Precedent decision reviews

Compensation for Unjust Administrative Detention: Yargıtay Overturned by Recognizing the Judicial Judiciary as Authorized

In this article 15 headings
  1. Short Answer: Unjust administrative detention
  2. Citation of the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation Decision
  3. How Did the Dispute Begin? 29 Days of Detention and Two Rounds of Litigation
  4. What Did the Plaintiff and Defendant Argue Regarding Jurisdiction?
  5. Why Did the Court of Cassation Reverse the Procedural Dismissal of the Case?
  6. What Did the Reversal Decision Resolve, and What Was Left Open?
  7. Do Civil, Criminal, and Administrative Court Decisions Answer the Same Question?
  8. What Did the Constitutional Court Say in the K.N. Pilot Decision?
  9. Which Paths Were Tried in the Decisions? Jurisdiction Risk and Loss of Time
  10. The Reversal Decision Is Not the End of the Case
  11. What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?
  12. Frequently Asked Questions
  13. Conclusion: The Question of Jurisdiction Points to the Judicial Courts, the Question of Compensation Remains Open
  14. Legal Resources and Related Reviews
  15. Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Written and reviewed by: Atty. Batın Yılmaz (Istanbul Bar Association, Reg. No: 77008)
Publication:  ·  Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.

Short Answer: Unjust administrative detention

unjust administrative detention

According to the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation and the Court of Jurisdictional Disputes, a lawsuit for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages filed due to unjust administrative detention is heard in the judicial courts. This is the strongest basis regarding jurisdiction. However, in the pilot decision rendered before these two rulings, the Constitutional Court determined that there is no effective remedy. Therefore, a definitive roadmap cannot be established.

The Chamber, on December 16, 2025, stated that the case would be heard in a judicial court in its decision numbered E. 2024/32, K. 2025/16829 stated. In the file, the foreigner, whose deportation process was cancelled by the administrative court, had requested compensation by stating that they were held at the Van Removal Center for 29 days. The court of first instance deemed the administrative judiciary to be the authorized body and rejected the case on procedural grounds; the appeal application was also rejected on the merits. The Yargıtay unanimously overturned the appellate decision and reversed the first instance decision.

This reversal does not mean that the plaintiff has won the compensation, because the Chamber has only resolved the jurisdiction issue and sent the file back to the court of first instance. The decisions of the 12th Criminal Chamber of the Yargıtay and the Danıştay provide answers to other questions. The 12th Criminal Chamber did not accept compensation via the CMK art. 141 path, and the 10th Chamber of the Danıştay used the classification of full remedy action in its decisions regarding duty and jurisdiction within the administrative judiciary, and did not discuss the jurisdiction of the judicial courts. The Anayasa Mahkemesi, on the other hand, in its K.N. decision found the problem to be structural and notified the situation to the TBMM without determining the authorized body.

This review is based on published decision texts. The appeal path followed for exit from the center is in the administrative detention objection letter, while the lawsuit against the deportation decision is in the guide for the cancellation of deportation decisions explained in the article on the open prison execution process.

Citation of the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation Decision

Title Information
Court Yargıtay 4th Civil Chamber
Basis and decision number E. 2024/32, K. 2025/16829
Decision date 16.12.2025
Appellate decision Van Regional Court of Justice 2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2023/1292, K. 2023/808
First instance decision Van 3rd Civil Court of First Instance, E. 2023/259, K. 2023/272
Request 100 TL pecuniary and 10,000 TL non-pecuniary damages, rights regarding the excess reserved
Appellate question Authorized judicial venue
Conclusion Overturning the appellate decision, reversing the first instance decision
Vote status Unanimous
Finalization There is no expression of "final" in the decision; finality is not understood from the text

How Did the Dispute Begin? 29 Days of Detention and Two Rounds of Litigation

The Van Governorate Provincial Directorate of Migration Management decided on the deportation and administrative detention of the foreign national plaintiff with an action dated March 30, 2022. The plaintiff was sent to the Van Removal Center and remained in administrative detention for 29 days. In the lawsuit filed against the deportation decision, the administrative court cancelled the action. Based on this cancellation, the plaintiff claimed that the detention was unjust and in accordance with Law No. 6458 on Foreigners and International Protection requested damages resulting from the decision taken.

Date Development Legal Significance
30.03.2022 Van Governorate Provincial Directorate of Migration Management action Deportation and administrative detention decision taken
Not in text Van 1st Administrative Court, E. 2022/1285, K. 2022/1898 Deportation action cancelled
17.02.2023 Civil court of first instance, E. 2022/433, K. 2023/70 Case partially accepted, 10,000 TL non-pecuniary compensation awarded with interest from 29.04.2022
12.05.2023 Regional Court of Justice, E. 2023/657, K. 2023/441 Appeal accepted, decision overturned, case sent back for re-trial
Not in text Civil court of first instance, E. 2023/259, K. 2023/272 Administrative judiciary deemed authorized, case rejected on procedural grounds
Not in text Van Regional Court of Justice, E. 2023/1292, K. 2023/808 Plaintiff's appeal rejected on the merits
16.12.2025 Yargıtay Decision of reversal regarding jurisdiction was rendered

Lines without historical dates have been placed in the order of the decision's narrative. The date of the annulment decision is not in the text, but since the plaintiff asserted the annulment in the petition, it is understood that the lawsuit was filed after this decision. The reasoning for the removal dated 12 May 2023 by the Regional Court of Justice is also not included in the decision.

What Did the Plaintiff and Defendant Argue Regarding Jurisdiction?

The plaintiff's attorney argued during the appeal that the judicial judiciary is the competent venue for compensation lawsuits regarding administrative detention measures. The attorney stated that although there is no Jurisdictional Dispute Court decision regarding this specific file, the court has indicated in many of its decisions that the judicial judiciary is the place of resolution. He added that the Constitutional Court decision relied upon by the Regional Court of Justice was dated, and that there are also decisions by the Van Regional Court of Justice that consider the judicial judiciary as the competent authority.

The defendant's attorney requested the dismissal of the lawsuit due to lack of standing, lack of jurisdiction, limitation periods, and statute of limitations, and argued that the Provincial Directorate of Migration Management's action was appropriate. The Yargıtay decision does not contain an evaluation regarding these defenses other than the lack of jurisdiction, nor does it explicitly state who the defendant is.

The numbers of the Jurisdictional Dispute Court decisions relied upon by the plaintiff are not in the text. The K.N. decision exemplifies this jurisprudence with decisions dated 23.11.2020 E. 2020/651, K. 2020/684 and dated 19.06.2023 E. 2023/176, K. 2023/482 (§§ 23-24). As the full text of these decisions has not been read, they are mentioned only by that citation.

Why Did the Court of Cassation Reverse the Procedural Dismissal of the Case?

The Chamber defined the dispute as a compensation claim by a foreigner who alleges that their right to liberty and security was violated due to an unfair administrative detention decision. The reasoning has three pillars, all of which are combined in a single sentence:

  1. The request does not fall under the scope of criminal procedure. The Chamber stated that the request Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271 is not within the scope of.
  2. The authority to apply against detention is the magistrate judge (sulh ceza hâkimi). The Chamber relied on the Law No. 6458 without citing the article number. According to the sixth paragraph of Article 57 on this matter, the relevant person, their legal representative, or attorney may apply to the magistrate judge, and the judge shall conclude the examination within five days and the decision is final.
  3. Compensation arising from the same action is also heard in the judicial judiciary. According to the Chamber, since the review of the detention decision is left to the judicial authority, pecuniary and non-pecuniary compensation lawsuits arising from this action also belong to the judicial judiciary.

“...it being understood that the request does not fall within the scope of Law No. 5271, and that it is regulated in Law No. 6458 that an application shall be made to the magistrate judge against the administrative detention decision, and that lawsuits for pecuniary and non-pecuniary compensation arising from the same action shall also be heard in the judicial venue...”

The Chamber did not use the word “competent” for the judicial judiciary, but said it “shall be heard in the judicial venue” and overturned the decision that considered the administrative judiciary as competent by calling it “not appropriate.” The decision does not contain an explicit evaluation regarding the nature of administrative detention as an administrative action, Pursuant to the provisions of the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577 its Article 2, or Constitutional Court decisions.

What Did the Reversal Decision Resolve, and What Was Left Open?

The only question the decision resolves is the judicial path; the actual questions regarding compensation are open.

Does the Annulment of the Deportation Decision Automatically Make the Detention Unfair?

The phrase “that the administrative detention decision is revealed to be unfair” appears in the decision. However, this phrase is within a sentence describing the allegation with which the lawsuit was filed and is completed with the words “with the claim of.” For this reason, it should not be read as a determination of the Chamber on the merits. The decision does not contain an explicit evaluation as to whether the annulment of the deportation action automatically renders the detention unlawful.

The question is important because the administrative court reviews the deportation decision, the magistrate judge reviews the detention decision, and the results of the two reviews may diverge. In the Jurisdictional Dispute Court file The deportation decision was cancelled by the administrative court, while the application made to the criminal judgeship of peace against administrative detention was rejected. How these two results are to be reconciled in a compensation lawsuit is not resolved in the examined decisions.

Deportation decision grounds of public order or country of origin information can be cancelled for various reasons such as. Since the justification for the cancellation is not included in the Yargıtay decision, the connection between the cancellation and the administrative detention cannot be established from the text.

Which Court in the Judicial Judiciary Will Hear the Case?

The Chamber stated that the case would be heard in the “judicial jurisdiction” but did not specify the type of court. Although the return of the file to the civil court of first instance and the exclusion of the request from the scope of Law No. 5271 point to the legal channel, the sentence “the civil court of first instance is authorized” is not present in the decision. The Court of Jurisdictional Disputes also explicitly stated that it does not have the authority to determine which authority within the judicial judiciary is authorized. The Constitutional Court, on the other hand, points to the ambiguity between heavy penal courts, criminal judgeships of peace, and general civil courts (K.N., § 42).

What Does the 10.000 TL Awarded by the First Instance Mean?

The Constitutional Court states regarding judicial authorities examining similar cases on their merits that “no data could be reached indicating that the compensation claim was accepted” (K.N., § 42). In the examined file, the civil court of first instance had ruled for 10.000 TL in non-pecuniary damages on February 17, 2023. Since this ruling was overturned during the appellate process, it is not an example of an acceptance that remained standing, but it shows a stage where the civil court adjudicated such a file on its merits.

Do Civil, Criminal, and Administrative Court Decisions Answer the Same Question?

The table below summarizes selected decisions; it is not a count and should not be read as a success rate. The decisions are not three separate answers to the same question, as most of them addressed a different procedural issue.

Ruling Status in the file Conclusion Effect on the question of jurisdiction
Yargıtay 4. HD, E. 2024/32, K. 2025/16829 (16.12.2025) Deportation procedure cancelled, 29 days of administrative detention Reversal, unanimous vote Judicial judiciary; request outside of 5271
Court of Jurisdictional Disputes, E. 2026/12, K. 2026/85 (16.02.2026) Administrative and judicial courts declared themselves unauthorized Unanimous, final Judicial judiciary; did not specify court type
12. CD, E. 2022/5310, K. 2025/828 (21.01.2025) Objections to administrative detention rejected, detention of approximately one year alleged Upholding, unanimous CMK Art. 141/1 and 141/3 do not apply
12. CD, E. 2022/7270, K. 2025/24 (06.01.2025) Criminal judgeship of peace ended the administrative detention Approval contrary to the notification, unanimous Legal conditions not met; jurisdiction not discussed
12. CD, E. 2021/7896, K. 2023/2148 (13.06.2023) The case is based on the decisions of the judge who rejected the objection Upholding, unanimous A decision by a criminal judgeship of peace is not an investigation or prosecution decision
Danıştay 10. D., E. 2024/6453, K. 2024/6832 (25.12.2024) Jurisdiction dispute between two administrative courts Adana Administrative Court authorized, unanimous, final Characterization as “full remedy”; the jurisdiction of the judicial judiciary was not discussed
Danıştay 10. D., E. 2020/5704, K. 2020/4941 (16.11.2020) Objection accepted, deportation procedure cancelled with finality Dismissal by the Council of State regarding its own jurisdiction, file sent to Muğla, unanimous, final Characterization as “full remedy”; the jurisdiction of the judicial judiciary was not discussed

Four conclusions can be drawn from these decisions:

  • The Yargıtay and the Court of Jurisdictional Disputes are on the same line. Both exclude the request from Law No. 5271 and leave the compensation arising from the same procedure to the judicial judiciary.
  • The criminal channel did not yield results in the examined Yargıtay decisions. In the decision E. 2022/5310, the 12th Criminal Chamber stated that the transaction was administrative and no protective measure was applied, while in the decision E. 2022/7270, it only stated that the legal conditions were not met. In the file E. 2021/7896, it stated that the decisions of the criminal judgeship of peace did not have the character of "decisions rendered during a criminal investigation or prosecution," stated that the conditions of CMK m. 141/3 were not met, and found the dismissal on jurisdictional grounds correct in terms of its result. The justification pointing to the administrative judiciary in that file belongs to the court of first instance. Since the Chamber did not issue a ruling indicating the administrative judiciary as the competent authority, there is no direct contradiction with the 4th Civil Chamber.
  • Decisions of the Council of State do not resolve the judicial-administrative distinction. What is discussed in these decisions is the duty and authority within the administrative judiciary. The decision E. 2020/5704 is seven days prior to the Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi decision dated 23.11.2020 mentioned in K.N. The decision E. 2024/6453 was rendered after that jurisprudence, but did not address the possibility of the judicial judiciary. Therefore, neither should be read as jurisprudence contrary to the line of the Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi.
  • The main divergence is at the level of regional courts. According to the K.N. decision, the Antalya Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi considered the judicial judiciary competent, while the Van Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi 2nd Civil Chamber considered the administrative judiciary competent in its 2025 decision (§ 27). The appellate decision overturned in the main judgment also belongs to the same Chamber.

What Did the Constitutional Court Say in the K.N. Pilot Decision?

The General Assembly of the Constitutional Court, on 20 November 2025, in its K.N. decision (App. No: 2022/8989, Official Gazette 22.05.2026, 33261) examined the same issue. The applicant had been released when the criminal judgeship of peace accepted the objection. The administrative court dismissed the compensation lawsuit on jurisdictional grounds, relying on the Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi decision. The criminal judgeship of peace also dismissed the compensation application on jurisdictional grounds, pointing to the high criminal court for the judicial process and the administrative court for the administrative process (§ 13).

The Court recalled in its B.T. decision dated 2017 that it considered the full remedy action in the administrative judiciary an effective remedy and stated that this action could not be filed without objecting to the criminal judgeship of peace (§§ 39-40). After the decisions of the Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi, administrative courts began issuing dismissals on jurisdictional grounds, and different results emerged in the judicial judiciary (§ 42). According to the Court, the concerned parties remained "in a serious state of uncertainty" (§ 43). Consequently, it was accepted that "there is no effective administrative and judicial remedy" (§ 44), and the ninth paragraph of Article 19 of the Constitution, in conjunction with its second paragraph, was violated.

The pilot judgment procedure was applied in the ruling, the situation was notified to the TBMM, and the examination of similar applications was suspended for four months from the date of publication in the Official Gazette. The decision was rendered unanimously, and the applicant was awarded a net of 10,000 TL in non-pecuniary damages. The decision does not contain any expression determining the competent authority or directing the applicant to a specific court, and it is stated that a clear legal regulation is required. The remedy to be established must be able to determine whether the detention constitutes a violation of rights and must be able to provide compensation for damages if a violation exists (§ 56).

The decision does not state that compensation arises for every detention. The violation is based not on the illegality of the detention, but on the lack of a compensation remedy.

In our examination of the individual application against the deportation decision, also mentioned in in the Abdulkerim Mavvas decision The First Section had declared the complaint regarding unlawful detention inadmissible on 30 July 2025 due to the failure to file a compensation lawsuit (§§ 19-21). In the K.N. judgment, it was established at the General Assembly level that there is no effective remedy in this field. The Yargıtay decision was rendered approximately one month after the K.N. judgment; however, the K.N. judgment had not yet been published in the Official Gazette at that time, and the Yargıtay decision contains no evaluation regarding this judgment. The Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi decision dated 16 February 2026 is also prior to publication and does not contain a citation to K.N. The finding in K.N. is based on the practice existing prior to these two decisions.

Four Months Have Passed: Has the Law Been Enacted?

The suspension period expired on 22 September 2026, following the publication on 22 May 2026. The provision does not state what will happen at the end of the period, but it is stated in paragraph 52 of the judgment that if the problem is not resolved, similar applications may be decided collectively.

In a web search conducted in November 2026, no regulation establishing a new legal remedy for compensation for unlawful administrative detention was encountered. The source conveying the text of Law No. 7589, published in the Official Gazette dated 31 July 2026, also does not contain the phrase “administrative detention,” and neither Article 57 of Law No. 6458 nor Article 141 of the CMK is amended. This finding is valid within the scope of the search, and the current text of Law No. 6458 should be checked separately.

Which Paths Were Tried in the Decisions? Jurisdiction Risk and Loss of Time

According to the finding of the Anayasa Mahkemesi, there is no specific legal provision on this matter. The table below shows only the grounds and risks arising from the examined judgments; it is not a definitive recommendation of a path, and which path to follow must be evaluated separately in each concrete case.

Directions Grounds in the judgments Risk observed in the judgments
Civil court in the judicial judiciary Yargıtay 4th Civil Chamber; Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi E. 2026/12 Court type is not written in the judgments; civil courts have also issued decisions of lack of jurisdiction; there is no data on acceptance on the merits (K.N., § 42)
Full remedy action in the administrative court Classification by Danıştay 10th Chamber (without discussing the judicial judiciary); B.T. decision (not considered an effective remedy under the conditions present in K.N.) Six regional administrative court chambers mentioned in K.N. deemed it outside their scope of duty (§§ 25-26); a rejection based on jurisdiction was also issued in the Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi case file
Heavy Penal Court, CMK Art. 141 Ankara Regional Court of Justice 26th Penal Chamber decision mentioned in K.N. (§ 28) Yargıtay 12th Penal Chamber did not accept the request in three decisions; the 4th Civil Chamber and the Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi considered the request outside of 5271
Criminal judgeship of peace Only the supervision of detention (Art. 57/6) In the K.N. case file, the compensation application was rejected based on jurisdiction
Constitutional Court (Anayasa Mahkemesi) The finding in the K.N. judgment that there is no effective remedy Discussion on the exhaustion of legal remedies, suspension, and possible new law

How Much Time is Lost if a Conflict of Jurisdiction Occurs?

The clearest example is the Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi file. The detention lasted between 24 April and 17 December 2023. The administrative court indicated the judicial judiciary on 29 July 2024, and the appeal was rejected on 13 February 2025. The civil court of first instance indicated the administrative judiciary on 10 September 2025, and the appeal was rejected on 25 November 2025.

Once the rejection decisions in the two judicial branches became final, the plaintiff’s attorney Based on Article 14 of Law No. 2247, requested the resolution of the negative conflict of jurisdiction, and the Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi declared the judicial judiciary as the competent authority on 16 February 2026. Since the first decision of rejection based on jurisdiction in the file was dated 27 February 2024, only the judicial branch was determined in approximately two years.

How Will the Lawsuit Period Be Calculated?

None of the examined decisions have determined which limitation period applies to compensation for unlawful administrative detention. In the Yargıtay case file, the defendant raised a defense of statute of limitations and mandatory time limits, but the Chamber did not evaluate this matter. In the Danıştay case files, the plaintiffs first applied to the administration and filed a lawsuit following the implied rejection; however, whether this preliminary application is required in the judicial courts was not discussed in the decisions.

Article 9 of Law No. 2577 allows for the filing of a lawsuit in the competent court within 30 days from the day following the finalization of a decision in cases rejected due to lack of jurisdiction in the judicial judiciary, and deems the date of application to the non-competent judicial authority as the date of application to the administrative judiciary. The article only regulates the transition from judicial to administrative jurisdiction and does not contain a rule in the opposite direction. How the provision will be applied to administrative detention compensation is not addressed in the examined decisions. Therefore, the calculation of the time limit must be evaluated separately in the specific case file.

According to the second paragraph added to Article 46 of Law No. 2577 by Law No. 7589, an appeal to the Council of State (Danıştay) against a decision issued anew by the regional administrative court following an annulment is closed in cases arising from the implementation of Law No. 6458. Whether an administrative compensation lawsuit falls within this scope must be examined separately.

When Does an Individual Application Arise?

In the K.N. file, the application was found admissible even though the peace criminal court decision was not appealed and the matter was not referred to the Jurisdictional Court (Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi); the Court stated that in these circumstances, exhaustion of such remedies cannot be expected (§ 42). This assessment depends on the conditions of that specific file. How subsequent decisions of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) and the Jurisdictional Court will affect the debate on the exhaustion of judicial remedies is not yet known. For procedures, see the section on the duration and procedure of individual application can be consulted.

The Reversal Decision Is Not the End of the Case

It cannot be concluded from the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) decision that the right to compensation has been accepted:

  • The file returns to the court of first instance: The Chamber's ruling is to send the file back to the court of first instance that rendered the decision, and the proceedings will continue there.
  • The merits are clear: The Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) has not made any findings regarding the illegality of the detention, the existence of damages, the amount of compensation, the defendant party (husumet), and the time limits.
  • The reasoning is limited to detention: The Chamber addressed the compensation arising from the same administrative act; it did not make an assessment regarding the damages arising from the deportation process itself.
  • Finalization and subsequent course: The decision does not contain the phrase "with final effect," and the subsequent course of the file after the reversal is not understood from the published text.
  • Other files: The decision does not automatically produce results for other files; each file is examined according to its own administrative act, time limits, and damages.

What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?

The first step is to distinguish between the deportation order and the detention order. Subsequently, the following points can be checked:

  • Appeal to the peace criminal court: It must be determined whether the detention was challenged and what the result was. In file E. 2022/7270, detention was terminated, while in file E. 2022/5310, the objections were rejected. The K.N. decision also recounts the distinction made based on the outcome of the objection in previous jurisprudence (§§ 40-41).
  • The governorship that performed the final act: In two decisions, regarding jurisdiction within the administrative judiciary, the Council of State (Danıştay) considered the process as a whole even if the detention continued in several provinces and deemed the administrative court dealing with the dispute that finally caused the damage to be the competent one.
  • Defendant: In the Jurisdictional Court (Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi) file, two governorships are involved; in file E. 2024/6453, the Ministry of Interior is the defendant, while in the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) file, a defense regarding the proper defendant party (husumet) was raised.
  • Relation to the criminal file: The 12th Criminal Chamber stated in its decision E. 2022/5310 that no protective measure was applied. In cases of detained foreign nationals, the duration of custody and detention must be checked separately.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Branch of the Judiciary Did the Court of Cassation Deem Competent for Unjust Administrative Detention Compensation?

The 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, in its decision dated December 16, 2025, numbered E. 2024/32, K. 2025/16829, overturned the dismissal decision that had deemed the administrative courts competent, stating that the case should be heard in the judicial courts. According to the Chamber, the claim does not fall under the scope of Law No. 5271, and since an application against the detention is made to the magistrate judge (sulh ceza hâkimi), the compensation arising from the same action must also be handled by the judicial courts.

Does a Foreigner Whose Deportation Decision Is Cancelled Automatically Receive Compensation for the Days Spent in the Removal Center?

No, the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation has only determined the competent court, reversed the first-instance decision on the grounds of jurisdiction, and sent the file back to the court that rendered the decision. The reversal is not the end of the lawsuit. There is no explicit assessment in the decision stating that the cancellation of the deportation action automatically renders the administrative detention unlawful. Issues regarding unlawfulness, damage, amount, liability, and time limits remain open.

Can Compensation Be Requested in the High Criminal Court for Unjust Administrative Detention Pursuant to CMK 141?

The 12th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld the outcomes of cases filed via this route in three decisions from 2023 and 2025. According to the decision numbered E. 2022/5310, the action is administrative, and no protective measure has been applied. The Constitutional Court, however, cites a conflicting decision by the Ankara Regional Court of Justice.

Can Compensation for Administrative Detention Be Requested in the Administrative Court?

The Council of State (Danıştay) characterized this case as a full remedy action arising from an administrative act but did not debate the jurisdiction of the judicial courts. The Court of Jurisdictional Disputes (Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi) declared the judicial courts competent in 2026, and the Constitutional Court noted that six chambers of regional administrative courts did not consider the administrative courts competent. Therefore, there is a risk of dismissal based on jurisdiction.

Did the Court of Jurisdictional Disputes Specify Which Court Should Handle Administrative Detention Compensation?

No. In its decision dated February 16, 2026, numbered E. 2026/12, K. 2026/85, the Court of Jurisdictional Disputes declared the judicial courts competent. However, it explicitly stated that it does not have the authority to determine which specific authority within the judicial branch is competent.

What Does the Constitutional Court's K.N. Pilot Decision Say About Administrative Detention Compensation?

The General Assembly of the Constitutional Court, in its decision under App. No: 2022/8989, determined that there is no effective remedy for damages arising from unlawful administrative detention, ruled that Article 19 of the Constitution was violated, applied the pilot decision procedure, and notified the Grand National Assembly of Turkey (TBMM) of the situation. The competent authority was not determined in the decision.

Conclusion: The Question of Jurisdiction Points to the Judicial Courts, the Question of Compensation Remains Open

The decision of the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) dated December 16, 2025, is in the same direction as the decision of the Jurisdictional Court (Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi) dated February 16, 2026. The question of jurisdiction for the compensation lawsuit filed for days spent in the removal center currently points to the judicial judiciary, but the reversal decision leaves the existence of the right to compensation, the amount, and the time limit open.

Prior to these two rulings, the Constitutional Court determined on November 20, 2025, that there was no effective remedy in this field and notified the Turkish Grand National Assembly accordingly. The Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi file demonstrates that an application to the wrong judicial venue can result in the loss of years without the merits being examined. Therefore, the risk of jurisdiction and the statute of limitations must be evaluated separately in every file, and the possibility of legislative amendments should be monitored.

Legal Resources and Related Reviews

Legislation

Decisions

The list includes the decisions referenced in the article. Regional court decisions cited in the K.N. decision and previous Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi decisions have not been included in this list.

Other Resources and Related Articles

Author and Legal Information

Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008

This text is a legal review based on the decision of the Yargıtay 4th Civil Chamber dated 16.12.2025, numbered E. 2024/32, K. 2025/16829. The review is limited to the published decision text; it does not imply that the same result will be obtained in other cases.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Author

Atty. Batın Yılmaz

Founding attorney of Batın Yılmaz Law Office. Handles litigation and consultancy in foreigners and citizenship law, as well as criminal, corporate, administrative, real estate, enforcement, and compensation law.

About our office