What is Effective Remorse? (TCK Art. 93)

Effective remorse, does not merely consist of a person saying "I am sorry" after committing a crime. In order for it to produce legal consequences, the perpetrator must, voluntarily :

• crime reporting to the competent authorities,
• of the crime assisting in its discovery,
• of the other perpetrators facilitating the apprehension

such as concrete and effective steps are expected to be taken.

The purpose of this institution is twofold:

1. Strengthening the fight against crime (uncovering the criminal network/other perpetrators),
2. Of the person who turns away from crime their reintegration into society to encourage.

---

How is Effective Remorse Applied in the Crime of Organ or Tissue Trafficking?

In the scenario of "Article 93" shared by you, there are two distinct situations. The difference between the two is the timeframe of whether the authorities have learned of the crime or not.

1) Before Official Authorities are Notified: Impunity (No Penalty Shall Be Imposed)

Under what circumstances is no penalty imposed?

If the person who sells their organ or tissue:

• before being discovered by official authorities
• the situation reports to the competent authority
• and if this report facilitates the apprehension of the offenders

regarding this person no penalty is imposed (meaning the law completely eliminates the penalty as a result of effective remorse).

The critical points here

• Timing: Reporting before the authorities become aware.
• Content: The report must be "effective" (facilitating apprehension).
• Purpose/result: Concrete contribution to the apprehension of the offenders.

2) After Official Authorities Are Informed: Sentence Reduction

In which cases is the reduction applied?

If the person who sells their organ or tissue, after the crime is discovered by the authorities:

• voluntarily
• of the crime comes forward
• of other offenders apprehension

services and assists in, the penalty to be imposed depending on the nature of the assistance:

• from one-quarter (1/4)
• up to one-half (1/2)

may be reduced.

What does \u201cdepending on the nature of the assistance\u201d mean?

Courts/practitioners generally weigh the "nature of the assistance" by asking the following questions:

• Is the provided information accurate and verifiable?
• Information new, or does it merely reiterate already known facts?
• As a result of the information, who was apprehended, and what evidence was recovered?
• How early was the assistance rendered?
• The perpetrator's statement is sincere and consistent?

Therefore, a "discount range" is provided in the same article: between 1/4 and 1/2 the reduction is determined based on the weight of the contribution.

---

Conditions for Effective Remorse (For Article 93)

Condition of voluntariness

For the perpetrator's assistance to be considered "effective remorse" not under duress, but they are expected to act of their own free will.

Notification to the competent authority

The notification must not be merely "telling a friend"; to the competent authorities it must be made (in practice, law enforcement or prosecutor's office channels may come into play).

Facilitating apprehension / contribution to uncovering the crime

Not merely an abstract statement, a concrete contribution is required:

• identity information of other perpetrators,
• meeting points,
• payment/communication method,
• information leading to evidence, etc.

---

The Difference Between Effective Remorse and Simply Saying "I Regret It"

Effective remorse

• There is a concrete act: notification, assistance, evidence, facilitation of apprehension
• There is a statutory consequence: impunity or sentence reduction

Merely a declaration of remorse

• Saying "I am sorry" on its own
• Generally does not automatically result in a sentence reduction (other legal mechanisms, such as discretionary mitigation, may be evaluated separately)

---

Points to Consider in Practice

At which stage should the application be made?

• Strongest outcome: Disclosure before the authorities are aware → possibility of impunity
• Subsequent assistance → Possibility of 1/4 to 1/2 reduction

How is the notification proven?

• It is important that it is recorded through means such as statement minutes, written applications, applications made through a lawyer, and materials delivered.

Why is it important to proceed with an attorney?

If effective remorse (active cooperation) is not exercised at the right time, to the right authority, with the right content, it may not yield the expected result. Furthermore, while expressing themselves, the person may also run the risk of aggravating the imputation of another crime . Therefore, the process must be conducted professionally.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1) What is effective remorse (active cooperation)?

Effective remorse, in exchange for the perpetrator voluntarily reporting the crime after its completion or assisting in the emergence of the crime / apprehension of other perpetrators, dismissal of the penalty or reduction of the penalty is a legal mechanism that can produce the consequence of.

2) According to Article 93, when is no penalty imposed?

According to the text you shared, a person who sells their organ or tissue before official authorities are informed reports the situation to the competent authority and this notification facilitates the apprehension of the offenders, no penalty shall be imposed.

3) Can effective repentance apply after the crime has been uncovered?

Yes. According to the shared text, even after the crime is discovered, if the perpetrator voluntarily assists in uncovering the crime and apprehending the other offenders in such a way, 1/4 to 1/2 reduction may be applied.

4) Why is the reduction rate not fixed?

Because the law states "according to the nature of the assistance." In other words, as the concrete benefit, accuracy, timing, and outcomes of the assistance change, the reduction rate may also change.

5) Does effective remorse completely clear one's criminal record?

Generally, if the conditions are met, effective remorse can eliminate the sentence or reduce the sentence; however, an automatic interpretation such as "under no circumstances will it produce any record/consequence" should not be made. The nature of the specific case and the type of decision are important.

6) Where is the application for effective remorse made?

In practice, the application is made to the competent authorities , depending on the circumstances of the case, and the process is usually handled by the Public Prosecutor's Office / law enforcement proceeds accordingly. Since the correct application method may vary depending on the specific circumstances of the case, legal counsel is recommended.

---

E-Mail:
info@batinyilmaz.av.tr

Telephone:

0 (532) 669 34 90

0 (532) 732 34 90

Address:
Skyport Residence
Floor: 12 No: 133
Beylikdüzü / Istanbul

Atty. Batın YILMAZ