Precedent decision reviews
Drugs Found in a Package Opened by a Courier Not Considered Evidence: Yargıtay Overturns Conviction
In this article 13 headings
- Short Answer: What Happens If Drugs Are Found in Cargo and the Courier Opened the Package?
- Citation of the Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber Decision
- How Did the Dispute Begin? From Suspicious Cargo Shipment to Reporting
- Why Did the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) Consider Drugs in Cargo as Unlawful Evidence?
- Why Was CMK 129 Decisive in This File?
- Unlawful Evidence in a Cargo Shipment: Three Different Scenarios
- Where and How Was the Case Tried?
- What Does the Reversal Decision Mean?
- Which Points Should Be Examined in a Similar Case File?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion: Who Opened the Package in the Cargo Shipment Determines the Result
- Legal Resources and Related Reviews
- Author and Legal Information
Publication: · Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.
Short Answer: What Happens If Drugs Are Found in Cargo and the Courier Opened the Package?
The fact that the courier detects the drugs inside by opening the package on their own initiative makes this substance neither evidence of the crime nor the subject matter of the crime; because a finding obtained by a person who does not have the authority to investigate and prosecute is unlawful evidence. In its decision dated February 5, 2026, numbered E. 2025/6055, K. 2026/1115, the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay applied this principle to the concrete case in a manner resulting in an acquittal for drug-related charges in a shipment. A cargo company employee grew suspicious of two packages dropped off by the same person, opened one of them, found narcotic substances inside, and reported it to law enforcement. Upon this report, the Public Prosecutor issued a search and seizure warrant based on CMK 116 and subsequent articles. However, the Yargıtay determined that the package had been opened by an unauthorized person for the first time. In accordance with CMK 129, a shipment at a postal service provider may only be seized by a decision of a judge, or a public prosecutor in cases where delay is hazardous; the cargo employee had no authority to open the package.
The Chamber unanimously overturned the conviction and ordered the defendant's release, stating that the substance obtained unlawfully could serve neither as evidence nor as the material subject of the verdict. The result does not mean that drugs in every cargo shipment will lead to an acquittal; what is decisive here is that the package was opened by unauthorized persons. For the general framework related to the subject, you may refer to the article on acquittal for drug trafficking., for concepts of evidence law, to the article on what is digital evidence and for the legal framework regarding unlawful searches, to our article on unlawful searches For the penalty, elements, execution of the crime, and its consequences for foreigners, please refer to the guide on the crime of drug trafficking. can be consulted.
Citation of the Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber Decision
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Title | Information |
|---|---|
| Court | 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation |
| Basis and decision number | E. 2025/6055, K. 2026/1115 |
| Decision date | 05.02.2026 |
| First instance court | Siirt 3rd High Criminal Court, E. 2025/495, K. 2025/1259 |
| Regional Court of Justice | Diyarbakır Regional Court of Justice 10th Criminal Chamber, dismissal of the appeal on the merits |
| Subject of the lawsuit | Drug trafficking under TCK 188/3 |
| Opinion of the Prosecutor’s Office (Tebliğname) | Reversal |
| Conclusion | Reversal and release of the defendant |
| Vote status | Unanimous |
How Did the Dispute Begin? From Suspicious Cargo Shipment to Reporting
The starting point of the dispute is a cargo company employee becoming suspicious of two separate shipments left by the same individual. The employee, on their own initiative, opened one of the packages sent to an Istanbul address, found narcotic substances inside, and reported it to law enforcement. Based on this report, the Public Prosecutor issued a search and seizure warrant pursuant to CMK 116 and subsequent articles. The defendant was tried and convicted of the crime of drug trafficking at the Siirt 3rd High Criminal Court. The decision became final for two other defendants who did not appeal.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Stage | Development | Legal consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Finding | The cargo employee grew suspicious of two packages from the same sender and opened one. | This is an intervention made without a seizure warrant issued in accordance with CMK 129. |
| Report | The employee informed law enforcement that they found drugs inside. | The Public Prosecutor issued a search and seizure warrant in accordance with CMK 116 et seq. |
| Trial | The Siirt 3rd High Criminal Court convicted the defendant pursuant to TCK 188/3. | The conviction decision was based on the cargo employee's findings and the prosecutor's warrant. |
| Appeal (Istinaf) | The Diyarbakır Regional Court of Justice 10th Criminal Chamber dismissed the appeal on the merits. | The decision of the court of first instance was upheld. |
| Appeal on points of law (cassation) | The defense counsel appealed; the notification (Tebliğname) also expressed an opinion in favor of reversal. | The 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay unanimously overturned the conviction. |
It is observed that five separate objections were raised in the appeal petition of the defendant's counsel: that the elements of the crime were not formed, that the evaluation of evidence was performed erroneously, that there was an incomplete investigation because the witnesses to the report were not heard, that the decision was contrary to procedure and law, and that evidence was gathered unlawfully. The Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor at the Yargıtay also expressed an opinion for reversal in its notification, while the request for a hearing was rejected pursuant to CMK 299/1.
Why Did the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) Consider Drugs in Cargo as Unlawful Evidence?
The reasoning of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay is based on three legal findings. The Chamber connected these findings to conclude that the substance could serve neither as evidence nor as the material subject of the verdict.
The first observation is that a cargo employee lacks the authority for investigation and prosecution. The Criminal Procedure Code (CMK) No. 5271 grants the authority to collect evidence to the public prosecutor and the law enforcement officers acting under the prosecutor's orders and instructions. A cargo company employee does not fall within this framework of authority; they have the right to report, but they do not have the authority to open a shipment that constitutes mail. The employee opening the package based on suspicion is an intervention that exceeds legal limits, and the findings obtained as a result of this intervention constitute unlawfully obtained evidence.
The second observation is that the seizure of a cargo shipment and the opening of the package are subject to the procedure in CMK Article 129. Article 129 of the Law regulates that shipments in organizations providing postal services may be seized by the decision of a judge, or a public prosecutor in cases where delay is hazardous. In the concrete case, there was no such decision at the time the package was opened; the opening of the cargo shipment was based on neither a judicial decision nor a prosecutor's decision. The search and seizure decision issued by the public prosecutor was given after the report and did not render the opening of the package lawful; because the unlawfulness occurred with the act of the cargo employee prior to the prosecutor's decision.
The third observation is that a substance obtained through unlawful means cannot be taken as the basis for a verdict as either evidence of a crime or the subject matter of the crime. This principle is a well-established rule in Yargıtay practice, derived from CMK Articles 206/2-a, 217/2, and 230/1. In the concrete case, the narcotic substance found in the package opened by the cargo employee is the sole and decisive evidence of the case; when this evidence is excluded, there is no finding left to constitute the subject matter of the crime. If the subject matter of the crime does not exist, the elements of the crime are not formed.
Cargo employees, who lack the authority of investigation and prosecution, obtained evidence without judicial authority and by exceeding legal boundaries. This evidence is unlawful and cannot be used as a basis for conviction. There is also no seizure order for mail issued under CMK Article 129.
The Chamber, evaluating these three observations together, concluded that the conviction was unlawful and unanimously overturned the decision of the Diyarbakır Regional Court of Justice in accordance with CMK Article 302/2. Along with the reversal decision, it was decided to write to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office for the release of the defendant, provided that they are not convicted or detained for another offense. The provisions for extension were also applied to two defendants who did not appeal the verdict.
Why Was CMK 129 Decisive in This File?
CMK Article 129 regulates the seizure of shipments found in any official or private organization providing postal services. According to the first paragraph of the article, shipments suspected of constituting evidence of a crime and deemed necessary to be under the disposal of the judiciary to uncover the truth may be seized by the decision of a judge, or a public prosecutor in cases where delay is hazardous. The second paragraph stipulates that law enforcement officers executing the seizure cannot open the envelopes or packages; the shipments are to be sealed and delivered to the judge or prosecutor who issued the decision. The third paragraph regulates that in certain crimes such as drug trafficking, provided there is a seizure decision or order, the package may be opened by law enforcement under the instruction of the public prosecutor.
In the concrete case, no stage of this process was followed. The person who opened the package was neither a judge, a prosecutor, nor a law enforcement officer; it was an employee of a courier company. While the employee has the right to report based on suspicion, they lack the authority to physically open and inspect the contents of a shipment. Since the article covers every type of public or private institution providing postal services, shipments at courier companies are also subject to this provision. This assessment is also consistent with Article 22 of the Constitution, which protects the freedom of communication and the privacy of correspondence.
This approach by the Chamber is also indicative of how courier employees should behave in cases of suspicion of a crime. The employee should report the suspicious shipment to law enforcement or the Public Prosecutor without opening it, and subsequently, the shipment should be opened by the authorized authorities within the scope of CMK 129. Any action to the contrary poses the risk of the evidence being considered unlawfully obtained, and this risk materialized in the concrete file. This principle in the article examining the rules of evidence collection in criminal proceedings is also seen to overlap with the general framework addressed.
Unlawful Evidence in a Cargo Shipment: Three Different Scenarios
The legal consequence of seizing drugs from a courier shipment changes depending on how and by whom the substance was accessed. The table below compares the framework established by the reviewed decision with two different scenarios, showing the variables that affect the outcome.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Scenario | Person opening the package | Compliance with CMK 129 | Status of evidence | Possible outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reviewed decision (E. 2025/6055) | Courier employee, on their own initiative | No judge decision, no prosecutor order | Unlawfully obtained evidence; neither evidence nor subject matter | Reversal of conviction |
| Employee reports, prosecutor issues seizure order | Law enforcement, upon instructions of the Public Prosecutor | Conditions of CMK 129/1 and 129/3 are met | Lawfully obtained evidence | Conviction possible if other conditions are met |
| Seizure with a judge's decision | Law enforcement, upon instructions of the prosecutor following a judge's seizure order | Conditions of CMK 129/1 and 129/3 are met | Lawfully obtained evidence | Conviction possible if other conditions are met |
The scenario in the first row of the table corresponds to the facts in the reviewed decision. In the second and third scenarios, the difference lies in the fact that the method of accessing the substance remains within the legal framework. There is a threshold in between: the difference between a courier employee reporting a package and opening it determines the legal nature of the evidence and, consequently, the outcome of the case. The practical implication of this is that the process starting with a report must be conducted within the scope of CMK 129; otherwise, the chain of unlawfulness cannot be remedied even by a subsequent search warrant issued by the prosecutor's office.
The issue of unlawfully obtained evidence addressed in this decision is also connected to other files examined in the same series. The article examining the dismissal of evidence due to the expiration of the search warrant period demonstrates a similar principle in a different plot; the common point in both files is that the procedural irregularity in the manner the evidence was obtained directly affects the result. The subject also has a connection with the guide section explaining effective remorse in drug crimes: the difference between the defendant voluntarily surrendering the evidence and the evidence being found by an unauthorized person differentiates the sentence reduction mechanisms.
Where and How Was the Case Tried?
The crime of drug trafficking falls under the jurisdiction of the high criminal court in accordance with Law No. 5235. The first instance trial was conducted at the Siirt 3rd High Criminal Court, and the defendant was convicted pursuant to TCK 188/3. The Diyarbakır Regional Court of Justice 10th Criminal Chamber rejected the appeal on the merits. Upon the appeal application by the defendant's counsel, the file came to the Yargıtay 10th Criminal Chamber, and the Chamber reviewed the file on the record; the request for a hearing was rejected at the discretion of the court pursuant to CMK 299/1.
The 10th Criminal Chamber is the specialized chamber at the Yargıtay (Court of Cassation) that handles drug-related offenses. It rendered its decision unanimously and in accordance with the prosecutor's opinion (Tebliğname). The case file has been submitted to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office at the Yargıtay to be sent to the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Diyarbakır Regional Court of Justice (Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi), pursuant to Article 304/2-b of the CMK (Criminal Procedure Code). It was also decided that a separate writ be issued for the release of the defendant in accordance with the reversal decision. The provisions of extension (sirayet) were applied to the other two defendants who did not appeal the judgment, thereby extending the effect of the reversal decision to them as well.
In a similar file, the following point regarding the statute of limitations must also be considered: the statute of limitations for drug crimes is calculated according to Articles 66 and 67 of the TCK (Turkish Penal Code) and generally covers a long period of time. However, the time spent in detention is separately considered in the evaluation of the defendant's release request. In the reviewed file, the fact that a release decision was issued along with the reversal decision signifies that the conditions requiring the continuation of detention have ceased to exist.
What Does the Reversal Decision Mean?
The Yargıtay's reversal decision does not mean that the defendant is definitively acquitted; it requires the file to be sent to the Diyarbakır Regional Court of Justice. However, the nature of the grounds for reversal makes the outcome largely predictable: since the sole evidence in the file is considered unlawful, a conviction cannot be established unless new evidence is obtained. The concrete results of the reversal decision can be summarized as follows:
- The defendant shall be released immediately, provided they are not a convict or detainee for another crime; a writ has been issued to the Chief Public Prosecutor's Office regarding this matter.
- The file will return to the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Diyarbakır BAM and will be re-evaluated; the Regional Court of Justice is bound by the Yargıtay's determination of unlawful evidence.
- Since a decision of extension was made regarding the two defendants who did not appeal the judgment, the effect of the reversal has been extended to these defendants as well.
- The unauthorized opening act by the courier employee has been registered as a violation of CMK 129; this determination serves as a precedent for similar files.
It is also necessary to determine the scope of the decision: The Chamber does not state that the presence of drugs in a cargo shipment will lead to acquittal in every case. The determining factor here is by whom and under what authority the package was opened. A finding obtained as a result of an action taken by an authorized authority within the scope of CMK 129 may be evaluated as lawful evidence. The difference between unauthorized intervention and authorized action is the fundamental distinction in this file.
Which Points Should Be Examined in a Similar Case File?
- It must be meticulously determined who opened the cargo shipment; was the package opened by law enforcement, the courier employee, or the recipient or sender? The actor of the opening act directly determines the legal nature of the evidence.
- It should be investigated whether the shipment was seized pursuant to CMK 129 by the decision of a judge, or a public prosecutor in cases where delay is hazardous. It must be further checked from the records by whom and under whose instruction the package was opened.
- It must be clarified in the timeline whether the search warrant was issued before or after the courier employee's report; in the reviewed file, the prosecutor's decision was issued after the report, and this was insufficient to remedy the unlawfulness.
- It must be evaluated whether there is any other evidence left in the file when the unlawful evidence is excluded; in the reviewed file, when the substance in the cargo package, which is the sole evidence, is excluded, the material subject of the crime also disappears.
- The applicability of the provisions of extension must be checked; defendants who did not appeal the judgment may also benefit from the reversal decision, as was the path used in the reviewed file.
- Of the defendant effective remorse whether they can benefit from the provisions of [the law] must also be evaluated; the position of a defendant who voluntarily surrendered the evidence is different from that of a defendant whose evidence was found by unauthorized persons.
Frequently Asked Questions
If a courier finds drugs in a package, does this count as evidence?
According to the examined decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), it does not. Findings obtained by a courier who lacks investigation and prosecution authority by opening the package on their own initiative constitute unlawful evidence and cannot be used as a basis for conviction.
Does a search warrant subsequently issued by the public prosecutor remedy the illegality?
In the examined file, it did not. The illegality occurred through the act of the courier prior to the prosecutor's decision; a subsequently issued search warrant does not render the finding, which was already obtained unlawfully, legally compliant.
Who can open a cargo shipment under CMK 129?
In accordance with CMK 129, shipments at a postal service provider may be seized upon the decision of a judge or, in cases where delay is disadvantageous, the public prosecutor. Law enforcement officers performing the seizure cannot, as a rule, open the package; in cases of suspicion of drug trafficking, the package may be opened by law enforcement under the instruction of the public prosecutor. This authority is not granted to the courier.
If unlawful evidence is detected in a cargo shipment, is the defendant automatically acquitted?
An automatic acquittal is not the case; however, if there is no other evidence remaining in the file once the unlawful evidence is excluded, as in the examined file, the elements of the crime are not established. If there is other independent and legally obtained evidence in the file, conviction may still be possible.
How were the provisions on extension (sirayet) applied in this decision?
Although there were convictions that had become final for two defendants who did not appeal the verdict, a decision of extension was issued because the reason for the reversal was of a common nature. Thus, the effect of the reversal was extended to the defendants who had not filed an appeal.
What should a courier do with a suspicious shipment?
According to the principle established by the examined decision, the courier should report the suspicious shipment to law enforcement or the public prosecutor without opening it. Subsequently, the shipment should be seized in accordance with CMK 129, and the package should be opened under the instruction of the competent authority; any intervention contrary to this poses a risk of unlawful evidence.
Which court has jurisdiction in a drug trafficking case?
The crime of drug trafficking within the scope of TCK 188 falls under the jurisdiction of the Heavy Penal Court (Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi) pursuant to Law No. 5235. In the examined file, the trial was conducted at the Siirt 3rd Heavy Penal Court, and the appeal review was carried out by the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay).
Conclusion: Who Opened the Package in the Cargo Shipment Determines the Result
The decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay dated February 5, 2026, has once again confirmed that the fate of evidence concerning narcotics sent via cargo depends on the manner in which the substance is accessed. The unauthorized intervention of a cargo employee signifies a bypass of the seizure and opening procedures mandated by CMK 129, and the consequence of this omission is the classification of the evidence as unlawful. In the case file examined, this result eliminated both the evidence and the material subject of the crime, leading to the reversal of the conviction judgment.
The boundary drawn by the decision is clear: the distinction between the right to report and the authority to collect evidence determines the legality of the process. When a cargo employee is suspicious, the correct procedure is not to open the package but to notify the competent authorities. This principle renders the connection between Article 22 of the Constitution, which protects the privacy of correspondence, and CMK 129 visible in a concrete case. The result should not be interpreted as if every narcotic shipment will lead to an acquittal; the decisive factor here is the procedural irregularity in the manner the evidence was obtained.
Legal Resources and Related Reviews
Legislation
- Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237, Art. 188/3 (drug trafficking).
- Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271, Art. 116-119 (search), Art. 129 (seizure of mail), Art. 206/2-a, 217/2 and 230/1 (prohibition of unlawful evidence), Art. 299, 302, 304.
- Constitution, Art. 22 (freedom of communication).
Court of Cassation Decisions
The list contains the decision examined in this article; for all compared and cited decisions, the relevant articles of the same series can be consulted.
- Court of Cassation 10th Criminal Chamber, E. 2025/6055, K. 2026/1115, T. 05.02.2026
İlgili Yazılar
- Acquittal Decision in Drug Trafficking
- Detection Periods of Substances in Blood and Hair
- What is Digital Evidence and What Is Its Impact in Courts?
- What Is Unlawful Search? (TCK 120)
- Collecting Evidence in Criminal Proceedings
- Drug Trafficking Offense (TCK 188): Penalty, Elements, Prosecution, and Enforcement
- Drugs Discovered After the Expiry of the Search Warrant Are No Longer Admissible as Evidence: Yargıtay
- In-Vehicle Footage Recorded by an Undercover Agent Ruled Unlawful: Yargıtay Overturns Conviction
- Cannabis Greenhouse Set Up at Home: General Assembly of Criminal Chambers Rules It Was for Personal Use
- Phone Search Conducted with Consent Ruled a Violation of CMK 134: Yargıtay Overturns Conviction
Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registration No: 77008
This text is a legal decision analysis based on the decision of the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay dated 05.02.2026, E. 2025/6055, K. 2026/1115. The analysis is limited to the published text of the decision; it does not imply that the same result will be obtained in other cases.
The contents on this page are for general information purposes and are open for use by all our colleagues. However, in accordance with the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, if all or a portion of this text is used, we kindly request that you provide a citation in the form of 'Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr' and include a link to the relevant article.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.