Precedent decision reviews
Individual Application Against Deportation Decision: Constitutional Court Found Violation of Rights
In this article 18 headings
- Short Answer: Individual application against a deportation decision
- Citation of the Muhammad Ashraf Abdullah Judgment
- How Did the Dispute Begin? From the Rejection of the Protection Request to the Constitutional Court
- What Did the Applicant Claim Before the Constitutional Court?
- How Does the Constitutional Court Examine the Risk of Ill-Treatment?
- Does a Previous Protection Case Eliminate the Risk Assessment in a Deportation Case?
- When Does the Protection in the Deportation Process Begin and End?
- What Conclusion Did the Constitutional Court Reach in Which Deportation Application?
- Why Did the Public Order Rationale Lead to a Different Outcome at the Constitutional Court?
- How Did the Constitutional Court Decisions Examining Claims of Family Life Conclude?
- The Y.T. Pilot Judgment and Article 53: Have the Case Duration and Finality Changed?
- How and Within What Timeframe Is an Application Made to the Constitutional Court?
- What Are the Consequences of a Violation Judgment?
- What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion: The Constitutional Court, as a Rule, Supervises How Risk Is Examined
- Legal Resources and Related Reviews
- Author and Legal Information
Publication: · Last update:
This content is for general information purposes; it does not constitute legal advice for your specific case.
Short Answer: Individual application against a deportation decision
Yes, but this is an exceptional opportunity, and an individual application does not automatically stay the deportation process. The Constitutional Court may issue an interim measure if it observes a serious danger to life or physical and moral integrity while the application is pending; in a case where it finds a human rights violation, it may also order a stay of deportation until the retrial concludes.
The Court used both these tools in the case of Muhammad Ashraf Abdullah whose principal judgment is dated July 2, 2025. The applicant, who claimed he had served as a police officer in Afghanistan and had been threatened with death by the Taliban, had his lawsuit rejected by the Sakarya 1st Administrative Court. The Second Section stayed the deportation process as an interim measure three days after the application. In its principal judgment, it determined that the Administrative Court had failed to investigate the alleged risks and had not evaluated the submitted documents, and it unanimously decided that the right to life and the prohibition of ill-treatment under Article 17 of the Constitution had been violated.
This outcome does not mean that the deportation decision was cancelled or that the applicant will remain in Türkiye. The Court determined not that the risk in Afghanistan was real, but that the risk was not properly examined, and it sent the file back for a retrial. The claim of family life is subject to a different criterion and did not result in a violation in any of the examined deportation decisions.
This examination is based on the published judgment texts and covers the period after the administrative court stage has ended. For filing a lawsuit, to the section on filing a lawsuit against a deportation decision, for the detention center stage, to the removal center and deportation objection letter can be consulted.
Citation of the Muhammad Ashraf Abdullah Judgment
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Title | Information |
|---|---|
| Court | Constitutional Court, Second Section |
| Application | Muhammad Ashraf Abdullah, App. No: 2021/1175 |
| Application date | 08.01.2021 |
| Interim measure | 11.01.2021, Internal Regulations Art. 73 |
| Decision date | 02.07.2025 |
| Official Gazette | 16.02.2026, Issue: 33170 |
| Basis for deportation | Law No. 6458 Art. 54/1-(i) |
| Right examined | Constitution Art. 17, right to life and prohibition of ill-treatment |
| Conclusion | Admissible, violation, unanimous |
| Remedy | Sending to the Sakarya 1st Administrative Court (E.2019/941, K.2020/193) for retrial and staying deportation until the trial concludes |
How Did the Dispute Begin? From the Rejection of the Protection Request to the Constitutional Court
The applicant, an Afghan national, applied for international protection in Sakarya in 2018. Following the interview, the administration rejected the request, accepting that the application was primarily based on economic reasons and that there was no individual ill-treatment directed at the applicant; the lawsuit filed against this action also yielded no results. The issue of access to interview documents was examined in the interview report examination has been addressed.
of the series. After the deportation decision, the content of the file changed. The applicant stated this time that he had worked as a police officer in Afghanistan, had captured a Taliban member, and was threatened with death; he also submitted documents regarding his service record and a death warrant. The documents were black-and-white photocopies written in Arabic or Farsi. The Administrative Court rejected the lawsuit, stating that the allegations in the protection case were reiterated and that there was no new situation requiring him to remain in the country.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Date | Development | Legal Significance |
|---|---|---|
| 21.01.2019 | The Sakarya Governorship rejected the protection application. | The foundation for the deportation process was established. |
| 10.09.2019 | The appeal against the protection case was finally rejected. | The protection request was judicially concluded. |
| 26.09.2019 | The Governorship issued a deportation order. | The legal basis is subparagraph (i) of the first paragraph of Article 54 of the Law. |
| 04.02.2020 | The applicant submitted a petition and documents explaining the Taliban threat. | These are the claims that the Constitutional Court considered 'new and serious'. |
| 05.03.2020 | The Administrative Court dismissed the case and indicated that the path for appeal is open. | The notification of the legal remedy was incorrect. |
| 24.11.2020 | The appellate authority rejected the application without review because the decision was final. | The applicant learned of this decision on December 24, 2020. |
| 08.01.2021 | Individual application was filed. | It was deemed submitted on time due to being misled. |
| 11.01.2021 | The Chamber issued an interim measure to stay the deportation proceedings. | The decision was based on Article 73 of the Internal Regulations. |
| 02.07.2025 | The Court ruled that a violation had occurred. | The decision was taken unanimously. |
What Did the Applicant Claim Before the Constitutional Court?
The applicant argued that he was a target of the Taliban due to his police duties and that he would face a risk of death if he returned to his country, and that the Administrative Court failed to investigate these risks. He based his complaint on the right to a fair trial, the right to life, and the prohibition of ill-treatment. The Court characterized the allegations within the framework of Article 17 of the Constitution. The published text does not contain a section regarding the Ministry's opinion.
The characterization is significant as deportation proceedings do not fall within the scope of the right to a fair trial. The Court, in its L.A. decision, found such a complaint inadmissible due to lack of subject-matter jurisdiction (§§ 41-43). Therefore, the complaint of insufficient investigation must be directly linked to Article 17 in the application.
How Does the Constitutional Court Examine the Risk of Ill-Treatment?
The entry, residence, and removal of foreigners are within the sovereign authority of the State; the limit of this authority is drawn by the absolute prohibition in Article 17. The general principles of the decision can be summarized as follows:
- There is no exception to the prohibition. If there are substantial grounds to believe that there is a real risk in the country of destination, the prohibition against deportation may be violated. The obligation also covers indirect removal (§ 23).
- The initial burden lies with the foreigner. The foreigner must reasonably explain the risk and submit supporting information and documents, if any, to the administrative and judicial authorities (§ 24).
- The source of the risk changes the criteria. If the risk originates from persons or groups who are not public officials, the foreigner must prove the reality of the risk and that the state would be insufficient to eliminate the risk. In the case of claims of general instability, administrative and judicial authorities must demonstrate that country conditions do not constitute a violation of the prohibition (§ 25).
- Once the burden is met, the investigation shifts to the administration and the court. Authorities must meticulously examine the foreseeable consequences, the general situation of the country, and the personal situation (§ 26).
- The base date is, as a rule, the date of the deportation decision. However, significant developments that would directly affect the outcome are also taken into account (§ 27).
- The Constitutional Court, as a rule, reviews procedural guarantees. If safeguards are provided, the existence of a real risk is evaluated separately; the Court may, exceptionally, examine the risk itself under the specific circumstances of the concrete case (§ 28).
The decision is based on two findings. The first is that the applicant reasonably explained the risk and submitted the documents (§ 30). The second is that the Administrative Court did not conduct 'any investigation,' did not justify why it did not credit the allegations, and did not examine the content, reliability, or whether the documents supported the allegations (§ 31). The conclusion is summarized in the following sentence:
'Rendering a decision without evaluating the applicant's new and serious allegations and the documents submitted reveals that the effective procedural safeguards providing protection against being sent to a country where the applicant would face a risk of ill-treatment were not provided.'
The decision does not contain a finding regarding whether the documents are authentic or whether the applicant is actually at risk in Afghanistan.
Does a Previous Protection Case Eliminate the Risk Assessment in a Deportation Case?
The Administrative Court had accepted that the allegations were examined and rejected during the protection proceedings and that no new situation had arisen (§ 15). The Constitutional Court, on the other hand, characterized the same allegations as 'new and serious' and required an explanation as to why they were not credited (§ 31). The account given during the protection interview was different; the applicant had stated there that he had performed military service, was afraid of the Taliban, and that there were no job opportunities in Afghanistan (§ 7).
The decision does not specifically discuss the impact of the previous protection case on the deportation case. There is also no evaluation regarding the discrepancy between the interview statements and the subsequent account. Nevertheless, the conclusion demonstrates that, in relation to this file, the reference made to the final denial of protection is insufficient to address the concrete allegations. How the review was conducted during the trial phase in the country of origin research letter has been examined.
When Does the Protection in the Deportation Process Begin and End?
The answer to the question of what happens after an administrative court decision involves distinguishing between three stages of protection, each with different legal foundations.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Stage | Legal Basis | How does protection arise? | When does it end? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Administrative court | Law No. 6458, Article 53/3 | By law, provided the foreigner's consent is reserved | When the trial concludes |
| Individual application | Law No. 6216, Article 49/5, Internal Regulations, Article 73 | Only if a Section grants a preliminary injunction | Expires if no final decision is rendered within six months and no decision is taken to continue the injunction; it can also be terminated in the final decision |
| After the finding of a violation | Operative part of the judgment, Law No. 6216, Article 50 | If explicitly written in the judgment | When the retrial concludes |
of Law No. 6458 The guarantee in the third paragraph of Article 53 is established with these words: "Provided that the foreigner's consent is reserved, the foreigner shall not be deported within the period for filing a lawsuit or, in case of recourse to judicial remedy, until the conclusion of the trial." According to the same paragraph, the court's decision is final. No stay of execution effect is envisaged in the judgment regarding an individual application.
The path to be taken in the interval after a final decision is the preliminary injunction. Of Law No. 6216 Article 49 authorizes the Sections to decide on measures they deem necessary for the protection of fundamental rights. Article 73 of the Internal Regulations requires the presence of a "serious danger to the applicant's life or physical or moral integrity." Gonca Erol's 2017 study emphasizes that this authority is exceptional. According to the study, requests where no concrete and imminent danger is seen are rejected, and the requests of applicants who do not yet have a deportation decision or who have filed an annulment lawsuit also yield no results in this scope. Accordingly, a request for an injunction gains meaning, as a rule, after the administrative court trial ends.
According to Law No. 6216, when an injunction is granted, the final decision must be rendered within six months; otherwise, the injunction expires automatically. The fourth paragraph of Article 73 of the Internal Regulations, mentioned by Erol, also ties the expiry to the failure to take a new decision regarding the continuation of the injunction. In the Abdullah file, the injunction was granted in 2021, and the final decision was rendered in 2025; there is no information in the published text regarding the continuation of the injunction, nor is there a clause in the judgment terminating the injunction. The operative part of the judgment tied the duration of protection to the result of the retrial and did not address whether the injunction needed to be requested again if the lawsuit was rejected again.
What Conclusion Did the Constitutional Court Reach in Which Deportation Application?
The following decisions were selected to demonstrate the difference in outcomes. The table is not statistical and should not be read as a success rate. All five decisions were rendered unanimously.
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Ruling | Basis for deportation | Measure | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abdullah, 2021/1175 (02.07.2025) | Article 54/1-(i) | Rendered on 11.01.2021 | Violation of Article 17; no deportation until the retrial is concluded |
| Mavvas, 2020/33319 (30.07.2025) | Article 54/1-(d) | On 13.11.2020, the Commission decided that there were no grounds to refer the application to the Section | Violation of Article 17; Article 20 was not examined separately; legal remedies were not exhausted in the administrative detention complaint; the same provision regarding non-deportation was given |
| L.A., 2021/361 (29.07.2025) | Article 54/1-(d) and (h) | Interim decision dated 25.01.2016 in the previous application | No violation of Article 17 in the second application after the retrial |
| Majid Momtaz, 2017/24261 (30.09.2020) | Article 54/1-(d) | Rejected on 29.05.2017 | No violation of Article 20 |
| Lalazar Aghayeva, 2020/14880 (25.03.2025) | Article 54/1-(ğ) | Rendered on 27.05.2020, concluded with the final decision | Claims of ill-treatment and family life are inadmissible; violation of Article 40 in conjunction with Article 23 |
Four conclusions can be drawn from these decisions:
- The subject of the review is the manner in which the risk is examined. In the L.A. file, the Court issued a violation decision in 2019 on the grounds that the risk had not been sufficiently investigated. When the Administrative Court evaluated the personal situation and country reports together during the retrial, the same Court found no violation (§§ 12, 38).
- The injunction stage does not determine the final result. In the Mavvas case, a stay of proceedings was requested, the Commission decided there was no ground to send the application to the Chamber, and the text does not indicate that an interim measure was granted at that stage. Despite this, a violation was found in 2025, and it was also reflected in the file that the applicant did not leave Türkiye (§§ 5, 7).
- An interim measure may coincide with the actual transfer on the same day. In the L.A. file, the records show that the applicant was removed from the country on the same date as the interim decision; however, the times in the institution’s documents do not match, and it is unclear from the text whether the transfer occurred before or after the interim decision (§ 11).
- The provision against deportation was not included in every violation judgment. While this provision was established in the Abdullah and Mavvas files by finding a violation of Article 17, the measure was terminated and no similar provision was established in the Aghayeva file, where a violation of Article 40 in conjunction with Article 23 was found.
Why Did the Public Order Rationale Lead to a Different Outcome at the Constitutional Court?
In the Mavvas and Momtaz files, the deportation decision is based on sub-paragraph (d) of the first paragraph of Article 54, which regulates the threat to public order, public security, or public health. The outcomes, however, are in opposite directions. The main difference lies in the nature of the right under examination.
In the Momtaz file, Article 20 was examined, and the Court followed the steps of legality, legitimate aim, and proportionality. Regarding the applicant, who was convicted of forgery offenses, the protection of public order took precedence over family interests (§ 50). In the Mavvas file, Article 17 was applied, and since the third country to which the applicant would be sent was not identified either during the processing or afterwards, the conclusion was reached that there was no procedural safeguard against indirect removal (§§ 13-14).
The judgment contains no assessment regarding the appropriateness of the public order justification. Therefore, the violation judgment should not be read as finding the assessment of the threat to be unlawful. The concrete basis for the justification is discussed at the administrative court stage; this review in the deportation decision document justified by public order, and the issue of the third country is in the safe third country document has been addressed.
How Did the Constitutional Court Decisions Examining Claims of Family Life Conclude?
In the examined judgments, the claim of family life followed three different paths, and in none of them was a violation of Article 20 reached due to the deportation procedure. This finding is limited to the limited screening as of November 2026 and the judgments mentioned in the text; it does not mean that no such judgment exists. Regarding the entry ban to the country in the Musa Polat judgment however, a violation of Article 20 was found.
- If a violation of Article 17 is found, it may not be examined separately. In the Mavvas judgment, the Court did not find it necessary to examine the case in terms of family life, as a violation of the right to life and the prohibition of ill-treatment was determined (§ 16). This outcome does not mean that the claim was rejected.
- If it was not asserted in the administrative court, it may be considered inadmissible. Aghayeva stated in her individual application that family integrity would be disrupted due to her Turkish spouse and grandchild, but since she had no such complaint in the cancellation lawsuit, domestic remedies were deemed not exhausted (§§ 20-23).
- If examined on its merits, a balancing test is performed. In the Momtaz file, the life maintained with a Turkish citizen spouse and two children was accepted as family life (§ 37). In contrast, the unlawful residence, the gravity of the crime, and the lack of evidence of serious obstacles to living together in Iran were decisive factors (§§ 47-51).
Since the prohibition of ill-treatment is absolute, no balancing for the purpose of public order was performed in the examined judgments; instead, procedural safeguards were scrutinized. In family life, however, an individual’s ties are weighed against the purpose of public order. For this reason, documents regarding family ties must be submitted at the administrative court stage. For the general framework of the subject to the section on family life and the best interests of the child one may refer. In the Aghayeva file, where the applicant had a valid residence permit, the Court relied on the guarantees of Protocol No. 7 and considered the failure to provide reasons for evidence requests as a violation of the right to an effective remedy in conjunction with Article 23 (§§ 25, 33-36).
The Y.T. Pilot Judgment and Article 53: Have the Case Duration and Finality Changed?
The judgment, which was reflected to the public as “1545 immigrants”, is the pilot judgment of the General Assembly dated May 30, 2019, Y.T.In the decision, the number 1,545 does not refer to the number of persons, but rather to the applications of the same nature made as of April 8, 2019 (§§ 73, 77). The Court determined that the right to an effective remedy, in conjunction with Article 17, was violated due to the 2016 amendment that removed the guarantee during the litigation process for clauses related to public order and terrorism, and stated that the problem stems from the law (§§ 62, 74). The examination of the applications has been postponed for one year (§ 78).
Scroll sideways for the entire table
| Date | Regulation or decision | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| 29.10.2016 | Decree Law No. 676 (Official Gazette date) | Those within the scope of Article 54/1-(b), (d), (k) and Article 54/2 were excluded from the guarantee of judicial review. |
| 30.05.2019 | Y.T. pilot judgment (judgment date) | A violation of the right to an effective remedy was established, and it was stated that the decision must be notified to the legislative body. |
| 06.12.2019 | Law No. 7196 Article 75 (law date) | The exception was removed, and the filing period was reduced from fifteen days to seven days. |
| 30.11.2023 | E. 2023/57, K. 2023/200 (judgment date) | The challenge against the phrase "seven days" was rejected without entering into the merits because the annulment request had been rejected on the merits with decision E. 2020/30, K. 2023/12, and the ten-year barrier was in effect. |
| 30.05.2024 | E. 2024/25, K. 2024/116 (judgment date) | The sentence stipulating that the decision is final was unanimously found not to be in violation of the Constitution. |
| 30.11.2024 | Law No. 7533 Article 36 (Official Gazette date) | The seven-day period, finality, and safeguards were preserved; provisions regarding the completion of the file, notification, and hearings were established, and the fifteen-day decision period was set to begin upon completion. |
Since the first administrative trial in the Abdullah case concluded in 2020, Law No. 7533 was not applied in that proceeding; the procedure followed in the retrial cannot be understood from the decision text. The source relaying the new text In the decision of the Council of State 10th Chamber, E. 2025/3226, K. 2025/3437 stated that the purpose of the amendment was to expedite the judicial process. In a scan of secondary sources as of November 2026, no law or annulment decision changing the filing period or finality after July 2, 2025, has been encountered. No Constitutional Court decision could be found regarding the completion of file, notification, and hearing clauses introduced by Law No. 7533.
How and Within What Timeframe Is an Application Made to the Constitutional Court?
- First, the Administrative Court: The lawsuit must be filed within seven days from the date of notification. The Council of State 10th Chamber accepted that since the judicial procedures for deportation proceedings and regulatory actions are different and there is no connection between them in that file, they cannot be challenged in a single petition. The petition was rejected with the possibility of renewal within 30 days.
- As a rule, there is no right to appeal (istinaf): According to decision K. 2024/116, Protocol No. 7 does not require a further legal remedy (§ 15).
- The period for individual application is 30 days: The period is regulated in Article 47 of Law No. 6216. The acceptance in the Abdullah file was granted "because the applicant was misled regarding the legal remedy" (§ 16). Without an erroneous notification, the same result is not guaranteed.
- An interim injunction must be requested separately: The court may decide on an injunction ex officio, but a concrete explanation of the danger must be included in the request. In cases requiring an injunction, the Commission performs the review immediately and sends the application to the Section.
- Administrative detention is a separate path: In the Mavvas decision, the complaint of unlawful detention was found inadmissible because no compensation lawsuit had been filed (§§ 19-21).
- Legal aid may be requested: In the Abdullah decision, it was stated that if the conditions are met, the request should be accepted even if the condition of reciprocity is not fulfilled (§ 18).
What Are the Consequences of a Violation Judgment?
The Constitutional Court did not annul the deportation decision but sent the file to the Sakarya 1st Administrative Court for a retrial. The decision includes the provision: "NOT TO DEPORT the applicant until the judicial process regarding the deportation decision is concluded." The Court also set boundaries by stating, "It should not be inferred from the violation decision that the Constitutional Court has taken a stance regarding the outcome of the lawsuit" (§ 35).
The outcome of the retrial and the current status of the applicant cannot be understood from the decision text. The L.A. file demonstrates that the lawsuit can be rejected again following a violation decision. The decision pertains only to the applicant and does not produce automatic consequences for other files.
What Issues Should Be Examined in a Similar File?
The first step is to determine whether the risk claim was concretely entered into the administrative court file and whether the court addressed this claim. In addition, the following issues may affect the outcome:
- Personalized narrative: In the L.A. decision, general country conditions were not considered sufficient, risk was required to be sought based on the applicant's personal situation, and it was also noted that the allegation of religious and political persecution in the petition was not included in the application form (§§ 37-38).
- Fate of the documents: What is decisive in the Abdullah case is that the submitted documents were not addressed in the court ruling (§ 31).
- Country of destination: In the Mavvas case, the uncertainty of the country was considered a lack of procedural safeguards (§§ 13-14).
- Family and residence information: In the Momtaz case, the failure to provide information about the spouse and the failure to regulate the residence were taken into account against the applicant (§§ 48, 51).
- Evidence requests: In the Aghayeva case, the failure to provide grounds for requests for camera footage and site inspection became the reason for the violation (§ 33).
- Relation to the protection file: In the international protection application statements must be reviewed together with the account in the deportation lawsuit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the Constitutional Court Stay Deportation Proceedings?
If the Constitutional Court perceives a serious threat to life or physical and moral integrity during an individual application, it may, pursuant to Article 73 of the Internal Regulations, order an interim measure to stay the deportation; this authority is exceptional. In the Muhammad Ashraf Abdullah case, the Section granted an interim measure three days after the application and, in 2025, ordered that the deportation not be carried out until the retrial concludes.
Does an Individual Application against a Deportation Decision Automatically Stay the Process?
No. The protection under Article 53 of Law No. 6458 covers the period for filing a lawsuit and the administrative court proceedings. No automatic stay effect is provided for in this article regarding applications made to the Constitutional Court. Therefore, a request for an interim measure in an individual application must be made separately and with justification.
How Many Days Do You Have to Apply to the Constitutional Court After an Administrative Court Decision?
An individual application must be made within 30 days, in accordance with Article 47 of Law No. 6216. Since the administrative court decision in a deportation case is final, the time limit must be calculated based on this decision. In the Abdullah file, despite an appeal application, the Constitutional Court deemed the application to be within the time limit because the applicant was misled regarding the legal remedies.
Can an Administrative Court Decision in a Deportation Case Be Appealed?
As a rule, no. Article 53 of Law No. 6458 deems the administrative court’s decision to be final. In its decision numbered E. 2024/25, K. 2024/116, the Constitutional Court unanimously found this rule not to be unconstitutional, stating that Protocol No. 7 does not require a higher legal remedy.
Does the Constitutional Court Cancel a Deportation Decision?
In the reviewed cases, when the Constitutional Court found a violation, it did not cancel the deportation decision itself but sent the file back to the administrative court for a retrial. According to the Abdullah decision, a finding of a violation does not imply an opinion on the outcome of the case. In the L.A. case, the lawsuit was rejected again during the retrial, and no violation was found in the second application.
Does the Constitutional Court Always Examine Claims of Family Life in Deportation Files?
No. In the Mavvas decision, because a violation of Article 17 was found, the claim regarding family life was not examined separately; in the Aghayeva decision, the claim was deemed inadmissible because it had not been raised in the annulment lawsuit. In the Majid Momtaz decision, however, the Constitutional Court examined Article 20 on its merits and found no violation in light of the public order objective.
Can the Risk of Ill-treatment Be Raised in a Deportation Decision Based on Public Order?
Yes. According to the Constitutional Court, there is no exception to the prohibition in Article 17. In the Mavvas file, which was based on subparagraph (d) of the first paragraph of Article 54 of the Law, the Court found a violation by identifying a lack of procedural safeguards because the country to which the person would be sent had not been determined. The validity of the public order justification was not evaluated separately.
What Is the “1545 Migrants” Decision Mentioned in the News?
The decision in question is the pilot judgment of the Plenary Assembly of the Constitutional Court dated May 30, 2019, regarding Y.T. The number 1,545 in the decision does not indicate the number of people, but the number of applications of the same nature. The Court determined that the right to an effective application was violated due to the 2016 amendment to Article 53 of Law No. 6458, postponed the review for one year, and stated that the decision should be notified to the legislative body.
Conclusion: The Constitutional Court, as a Rule, Supervises How Risk Is Examined
The Muhammad Ashraf Abdullah decision demonstrates that the deportation procedure can be stayed exceptionally even after a final rejection decision by the administrative court. This result does not mean that the procedure will be stayed automatically; at this stage, protection only arises through an injunction or an explicit statement in the operative part of the judgment.
As a rule, the court does not supervise whether the risk will actually materialize, but whether concrete allegations are addressed. In the reviewed decisions, no balancing for public order was performed regarding the prohibition of ill-treatment, whereas it was performed regarding family life. For this reason, putting forward both claims with concrete documents at the administrative court stage can directly affect the result.
Legal Resources and Related Reviews
Legislation
- Constitution of the Republic of Turkey, Art. 17, 20, 23, 40 and 152.
- Law No. 6458 on Foreigners and International Protection, Art. 53 and 54. The text of the clause is taken as quoted in the decision of the 10th Chamber of the Council of State below.
- Law No. 6216 on the Establishment and Rules of Procedure of the Constitutional Court, Art. 47, 49 and 50.
- Internal Regulations of the Constitutional Court, Art. 73.
- Law No. 7196 Art. 75 and Law No. 7533 published in the Official Gazette dated 30.11.2024, No. 32738, Art. 36.
Constitutional Court Judgments
The links lead to the pages where the decision text is read or to the records in the Decisions Information Bank. Decisions can also be searched in the Constitutional Court Decisions Information Bank by application number.
- Muhammad Ashraf Abdullah, App. No: 2021/1175, 02.07.2025, O.G. 16.02.2026, 33170.
- Abdulkerim Mavvas, App. No: 2020/33319, 30.07.2025.
- L.A., App. No: 2021/361, 29.07.2025.
- Lalazar Aghayeva, App. No: 2020/14880, 25.03.2025.
- Majid Momtaz, App. No: 2017/24261, 30.09.2020, O.G. 09.12.2020, 31329. Judgment text.
- Y.T. [Plenary], App. No: 2016/22418, 30.05.2019, O.G. 09.07.2019, 30826.
- Musa Polat, App. No: 2021/2290, 27.11.2024 (entry ban to the country).
- E. 2023/57, K. 2023/200, 30.11.2023, O.G. 05.01.2024, 32420.
- E. 2024/25, K. 2024/116, 30.05.2024, O.G. 17.09.2024, 32665.
Council of State Decision
Other Resources and Related Articles
- Gonca Erol, ‘Injunction’ in Individual Application to the Constitutional Court, TBB Journal, 2017, Issue 130.
- Diken news regarding the Y.T. pilot decision.
- What is a deportation decision and what lawsuit should be filed?
- Country of origin research and cancellation of deportation
- Cancellation of a deportation decision based on public order
- Safe third country and cancellation of a deportation decision
Author and Legal Information
Atty. Batın YILMAZ
Istanbul Bar Association – Bar Registry No: 77008
This text is a legal review based on the Muhammad Ashraf Abdullah decision of the Second Section of the Constitutional Court, dated 02.07.2025, App. No: 2021/1175. The review is limited to the published text of the decision; it does not mean that the same result will be obtained in other cases.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.
The contents on this page are for general informational purposes and are open to the use of all our colleagues. However, pursuant to the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, in the event that all or a part of the article is used, we kindly request that the source be cited as "Batın Yılmaz Law Firm – batinyilmaz.av.tr" and a link be provided to the relevant article.