work performed.
Nature and Form of Construction for Land Share Agreements
A land-share construction contract is a combination of two contracts:
- On one side is the contractor's obligation to build the structure, a contract for work (construction agreement) (Article 470 et seq. of the TBK).
- On the other side is the landowner's obligation to transfer the land shares in return, promise to sell immovable property. exists.
Because it contains a promise to transfer immovable property, the contract in the form of a deed at a notary must be executed via a notary. An ordinary written contract is, as a rule, invalid. However, if obligations have been largely performed, asserting invalidity may be considered contrary to the rule of good faith.
In practice, cases requesting the annulment of title deeds by asserting the invalidity of the contract can reach the General Assembly of Civil Chambers (HGK). In a case subject to an HGK decision dated 2026, the first-instance court had determined the invalidity of the land-share construction contract in terms of form and authority. The Assembly reviewed the resistance decision on procedural grounds because the operative part of the judgment was not established in accordance with Article 297 of the HMK (HGK, 16.09.2026, E. 2026/587, K. 2026/508).
The specific rules of Law No. 6306 also apply to contracts within the scope of urban transformation. See. Istanbul Urban Transformation Construction Contract and the Building Joint Resolution Protocol.
Difference Between Incomplete and Defective Work
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Incomplete work | Defective work | |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Work provided for in the contract or project that was never performed | Work performed but contrary to the contract, project, technical specifications, or principles of construction science |
| Example | Failure to install elevators, failure to complete landscaping, parking areas, shelters, or thermal insulation, failure to obtain an occupancy permit | Cracked plaster, leaking terraces, low-quality materials, construction contrary to the permit, missing square footage |
| Is a notice required? | As a rule, no, it is the contractor's obligation to perform | Yes, without delay (Article 474 of the TBK) |
| Request | Performance of the work or its value, delay compensation | Free repair, price reduction or withdrawal, compensation for damages (Article 475 of the TBK) |
Notice of Defects: When and How?
- Inspection and notification: After taking delivery of the work, the owner of the work must inspect it as soon as there is an opportunity according to the ordinary course of business and notify the contractor of any defects within a reasonable time (Article 474 of the TBK).
- Latent (hidden) defect: When defects that could not be understood through ordinary inspection (dampness, static problems, hidden installation faults) emerge, immediately they must be notified. Otherwise, the work is deemed accepted (Article 477 of the TBK).
- Form: The law does not require a formal condition. However, a notarial warning notice should be used for proof, and each defect should be listed separately.
- Acceptance record: A record signed upon delivery stating 'everything received without deficiency' may imply acceptance regarding apparent defects. Any deficiencies observed should be written in the record and the phrase 'my rights regarding latent defects are reserved' should be added.
- Gross negligence: If the contractor has intentionally hidden the defect or is guilty of gross negligence, late notification does not eliminate the landowner's rights.
Landowner's Alternative Rights
Pursuant to Article 475 of the TBK, if the work is defective, the employer may choose one of the following rights:
- Rescission of the contract: If the work is so defective that it cannot be used or cannot be expected to be accepted in accordance with equity. However, in the case of buildings constructed on land, rescission is limited if the demolition of the structure would cause great damage.
- Reduction in the price: In practice, because the landowner does not pay money in exchange for the plot, the cost of defective work converts into a monetary receivable.
- Free repair: If it does not require excessive cost, the landowner may request the contractor to remedy the defect. If the contractor does not remedy it within a reasonable period, the landowner may have it done by others at the contractor's expense.
In addition to these, the defaulting contractor may be requested to compensate for damages according to general provisions. For instance, rent loss for an apartment that cannot be leased due to the defect, or expenses for staying elsewhere, may be requested.
How Are Incomplete and Defective Work Costs Calculated?
- Site inspection and expert witness: A commission consisting of a civil engineer, an architect, and, if necessary, an electrical and mechanical engineer, examines the building according to the project and the agreement.
- Pursantage (work item ratio): If the percentage of work items is determined in the agreement, the deficiency is calculated according to this table. If not determined, an expert determines the completion rate of the work. In a 2026 decision regarding a construction contract, as there was no pursantage table, the experts calculated the completion rate of the work as 83,93% and the rate of incomplete and defective work as 16,07%, and the decision was upheld (6th Civil Chamber, 01.07.2026, E. 2026/504, K. 2026/2961).
- Price basis: As a rule, the free market prices at the time the works were completed by the landowner are taken as the basis if the deficiencies were completed by the landowner, or the market prices at the date of the lawsuit if they were not. For this reason, completion invoices and payment documents should be kept.
- Evidence assessment report: Having an assessment made by the civil judgeship of peace before having the deficiencies completed prevents the subsequent defense that 'there were no deficiencies'. In the decision numbered 2026/2961, the calculation was based on the report in the assessment file obtained by the employer before having the work completed. The contractor's objections that 'the assessment was not served and no site inspection was conducted' were not accepted.
Occupancy Permit (Structure Usage Permit) and Security Units
In most agreements, obtaining the occupancy permit (iskân) is the contractor's obligation. Without the occupancy permit, electricity, water, and natural gas subscriptions, credit usage, and sales become significantly difficult. Failure to obtain the occupancy permit is considered incomplete work.
Collateral apartments: Agreements usually stipulate that title deeds be granted in stages based on the construction level and that the last few apartments be held by the landowner until the occupancy permit is obtained and deficiencies are remedied. Pursuant to Article 97 of the TBK, the landowner may withhold the title deed of these apartments until the contractor completes their performance. Article 97 of the TBK regulates that in reciprocal agreements, the party who does not fulfill their performance cannot request the counter-performance (defense of non-performance).
Measurement is important: In the case subject to the 2026 decision of the 6th Civil Chamber of the Yargitay, the agreement stipulated that title deeds be granted according to the progress of the floors, and that the remaining parts be transferred upon the general occupancy permit. The construction level was 97,65% and the occupancy permit had not been obtained. Four independent units had not yet been transferred to the contractor.
The Chamber made the following finding: Even if half of the share of the requested shop is transferred, sufficient collateral apartments will remain in the hands of the landowners for the occupancy permit and deficiencies. For this reason, a decision for registration should be made without the need for an escrow decision. The Chamber reversed the dismissal decision of the court of first instance (6th Civil Chamber, 03.06.2026, E. 2025/3570, K. 2026/2345). Lesson: Collateral apartments must be kept proportional to the cost of the deficiencies. Any excess may be considered as unfair withholding against the contractor and those who bought apartments from them.
Delay: Loss of Rental Income and Penalty Clause
- Default: If there is a definite delivery date in the agreement, the contractor falls into default upon the passing of this date without the need for a formal notice (TBK Art. 117/2). If the date is not specified, a notarial warning notice is required.
- Loss of rental income: The comparable rental value that would have been obtained if the independent units falling to the landowner had been delivered on time may be requested for each month of delay. The expert determines the comparable rent for each period.
- Penalty clause: If there is a provision such as "... TL per apartment for each delayed month," it may be requested. Whether a penalty clause and loss of rent can be requested together depends on the wording of the agreement. An excessively high penalty may be reduced by the judge. However, a debtor who is a merchant cannot claim that the penalty is excessive (Article 182 of the TBK, Article 22 of the TTK).
- Reservation of rights: If you do not reserve the right to the penalty clause when taking delivery of the apartments, the penalty may not be claimable (Article 179/2 of the TBK).
- Early return: If the contractor does not start work on time or delays the work in violation of the contract, the landowner may withdraw from the contract without waiting for the delivery date (Article 473 of the TBK).
Regarding the rights of the apartment buyer in case of delay: What Happens If the Contractor Does Not Deliver the Apartment?
Termination: With Retroactive or Prospective Effect?
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Retroactive withdrawal | Prospective termination | |
|---|---|---|
| When? | Construction progress is low, contractor is at gross fault | In Yargitay practice, if the construction is approximately 90% or more complete or if withdrawal would lead to results contrary to equity |
| Conclusion | The contract ceases to exist from the beginning; the title deeds transferred to the contractor are returned | The contract terminates from the moment of termination; the contractor acquires the right to an independent unit or payment in proportion to the work performed |
| The construction work performed | The contractor may be paid based on the rules of unjust enrichment | Incomplete and defective work is deducted from the contractor's entitlement |
| Third parties | The rights of those who purchased independent units from the contractor are endangered | Those who purchased the units to which the contractor is entitled may be protected |
Path for termination: The contractor is given a reasonable time by means of a notarial warning notice. It is notified that the right of termination will be exercised if the performance is not completed within this period (Articles 123–125 of the TBK). Subsequently, the court is requested to terminate the contract and to cancel and register the title deed shares transferred to the contractor. A termination lawsuit may lead to new disputes regarding third parties who have purchased apartments from the contractor. Therefore, title deed records and the chain of sales must be examined in advance.
Third Parties: Those Who Bought from the Contractor and the Landowner
- Those who purchased apartments from the landowner: A person who purchases the independent unit falling to the landowner is not a party to the construction agreement in return for land. To be able to file a lawsuit against the contractor for incomplete and defective work, the landowner's rights arising from the contract must be assigned to them. Filing a lawsuit together with the landowner may also be considered an assignment (6th Civil Chamber, 10.06.2026, E. 2025/3351, K. 2026/2508).
- Those who purchased apartments from the contractor: In the same decision, the Chamber stated that those who purchased apartments from the contractor rely on the sales contract between them and the contractor, not on the construction agreement in return for land. If these persons are consumers, it accepted that the consumer court is the competent authority The lawsuit must be severed with respect to these persons.
- Status of the person who purchased from the contractor against the landowner: If the contractor has assigned their rights to a third party without fulfilling their performance fully or partially, the landowner may also assert the plea of non-performance under Article 97 of the TBK against this person (6th Civil Chamber 2026/2345). The person who purchased the apartment may be forced to prove that the contractor has completed their performance or has sufficient collateral.
Statute of Limitations
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Request | Duration | Commencement |
|---|---|---|
| Defects in immovable structures | 5 years | Delivery of the work (Article 478 of the TBK) |
| Contractor's gross fault (such as concealing a defect) | 20 years | Delivery |
| Incomplete work, delay compensation, penalty clause | 10 years (general period) | Date when the receivable becomes due (Article 146 of the TBK) |
Statute of limitations should not be confused with the notification period. Even if within the five-year period, if the defect is not notified in time, the work may be deemed accepted.
Evidentiary Assessment, Court, and Mediation
- Evidence collection: Before having incomplete and defective work completed, a request for inspection and expert examination must be filed with the civil court of peace (Article 400 et seq. of the HMK).
- Competent court: As a rule, the civil court of first instance. If the parties are merchants and the contract relates to their commercial enterprises, the commercial court of first instance.
- Mediation: In commercial lawsuits involving claims for the payment of an amount of money and compensation, mediation as a condition precedent to litigation is applied (Article 5/A of the TTK). Claims for cancellation and registration of title deeds are not within this scope.
- The competent chamber at the Yargitay: With the work allocation decision dated 29.06.2026, the duty to examine lawsuits for cancellation and registration of title deeds arising from construction agreements in return for land belongs to the 6th Civil Chamber of the Yargitay (1st Civil Chamber, 24.09.2026, E. 2026/6877, K. 2026/6411).
- Waiver and settlement: In long-running lawsuits, the parties may reach an agreement at any stage of the proceedings. In a case pending before the General Assembly of Civil Chambers (Hukuk Genel Kurulu) in 2026 regarding outstanding work, delay compensation, and liquidated damages, the plaintiff waived the lawsuit, and the General Assembly of Civil Chambers issued a decision due to the waiver (HGK, 16.09.2026, E. 2026/97, K. 2026/507).
Checklist Before Signing an Agreement
- Is the contract drawn up in the form of an official deed by a notary?
- Are the project, the list of finishes, and the technical specifications (material brand and class) attachments to the contract?
- Are the definitive start and delivery dates, the delay penalty, and the rent assistance written down?
- At which construction stage will the title deeds be issued? Is the number of collateral units sufficient?
- Who will obtain the occupancy permit (iskân), and who shall bear the costs?
- Does the contractor have sufficient financial strength, reference projects, and a bank letter of guarantee?
- Is the contractor restricted from transferring the work or subcontracting?
- In the event of a dispute, have the competent court and the expert witness method been determined?
For the selection of a contractor: Points to Consider When Choosing a Contracting Company.
2026 Court of Cassation Decisions
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Chamber, date, merit no., and decision no. | Subject | Principle and outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 6th Civil Chamber, 03.06.2026, E. 2025/3570, K. 2026/2345 | Collateral units and the occupancy permit | If sufficient collateral remains at the 97.65% level, registration of the requested portion is required; reversal. |
| 6th Civil Chamber, 10.06.2026, E. 2025/3351, K. 2026/2508 | Those purchasing from the landowner and the contractor | Those purchasing from the landowner may file a lawsuit via assignment; for those purchasing from the contractor, the consumer court has jurisdiction; upheld (by majority vote). |
| 6th Civil Chamber, 01.07.2026, E. 2026/504, K. 2026/2961 | Rate of incomplete work and determination report | If there is no percentage of completion, the completion rate is determined by an expert; the calculation based on the determination report was upheld. |
| General Assembly of Civil Chambers, 16.09.2026, E. 2026/97, K. 2026/507 | Incomplete work, defective work, delay, and penalty clauses | Withdrawal of the lawsuit at the General Assembly of Civil Chambers stage; decision rendered due to withdrawal. |
| General Assembly of Civil Chambers, 16.09.2026, E. 2026/587, K. 2026/508 | Invalidity of the contract in terms of form and authority | The operative part of the decision of the resistance was examined in terms of Article 297 of the HMK. |
| 1st Civil Chamber, 24.09.2026, E. 2026/6877, K. 2026/6411 | Competent chamber | The file was sent to the 6th Civil Chamber in accordance with the 29.06.2026, 2026/1 division of work of the Board of Civil Chambers. |
Selection method: The decisions were selected by reading the texts from the searches conducted in November 2026 in the UYAP Precedent Decision Search using the phrases “land share for construction,” “cost of incomplete work,” “termination with prospective effect,” “loss of rent,” and “cost of incomplete and defective work.”
Frequently Asked Questions
The contractor left work incomplete; what can I do?
First, have a determination of evidence conducted by the civil court of peace. Then, give a deadline for the completion of the deficiencies via a notarial warning notice. If not completed, you may seek the cost of the incomplete work, loss of rent for the delay, and any applicable penalty clause through litigation.
Within what period can a lawsuit be filed for defective work?
For immovable structures, five years from delivery, and twenty years if there is gross negligence on the part of the contractor. However, defects must be notified to the contractor without delay after delivery or when they appear.
Must I surrender the title deeds if the contractor does not obtain the occupancy permit?
You may withhold the title deeds of the independent units intended to be kept as collateral until the occupancy permit is obtained and deficiencies are rectified (Article 97 of the TBK). However, if the collateral you hold is sufficient, keeping the other units may not be considered justified (6th Civil Chamber 2026/2345).
How are the costs for incomplete work calculated?
If you had the deficiencies completed yourself, it is generally calculated based on the free market prices at the time of completion; if not, it is calculated based on the market prices at the date of the lawsuit. Keep your invoices and payment documents.
Can I terminate the construction contract for land share?
If the contractor does not start the work, delays the work significantly, or acts in breach of the contract, you may grant an appropriate deadline and exercise your right of termination. If the construction is at an advanced stage, the termination is generally prospective, and the contractor becomes entitled to payment in proportion to the work performed.
Can I sue the contractor for defects in the apartment I purchased from the landowner?
You cannot file it directly. You must take an assignment of the rights arising from the land share construction contract from the landowner or file the lawsuit jointly with the landowner (6th Civil Chamber, 10.06.2026, E. 2025/3351, K. 2026/2508).
Conclusion
In land share construction, the landowner’s strongest tools are: timely notification of defects, determination of evidence, keeping a proportionate amount of collateral units, and exercising alternative rights at the right time. Having deficiencies completed without a determination report, notifying defects late, signing the delivery record without reservations, and withholding more title deeds than necessary are the main errors leading to loss of rights in 2026 decisions.
Related articles
- What Happens If the Contractor Does Not Deliver the Apartment?
- Istanbul Urban Transformation Construction Contract
- Risky Building Assessment Process
- Transfer of Zoning Rights
Sources
- Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Article 97, 117, 123–125, 146, 179–182, 470–478, 484
- Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, Article 5/A, 22
- Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Article 297, 400 et seq.
- Law No. 6306 on the Transformation of Areas under Disaster Risk
- The Court of Cassation decisions included in the table above (Supreme Court Decision Search)
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.